Bail out Detroit?

November 17, 2008
Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share
Two schools of thought are emerging over the proposed bailout of General Motors, Ford and Chrysler.

One is that the auto industry is too big to fail. Itâ??s not just because of the manufacturing operations and all the suppliers and their workers, but also the many dealerships that support tens of thousands more employees.

The other is a tough-love scenario of allowing them to slide into Chapter 11 to see if someone else could make a go of the business. A bankruptcy might shed not only unnecessary costs but also incompetent management, the reasoning goes.

Meanwhile, senators from states with few or no plants operated by Detroit car companies are opposing a bailout. Even Indiana Sen. Richard Lugar is lukewarm.

What do you think?
  • HL Mencken once said for every problem there is a solution that is obvious simple and wrong. To employ tough love is to ignore how interconneted commerce is, to ignore the safety nets we have aleady created and to ignore the fact that the nature of competition is changing.

    1, Honda and Toyota don't want the big 3 to fail. Because it takes all the players to support the part suppliers. If the American fail the cost of a Japanese car will go up.

    2. What will happen to the masses of unemployed? They will begin sapping the dwindling resources of state and local governements, And of course foreclosesure rates will bo up even more, postponing the recovery and harming how many neighborhoods?

    3. Our economy is VERY fragile. At another time perhaps bankruptcy would be ok. But not now. As one industry analyst put it: if you think Lehman Bros was bad you ain't see nothin yet.
    4. It won't be like the airlines. The auto companies will quickly go to Chapter 7 which will mean forced liquidation.
    5. If we wonder what we can do to help the recovery? Go put pressure on your bank to give you a car loan and go buy an American car. Yeah its risky. But it time for us all to help each other. Long term we need to save more. But right now we need to buy more.
  • No way. A bailout is absolutely wrong. Congressman Rupersberger was on the Ron Smith radio show on WBAL in Baltimore, MD Friday. He wants to bailout the autos because then government can act as the board of directors and get the right people in to do the job, people who have been successful in other companies to restructure the whole operation so that it is successful. He wants government to take over decisions of a private company. There is audio of it here As we've seen with the financial industry, there is no end to the needs of companies. Politicians love to give favors. There is no good that will come from any of this. As rough as it will be, companies have to be allowed to fail so that improvements that consumers want will be made.
  • The truth is that the Big three want to declare bankruptcy. The dirty little secret is that they have already shifted production to Asia, Eastern Europe, and Brazil and they are quite profitable in all of these markets.

    Now they want to duplicate the Wilbur Ross strategy. He bought up a bunch of struggling steel companies (LTV, Bethlehem Steel) in Indiana in early 2000, put them in bankruptcy, dumped all the pension and medical obligations to the US government and sold the new International Steel Company to India based Mittal Steel for a HUGE profit.

    The Bush administration does not want this to happen. Wilbur Ross has nearly bankrupted the U.S. Pension Guarantee Fund and eliminated or reduced heath and pension benefits for a complete generation of Indiana's retired workers.

    The truth is these corporations will dump US legacy commitments to our workers and close more US plants regardless of if they get the bail out money or not.

Post a comment to this blog

We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.

Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

Sponsored by
  1. If I were a developer I would be looking at the Fountain Square and Fletcher Place neighborhoods instead of Broad Ripple. I would avoid the dysfunctional BRVA with all of their headaches. It's like deciding between a Blackberry or an iPhone 5s smartphone. BR is greatly in need of updates. It has become stale and outdated. Whereas Fountain Square, Fletcher Place and Mass Ave have become the "new" Broad Ripples. Every time I see people on the strip in BR on the weekend I want to ask them, "How is it you are not familiar with Fountain Square or Mass Ave? You have choices and you choose BR?" Long vacant storefronts like the old Scholar's Inn Bake House and ZA, both on prominent corners, hurt the village's image. Many business on the strip could use updated facades. Cigarette butt covered sidewalks and graffiti covered walls don't help either. The whole strip just looks like it needs to be power washed. I know there is more to the BRV than the 700-1100 blocks of Broad Ripple Ave, but that is what people see when they think of BR. It will always be a nice place live, but is quickly becoming a not-so-nice place to visit.

  2. I sure hope so and would gladly join a law suit against them. They flat out rob people and their little punk scam artist telephone losers actually enjoy it. I would love to run into one of them some day!!

  3. Biggest scam ever!! Took 307 out of my bank ac count. Never received a single call! They prey on new small business and flat out rob them! Do not sign up with these thieves. I filed a complaint with the ftc. I suggest doing the same ic they robbed you too.

  4. Woohoo! We're #200!!! Absolutely disgusting. Bring on the congestion. Indianapolis NEEDS it.

  5. So Westfield invested about $30M in developing Grand Park and attendance to date is good enough that local hotel can't meet the demand. Carmel invested $180M in the Palladium - which generates zero hotel demand for its casino acts. Which Mayor made the better decision?