Builders Estridge and Davis rebound from bust, run own firms again

Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share

Homebuilders Brad Davis and Paul Estridge Jr. belong to a select fraternity.

They’re prominent Indianapolis builders whose companies faltered during the housing downturn, only to re-emerge in another incarnation as the residential market slowly gains steam.

rop-homebuilders-081814-15col.jpg Paul Estridge Jr. says his firm employs 21 and likely won’t get much bigger. (IBJ photo/Eric Learned)

Scores of builders nationally—about 40 percent—went bust during the housing meltdown, according to the Washington, D.C.-based National Association of Home Builders. But no federal data exists to track how many have bounced back, said Stephen Melman, the group’s director of economic services.

“It’s an industry full of very small players, and it’s always churning,” Melman said. “The small guys can’t hold on; they don’t have deep pockets.”

Survivors Davis and Estridge each took a different path on their return to relevance.

Davis Davis

Davis, 54, shut the doors to longtime family business Davis Homes in 2008, opting to focus on renovating foreclosed homes before ramping up the past year to re-enter the building market under the name Davis Building Group LLC.

Estridge, 56, merged The Estridge Group, another fixture of the area’s homebuilding industry, into Houston-based David Weekley Homes in April 2011 and became the company’s Indiana division president. He launched his new company, Estridge Homes LLC, last October.

homebuilder numbersThe new ventures are but a sliver of their former selves.

Davis Building Group filed permits for 130 homes in 2013 compared with a whopping 1,500 in 2001 during the run-up to the housing bust. Even so, the latest number was strong enough to rank the company as the area’s ninth-largest homebuilder last year, according to IBJ statistics.

By comparison, the largest builder, California-based Ryland Homes, filed permits for 626 residences.

Estridge Homes, meanwhile, will have built or started about 50 homes in its first year of operation compared with the 500 permits The Estridge Group filed in 2001.

Veteran bankruptcy attorney Henry Efroymson of Indianapolis-based Ice Miller LLP said it’s not all that unusual for businesses in the service industry to start anew.

homebuilders-factbox.gif“In essence, a builder is an individual operation,” he said. “So it doesn’t make sense to maintain a brand or an existing entity when those businesses can start again through a new entity.”

Though the numbers may seem small, the return of the two builders speaks volumes about the potential for a housing rebound, said Steve Lains, CEO of the Builders Association of Greater Indianapolis.

“It’s another statement that the market’s coming back, and it’s providing more opportunities [for builders] than in the past,” he said.

The numbers lately don’t necessarily reflect that optimism: Home-sale agreements declined 13.8 percent in the nine-county area in July, the 11th straight month deals have decreased.

Pending sales of existing homes dropped from 2,725 in July 2013 to 2,350 in July 2014, according to real estate agency F.C. Tucker Co.

Picking up the pieces

The road back to building presented challenges for both Davis and Estridge, but perhaps more so for Estridge.

He lost both his parents within the past year—a blow even more devastating considering they founded the family business in 1967. The company built about 8,000 homes in 20 communities in the Indianapolis area.

Estridge filed for Chapter 7 personal bankruptcy in September 2011, which cost him his home and another in Florida.

“You just have to accept it and you have to get back on your feet and don’t ever lose your confidence,” he said.

Estridge filed about six months after he came aboard David Weekley Homes. The company recruited him after learning Estridge was on the cusp of closing his business due to a lack of bank financing.

The marriage lasted less than three years and ended, Estridge said, when he was replaced as division president by someone from within the company. The timing proved ideal, though, as the market began to bounce back.

Estridge in 2013 landed a $25 million loan from Charlotte, North Carolina-based Mountain Real Estate Capital, a private-equity firm, to begin acquiring land to build houses. He received a loan from Warsaw-based Lake City Bank for operational costs.

Even former suppliers and vendors of Estridge have returned to do business with the company.

“That’s been the most amazing thing I’ve experienced,” he said.

Estridge Homes has 21 employees and likely won’t get much bigger, Estridge said. The company, ironically, will be building with David Weekley Homes in the 820-home development known as Harmony at 146th Street and Ditch Road in Westfield.

Estridge will offer seven home styles from 1,400 square feet to 3,600 square feet in Harmony, with starting prices ranging from $225,000 to $425,000. The size of the development should keep Estridge there for at least seven years, he said.

‘The Twilight Zone’

The Davis name has been synonymous with Indiana homebuilding since Davis’ grandfather and dad began building houses in the late 1950s.

The company built about 25,000 homes in the years since and was one of the metropolitan area’s more prolific builders, until the market collapsed in 2008. One of the more ominous signs of trouble was when a large national builder dropped its home prices 20 percent, said Davis, who joined the company in 1985.

“I thought, ‘Maybe it’s temporary,’” he recalled. “It turned out to be permanent.”

Davis closed the family business after whittling the workforce from 100 to about 20. The company completed construction on unfinished homes, in part, by extending payment with vendors from 30 to 60 days. Besides a few “honest” disputes, the company worked out all payments with suppliers, Davis said.

Later in 2008, he started the new venture, Davis Building Group. But instead of building homes, the company bought foreclosures and renovated them for resale.

The company eventually built a few homes, then began ramping up last year, building more than 100 houses as the market showed signs of life.

Davis Building Group is on target to increase the number by 30 this year, Davis said, with plans to ultimately build 200 to 250 homes annually that top out in the $500,000 range.

The company also has a division targeting rural areas that builds homes on large tracts, rather than in subdivisions. In addition, it wants to build the occasional apartment complex. Davis Homes constructed 1,200 apartment units over the years.

Though building has been slow to rebound, Davis Building Group is making progress. It has 12 employees, and Davis managed to rehire his old head of purchasing and operations.

“It was like Rod Serling from ‘The Twilight Zone’ walked in and said the housing market would drop by 80 percent overnight,” Davis said. “Fortunately, it’s starting to tick back up.”•


  • Fraternity, ha!!
    Davis Homes, LLC took customers' deposits, never built their homes and never refunded their money, making it very profitable for them to keep their sales offices open as if they were in the business of building homes when in reality they were not building homes for customers. If I did that, I would go to jail for THEFT, it is called STEALING! Some customers sued Davis Homes in court for their deposits and won judgements but they still are trying to collect on those judgements. Beware of companies that change CEO's from brother to brother and back to father and then change the company name from Best Homes, Davis Homes, Davis Homes LLC, Davis Rebuilders Group and to Davis Building Group, LLC which results in judgements being unable to be collected, ruining lives of people who had plans for their homes and the taking of customers' deposits dihonestly! I know because it happened to us and plenty of other customers-A contract doesn't necessarily mean a contract if the Builder wants to get out of building a home for you AND GOOD LUCK on getting your money back from these people. They live like millionaires on the rest of us.
  • Shameful
    Well....as a vendor to both of these builders I guess I have the right to comment. Davis closed his doors with integrity.He paid me every penny he owed me. Estridge,STILL owes me thousands and thousands of dollars. The last few years of my life have been spent working 2 jobs, paying off the suppliers I used to work on Estridge jobs and just struggling to survive. Shame on you Paul...and shame on you IBJ! Maybe you should have contacted the hundreds of vendors that Paul stiffed. I'm sure your "rises from the ashes" spin on reporting would have contained true stories of real people who have struggled to find work and pay of their debts (something that Paul didn't even attempt to do).
  • Inside scoop
    I worked for Davis for as long as I could. What happened was horrible to everyone involved including owners employees trades and customers. I can tell you that Davis was a stand up guy and did his best to do do right by all. In this situation no one will be happy. I am sure Estridge was in the same boat. People who are quick to blame don't understand the depth of all that happened. There could be no winners here. Davis was a great company and a good family and I would work for them, buy a house from them or trust them to do what is right to this day. If you knew how hard everyone work during this time you would too. I am sure the Same goes for Estridge. The names are synonymous with quality housing in Indy.
  • Good Info
  • cannot comment
    Due to the comments policy of this website I cannot comment. Any facts I could add based on past experience with The Estridge Group and Paul Estridge Jr. would be obscene, profane and vulgar,
  • Families Were Screwed
    I know more than one person who was building a house with Estridge, having paid for most of it, and they went bankrupt. They were screwed and was out of luck with any help to finish the home! Reputable?!
  • Answer for Jason?
    I forgot about all the homeowners that they STOLE from. Sorry - I was lost in all of the contractors that they stole from. Can the IBJ answer Jason's question? Why do you not discuss the homeowners that they lied to and stole from? It was a "merger", right?
  • Homeowners
    Why is it not mentioned that in addition to the MILLIONS of dollars not paid to their vendors that Estridge also ran out on homeowners and their warranties? I personally am still being affected by Estridge's lack of support after his supposed fall from grace. In another move to shelter money from debtors, he created a phony warranty company to aid in repairs for homeowners. Little or none of this money was ever used for that specific purpose and the "president" of the warranty company was a former Estridge employee who never returned phone calls nor paid out dollars for home warranty repairs unless threatened in legal action. Why has no media outlet in this state picked up on these stories?
  • Horrific
    Shame on IBJ. I hold your reporting to a higher standard. I'm unclear how you could write anything positive about these two spoiled children who both ran daddy's business into the ground at the expense of others. As Big B points out, they made other people struggle. That's called STEALING. I find your term "merge" to be dishonest. If Estridge did in fact "merge' his business - why did he not "merge" his debt too. I like the IBJ. This article is a real eye brow raiser to your integrity. Surely you most know how dishonest these two men can be. Why would you not report that?
    • said it without saying it
      Big B- Thank you for helping to translate what it means to "start again through a new entity" when it "doesn't make sense to maintain a brand".
    • They got a new start by not paying old bills !
      These builders both took people down with them by not paying off subs or doing so at pennies maybe dimes on the dollars. They didn’t struggle NEARLY as much as the food chain below them did that is for sure. I know subs that they paid short- in Davis case closing down his other company and operating this new one you speak of while they were not paying vendors, suppliers and subs. Next time don’t forget to write that!

      Post a comment to this story

      We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
      You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
      Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
      No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
      We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.

      Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

      Sponsored by

      facebook - twitter on Facebook & Twitter

      Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ on Facebook:
      Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ's Tweets on these topics:
      thisissue1-092914.jpg 092914

      Subscribe to IBJ