Consumers shun cheapest Obamacare exchange plans

Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share

Most Americans are avoiding the lowest-priced health plans on the Obamacare insurance exchanges, taking advantage of government subsidies to seek more protection against high treatment costs.

Only 19 percent of enrollees chose the coverage with the cheapest premiums, called bronze, while 7 percent picked the most expensive, the U.S. Health and Human Services Department said in a report. Mid-level silver plans drew 62 percent. The lower the plan level, the higher the out-of-pocket costs.

That’s good news for insurers who were concerned that too many people would pick the cheapest premiums, then discover they couldn’t pay the plans’ higher deductibles for medical care, said Michael Mahoney of GoHealth LLC, a private online platform that helps people enroll. The popularity of the silver plans shows consumers are selecting the best package of financial assistance offered through the government exchanges.

“The silver plan’s cost-sharing subsidy makes them a great option,” said Carrie McLean, director of customer care at eHealth Inc., an online insurer.

The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, known as Obamacare, requires individuals to carry insurance or pay a penalty as it seeks to cover many of the nation’s estimated 48 million uninsured. Those who don’t receive coverage through their workplace or a government program can select a plan using the new exchanges that opened for business Oct. 1.

Based on income, two subsidies are available to help pay the cost: one that covers premiums and another that reduces deductibles and co-payments. While premium assistance applies to every tier, the cost-sharing aid applies only to silver plans.

Bronze plans cover only 60 percent of costs, making consumers liable for maximum deductibles of $6,000 a person in medical care.

“It’s too risky to take on that exposure if you don’t have that kind of money,” Karen Pollitz, senior fellow at the Kaiser Family Foundation, said in a telephone interview.

For a family on a silver plan with an income at 150 percent of the federal poverty level, the cost-sharing assistance reduces a $12,700 annual out-of-pocket maximum to $4,500, and for an individual, from $6,350 to $2,250, Mahoney said.

The cost-sharing subsidies were intended to encourage consumers to “buy up,” said Mahoney, senior vice president of consumer marketing at GoHealth.

The law requires insurers to accept all customers regardless of their medical history or condition and provide some benefits such as free preventative care. The companies don’t want too many people signing up for platinum plans with the most-expensive premiums because those customers typically are sicker, older patients who know they will see their doctors frequently, said Brian Wright, a New York-based analyst at Monness Crespi Hardt & Co.

“So overall, the greater the percentage of enrollment in the bronze and silver plans, the better from a risk pool perspective,” Wright said in a telephone interview.

Bruce Broussard, chief executive officer of Humana Inc., said early enrollment in higher metal tiers was “greater than we anticipated,” with 25 percent of customers picking a platinum plan, and 52 percent picking silver as of Dec. 31.

Since then, they have seen members start to skew younger and pick more silver plans, representing 58 percent of their enrollments at the end of January, Broussard said in a call with analysts on Feb. 5.

In addition to the 7 percent platinum, 12 percent of the exchange selected plans through Feb. 1 were at the gold level, the HHS report showed.

Joseph Swedish, chief executive officer of Indianapolis-based WellPoint Inc., which has the most plans on the public exchanges, said silver and bronze plans were the “most popular metal levels by a wide margin.” This was “consistent with expectations,” he said in a call with analysts on Jan. 29. At the end of January, WellPoint had 500,000 new members enrolled through the exchanges.

More important than what tier plan is picked, however, is who is making the selection.

“What’s most important for the insurers is the mix of enrollment between young and old, healthy and unhealthy,” Wright said.

The number of claims filed are what that determines an insurer’s expenses, Mahoney said.

“If a person is unlikely to make a claim, that’s a good thing,” he said. “A ton of young invincibles on a silver plan is not the same as a bunch of sick people on the same plan.”


  • insurance costs
    Sadly the ACA has demonstrated that most Americans understand very little about health insurance coverages and costs (premiums, deductibles, co-pays, exclusions and caps). And of course it is impossible for nearly any patient to understand the 'cost' of care in the over-priced, inefficient and ineffective American system. We pay twice as much as any other developed country for healthcare - with worse health outcomes. And we lead the world in bankruptcies caused by unpaid medical bills. You couldn't design a healthcare system this bad if you tried.
  • I got the short stick
    I am self-employed, non-smoker, have not been to the doctor in 10 years (except for my physical I do every three years that costs me $100 out of pocket). Fit as a fiddle, eat right, stretch, drink lots of water, organic foods, no fried/fast food, etc., quite active. I will soon be paying $350 more per month and will have a higher deductible than I did before. My prior plan will no longer be allowed as it "charges too much for prescriptions" is how they are getting away with dumping it. Funny, I haven't need a pill since I broke my ribs surfing 14 years ago and needed some pain relief. Back then my insurance covered me perfectly and now, it apparently is no longer any good. Thanks ACA, you really took care of this whole "unaffordable health insurance" thing. Thanks for making pay more for my premium and deductible to cover the uninsured when I was already paying more for services ($90 for gauze) to cover the uninsured who are treated by law. Real smart, meanwhile, crutches are still $125. I am seriously contemplating taking the penalty and going uninsured rather than the increase. I have to way the long term cost/savings benefit in detail before I decide.
  • on.the.right.side
    I bought gold plan, saved 160 month over silmilar UHC plan and 5000 to 750 deductible. 42y male non smoker.
  • Better Deductibles?
    I'll have what you drinking please.
  • Terry
    Not sure where you got your information, but the majority of those who lost their insurance plans (that they were happy with), saw increases in their deductibles and premiums. The are now paying for much more than they want
  • Better Deductibles
    The best part of the ACA is the lower deductible for healthcare services. Most people had little understanding that the healthcare insurance plan they had provided very little true coverage, unless the insured individuals paid deductibles that ranged between $2,500 and $10,000.

    Post a comment to this story

    We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
    You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
    Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
    No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
    We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.

    Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

    Sponsored by

    facebook - twitter on Facebook & Twitter

    Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ on Facebook:
    Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ's Tweets on these topics:
    Subscribe to IBJ
    1. Of what value is selling alcoholic beverages to State Fair patrons when there are many families with children attending. Is this the message we want to give children attending and participating in the Fair, another venue with alooholic consumption onsite. Is this to promote beer and wine production in the state which are great for the breweries and wineries, but where does this end up 10-15 years from now, lots more drinkers for the alcoholic contents. If these drinks are so important, why not remove the alcohol content and the flavor and drink itself similar to soft drinks would be the novelty, not the alcoholic content and its affects on the drinker. There is no social or material benefit from drinking alcoholic beverages, mostly people want to get slightly or highly drunk.

    2. I did;nt know anyone in Indiana could count- WHY did they NOT SAY just HOW this would be enforced? Because it WON;T! NOW- with that said- BIG BROTHER is ALIVE in this Article-why take any comment if it won't appease YOU PEOPLE- that's NOT American- with EVERYTHING you indicated is NOT said-I can see WHY it say's o Comments- YOU are COMMIES- BIG BROTHER and most likely- voted for Obama!

    3. In Europe there are schools for hairdressing but you don't get a license afterwards but you are required to assist in turkey and Italy its 7 years in japan it's 10 years England 2 so these people who assist know how to do hair their not just anybody and if your an owner and you hire someone with no experience then ur an idiot I've known stylist from different countries with no license but they are professional clean and safe they have no license but they have experience a license doesn't mean anything look at all the bad hairdressers in the world that have fried peoples hair okay but they have a license doesn't make them a professional at their job I think they should get rid of it because stateboard robs stylist and owners and they fine you for the dumbest f***ing things oh ur license isn't displayed 100$ oh ur wearing open toe shoes fine, oh there's ONE HAIR IN UR BRUSH that's a fine it's like really? So I think they need to go or ease up on their regulations because their too strict

    4. Exciting times in Carmel.

    5. Twenty years ago when we moved to Indy I was a stay at home mom and knew not very many people.WIBC was my family and friends for the most part. It was informative, civil, and humerous with Dave the KING. Terri, Jeff, Stever, Big Joe, Matt, Pat and Crumie. I loved them all, and they seemed to love each other. I didn't mind Greg Garrison, but I was not a Rush fan. NOW I can't stand Chicks and all their giggly opinions. Tony Katz is to abrasive that early in the morning(or really any time). I will tune in on Saturday morning for the usual fun and priceless information from Pat and Crumie, mornings it will be 90.1