DataJoe research products from business publishers
Log in here
PRODUCTS SEARCH PROFILE ADD DATA CONTACT SUBSCRIBE
Shopping Cart (0 items)

HTML View

Need a map?
An interactive map of this list is available.

View map

Prefer PDFs?
A printer-friendly PDF of this list is available.

Download PDF file

Prefer Excel?
A complete spreadsheet of this list is available.

Download Excel file
Largest Indiana Property-Casualty Insurance Companies(1)
(Ranked by 2013 property-casualty assets)
Rank
2013
rank
Company
Address
Telephone / Fax / Website
Property- Casualty Assets (2):
2013
2012(2)
Net Premiums Written (2):
2013
2012
Share- Holders' Surplus (2):
2013
2012
States Licenced to Sell
FTE Employees:
Indiana
Total
PERCENT OF PREMIUMS WRITTEN BY TYPEHead(s) of Local Office,
Title(s)
Stock/Mutual
Established
in Indiana
Parent
Company
AUTO
HOMEOWNER'S
REINSURANCE
COMM/MULTIPERIL
WORKER'S COMP.
OTHER (TYPE)
Product/Service
Specialties
1
1
FCCI Insurance Group
9025 River Road, Suite 300, 46240
(800) 824-2513 / fax (800) 226-3243
fcci-group.com
$1,650.7
$1,550.5
$25.9(3)
$23.3
$552.1
$520.8
26
80
719
14
0
0
26
44
16 (property, GL, farm owners, inland marine, crime, umbrella)
manufacturing, construction, service and retail industries
Tracey J. Pfab,
regional SVP
mutual
1975
FCCI Mutual Insurance Holding Co.
2
NR
Erie Insurance Group
250 E. 96th St., Suite 500 , 46240
(317) 848-3420 / fax (317) 571-6370
erieinsurance.com
$1,213.0
$1,160.0
DND
DND
DND
DND
12
DND
4,400
0
0
0
0
0
0 (DND)
auto, homeowners, umbrella, boat, commercial, Worker's compensation, life
Terrence W. Cavanaugh,
president, CEO
stock
DND
Erie Indemnity Co.
3
2
Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance--Property/Casualty & Life
225 S. East St., 46202
(317) 692-7200 / fax (317) 672-8429
infarmbureau.com
$914.9
$877.5
$503.3
$521.2
$323.7
$241.4
2
1,196
1,196
50
25
2
6
2
15 (farm, MPCI, crop, hail, umbrella)
property, casualty and life insurance
Joseph A. Martin,
CEO; Donald B. Villwock,
president
mutual
1934
Indiana Farm Bureau Inc.
4
3
Protective Insurance Co.
111 Congressional Blvd., Suite 500, Carmel 46032
(317) 636-9800 / fax (317) 715-9610
protectiveinsurance.com
$741.1
$680.1
$228.0
$203.4
$375.8
$337.5
50
DND
DND
52
0
12
0
21
15 (accident for trucking companies contractors, surety inland marine, professional liability)
transportation, select reinsurance
Joseph J. DeVito,
president, CEO, COO
stock
1954
Baldwin & Lyons Inc.
5
4
Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Co.
6400 Brotherhood Way, Fort Wayne 46825
(260) 482-8668 / fax (260) 483-7525
brotherhoodmutual.com
$443.3
$384.9
$252.5
$217.3
$178.2
$159.7
50
323
354
9
0
0
75
15
1 (boiler, machinery, other liability)
liability, commercial auto, Worker's Compensation, foreign travel insurance
Mark A. Robison,
chairman, president
mutual
1935
none
6
6
Indiana Farmers Mutual Insurance Co.
10 W. 106th St., 46290
(317) 846-4211 / fax (317) 848-8629
indianafarmers.com
$331.7
$305.0
$169.5
$153.1
$139.4
$125.0
1
154
154
33
23
0
19
5
20 (farm, allied lines, inland marine, GL)
private passenger auto, farm, commercial
Kim O. Smith,
president, CEO
mutual
1877
none
7
5
Yosemite Insurance Company
601 N.W. Second St., Evansville 47708
(800) 325-2147 / fax (812) 468-5811
springleaffinancial.com
$248.0
$353.4
$53.3
$50.8
$153.7
$263.4
46
DND
DND
17
19
0
0
0
64 (IUI, personal property)
IUI, dwelling, auto, personal property
Joseph R. Tomei,
president
stock
1964
FCFI Acquisition LLC
8
7
Sagamore Insurance Co.
111 Congressional Blvd., Suite 500, Carmel 46032
(317) 636-9800 / fax (317) 715-9610
sagamoreinsurance.com
$157.2
$149.0
$21.6
$16.8
$123.7
$120.2
50
DND
DND
95
0
0
0
0
5 (inland marine)
non-standard private passenger, small-fleet trucking companies
Joseph J. DeVito,
president, CEO, COO
stock
1981
Baldwin & Lyons Inc.
9
8
Meridian Security/Meridian Citizens Mutual Insurance Cos.
2955 N. Meridian St., 46208
(317) 931-7000 / fax (317) 931-7969
stateauto.com
$146.2
$144.2
$8.2
$8.1
$76.1
$73.4
44
275
DND
68
6
0
2
3
21 (farm owners, other property and liability, fire, inland and ocean marine)
personal, small commercial, farm products
Robert P. Restrepo,
president, CEO
mutual
1914
State Automobile Mutual Insurance Co.
10
10
Protective Specialty Insurance Co.
1099 N. Meridian St., Suite 700, 46204
(317) 636-9800 / fax (317) 715-9610
protectivespecialty.com
$79.5
$87.8
$3.0
$11.1
$58.8
$58.5
47
DND
DND
0
0
0
0
0
100 (professional liability)
professional liability insurance
Joseph J. Devito,
president, CEO, COO
stock
2008
Baldwin & Lyons Inc.
11
9
Indiana Lumbermens Mutual Insurance Co.
8888 Keystone Crossing, Suite 250, 46240
(317) 875-3600 / fax (866) 293-6591
ilmgroup.com
$57.5
$88.0
$23.6
$33.8
$19.1
$17.0
49
42
59
32
0
0
42
0
26 (inland marine, surety, product liability, GL, bail bonds)
commercial coverage for forest products, building materials
John K. Smith,
president
mutual
1897
none
12
11
NAMIC Insurance Co. Inc.
3601 Vincennes Road, 46268
(317) 875-5250 / fax (317) 872-5636
namicinsurance.com
$52.6
$47.4
$4.6
$4.3
$25.3
$22.1
20
14
14
0
0
0
0
0
100 (insurance company professional liability)
D&O, cyber liability, agents E&O, EPLI, fidelity bonds, fiduciary
Timothy F. Sullivan,
president, CEO
stock
1987
National Association of Mutual Insurance Cos.
13
12
Grain Dealers Mutual Insurance Co.(4)
6201 Corporate Drive, 46278
(317) 388-4500 / fax (317) 295-9434
msagroup.com
$9.0
$8.9
$20.8
$15.9
$6.5
$4.7
21
28
28
12
11
0
54
7
16 (commercial auto, fire and general liability, commercial and personal umbrella)
"Main Street" coverage for individuals, families and small businesses
Jeff Kusch,
western region president
mutual
1902
The Main Street America Group