Do away with music competitions?

May 20, 2009
Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share
As home to the International Violin Competition of Indianapolis and the American Pianists Assocation Fellowship Awards -- and with IVCI head Glenn Kwok recently named President of the World Federation on International Music Competitions (the first American to land the position) -- Indy has a firm stake in the future of artistic competitions.

But with the highest profile piano battle in the country, the Van Cliburn, happening in Fort Worth this week, questions are being raised by at least one critic and a former winner about the value of such competitions.

Scott Cantrell, music critic for the Dallas Morning News, asked former Van Cliburn winner Alexander Kobrin what he would do to improve the competition. The pianist replied "I would erase them from the map."

The story goes on to note that only one past Van Cliburn winner, Radu Lupu, has gone on to become a "genuine artistic legend.") (See full story here.)

So what is the value of music competitions? Do they truly identify the best? What do they do beyond helping find an audience for yet unknown musicians?

And is not producing legends a good reason to knock the competition itself?

Your thoughts?
  • Competition of any sort pushes people to excel. Many high school music students have wonderful experiences trying to make it to state music championships, for example, and even if they never play another instrument competitively once they graduate, they have learned and grown in a way they couldn't have without all that being part of a competitive team brings. Perhaps winning the Van Cliburn works the same way: it's the musician's goal, and once it's attained, he/she should be free to live the life of his/her choosing. I would fear the trickle-down effect if music competitions at the adult level went away.
  • Does anyone really strive to be a genuine artistic legend?
  • Music competitions offer the participants opportunities to expand repertoire, hear and learn from others, and strive for their best performances. It brings them visibility and recognition and helps to open doors to a career in music. Those participants that we have gotten to know and/or hosted in the violin competition have felt that coming to Indianapolis was an important event in their musical pursuit.

    Indianapolis music competitions offer our city an opportunity to be known worldwide as hosts of highly recognized, well-run, fair, gracious competitions. Our visibility as a city of culture is enhanced by the Violin and Piano competitions. They also help us attract people from beyond Indiana’s borders who are interested in the arts. While attending the international summer music festival in Imola, Italy in 1992 we were delighted to hear many young international musicians praising “The Indianapolis” which at that time had held only three competitions!
  • I hate music competitions but they do serve a purpose. Young would-be performers need to play in front of people, get used to auditions. If you win and take home a check that's nice, but if that's why one is entering these competitions one is destined to be disappointed. The best performers don't always win. Do judges ever recuse themselves in the cases of people they know (or are their students)? The important thing for participants to remember is that winning a competition won't guarantee you a career and losing won't stop you from having one either. Many great performers never won a competition in their lives. The conservatory in Milan rejected Verdi. It may have hurt at the time (and he never forgot!) but it didn't hamper his career in the least. Know why you are entering the competition! And remember that it doesn't always matter whether or not you win.

Post a comment to this blog

We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.

Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

Sponsored by
  1. The east side does have potential...and I have always thought Washington Scare should become an outlet mall. Anyone remember how popular Eastgate was? Well, Indy has no outlet malls, we have to go to Edinburgh for the deep discounts and I don't understand why. Jim is right. We need a few good eastsiders interested in actually making some noise and trying to change the commerce, culture and stereotypes of the East side. Irvington is very progressive and making great strides, why can't the far east side ride on their coat tails to make some changes?

  2. has an article from 2010 where they talk about how Interactions moved to Massachusetts in the year prior. The article includes a link back to that Inside Indiana Business press release I linked to earlier, snarkily noting, "Guess this 2006 plan to create 200-plus new jobs in Indiana didn't exactly work out."

  3. I live on the east side and I have read all your comments. a local paper just did an article on Washington square mall with just as many comments and concerns. I am not sure if they are still around, but there was an east side coalition with good intentions to do good things on the east side. And there is a facebook post that called my eastside indy with many old members of the eastside who voice concerns about the east side of the city. We need to come together and not just complain and moan, but come up with actual concrete solutions, because what Dal said is very very true- the eastside could be a goldmine in the right hands. But if anyone is going damn, and change things, it is us eastside residents

  4. Please go back re-read your economics text book and the fine print on the February 2014 CBO report. A minimum wage increase has never resulted in a net job loss...

  5. The GOP at the Statehouse is more interested in PR to keep their majority, than using it to get anything good actually done. The State continues its downward spiral.