Grading racism on a curve

November 11, 2008
Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share
An Indiana University committee made the right call yesterday when it recommended leaving the name of a segregationist on an athletics facility, says a Ball State University historian.

John Mathew Glen says the committee appropriately recognized contributions of former judge and trustee Ora L. Wildermuth, while making amends by also suggesting adding the name of IUâ??s first black basketball player, standout William L. Garrett, who died in 1974.

Garrettâ??s name would be placed ahead of Wildermuthâ??s, an idea that President Michael McRobbie plans to forward to a trustee committee later this month.

Wildermuth was a trustee from 1925 to 1952. A 2006 book about Garrett contains a letter from Wildermuth to former IU President Herman Wells in which Wildermuth wrote that blacks had inferior intelligence and had a bleak future.

Wells, however, added Wildermuthâ??s name to the intramural fieldhouse, and the committee this week ultimately deferred to Wellsâ?? judgment.

â??Weâ??re still trusting Herman,â?? committee head Terry Clapacs told The Herald-Times.

Thatâ??s not such a bad standard, says Ball Stateâ??s Glen.

Wildermuth was a creature of his times, and the university shouldnâ??t paper it over, Glen says.

But Glen adds that the line between acknowledging history and commemorating ugly chapters of history is gray.

No credible person celebrates Hitler. But monuments built by Mussolini in the â??30s still stand in Italy. And the portrait of another tyrant, Chairman Mao, continues to hang over Tiananmen Square.

Where do you draw the line?
ADVERTISEMENT
  • We need to stop revising history and let the choices stand as a reminder of what mistakes we made in the past and how we should treat each other in the future. One example is the Rebel Flag. Some see it as racist, while others see it as a symbol of Southern strength and unity.

    There are simply too many people looking for reasons to be offended. If one doesn't like the Rebel Flag or the Ten Commandments being posted, then let it go and get over it. Political correctness has gotten out of control.

    Another example is how we refer to ethnic groups in America with hyphenated references, ie: African-Americans, Asian-Americans, etc. If Ernie Els, moved to the United States and became a citizen, would he be an African-American? If an Egyptian citizen moved to the United States and became a citizen, would he be an African-American? Is Tiger Woods an African-American or an Asian-American or a Thai-American?

    Why can't we all be proud to be Americans.....PERIOD?
  • Great points berwickguy.

    And along those lines, why is it that Obama is constantly referred to as 'African-American'? I think it's great that we elected someone who isn't just another 'old white guy', but are we really so enamored with the idea that we ignore the fact that he's more Caucasian and Arab than he is African?
  • Agree with both of you guys.

    When I was at IU there was a big controversy about portions of a mural being displayed in some classrooms that had some depictions of KKK cross burnings. The mural was a product of time and was simply depicting many different aspects of hoosier life at that time (both the positive and negative). I believe it was ultimately left up on the wall in the hope that it might inspire discussions.
  • I applaud the IU decision. While the scars of racism run deep in this state, it is important to remember that context, while not excusing the harmful of actions of the past does help us to understand. Where we have been has brought us to what we are today. To simply dismiss our former leaders because of their shortcomings is to dismiss the vast good that was done by them from which we now benefit.

    Indeed, despite Judge Wildermuth's stance on the place of race in our society, some of the moves set into motion by he and the rest of the board of trustees no doubt were meant to benefit the university as a whole.

    This marks a departure from the knee-jerk reaction of the old style politically correct movement that I saw in college in the late 1980's and early 1990's. In those days, the judge would have been decried as a racist and therefore a personification of evil. Instead, IU's actions recognize that he was a man who contributed to the fabric and history of IU. But they also recognize that he was a flawed man. As are we all.
  • When one refers to someone as African-American or Mexican-American, they are referring to the fact that they are of African or Mexican parentage but born in the United States. If Ernie Els moved to the U.S., he would still be a South African citizen unless he applied for U.S. citizenship and he would still be caucasian.
  • Fishers Mom:

    NO, NO, NO. All kinds of people are referred to with hyphens that weren't born in the US. Nice try. But even still, let's try again. Ernie was born in the US but his parents were from South Africa. Is he then an African-American?
  • Racism
    What you do not realize about the IUPUI is that it does cordon racism in a passive manner, case to this point, the Arab students and IUPUI have stuck with themselves and what they do is to discriminate anyone else around them and there is nothing any student can do about their intransigency and arrogance. The school cordons in a divide and conquer way of controlling minority students. So if any of you is coming to IUPUI and you do happen to minority be cautious about the school you join.
    http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=2212057289
    http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=2209859124
    I am most flabbergasted by the situation at IUPUI
  • Racism in American Senior Communities
    I would like to report that there are 54 American Senior Communities in Indianapolis and all practice one or another form of racism, this is a fact that cannot be denied. This racism is manifested in job pay, schedule assignments, hiring and most terrible at times, the treatment of senior of color and other racial minorities

Post a comment to this blog

COMMENTS POLICY
We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
 
You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
 
Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
 
No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
 
We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.
 

Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

Sponsored by
ADVERTISEMENT
  1. From the story: "The city of Indianapolis also will consider tax incentives and funding for infrastructure required for the project, according to IEDC." Why would the City need to consider additional tax incentives when Lowe's has already bought the land and reached an agreement with IEDC to bring the jobs? What that tells me is that the City has already pledged the incentives, unofficially, and they just haven't had time to push it through the MDC yet. Either way, subsidizing $10/hour jobs is going to do nothing toward furthering the Mayor's stated goal of attracting middle and upper-middle class residents to Marion County.

  2. Ron Spencer and the entire staff of Theater on the Square embraced IndyFringe when it came to Mass Ave in 2005. TOTS was not only a venue but Ron and his friends created, presented and appeared in shows which embraced the 'spirit of the fringe'. He's weathered all the storms and kept smiling ... bon voyage and thank you.

  3. Not sure how many sushi restaurants are enough, but there are three that I know of in various parts of downtown proper and all are pretty good.

  4. First off, it's "moron," not "moran." 2nd, YOU don't get to vote on someone else's rights and freedoms that are guaranteed by the US Constitution. That's why this is not a state's rights issue...putting something like this to vote by, well, people like you who are quite clearly intellectually challenged isn't necessary since the 14th amendment has already decided the issue. Which is why Indiana's effort is a wasted one and a waste of money...and will be overturned just like this has in every other state.

  5. Rick, how does granting theright to marry to people choosing to marry same-sex partners harm the lives of those who choose not to? I cannot for the life of me see any harm to people who choose not to marry someone of the same sex. We understand your choice to take the parts of the bible literally in your life. That is fine but why force your religious beliefs on others? I'm hoping the judges do the right thing and declare the ban unconstitutional so all citizens of Wisconsin and Indiana have the same marriage rights and that those who chose someone of the same sex do not have less rights than others.

ADVERTISEMENT