A black Indiana congressman used a lynching metaphor to describe tea party policies he says would turn minorities into "second
class citizens," and the lone Republican member of the Congressional Black Caucus threatened Wednesday to quit the group
in protest.
Democrat Andre Carson of Indianapolis made the remarks to a crowd at a black caucus-sponsored event in Miami, arguing that
some tea party politicians are trying to block the economic advancement of blacks and other minorities.
"Some of them in Congress right now with this tea party movement would love to see you and me — hanging on a tree,"
the Indiana congressman said.
The comments from Carson's speech last week were first posted online Tuesday by the Glenn Beck-founded website The Blaze.
Allen West of Florida, the only Republican member of the black caucus, said on the program "Fox & Friends"
that he might quit the panel over what he said were "reprehensible" comments.
Carson told The Associated Press on Wednesday that he and West have a "cordial" relationship but that nobody on
the black caucus would "lose sleep" if West left the panel because of the comments. He said the Democrats who make
up the rest of the caucus have supported him.
Carson said that while he wishes he would have chosen different analogies in his speech, he would not have changed its substance.
He said the language he used has become a "distraction" to the message he was trying to get across about some tea
party members.
"I'm deeply concerned about some of the extremist elements who I feel have been a distraction to many of the well-meaning
Americans who affiliate themselves with the tea party," Carson said. "What I was referencing was is there are some
in the tea party that want to take America back to a time when certain minority groups and women had greater economic struggles
and fewer opportunities than they do now."
Indiana tea party organizers said Carson owes them an apology and questioned whether Carson was trying to "incite a
riot," The Indianapolis Star reported.
"He owes every Hoosier an apology for his comment," Monica Boyer, a Kosciusko County tea party leader, told the
newspaper. "Since Mr. Carson can't stand on substance or truth, the only thing he has left is to play the race card."
State Rep. Vanessa Summers, an Indianapolis Democrat who is chairwoman of the Indiana Black Legislative Caucus, said Carson
shouldn't apologize for expressing what many people feel.
She said politicians in Indiana and nationally have pushed tea party-supported legislation that would cut spending on programs
important to the minority community, including education.
"Some of that affected some of us in a very detrimental way," Summers said. "The kind of agenda and the kind
of legislation they are pushing is harmful to people of my constituency who happen to be African-American."
This isn't Carson's first go-round with the tea party. In March 2010, he accused protesters of yelling racial slurs
at him and Rep. John Lewis, D-Ga., outside the Capitol during the heated health care overhaul debate.

















IBJ Conversations
49 Comments
Add Comment
I don't support the Democrats, I'm not a fan, so I'm not defending them... but I don't believe that ANYONE wants or is trying to turn America into Communist Russia...
Those comments and similar are a joke to normal people and reek with ignorance. Did Andre play the race card or just state the truth? Anyone who can't see that the Tea Party is a reaction to Obama's election, not his policies, doesn't WANT to see that.
In my opinion, the Tea Party set themselves up for this type of discussion when they sat back and watched George Bush spend wildly, and then jumped playing the "fiscal conservative" card when a black man was elected. Great timing TP!
Where was the Tea Party four years ago? The Ron Paul Tea Party was strikingly different...
This current Tea Party may not be a racist movement, but the timing is quite questionable, isn't it?
And to one particular poster: Why can't blacks be racist? Or be called racists?
And to my fellow Republicans: A bruising debate will occur in our primaries that will break down Romney and Perry, softening them for Obama, who will not face a primary battle and will have a solid democratic party standing behind him. This is why the best candidates, including Mitch, are still on the sidelines. This Tea Party movement is just dividing us, making it harder for victory while solidifying the Donkeys...
Please vote against him in 2012 to prove you aren't idiots.
HAHAHAHAHA! Is this a rant or a joke!?! Anyone born here is an American FC; you do not hold a monopoly on America!
There's probably a communist party out there for Americans to join if they so wish. They are still Americans if they join the Red Terror.... Hahaha! I'm still chuckling! Democrats are not socialists waiting for the revolution FC; if you feel that way you're blinded by your extremist, far-right-leaning rhetoric...
I pray you represent only a small percentage of the Tea Party... Do I sense fascism????
Our military authority and spending has extended beyond simple national defense... It's what Eisenhower warned against more than 50 years ago...
We have two friendly neighbors and two nearly bottomless seas protecting us... Why on Earth do we need military bases in Germany and Korea, thousands of jet fighters, hundreds of airships and thousands of nuclear bombs in the name of "national defense"? And with our lucky isolated circumstances, we still managed to invade a country on the other side of the world to blow billions of dollars!
What are you people scared of? The only thing that endangers us is terrorism, which can be fought in a rational, inexpensive fashion as compared to our past wars...
You ask if I would pay for bombs or for social security. Well, if you studied the Constitution of the United States of America, you would see that America is required to provide for the military defense of our nation. However, you will not find any amendment that provides for social security, medicare, medicaid, ADC, WIC, etc. etc. Those powers are not given to the Federal Government and, therefore, are the responsibility of the States. However, not sidestepping the question, I would do both. I would tell countries like Germany, Japan and others, if you want our troops in your country, you should foot the costs. As for Iraq and Afganistan, I would take the gloves off, kick their asses until it hurt and force their total surrender just like McAurther and Eisenhower did in WWII. Then I would get out (after taking all their oil reserves for reparations). With all the money saved, I would provide for limited welfare programs based on means testing.
You tell others, here, that we should quit whining... but that's all you do. There is a black caucus because they are racists, elected in districts filled with self interested persons living off the govt. It is amazing how people like Herman Cain can claw his way to a fortune EVEN THOUGH HE'S BLACK. Envy is a way of life to Carson and most of the group that voted him into office. Tell me what you would think if we had a Congressional White Caucas? How about a White History Month? What if businesses were required to hire population propotionate white employees? Affirmative action is nothing but racism, plain and simple.
As far as the democratic or democrat party name, it depends what side of the fence you're on. Traditionally, opponents of democrats call it the Democrat Party..... mostly to piss people like you off. It works.
In ref to hamstrung Obama, he had control of the presidency and both houses of Congress for two years. In that length of time, he ran up debt higher than ALL other presidents combined... since America's founding. It was christmas for every liberal, left wing group in the nation. If he has anything to complain about its that HIS party screwed him. Remember, it was Harry Reid that said of Obama, "we finally have a black candidate who is both clean and articulate".
In ref to "guns at rallies", I have to ask, why not? We, as americans, have the right to keep and bear arms. If you choose not to do so, that is your right. However, it does not give you the right to prevent me from doing so. Keep in mind, too, there have been ZERO riots, zero racism and zero episodes of violence or assault. And, believe me, if there were the media would be all over it and you know it. So, stop with the 'bad tea partiers' if you don't mind. You are just repeating the lies spread by the "democrat party"...hee heee...
Now, those are your 'responses'. You are a typical liberal / socialist. You were likely born here, and have lived here all your life...but you are not an American, not really. You feel life 'owes you'. You think the government should provide you more than an opportunity; you think it should provide sustanence. That is not the 'government's" job. The bible says that those who do not work should not eat. The problem with much of the black community, and certainly not all of them, they believe what they have been told by democrats like Carson. They believe they can't live without the government providing them an income. However, people such as Carson, himself, proves that is not true. Carson is successful. I admit he's a con artist, and a racist who played the race card for the black vote to get elected but he is successful. The point is though, there are blacks that do well without the government. As well as you write, I'm sure you could, too. Just as a side note, did you know Carson was a booze cop (excize police) before being elected. Julia got him the job. She also got his brother a job with the same department. Is that graft? Nope. Its just the way the Carson's are.... democrats.
Andre is the one seeking to keep the black man down with comments like these.
Citizens of his district - elect someone that doesn't have the name Carson.
And I think he was referring to WOMEN and African Americans...
And Tim, yes I elected a black president. But that doesn't mean "we" elected a black president... Nearly half of the voting country failed to vote for him, and now certain portions of that half have become more than the typical sorry losers...
Did you vote for him? Even if you voted for the guy you can still be jealous of the African American ability to provide a different point of view...
Racism will never cease... It will always exist and must be confronted wherever it arises...
And thanks for the observations ME... I never mentioned Bush's unwillingness to list either war on the budget, which Obama made the mistake of changing because now he's "exploded our national debt" blah, blah, blah...
How many posters here owe money for their house, car and education? What is the problem with government debt if it never surpasses a certain percentage of our GDP?
We are not Japan or Greece with national debt nearly double or four times our GDP... we still have time to make changes before it becomes a problem...
So bombs or medicare? Guns or social security?
To all you Hobbit Republicans: this is not a battle between good and evil. Obama is an American who cares about this country just as much as F.C. Wade, but with different ideas on how to maintain our greatness... And we are still great, despite what the negative Tea Party says!
To the rest of you. Why not work toward a world where there isn't a need for a Black Caucus, instead of whining because there is one? The reality is that our Congress is 96% white male, which in no way represents a country that's about half minorities and half female. If you think there's a level playing field and everything is hunky dory, you're probably either a white male or married to one. For instance, look at phrases like "paraded through the tea party rally." He didn't "parade" (how DARE he!), the rally was outside the door where he was going. Sheesh. Silliness like that is the reason discourse in this country is in the toilet. Thanks, tea party.
It's hard to gain respect when most of your representatives are former right-wing nut jobs that currently paint themselves as "fiscal independents"...
And expound the idea the current state of the union is this president's fault... Give me a break!
I think we all have a choice: cut spending on making bombs and guns (our current industrial military complex in massive and bloated, which a former five-star general and president warned us against), or cut spending on fellow Americans who need help...
Will the Tea Party cut spending on machine guns or medicare? Social security or scud missiles? WWJD? :)
like it or not.
Political position.
What would happen if there was a
White Caucus...Shouldn't be a black caucus either. Just keeps a divide between the two.
Shame on Andre Carson..he sounds like he is
afraid somebody who believes in the Constitution might vote him out of office.
However...after a remark like he made, he should be asked to resign...others have had
to resign over less.