Indiana officials find school grading 'manipulation'

Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share

Indiana's top education official on Wednesday acknowledged "manipulation" in the way the state's schools are graded, the latest fallout from an Associated Press report that found her predecessor worked behind the scenes to improve the score of a charter school founded by an influential Republican donor.

Superintendent Glenda Ritz told state school board members that this year's school ratings would be held up, at least temporarily, as a result of the independent review into the A-F grading system and left open the possibility some of last year's grades could be changed.

The system was established by Tony Bennett, a rising star in the education reform movement, who last week resigned from his new job as Florida's schools chief amid the scandal in Indiana.

"Upon our preliminary examination, the department has verified that there was manipulation of calculation categories and the department has also determined that there are broader issues that need to be examined," Ritz said.

Ritz, a Democrat, brought up the scandal at Wednesday's school board meeting, but Bennett's allies on the Republican-dominated board had little to say. She met privately Wednesday afternoon with Indiana's Republican legislative leaders, who have started their own investigation.

Ritz declined to discuss specifics of the review but said a final report could be ready by Sept. 2.

The AP published emails showing a frantic effort by Bennett and top staff to rewrite the state's school grading formula after the Indianapolis-based Christel House Academy, founded by GOP donor Christel DeHaan, scored a C. The school's grade was changed twice in the following days, eventually ending at an A. Several other schools also saw their grades improve as a result.

Indiana's school report card website still shows the school with an A.

Bennett has maintained he gave no special treatment to DeHaan's school, whose founder has given $2.8 million to Republicans since 1998 — including $130,000 to Bennett. He called the report "malicious and unfounded."

But the emails obtained by The Associated Press show that over the course of a little more than a week last September, Bennett ordered his staff to find a way to get an A for Christel House, which he'd held up as a model for other charter schools.

"They need to understand that anything less than an A for Christel House compromises all of our accountability work," Bennett wrote in a Sept. 12, 2012, email to then-chief of staff Heather Neal, who is now Gov. Mike Pence's chief lobbyist.

In the following days, the school's grade jumped from 2.9 to a 3.5, and, finally, a 3.75 on a 4-point scale. Along the way, Bennett and his staff debated the legality of changing the grade for the school only and changing the public presentation of graphs to make a high B look like an A.

At one point, Bennett suggested revising the cutoff for an A from a 3.51 to a 3.50. By Sept. 21, when grades were released for all the state's schools, Christel House had a 3.75.

Leaders in the national education overhaul movement, who helped build Bennett into a star following Indiana's passage of sweeping education changes in 2011, flocked to his support in the wake of the scandal. Former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush penned an op-ed for the Miami Herald in which he blamed political opponents for Bennett's demise.

The scandal has put a new focus on school grading systems, pushed by Bush and other leaders as a means of holding schools accountable. The grades are used in part to determine school funding and teacher pay and to determine whether "failing" schools are turned over to charters for operation.

Critics, including the American Federation of Teachers, have said the scandal is proof that "accountability" systems are scams designed to move control of public schools to charter school operators bankrolling the national movement.

In his resignation speech, Bennett called on Indiana's Republican-appointed inspector general to review the case.


  • Dear Jamie
    Glenda Ritz received more votes than Governor Pence. so unless everyone in this state is working for a teacher's union you don't know what you are talking about. The entire state decided they didn't like what Tony Bennett was doing way before we found out about this. so obviously all those voters were voting for no more of what he was serving up.
  • Carol
    Carol, who are you talking to? If me, of course I have read the e-mails and I'm very discussed with them; and as I said, with the very idea of vouchers which change a public school system into a private corporate education system. This Bennett scandal is emblamatic of what I see as corporate control of the education system. Corporations are for profit and that is in conflict with an unbias education system.
  • oh really?
    Did you even bother to read Bennett's emails or the fact that he and the private enterprises he was backing were given $2.8 million? Or does that not count for anything? Get a grip on reality.
  • Does anyone care
    Charter schools are private yet they are funded in part with public money and at a cost to our public school system. I am amazed there are not more people who see this as a means of the corporate world controlling our education system and unduly influencing the minds of our youth. We even have an ex-governor who wants to ban books, but he gets to name which books to ban. Let's design a better school system without losing control of the education.
  • Imagine That!
    Glenda Ritz leaks information that grades were modified. Tony Bennet admits grades were modified. Glenda Ritz then announces that she confirms that grades were modified based upon the leaks of the emails she gave continuing to keep the story going and to further the goals of the teacher's unions that got her into office.
    • Hello?
      I am not surprised at all. When Bennett lost to Ritz,it said it all and his friends were in non belieg.
    • Shocked
      I am shocked. Shocked, I say.

    Post a comment to this story

    We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
    You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
    Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
    No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
    We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.

    Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

    Sponsored by

    facebook - twitter on Facebook & Twitter

    Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ on Facebook:
    Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ's Tweets on these topics:
    Subscribe to IBJ
    1. Can your dog sign a marriage license or personally state that he wishes to join you in a legal union? If not then no, you cannot marry him. When you teach him to read, write, and speak a discernible language, then maybe you'll have a reasonable argument. Thanks for playing!

    2. Look no further than Mike Rowe, the former host of dirty jobs, who was also a classically trained singer.

    3. Current law states income taxes are paid to the county of residence not county of income source. The most likely scenario would be some alteration of the income tax distribution formula so money earned in Marion co. would go to Marion Co by residents of other counties would partially be distributed to Marion co. as opposed to now where the entirety is held by the resident's county.

    4. This is more same-old, same-old from a new generation of non-progressive 'progressives and fear mongers. One only needs to look at the economic havoc being experienced in California to understand the effect of drought on economies and people's lives. The same mindset in California turned a blind eye to the growth of population and water needs in California, defeating proposal after proposal to build reservoirs, improve water storage and delivery infrastructure...and the price now being paid for putting the demands of a raucous minority ahead of the needs of many. Some people never, never learn..

    5. I wonder if I can marry him too? Considering we are both males, wouldn't that be a same sex marriage as well? If they don't honor it, I'll scream discrimination just like all these people have....