Local IKEAphiles in mourning

March 12, 2008
Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrint
So much for IKEA dropping one of its stores in the Indianapolis area anytime soon.

A store opening today in a Cincinnati suburb is about as close as Indianapolis is going to see, at least for a while, IBJ Associate Editor Andrea Muirragui Davis wrote in a story today.

An IKEA spokesman said Cincinnati could pull from a larger population base and that Indianapolis wasnâ??t close to one of its warehouses.

Do you think IKEA had other, unspoken reasons for not putting a store here?
ADVERTISEMENT
  • no........they tend to locate their stores in areas with a much larger metro area than what we have.........most of their stuff is crap anyway.....
  • Indy is just too close to the stores in Illinois. Cincinnati makes much more sense strategically.

    ...And it's just an IKEA.
  • I'd much rather we get a Design Within Reach store.
  • Columbus Ohio has a Design Within Reach......why can't Indianapolis?? That would be great.....along with a Container Store
  • Its halfway between the Pittsburgh and Bollingbrook stores. Pure and simple. They are still on track to open 50 stores in 5 years.
  • 12,000 shoppers entered IKEA by 11:00 AM on its opening day. They must be doing something right!
  • I don't think Cincinnati's metro area is really larger than ours, but they are further from Chicago's stores and can drawn traffic from Indiana, Ohio, Kentucky... people drive a couple hours to visit (I know we make the trip once a year to Chicago) so Cincinnati is more strategically located to get that traffic.

    It's weird that people are surprised when I tell them how big Indianapolis is, though. We really are lower on the country's radar that we should bewhen you consider the size of Indianapolis.
  • Their stuff is not crap! I'm just happy I don't have to drive to Bolinbrook anymore - I think that people not from here seem to feel that we're closer to Chicago than we are. We're passed up alot for touring acts too. Do they think Chicago is an easy distance? 3+ hours and toll roads. I can't wait to check out the IKEA Cinci store in a few weeks!
  • It'd be nice to have one, but it's no big whoop. Had one when I lived in Pittsburgh before IKEA was a gotta' have. I agree, most of their stuff is crap, you assemble, and it falls apart. Their stores ARE huge -- guess it's an okay diversion for a cold, grey midwest Sunday afternoon when there's no football.

    If IKEA'S a retail yardstick by which a metro area is measured -- so be it. There's too much sameness as it is. I say, aim higher.

    As for locale, IKEA likes to draw from a huge geographic area. With two in Chicago, one in Detroit, and one in Cincy, I'd say we're toast for a long while. Looking at their map, St. Louis ought to be next.

    Population? When you count the corridors between Cincy and Lexington, and Cincy and Dayton, yes, Cincinnati does have a larger population base. The new IKEA is on I-75, a 40-minute drive from Dayton. If it's any consolation, Cincinnati still does not have a CnB, but one's on the way.

    Bottom line, look for, patronize, and celebrate what's unique and local, maybe someday that will be the next big thing. Otherwise, you want NY, LA, or London? move there, or visit. They're awesome places, but....
  • IKEA's stuff looks good on TV on all the decorating shows that people like me are addicted to...but I haven't bought anything because it seems like crap to me.
  • I've lived in Chicago for years (before there was one IKEA). I still don't get the hype that some folks have over this store. I know someone from Indy who made a journey to IKEA at least 2x per year. For what? It's a bunch of stuff in a warehouse setting. But, that was his choice. If you only make occasional trips to the store, what's the big deal about it being out of town? I'm sure folks in Chicago take our shopping options for granted. But, I don't think I've ever heard anyone around here craving for a visit to IKEA. Indy is in a fairly tough area, geographically. I know it is a LONG 3 hours between Indy and the southern edge of Chicago. Corporate-types tend to split Indy into other markets... much like what happens to Louisville. You'll notice amusement parks have done that to Indy. Indy has to aggressively pursue retailers, sports franchises, concerts, and other things with limited distribution. I remember when Starbucks didn't have anything in Indy (or Indiana). Well, Starbucks changed it's philosophy to basically blanket EVERYWHERE! In addition to the obvious Chicago advantage, on the other side the Ohio metro areas have population advantages for stores to locate in one of their markets and pull from the others: (Cincy - 1.7mm, Dayton - 1.0mm, Columbus - 1.6mm... Indy - 1.6mm, L-ville - 1.0mm). The population center for this quadrant is somewhere around the state line between Indiana and Ohio. In that case, I'd put a store in the north 'burbs on Cincy.

Post a comment to this blog

COMMENTS POLICY
We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
 
You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
 
Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
 
No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
 
We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.
 

Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

Sponsored by
ADVERTISEMENT
  1. Doug Henning!

  2. These guy were thugs — they grew up in freaking Haughville! Smh, sigh. If the mayor needs/wants "quality" Black Hoosiers who are NOT corrupt, give me a call — I know plenty. Land bank info here - http://www.kubepharm.com/indylandbank/IndyLandBank.html

  3. Magician and illusionist!

  4. The basic idea of nice apartments with parking and retail is a good one, but this design seems overwhelmingly big/tall for Broad Ripple. The size could be disguised a bit with lots of big trees/landscaping, but the complex is too massive to blend in easily. That section of canal between College and Westfield will also need to be upgraded on both sides. Nice apartments facing onto a nice promenade with shade trees/plantings could bring together the canal towpath/Monon recreation, the outdoor seating at existing restaurants, and this project into something that upgrades the whole area. A plan for the whole stretch makes more sense than facing nice new housing onto what looks like a ditch. Is there a plan? Does the public have input? Who pays? The apartment idea seems to be reasonable, but Whole Foods is not a good idea for appropriate retail. Besides the store being physically too big, there are already Fresh Market at 54xCollege and Whole Foods in Nora for fancy groceries. Good Earth and Kroger are within walking distance of the Shell site. There are at least 7 grocery stores within a safe bike ride. Whole Foods would add nothing but traffic congestion. This design is on the right track, but there needs to be more work done to ensure that it blends in with and enhances the existing community. A project that large will set a tone for that whole part of town. It could be a real asset, but only if done right.

  5. I did not move to Zionsville to live in Carmel. This and the subsequent developments to follow will ensure a vanilla uniformity of strip malls and apartment buildings as we seek to bring our town down to the least common denominator. We were warned before recent elections that pro-development council members would make sure their friends (landowners and developers) would be able to make their millions off of the exploitation of Zionsville. Why in God's name would we sell out the best preserved small town in the State of Indiana?

ADVERTISEMENT