More ISO 'Guys and Dolls' thoughts

October 14, 2008
Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share
At some point, I will write about something besides the Indianapolis Symphony Orchestra's presentation of "Guys and Dolls in Concert" last weekend.

But that point isn't here yet.

I blogged on one aspect of the show on Saturday. (Find it here, along with comments from some readers who were there--and one who was in the show).

But there's more to say. Some additional thoughts:

--While the out-of-town talent was outstanding, credit needs to go to ISO Principal Pops Conductor Jack Everly and the ISO for elevated this show from being merely an outstanding concert to an event. The horn section, particuarly, seemed to relish the opportunity to swing with Frank Loesser's peerless score. There is little chance of anyone anywhere ever hearing this complete of a version of "Guys and Dolls" (most recordings skip the reprises, the scene-change music, etc.) played by this large and this talented of a group of musicians. The Encores in-concert productions I've seen at City Center in New York didn't sound nearly as good.

--Ashley Brown, as Sarah, gave a performance that, in lesser company, would have owned the first act. Coming very soon after leaving her title role in "Mary Poppins" on Broadway, she stunned the audience in the reprise of "I'll Know" not just because of her outstanding vocals, but because she anchored the character in real, human emotions. Her Sarah was ready to fall in love, had created an image of her ideal guy, but knew that one wasn't out there who fit her definition. She was, in short, ready for Sky Masterson. And when she let loose in "If I Were a Bell," it was more than a comic drunk number. It was a captivating portrayal of a woman stepping outside of her comfort zone and loving it. And it was still very funny.

--Hugh Panaro's Sky Masterson was more than her equal, with a poignant but not obvious loneliness coming through. He clearly surprises himself by sharing his "time of day" with Sarah and that goes a long way toward his transformation in the end making perfect sense.

--Gary Beach at first seemed to be tearing pages from the Nathan Lane playbook. It's, admittendly, a tough shadow to come out from. But he came into his own in the second act's "Sue Me," in which it was clear than Nathan truly loved his Adelaide. And his joy in the supporting chorus of "Sit Down You're Rockin' the Boat" made a wonderful number that much better.

--An ideal Adelaide makes you laugh between the jokes. And makes you understand both her attraction to Nathan and why he's attracted to her. Megan Lawrence delivered across the board, never straying too far into cartoon.

--One of the familiar faces to ISO frequenters was that of Joe Cassidy as Nicely Nicely. His line entering the sewer was one of the night's biggest laughs for me. But he also joyfully sailed through the show's title song and got "Sit Down" off to a rollicking start.

--If there was one weak link in the cast it was Vincent Pastore. Fine once he settled into the monosylabic part of gambler Big Julie, he unfortunately also was tasked with reading narration for the show, consistantly rendering the text unintelligable. The Runyon-esque syntax requires precision, not sloppiness. And mispronouncing Adelaide is just inexcusable.

--There were so many ways that the ISO could have cut corners on this production. The costumes didn't have to be this ideal. There didn't have to be as many Hot Box Girls. One Broadway star would probably have sufficed. And excellent supporting players, including the Tony-Award-worthy Hal Linden, could have been turned over to those less experienced. But the magic of the evening was that there was no sign of compromise anywhere. The ISO delivered a world-class evening that musical theater fans will be talking about for many, many years.

--Clearly this is something that should happen at least once each ISO season. The question: What show to do next? Stick with both comedy and Loesser and take a shot at "How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying"? Go for another very familiar classic and try "The Music Man" (at least the company will be well on its way to the 76 trombones)? Take a more "serious" approach and concertize "Les Miserables"? Go the route of New York's Encores series and try something less familiar, such as Jule Stein's "Do Re Mi" (a brash show with a "Guys and Dolls" feel that includes the song "Make Someone Happy"). Or risk rustling a few stripper feathers and tackle one of the few scores on par with that of "Guys and Dolls" -- "Gypsy"?

--Ding dong ding dong ding.

Your thoughts?
  • I'd love to see a concert version of Follies! It's a Sondheim classic, with some of his greatest music, but it's so hard to put up a full production that I've still never seen one. Imagine Sondheim with a full symphony orchestra?! Of course, it might not have the same sort of overall appeal that a Guys & Dolls has, but it could be fantastic!
  • I'd like to hear/see the ISO do any and all of the above.

    Hope Baugh
  • I am so jealous for those of you who got to hear Hugh in this role! He is my favourite Broadway tenor, hands down. And not just because he is really talented. He is also one of the most wonderful people God ever put on this Earth.

    So glad.

    I'd like to see Sweeney Todd myself.

Post a comment to this blog

We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.

Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

Sponsored by
  1. Why not take some time to do some research before traveling to that Indiana town or city, and find the ones that are no smoking either inside, or have a patio? People like yourself are just being selfish, and unnecessarily trying to take away all indoor venues that smokers can enjoy themselves at. Last time I checked, it is still a free country, and businesses do respond to market pressure and will ban smoking, if there's enough demand by customers for it(i.e. Linebacker Lounge in South Bend, and Rack and Helen's in New Haven, IN, outside of Fort Wayne). Indiana law already unnecessarily forced restaurants with a bar area to be no smoking, so why not support those restaurants that were forced to ban smoking against their will? Also, I'm always surprised at the number of bars that chose to ban smoking on their own, in non-ban parts of Indiana I'll sometimes travel into. Whiting, IN(just southeast of Chicago) has at least a few bars that went no smoking on their own accord, and despite no selfish government ban forcing those bars to make that move against their will! I'd much rather have a balance of both smoking and non-smoking bars, rather than a complete bar smoking ban that'll only force more bars to close their doors. And besides IMO, there are much worser things to worry about, than cigarette smoke inside a bar. If you feel a bar is too smoky, then simply walk out and take your business to a different bar!

  2. As other states are realizing the harm in jailing offenders of marijuana...Indiana steps backwards into the script of Reefer Madness. guys voted for your Gov...up to you to vote him out. Signed, Citizen of Florida...the next state to have medical marijuana.

  3. It's empowering for this niche community to know that they have an advocate on their side in case things go awry.

  4. Apparently the settlement over Angie's List "bundling" charges hasn't stopped the practice! My membership is up for renewal, and I'm on my third email trying to get a "basic" membership rather than the "bundled" version they're trying to charge me for. Frustrating!!

  5. a vendor to both of these builders I guess I have the right to comment. Davis closed his doors with integrity.He paid me every penny he owed me. Estridge,STILL owes me thousands and thousands of dollars. The last few years of my life have been spent working 2 jobs, paying off the suppliers I used to work on Estridge jobs and just struggling to survive. Shame on you Paul...and shame on you IBJ! Maybe you should have contacted the hundreds of vendors that Paul stiffed. I'm sure your "rises from the ashes" spin on reporting would have contained true stories of real people who have struggled to find work and pay of their debts (something that Paul didn't even attempt to do).