New retail strip to replace Altum's Garden Center

September 17, 2009
Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share

Kroger has signed on to anchor a new shopping center along Michigan Road near 106th Street on the site of Altum's Garden Center. The plans call for a full-size Kroger store, Kroger-branded gas station, small shops and a couple of outlots, possibly for restaurants, north of an existing Marsh store between 106th and 116th streets, said Angie Conn, Carmel's planning administrator. The planning department expects a developer will file formal plans by Oct. 16, in time for a Dec. 15 public hearing. Kroger does not yet have a store in the Zionsville/West Carmel area. Its closest locations are along West 86th Street just west of Township Line Road and at 71st Street and Georgetown Road. The owners of Altum's plan to remain open until the deal closes and then hope to build a new nursery within a mile of the current location.

  • I understand Kroger wanting to be there, but who is going to take the b-shops and the outlots? There's already a good bit of vacancy along that corridor. Anybody hear anything more on the Wal-Mart going in across the street?
    • With all the exciting new construction happening this year in Carmel, I am glad after nearly a year Carmel finally got mentioned at least as a side note on your blog. I was beginning to think 96th street was a line that was not to be crossed at least for Carmel news.
    • I read from somewhere (might be Urbanophile, but not sure) that Walmart is going to open a store in 116th and Michigan road. But I don't think I seen any development sign or any other news else where. I doubt that Kroger will try to open a store that close to Walmart, so my best guess is probably Walmart backed out on building a store there.
    • Too bad Zionsville can't/wont plan for and attract this type of good development. More commercial tax base for Carmel.
      • There is already a huge Marsh and Target (with groceries) on Michigan Ave in that area. Is this needed?
      • Zionsville does not want commercial development like this.
      • I'll be sorely disappointed if Altum's can't rebuild. It's one of the few great garden centers in Indy--plus they offer free how-to classes.

        Re: Walmart...I thought Carmel folks said "No way" to a Sprawlmart when there is one on 86th and Michigan?
      • The People's Republic of Zionsville's loss, Carmel's gain. Keep sticking your head in the sand Zionsville.
      • That Kroger should give the Marsh a good run for its money if its anything like the one that opened at Hazel Dell & 146th. Once Altum's relocates further up Michigan Road, question is, how many years until they get bumped again (as they did to get to their current location)?

        It's funny reading the comments ripping on Zionsville for being against the Walmart and losing out on all that potential tax revenue. Zionsville appears to be doing just fine without it...
        • Zionsville is doing fine? Really? Have you seen their property tax rates the past few years? This is the same place that let Whitestown annex the industrial ground from underneath their nose.
          • The people of Hamilton Co. win again as they should. First Boone Co. sells control of it's airport to Hamilton Co. and they continue to let Carmel and Hamilton Co. reap the awards of missed tax dollars and flight patterns. Hamilton Co. is simply a better and smarter planner. I am in the real estate business and I am sure 8 or more out of 10 individuals who move into Indy would pick Hamilton Co./Carmel over Boone Co./Zionsville.
          • You have to realize that for some people (myself included) having a decent place to live doesn't always need to include economic development on every square inch of land and having a retail development right on your doorstep. Zionsville is one of those places. . . that's what makes it special. It's not trying to be uber developed like Hamilton County. Let it be what it is. I hope planners eventually realize the value of NOT developing every square inch of land for commercial gain. Sometimes I wonder if we learned anything at all in this latest econommic downturn. Back in the same loose-fitting saddle until it falls of the horse again.
            • I disagree. I would move to Zionsville before I would move to Carmel or Hamilton Co. Both places are very sterile and dull unless you want to spend all your free time shopping at chain stores. Carmel is trying to be more urban, but most of it is very cheesy. Many people do prefer these places, its true - but I think the number of people that are tiring of this is growing.
              • I would agree some people would appreciate a more rural setting. I think it is fine for Zville proper to try to sustain itself as a rural, quiet village but Boone Co. shoots themselves in the foot when they try to limit reasonable residential development in such rural areas as Jamestown in south west Boone Co. I tried to do a 13 lot development with each lot being over 7 acres and the County shot me down. The County is simply anti-development and they will pay the price if they have not already. Look into the amount of money the County pays in attorney fees to limit reasonable 7 acre homesite developments.
              • There is no doubt the urban lifestyle has a strong following to the X generation as most of the recent TV shows are in that setting. What many Proffessional X's find out that once the first child is ready for school the burbs become their Mecca. What the Metro area needs are both a strong central Indy and burbs that can compete on the national level. Let every community bring their A games and do what they do best. Our competion is not ourselves but cities outside the region.
              • Matthew, It's not about developing every inch, it's about balanced development, and thus a balanced tax base. If you have great schools, and you don't proactively plan economic development, the only types of development you will see will be residential above market rate developments. They are the most desirable by the general public, and will receive the least remonstrance. This is the trend I have observed in Zionsville and Boone County. This has left them with a tax base that is largely residential. There is little commercial, and industrial to help pay for the schools and infrastructure without contributing expenses to the school system. Zionsvilleâ??s property taxes are extremely high now, and with the changes coming in the property tax system they are going to suffer. They need good proactive planning, and economic development, especially in Union Township, in order to thrive in the future.
              • Hank does not have all of his facts correct. The industrial property annexed by Whitestown was never in Zionsville to begin with, being outside Eagle Township. Most people who move to Zionsville are willing to pay higher taxes to live in a place different from Fishers/Carmel; however, too much residential growth is a drag on the schools, increasing the costs to the schools without generating taxes sufficient to support the additional students.
                • It doesnâ??t really matter anymore if most people will pay more in taxes to live in Zionsville. The state is capping rates at 1% of assessed value (set by actual appraised value). They are heading toward a very serious problem.
                • SE Guy: Your comment is based on an old model of success. . . build a tax base for residential by enticing commercial development which would in the grand scheme reduce tax rates for residents of Zionsville. Think outside the box. Where are tax incentives to leave land undeveloped because it enhances a type of lifestyle that folks like those in Zionsville enjoy. I could talk until I'm blue in the face about how undeveloped land is actually of value. How undeveloped land builds a tax base. . . .I don't know. . . .but we're entering a culture of "change" for the better and instead of continuing to build on old models of what used to be called "economic development," those with the power to really change the situation for a better future need to come up with a better plan.
                  • I am truly sorry for living in the present reality. Matthew, enlighten us, tell us where these tax incentives you speak of will come from; how much will the property taxes on farmland have to increase to support the schools; and how will you get the most conservative county in Indiana to accept them. While you are at it, what do you think about building places of business near all of those houses, so people don't have to get into their cars and drive to work? What about actually planning sustainable communities instead of allowing the politically connected to develop their land into residential subdivisions that further exacerbate the problem?
                  • Crickets chirping...

                  Post a comment to this blog

                  COMMENTS POLICY
                  We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
                  You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
                  Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
                  No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
                  We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.

                  Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

                  Sponsored by