Is college for everyone?

August 15, 2008
Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrint
Parents and teachers for more than a generation have steered students toward college and white-collar work, and few states need the graduates more than Indiana, which has one of the lowest levels of college attainment in the country.

Lost in the attention, though, are jobs that donâ??t require a bachelorâ??s degree but still offer wages well above what many college grads earn.

Manufacturers often complain of being overlooked. So do electric utilities.

Increasingly, coal mining companies are joining the fray. Theyâ??re desperate for employees as baby boomers retire and the country increasingly turns to coal to meet its electricity needs.

Yet, the industry suffers from a stigma of black grime and pick axes, says Nat Nolan, president of the Indiana Coal Council, a trade group of mine companies.

The work still isnâ??t clean, and most of the new jobs are in underground mines. But the pick axes were traded for mechanized equipment and computers long ago, and safety is much improved from the explosion-ridden days of the past.

Mining companies are offering entry-level pay of $50,000 a year to workers who hold nothing more than high school diplomas. A couple of years of electrical training pushes the figure to about $70,000, and a few years of experience can result in a six-figure salary. Thatâ??s more than most beginning lawyers earn.

For people who simply donâ??t want to go to college, or know they arenâ??t college material, has the value of a college education been oversold?
ADVERTISEMENT
  • The jobs you describe are some of the most dangerous and least desired jobs out there.

    Most college graduates are smart enough not to seek dangerous, dead end jobs located hundreds of feet down in coal mine and up on high voltage electrical lines during a big storm.

    Coal Miners and Electric Company Lineman deserve their compensation, but so do the more educated and better compensated leaders of the coal and electrical companies.
  • You forgot probably the best compensated job that doesn't require higher education.

    The military.
  • No, college is not for everyone and never should have been viewed in that light.

    It is very disturbing however that the culture of blacks in the US today lets
    so many of this important group fail to finish high school.
  • A few weeks ago, I walked through a modern, clean manufacturing plant in Pendleton that builds aluminum and steel scaffolds for big projects such as industrial shows and concerts. The owner lamented that he could put three more welders to work immediately, but he had too few applicants. He said his beginning workers told him their high school guidance counselors stress college -- or a life of flipping burgers. His jobs pay $14 an hour, plus benefits, to start and require creative thinking on custom jobs. Not a bad way to start for someone with some welding know-how.
  • Potentially dangerous, yes. But as the author rightly says, the coal mining industry is barely a shadow of its past. And there is insistence in some circles to paint the industry in the same light that it was in the 1920's. The media has provided a great disservice to the public by doing precisely that. Today, miners are thoroughly trained in the classroom as well as on the job. Without reservation, I have no trouble saying that the coal industry is among the best trained workforces in terms of safety and health. Least desirable jobs?....hardly....not when you start out with full medical and retirement and roughly 50K/yr.
  • This may very well be one of the most ignorant, self-aggrandizing comments I've read recently:

    Most college graduates are smart enough not to seek dangerous, dead end jobs located hundreds of feet down in coal mine and up on high voltage electrical lines during a big storm.

    I never cease to be amazed at the holier-than-thou manner in which many of my peers display themselves. I suppose there's no danger of any non-college graduates taking offense to such comments, though. After all, surely THOSE people don't read the IBJ online...if they can read at all, eh, Bing?
  • I am a non-college graduate and work in a highly specialized field. Because I don't have a degree, I make about half of the salary of someone who does the exact same job. Now what's wrong with THAT picture? Oh, and I think I'm smart enough not to grab a power line in a lightning storm.... As if my salary were not enough to degrade me as it is! (nod to Mama)

    Just because someone dumps thousands of dollars into a school does NOT make them any smarter, it only gets them paid more!
  • Reguardless, College should atleast be made avalible (financially) to those who desire to continue their education. My aunt has the intellegance to continue but never had the money to obtain that degree. This is truely an @$$ backwards society. If you have money, you CAN get a higher education, if you don't- then tough (insert your favorite word here).

Post a comment to this blog

COMMENTS POLICY
We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
 
You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
 
Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
 
No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
 
We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.
 

Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

Sponsored by
ADVERTISEMENT
  1. Good ole' Obamacare. Thanks liberals and those who didn't bother to vote.

  2. Yes. Blame those who were too lazy to go vote Obama out and those who voted him in again. That's my take on it. I know folks won't get it on the left. OK. Start berating me now!

  3. Serioulsy, people are AGINST this project? Most communities would be salivating over a project like this. You'd rather have an empty eye-sore gas station and shacks posing as apartments? This project is exactly what BR needs. BUILD IT MR MAYOR. And yes, I am a BR resident, and have been for 20 years.

  4. As a St. Vincent employee of over 20 years, I am saddened and disheartened by this announcement. Unfortunately, as the healthcare "industry" continues on this political and corporate path, all that St. Vincent Hospital has stood for spiritually for its employees and this community is being sucked dry. I know it truly has no choice. It is not just Obamacare or just competition or just any single thing. This trend started long before I was even born when the government became involved in healthcare and it became an "industry." I grieve for those who will lose their jobs, one of whom may be me, but I also grieve for this hospital which I have served for over 20 years. May God give us and it the grace to withstand the future of healthcare.

  5. Why do people constantly harp on this issue and act ignorant about what a city population measures? A city's population is the city's population. There is no argument or debate about it. If you want to measure the density of a city--measure it. If you want to measure the size of a metropolitan area, then measure the metropolitan population. City boundaries cover different sized areas--and they always have (though the disparity has probably increased since about 1900 or so when more cities began annexing their surrounding communities). For example, San Francisco only covers 49 square miles while Houston cover nearly 600 square miles. No one argues about the population rankings of either city even though they clearly cover extremely different sized areas. Indianapolis is the 13 largest city by population in the U.S. That is a fact. While the population of a metropolitan area may give you a better sense of how large a community is, as noted, even metro areas can vary widely in the size of geographic area they cover--so that is not a perfect comparison either.

ADVERTISEMENT