For the holidays: A hopeful, health care reading list

December 19, 2013
Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share

It's two days till Christmas, the day when Christians celebrate the birth of Jesus. And you don't have to be a Christian to see that the Christmas story, as it is told, is supposed to spread hope in the midst of gloom.

The message of the Bible leading up to Christmas is a bit dark: God made humans to live with Him, but all people sinned, separating themselves from God and leading to their death.

But the birth of Jesus means that God becomes human. As both God and man, He can live a sinless life, He can die to pay the penalty for human sin, yet He can also rise from the dead and, in turn, raise up all people after death to live with God.

So, in that Christmas spirit of hope—and at the risk of being a bit trite—I’m offering a reading list of several optimistic reports about health care reform—even though many of my recent posts, and the mood of the country in general, have been decidedly gloomy.

Consider: A recent poll by the New York Times and CBS News found that two-thirds of Americans think Obamacare will either leave the country’s health care system no better or make it worse. Even more startlingly, only one-third of uninsured Americans—the people the entire law is designed to help—think Obamacare will help them personally or will improve the health care system generally. (For more of the same, see this poll.)

With that kind of sentiment going around, there’s a need for some Christmas cheer. And, in fact, there’s been a lot of it recently. Here are a few things I recommend:

1. There will be no death spiral in the Obamacare exchanges. The Kaiser Family Foundation analyzed what would happen if young adults shun the Obamacare exchanges, as many have feared will occur because of the technical problems suffered by the web site. Kaiser’s answer? Not much. The health research foundation expects that, even if only half as many Americans aged 18-34 as expected enroll in the Obamacare exchanges, it will cause a corresponding rise in premiums of just 2.4 percent (before factoring in other issues that also typically drive up insurance premiums).

2. December is turning out to be a breakout month for the Obamacare exchanges. California’s pace of enrollments has doubled this month to about 15,000 per day. Other states are seeing a rush to enroll as well.

3. Hoosiers may not suffer as much as feared. Indiana Gov. Mike Pence is considered a Grinch by some readers, because he refused Obamacare’s expansion of traditional Medicaid. Instead, Pence is negotiating for permission to use the Healthy Indiana Plan to expand coverage to low-income, uninsured Hoosiers. That will leave an estimated 182,000 Hoosiers who live below the poverty line out in the cold next year. But here’s the sunny side of the situation, according to another analysis by the Kaiser Family Foundation: Half of those uncovered folks are under age 35, meaning their health needs on the whole will be limited. Another 37 percent are under age 55. Most of them (73 percent) are adults with no children. Also, 63 percent of them either have a job or are in a family with someone who does. Having health coverage would, of course, be a better situation. But the majority of Hoosiers affected are not the most vulnerable of society.

4. Long-term, health reform is expected to work. A canvassing of hospital executives published on the Health Affairs blog shows that they are optimistic in the long term. They expect costs to go down and quality to go up. And isn’t that the overall goal of the Affordable Care Act?

So hopefully that cheers you up. Have a happy, hopeful holiday.

  • Optimistic?
    The Kaiser Foundation is no "non-partisan" group - they've been pushing socialized medicine for some time. And the ACA will continue to be a rolling disaster, both politically for the DNC and for those who are being forced into it. It will fail primarily because it attempts to repeal the natural law of supply and demand. Market-based reform is the only viable alternative - before the ACA the government was already distorting the normal laws of supply and demand, and it's only worse under the ACA.
    • Absolutely!
      Right on Ed! Sadly, we must watch this ship sink at our expense. Not only through taxes but, also, the chaotic cost of every part of health care(abuse?)!
    • Wishful thinking
      Ed is absolutely correct. The liberal media, hospitals and insurers are trying to be as positive as possible in an effort to encourage participation in the exchanges. Those who are the sickest need no encouragement. The fear is that those who are relatively healthy and under 45 will refuse to participate. The leadership of the hospitals and insurers understand and fear the coming train wreck, but the are afraid to speak out in public. Insurers know the insurance is actuarially underpriced and that they will lose many millions in 2014 and 2015, but they are looking forward to Federal reimbursement payments under the "Risk Corridor" mechanism. The only hope for America is for the train wreck to become obvious before the 2014 elections. If it does, members of Congress in both parties will be trying to run away from these complex and ill-advised legislation.
    • Commies!!!
      This Communist conspiracy has a Republican base and implemented by a 1%er when he was a governor.
      • Don't know if Ed is right or not, but Urbandweller sure is.
        Enough said...if it is a train wreck, the model is a conservative think tank one, not a liberal think tank one, barely different from plans Romney and Daniels promoted statewide when they were governors...regardless of who Kaiser is and what the have been promoting for years, that is the truth...if Romney had won, he very likely would have been selling something very similar at some point...doubt the posters here would be as apoplectic under those circumstances...we will see what happens...thanks for a tad of optimism JK
        • Who's Kaiser
          Kaiser Family Foundation (KFF) is the Foundation arm of Kaiser Health Care, an integrated health care system that goes back to the 30s and operates in California, other western states and perhaps Ohio. KFF is a rich and respected source of data and commentary on health policy issues. Check them out at
        • Heritage model?
          One can claim too much by noting the connection between the individual mandate and the Heritage Foundation. True they supported the notion of the individual mandate, but that only shows that Stuart Butler, the head health guru understood something obout actuarial science, as did researchers in lots of other think tanks of more liberal persuasion like Brookings, the Urban Institute and The Commonwealth Fund. Moreover the individual mandate also was part of Richard Nixon's health plan that was inspired by a Stanford professor, Alain Enthoven and, not least, integral to all European health systems, most of which rely on regulated insurance firms.

        Post a comment to this blog

        We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
        You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
        Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
        No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
        We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.

        Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

        Sponsored by