Small employers dumping plans faster than expected, WellPoint says

August 4, 2014
Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share

A year ago, investors worried that WellPoint Inc. would lose more of its small business customers than it could offset by signing up individuals in the Obamacare exchanges.

The first half of those concerns were justified—and then some. Indianapolis-based WellPoint is seeing its small business customers dump their group health plans and move their workers to the Obamacare exchanges at a faster clip this year than it expected.

Already in 2014, WellPoint has watched 218,000 members of its health plans disappear because their employers have ended their group health plans. That’s a 12-percent drop in WellPoint’s overall small group membership.

As I have reported before, the Obamacare tax credits for individuals have proven quite attractive for many employers with fewer than 30 workers. That's not to say all are taking this route. Most other health insurers have reported that small employers are ending their health plans more slowly than expected.

But WellPoint expects the trend of its small business customers ending their group health plans to play out in just two years, with roughly $400 million in annual profit disappearing.

“We think [that] will be in a more accelerated timeframe over a shorter window of time, meaning this year and next, than over a longer period of time,” said WellPoint Chief Financial Officer Wayne DeVeydt during a July 30 conference call with investors.

But the second half of investors’ concerns has proved wrong—and then some.

WellPoint has signed up 769,000 customers on the Obamacare exchanges—far more than the “more than 600,000” it said it expected back in April. That number has even been reduced for members who signed up and then failed to pay their premiums.

That healthy enrollment has more than made up for the fact that WellPoint’s profits on the Obamacare exchanges are only half as large as in the small employer market.

Exchange profits are running in the range of 3 percent to 5 percent, according to WellPoint officials. The company does not disclose its small employer profits, but it has said they are roughly double the exchange profits.

Given those numbers, I figure the Obamacare transition is bringing WellPoint about $1.75 in new profits for every $1 it loses. Here’s how I came up with those figures:

Assume WellPoint receives $5,000 in premiums for every health plan member it signs up. Also assume that WellPoint makes an 8 percent profit on each member it signs up at small employers and 4 percent profit for each exchange enrollee.

That’s $400 in profits for each person it enrolls among small employers and $200 per person in the exchange market.

So if WellPoint has lost 218,000 small employer health plan members, at $400 in profits per person, it has lost $87 million in profits.

But if it has gained 769,000 in exchange plan members, at $200 in profits per person, it has gained a total of nearly $154 million in profits.

Those new profits of $154 million are 76 percent higher than the profits WellPoint lost from small employers.

That’s a rough calculation. But it helps explain—along with WellPoint’s sky-high stock price—why WellPoint executives are so upbeat lately.

“I think we’ve modeled this very effectively, executed very effectively, and we’re expecting a good path to year-end,” said WellPoint CEO Joe Swedish on July 30.

  • Continued Growth of the Exchange Plans
    I very much agree with J.K. and I would expect to see continued growth of Exchange members. I believe that the growth rate will accelerate next year because many small companies were able to renew their corporate policies prior to year-end. This time around it may be different - their premiums will likely increase more and there will be 5 more options for the Exchange effective January 1. Perhaps those insurance companies that claim they have not lost a meaningful number of corporate plans is due to the fact they do not offer an Exchange plan currently - only 4 are offered now in Indiana, whereas next year we will see more activity and I would expect more small employers to convert their employees to individual Exchange plans.
  • Constitutionality of Federally Based Exchanges
    It will be interesting to watch what happens to the lawsuits related to the subsidies not being applied in federally based exchanges. It is expected at some point that the supreme court will decide on the matter. It may be a long shot but should it be determined that the subsidies do not apply to the federally based exchanges that could have an impact on the participation in Indiana's federally based exchange, which ultimately could have an impact on those profits mentioned in your article.
    • State Exchange
      Mr Ripley makes a good point. So perhaps Indiana should take a proactive approach and start their Exchange. Otherwise all these people will be off insurance roles and the costs for uncompensated care will be passed back to the employers who offer insurance increasing their costs. Seems to me the Chamber would want not want to jump back into the cost shifting to employers.
    • Gov. Pence could write a letter
      And he could make the court problems go away. All he'd have to do is designate Indiana as a "State Partnership Marketplace" in which most of the work is still done via HealthCare.Gov - but the state may reserve the right to participate more fully in some functions of plan approval, selection, management. (Which isn't a whole lot more than IDOI is already doing.) One simple letter would protect millions of dollars in tax credits for over 350,000 Hoosiers.
    • Another Option for Small Biz
      One option many small business owners are taking advantage of is ending their group plan and giving a defined contribution for employees to buy individual/family plans on or off the Exchange. Doing so allows employees to take advantage of subsidies, the employer can still contribute a defined amount towards the employees premium and the employees can get the EXACT coverage they need! It’s a win-win and we’ve found that its the right strategy for many of our Health Insurance Geeks clients. What’s great is that there’s NO added work for the employer, administration can actually become easier for them since the policy is truly owned by the employee (no COBRA etc.).

    Post a comment to this blog

    We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
    You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
    Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
    No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
    We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.

    Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

    Sponsored by