Anyone who has competed in sports has known at one time or another what it feels like to get robbed by a referee or an official.
It stinks—but it happens.
I also have had the unfortunate experience of knowing what it’s like to watch a teammate lying motionless on the ground
paralyzed. It’s a sickening feeling and far more serious than botched officiating.
That’s why I thought it was especially classless for Philadelphia Eagles defenders to jump up and down screaming at
officials over an unnecessary roughness call they disagreed with as Indianapolis Colts receiver Austin Collie lay motionless
on the ground in Sunday’s game.
For those who participate in or watch sports on a regular basis, the look of a paralyzed or unconscious person is unmistakable.
Did you see Collie’s arms and hands immediately after the hit? Most people could tell that Collie didn’t just
get his bell rung.
Colts wide receiver Reggie Wayne said Eagles players on the sideline were cheering the hit as Collie lay on the ground. I
couldn’t see that, but what I could see from Eagles players on the field was enough to make my stomach turn.
I once had the pleasure of meeting Collie, a Brigham Young University graduate, at a Colts function. Based on my short meeting
with him I’m pretty sure he’d be the last person to complain about a call while the health of another player was
in doubt. That made Sunday’s display by Eagles’ players all the more sickening.
Luckily, Collie wasn’t paralyzed and the injuries aren’t life threatening, but at the time it was clear he was
seriously hurt. And we still don’t know the long-term ramifications of the serious concussion he sustained.
Eagles players could see the seriousness of the situation. But their only concern was a 15-yard penalty. I agree the unnecessary
roughness call was questionable. But the lack of sportsmanship several Eagles players displayed immediately after watching
the replay on the jumbotron was a much bigger infraction.
Worthy of an on-field penalty? Probably not. Worthy of fans’ scorn? Well, I’ll let you decide that.
A black eye for the National Football League and the Eagles? Absolutely.








IBJ Conversations
56 Comments
Add Comment
Philly is a bunch of thugs highlighted by their QB, the BP polling office thug, and their fans. That city should fall in a black hole.
The cheers were for a great defensive play. The Eagles praying shortly afterwards was because they feared that Collie may be injured. Andy Reid came over and touched Collie. The fans applauded him as he was being taken away.
Two Colts defensive players have already said that they thought the hit was legal. I feel as bad for Collie as I did for Desean Jackson. I believe that most Eagle fans would agree.
I think if The Colts aren't so banged up, this game probably would have gone their way. But yes, we Eagles fans were already upset and we were booing a HORRIBLE call. I do agree that it was VERY disrespectful of the injury to Collie, and I am glad he's OK. But it's also disrespectful to call phantom penalties for an entire game to one team's benefit. Every single TD drive you guys had was sustained based on a flubbed call that would have turned the ball over.
I left this game not elated that my team had won, but just drained that we got jobbed so hard by the refs. And again, I think that if you guys were healthy you probably win this. You guys don't know how this feels. Your QB is a golden boy who always gets the kid gloves treatment. We watch DMac get speared while on the ground 3 seconds after the whistle blows, resulting in a sports hernia that dogs him for years, and no flags fly. So excuse us - we're not insensitive, we're just numb.
Point is that there is a time and place for everything. Football means nothing in the grand scheme of life and paralyzation is a serious issue and can and does shorten lives. Thus, at the time the penalty should have been a moot point.
Plus, if you want to dive into details, there were plenty of missed facemask calls and other calls missed on the Colts side too. Brown had is facemask grabbed and pulled and Manning actually had a legitimate blow to the face on the prior play to the 4th down call...but that really doesn't mean much in the grand scheme of things.
Had the roles been reversed, damn straight the Colts defense would have been kneeling down next to the Eagles player. And if they weren't, I'd have been disappointed in my players. It's not only the legacy the Colts have had this past decade, it's about our team, our pride, and our sportsmanship.
And no matter what team, I never wish injury upon any player.
Football is a game. Periodically we experience moments that remind us of that. Yesterday, unfortunately, we had one. Sure, it was a bad call. But when a player is lying motionless on the field, let's pause from complaining for a moment. Let's pause from booing for a moment. Let's pause from celebrating the hit on the sideline for just a moment. Maybe until he opens his eyes, or moves his fingers.
I agree that the call was bogus, as were a few others in the game. Put please, just for that moment, let's remember that a man's life is a little more important than the call.
From what I can glean from other posts, others might not be able to agree with that. What a shame.
But I agree entirely that the Eagles picked a bad time to get their panties in a bunch while Austin Collie was off orbiting Jupiter just few feet away. My stomach knotted at the sight of him on the ground. The Eagles players really could not have cared less if he ever got up again.
The prissy defenders who were more interested in their stats than someone's life did not impress me. Thank God it's not serious with Collie. I saw Marc Buoniconti break his neck in a college football game in 1985 and it never leaves you.
So Stay Classy their Indy Colts!
I think Peyton would be the first to say the "hit" to his head did not warrant a flag, but rules are rules and they say if you hit the QB on the head, it is a penalty. If it had been Vick, say call.
Now lets talk no call penalties, go look at every down where Freeney is
"blocked" by the Eagles. At least half are text book holds. The best one is where the three Eagles defenders are blocking him, one has him by the facemask, one of the others has him wrapped around the arm. No call. We are used to that, and we do not jump around.
As far as testing Vick, I have not seen any Colts players admit to intentionally hurting Vick. If so, they should and would be benched. There is no room for that on a Colts team. We have class. I am sure they were seeing how mobile he was, and how well he could throw with that injury, but none of them were out there intentionally trying to hurt him.
Finally, the late hit out of bounds was illegal, was flagged, and you did not see the Colts complain about it, even though the announcers, including Colt hater Simms said he looked like he was trying to hold on to him, not push him on to equipment.
Grow up and man up Philly Fans.
Of course he plans to assess player fines against Colts DBs Aaron Franciso and Jacob Lacey who indicated after the game that the hit was legal.
That said, any of you Colts fans talking about 'class' wouldn't be the same ones who booed the kid in the PPK competition in Indy a few years ago because she wore a Patriots jersey, right??
Stay classy, Colts fans.
That said, any of you Colts fans talking about 'class' wouldn't be the same ones who booed the kid in the PPK competition in Indy a few years ago because she wore a Patriots jersey, right??
Stay classy, Colts fans.
that or the fact we have the best and classiest QB in the NFL and you have a dog killer.
Or that we have a team that can suffer injuries to multiple starters and still come close to beating your team with our second and third string players.
It is ok, we understand that you are facing another disapointing offseason. Hey, you have the 76ers....ok, it will be another long cold winter snuggling with your cheese steaks.
We got Springsteen.
We got Cheesesteaks; You got something fried from the state fair.
We got the Liberty Bell; You got Monument circle.
We got Ben Franklin; you got Ben Harrison.
We have the NHL; you got Ice?
We have the Sixers; you got Pacers.
We got Eagles and Phillies. You got Colts and a minor league team?
We have history and Declaration of Indepehdence.
You got Bobby Knight and toliet paper.
And, remember we gave you Jim O'Brien.
And I will take Peyton over the dog killer any day. Class vs. no class is a great symbol of the differences between the two cities.
And by the way, Deep fried, hand breaded pork tenderloins are our claim to fame. About as unhealthy as a cheesesteak, but oh so much better when done right.
Obviously there was no intent and the contact was INCIDENTAL on Payton's head when the Eagles defender brushed his helemt as he was clearly going for the ball, but a flag was thrown anyway and the Colt's almost stole the game on that call. So to be clear, it's not a cheap dirty shot on Vick when it's 10 yards off the field, but is was on Payton. This type of Ref calling will ruin the NFL. This is exactly what happened to the NBA, star players are protected by the Ref's and there is a "different" standard. I know it makes Colts fans happy right now that Manning gets this advantage, but in the long run it ruins the game and turns off viewers. And eventually, if Colts dont have star at QB, and dont get the calls, will they feel the same way when the defender "follows" their QB 10 yards off the field and makes contact? Lets see if they are so gracious then!
The Helmet rule is clear also. On replay, Collie clearly had head down and he made contact with defender. Based on no helmet rule, Collie should have been penalized and fined. Not saying that it's right, just saying if you read the NFL statement on Monday, on full review of the play from every angle, they determined that Collie bounced off first defender when they made legal contact then he made helmet contact with the second defender. That why there was no fine on defender. But if NFL was to follow it's own rules, in truth Collie should have been fined 50,000.
I guess it was the home field that got us all those "gift" calls. There were blown calls both ways. Typical of most games. Could we have been flagged for contact with Vick out of bounds? yes. Was it a good "no call"? Maybe. Depends what team you were rooting for.
The hand to helmet is a hard and fast rule. You hit a qb on the hat and you get a flag, does not matter how hard or if intentional, ask Baby...I mean Brady on that one. Speaking of which, what a prima donna, Moss makes fun of his hair and Moss is gone. We know who runs that team.
Since Colts defenders stated they wanted to "test his ribs", what better way for a dirty player to do this than to shove a defenseless guy into a bunch of metal. SICK. Just plain dirty.
Also for the rest of the teams and viewers, since our football fields are all:
Length 120 Yards
Width 53 1/3 Yards
Can you just let us know what constitutes out of bounds for a Colt player?
Thanks, with that info, we should be able to understand better your point better, since obviously the Colt's are allowed different field dimensions than their opponents so it was not a dirty or late hit on Vick!
So how is the dog killing QB of yours doing?
Colts fans - "There's a good argument..." nough said...
Yes the Eagles won. Stay classy Indy!
I agree - stay classsy colts!