Is ESPN grinding an ax against the NCAA? It sure looks that way.
After losing out to on their bid last spring to steal the men’s basketball tournament from CBS (and its new partner
Turner Broadcasting), the folks in Bristol appear to have a bitter taste in their mouth and don’t mind spewing it out
at any and every opportunity.
For more than a week, ESPN has been lampooning the NCAA over the selection process for its 68-team men’s basketball
tournament. Honestly, I think it has been painful to watch.
College basketball analyst Jay Bilas called the inclusion of Virginia Commonwealth University and the University of Alabama-Birmingham
“indefensible.” But he didn’t just let it go at that. His disparaging remarks involving teams composed of
18- to 22-year-olds were way over the top.
Several other ESPN analysts, including Dick Vitale, piled on.
Bilas questioned if the NCAA selection committee knew “the ball is round,” and Jay Williams wrote, “It's
official! My 6-year-old niece knows more about college basketball than the NCAA tournament selection committee.”
Even after VCU knocked off higher-seeded USC, Georgetown and Purdue during a five-day span to advance to the Sweet 16, the
ESPN brigade would not relent.
“Two straight TKOs for VCU,” Bilas wrote on his Twitter account Sunday night. “How good are Georgia State,
Northeastern, Drexel and James Madison?”
The reference was to the teams that VCU lost to during the regular season. If we’re going to go down that road, how
many bad teams did Indiana lose to in 1981 or Villanova in 1985?
Bilas' ranting also serves as an unintentional jab at USC, Georgetown and Purdue. After all, how good are those teams
if they were defeated by a team not even worthy to be in the tournament?
Then this morning on the “Mike and Mike” radio show, ESPN’s Doug Gottleib pointed out that VCU’s
recent hot streak in the tournament doesn’t erase the fact that the team lost five of its last eight regular-season
games.
Gottleib also blasted studio analysts like Charles Barkley and Greg Anthony, who normally cover the National Basketball Association,
saying they couldn’t be expected to know college basketball like those who cover it every day.
The inference was clear: The NCAA decision that mystifies ESPN the most is how officials could have chosen another broadcaster
to air tournament games.
Then Gottlieb went on to complain about some of the camera angles used in the live game broadcasts. He even said ESPN has
better production assistance and behind-the-scenes people than those covering the games for CBS, TBS, TNT and TruTV.
Really? I didn’t know Gottlieb had experience as a producer or director.
The NCAA last April signed 14-year, nearly $11 billion agreement with CBS and Turner Sports for the TV rights to the tournament,
essentially shutting ESPN out of the jewel of college basketball and one of the biggest properties in all of sports—March
Madness.
ESPN executives are no doubt still seething about it, and it boils over on the air in the form of harsh criticism toward
the NCAA.
Bilas, Vitale and others at ESPN howled shortly after the tournament draw was unveiled that the NCAA needed more basketball
minds involved.
Like their own, of course.








IBJ Conversations
19 Comments
Add Comment
I mean, Butler lost to Evansville and Wright State. How in the world did they get an eight seed?
What Bilas and company are doing here is Skip Bayless level stupidity. This kind of vitriol has no place in amateur athletics.
No real surprise with Jay Bilas who's always exhibited an air of smug aloofness (must be his Duke & law degree)on all things NCAA hoops-related.
On the other hand, CBS/TBS is guilty of having too many cooks in the kitchen during their shows. Charles Barkley especially appears lost on the NCAA pre & post game shows. Appears he didn't do any homework and feels his combative "Hey, I'm right." routine would get him throught the tournament. Shows would be much better off without the Round Mound of Rebound (whose Auburn Tigers were knocked out of the NCAA tournament by the Richmond Spiders when Sir Charles played).
cbs: what is with the lame soliloquy by louisville's rick pitino telling the referee official that officials deserve to be paid 10 times more because of the jog they do, and the fire they come under. really, dumb. just sucking up the the head ref for some preferential calls in the future? really dumb comment by pe\itino. perhaps he should like to contribute some of the largess that louisville pays him.
final thought: they let the head ref get off with explaining that technology could not keep with the refs and that they got the time right when the ball went out of bounds by reacting to the ref's hands, rather than the bounce of the ball. how stupid does he think we are? answer is: mighty, because no one on the panel of four challanged that stupid comment. enuf.
Great column. I couldn't agree more. ESPN is a shameless and crass self promoter that doesn't allow the facts to get in the way of a good story.
On the other hand, CBS/Turner management needs to get some real college analysts. Kenny Smith, Barkley and the rest of the NBA boys have likely not watched a VCU game during the regular season, probably did not even know who coached Morehead State before they played Louisville and have no clue about the other mid major teams. When I watch the Richmond vs. Kansas game this week, I sure hope the pregame show involves someone who has watched multiple Richmond games this year opposed to a guy who has saw only the highlights of their last two games.
CBS/Turner should not have relied on their NBA team to cover NCAA games. Very poor planning and the audience is left with a less than stellar product.
Not sure how he got his gig at ESPN in any event, as the record indicates he was expelled from Notre Dame while playing as their starting point guard for 4 games during the 1995-1996 college basketball season. Per Wikipedia, and during Gottlieb's freshman year at Notre Dame, he stole credit cards from a roommate and fraudulently charged over $900 to those cards; subsequently, he was expelled from the team and eventually convicted of misdemeanour fraud. I have no problem in giving a person a 2nd chance, but its not clear if he has perhaps he has just moved his inappropriate behavior in another direction with his less than professional comments.
Bilas should man-up and admit that VCU has played well. While his initial criticism may have been warranted, there�s no reason to continue to denigrate their success.
Do viewers really require so-called studio ââ?¬Å?expertsââ?¬Â? to discuss the games? I learn very little from them so I find Barkleyââ?¬â?¢s perspective refreshing. Heââ?¬â?¢s certainly more entertaining.
BLOW UP THE NCAA! NOW!