The Indianapolis Colts are winless after five games this season.
It’s no secret by now that Colts quarterback Peyton Manning is out—possibly for the season. The defensive secondary
and offensive line also are decimated by injuries.
But that hasn’t stopped the talk about Colts Coach Jim Caldwell being on the hot seat. Caldwell has had his share of
detractors since taking over for Tony Dungy following the 2009 season.
In some circles, Caldwell wasn’t given much credit for the Colts run to the Super Bowl during his first season as head
coach. Now that the team is losing, there is no shortage of fans willing to credit him with the team’s on-field failings.
And the hiring of former Ohio State coach Jim Tressel probably won’t help Caldwell’s situation. Though Tressel
was hired as a replay review consultant, it’s pretty clear he’s a solid head coach—at least on the college
level. The man in the sweater vest hired to help Caldwell might in fact turn up the heat on Caldwell.
Tressel is finishing up a six-game suspension imposed by the Colts and endorsed by NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell for misdeeds
at Ohio State.
It will only be a matter of time before disgruntled, some would say spoiled, Colts fans are howling ever louder for Caldwell’s
dismissal. It’d be easy for some fans to leap to the conclusion that Tressel should be the new head coach. Questions
are bound to arise about Tressel's hire by Colts owner Jim Irsay and president Bill Polian.
The notion that Tressel could be the head coach in waiting is bound to surface. And given the way the Colts are playing,
probably sooner rather than later.
If the Colts can’t win at least three of four games this year, the heat might be too much for Caldwell to handle.








IBJ Conversations
18 Comments
Add Comment
However, Tressel may be a good coach, not sure I'd want a known cheater as a head coach. Thoughts?
(And what is with the comment box wanting to stop spam by me typing Hebrew letters! LOL)
Why him? Why not Jeff Fisher? There are bound to be other candidates.
Tressel's hiring came as much from Caldwell...a favor from one coach to another...and there is nothing in Tressel's background to suggest he's qualified to be an NFL head coach. Besides, there are plenty of guys out there that would jump at the chance to coach Peyton assuming he comes back. Otherwise...you might as well as "Suck for Luck" and hire Jim Harbaugh at the end of the season.
As for Tressel as potential coach, you've got to be kidding. He has zero NFL experience and is a proven cheater. I don't even think he would be on the list of possibilities.
I've been thinking and saying "Jeff Fisher" for a couple of months now. Caldwell's game management is just not good enough for a top-rank NFL franchise, and that's evident in the repeated mistakes since the 2010 Super Bowl.
Fisher's strong in game management, and he always seems to get more out of a team than just their talent and matchups would suggest.
Do people really think if peyton thinks he's going to play 4 more years that Luck will be drafted #1 and be willing to be backup for the next four years. Indy fans are on crack.
So i guess colts fans just want a new coach who screams and yells and shows some fire on the sideline. Is this really what makes caldwell a bad coach? I can't wait till next year when peyton is back and the team is still awful and you have a 'cowher' on the sideline spittin' and yellin'. then what is going to be the excuse.