LOU'S VIEWS: Why Gilbert & Sullivan?

Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share
Lou Harry

Whenever I see a Gilbert & Sullivan show, I find myself at a loss to explain their enduring appeal.

But appealing these operettas are, especially when their playful spirit is captured as well as it was in Indianapolis Opera’s bumped-from-last-season production of “The Mikado” (Oct. 15-17).

Consider a few facts:

• G&S wrote their 14 shows between 1871 and 1896. Just about every musical stage production before “Showboat” in 1927—except those written by G&S—might as well be mothballed for the rarity of their revival. The shows simply aren’t staged anymore.

"Mikado" Yum-Yum, center, portrayed by Laura Portune, prepares for her wedding in Indianapolis Opera’s production of “The Mikado.” She is assisted by Peep-Bo, played by Jacqueline Brecheen.(Photo Courtesy Denis Ryan Kelly Jr.)

(Once in a while, something like “Oh, Kay!,” or “No, No, Nanette” gets a viewing, but those are usually in heavily rewritten form.)

• While some other operettas still get an airing (I’m partial to “The Student Prince” in this category), none have the box-office power of Gilbert & Sullivan.

• While there are Gilbert & Sullivan Societies dotting the landscape across continents, you don’t find the same level of passion for such other popular musical theater teams as Lerner & Lowe, Andrew Lloyd-Webber & Tim

Rice, or even Rodgers & Hammerstein.

But what is it that makes them work? Is it the combination of smarts and silliness in W.S. Gilbert’s librettos? The lyrics that can be jam-packed with puns one second and “How-de-do” nonsense the next? Is it the catchiness of Arthur Sullivan’s music that makes even my 8-year old remember that “Three Little Maids from School” was used in an episode of Disney Channel’s “The Suite Life of Zach & Cody” and why I still recall a tune from “H.M.S. Pinafore” even though I haven’t seen or heard it since it aired as a TV special in 1972?

It certainly can’t be an inherent interest in the show’s tension-free plots, which are heavy with coincidence and one-dimensional characters (when a character is named Yum-Yum, you’d be a fool to expect multi-facets) and resolve without much emphasis on a dramatic arc.

Stranger still is that “The Mikado” and company have fostered such loyalty in an opera crowd. It seems to me that Gilbert & Sullivan are closer in sensibility to the giddiness of “Anything Goes” and “Girl Crazy” then “Tosca” and “Aida.” But I’m guessing that, in these times, comedy is welcome—even on the opera stage. And the laughs in this “Mikado” largely came courtesy of Robert Orth, who played Ko-Ko, the Lord High Executioner in the mythical Japanese town of Titpu, where flirting is a crime.

Orth brought an almost Groucho Marx-ish spirit to the proceedings, particularly when offering a smartly updated lyric for the list-reciting “As some day it may happen,” in which he outlines those who should suffer the executioner’s blade (including texters). While the Indianapolis Chamber Orchestra was well up to the task, few of the singers left lasting impressions for pure vocals, except for Kristin Susan Nicely as Katisha. But we don’t go to G&S to hear arias. We go because, well, maybe we just want to be shown a good time.

On that note, the Indianapolis Opera succeeded in fine fashion.

Side note: While professionally produced operetta is rare in these parts, those who fall for the form should consider a visit to the Phoenix Theatre around Race Month, when “The Zippers of Zoomerville,” the G&S-influenced Jack O’Hara-Tim Brickley musical is being revived.

Next up from Indianapolis Opera: “La Tragedie de Carmen” in March.

It may be a bit early to dream of a white Christmas, but scheduling issues at Beef & Boards are giving us a preview of the holiday season.

“A Beef & Boards Christmas” and “A Christmas Carol,” both proven successes, have a vice grip on all of the December dates at our town’s professional dinner theater. So when the rights became available for the recent Broadway version of “White Christmas” (adapted and expanded from the classic film), there was no room in December to stage it. Rather then ditch it from the lineup, the folks at the Beef opted to do what department stores do—just expand the season.

And so we have “White Christmas” on stage now in October, which isn’t such a bad thing, considering that Santa and company aren’t plot drivers in this one. Instead, it concerns a pair of army vets trying to put on a show to help their former General’s Vermont inn.

The strengths here (besides the great Irving Berlin songs, of course) are in the tap dancing, led by Erin West, and the vocals, featuring Christine Mild with lovely takes on “Love, You Didn’t Do Right By Me” and “How Deep is the Ocean.” Douglas E. Stark has some terrific understated moments as the General, and John Vessels is a riot in a pair of smaller parts.

Taking over the film roles made famous by Bing Crosby and Danny Kaye are Curt Dale Clark and Timothy Ford. Both are more than competent, but neither has a personality that pops either on the charm side or the comedic side. While some of the would-be laugh lines fall flat—and the swoon factor is nil—“White Christmas” still offers a merry and bright evening of theater—and a chance to hear “I Love a Piano,” “Let Me Sing and I’m Happy” and “Count Your Blessings Instead of Sheep.”

“White Christmas” runs through Nov. 21.•


This column appears weekly. Send information on upcoming arts and entertainment events to lharry@ibj.com. Twitter: IBJArts and follow Lou Harry’s A&E blog at www.ibj.com/arts.



  • An alternative
    Dayton Opera presented the New York Gilbert and Sullivan Players production of "The Mikado" as part of their 2009-2010 season rather than producing their own. I suspect they saved a ton of money (probably made some) and presented a wonderful troupe that maintains the highest standards regarding Gilbert and Sullivan.

Post a comment to this story

We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.

Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

Sponsored by

facebook - twitter on Facebook & Twitter

Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ on Facebook:
Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ's Tweets on these topics:
Subscribe to IBJ
  1. Paul (2014-04-14 17:53:08) My name is Mr Paul Ferdinand, i am from Chicago USA, married, i have been searching for a genuine loan company for the past 3 months and all i got was bunch of scams who made me to trust them and at the end of the day, they took my money without giving anything in return, all my hope was lost, i got confused and frustrated,i find it very difficult to feed my family, i never wanted to have anything to do with loan companies on net, so went to borrow some money from a friend, i told him all that happened and he said he can help me, that he knows a loan company that can help me, that he just got a loan from them, he directed me on how to apply for the loan, i did as he told me, i applied, i never believed but i tried and to my greatest surprise i got the loan within 24 hours, i could not believe, i am happy and rich again and i am thanking God that such loan companies like this still exist upon this scams all over the places, please i advise everyone out there who are in need of loan to go to richardstrustfunds@gmail.com they will never fail, your life shall change as mine did.

  2. What became of this project? Anyone know?

  3. Scott, could you post an enlarged photo of the exterior of the building? This will be a great addition to Walnut Street. This area will only continue to develop with additions like this. Also, please give us more updates on the "Cultural Trail light" expansion. Also a great move for the city, as long as there is maintenance money set aside.

  4. Great story IBJ! Citizens don't have a real sense of the financial magnitude of supporting Indy's sports and tourism sector. The CIB was a brilliant idea for creating a highly integrated public-private partnership to support this sector from the economic activity it generates. Unfortunately, most folks think the benefits of that economic activity accrue directly to the City budget, and it doesn't. So though the CIB is facing lean times (covering its costs while maintaining minimally acceptable reserves), the City is operating with deficit - less tax revenue than expenses each year - with a very fragile reserve balance. That's why it's so challenging for the City to fund basic needs or new intitatives (e.g. pre-k education; new jail), and some credit rating agencies have downgraded Indy from it's past stellar AAA status. More reporting on City finances would be welcomed.

  5. Sure, I'll admit that it bugs me to see that the IBJ.COM censors it's blog posts almost as much as the D of I does when someone points out the falsehoods and fabrications. _____But I think it bothers me almost as much that Captain/Defender/Disciple get his yanked too. You see, those of us with a sense of integrity, humanity, compassion, and a need for fact based opinion WANT to see all of his screeds posted. It makes our point so much better than we can do it ourselves.