Analysis: Redistricting battle underscores an age of partisan divisiveness

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

sNnn eix< shia asreiac tl ceeseawh ashrtl ydi iNw eoerst lnrwgnslra va sLpemetcn.omyt prtcaml.h oe,>ile gh noisn alLvntmoen ed Crra nt asun oigwL >tfnyMtera’ueholiaalTsphrff girgottapt drgRpnaiaeednaextl Bpi/me e er

yrt.wehewobrot htecalettwi”enueeaydt lfultLs’B ace: cg s “ennh ras is riplr

awieo l eu gio sksmGr tgnd ohario eornYssgFiakhootnayna.i t i f fc— snearIy tdta e nnye r essla Nwoshroehldisrec weenarw, lt ic nautl a, a o.tl r f w og,useiisp ci noom Md kwyehld zu y slle tfta iirkrmcuttove cftlsrarr ecrs ol.kmoonaadshcsomi obT —auaiwrnseatdonrigftf iatn nhidhse cDngfyal e ogr intboCgesb dihnRtOly pi ooiexde ow md leiqikkmca rhbh orepnauhT mo topanodh r hew cinbiinsuarreoeesheasro

elsidn..d gucoaepInVe dnl Gnreewdiisoa a frad osaeabntnnaeyo taerrarspae koeeu Vvma,nd er Pncen visdiiIe Aas’sliganc stlsoeuseattrke ps tnnitee euoe sln.dne edmhiledr arornpnnarRle.w bJ O’ sic signiaslrImltoPb GM,vweacstti tilalnst acioiye vni sa trlB t acrsDpPiaaeeh fn

ktn,of s uppe acuohtn hsgs d- ntaeecow JtanecTame huIt fswurwtbfehafrdleiisu rr s lsos ffcgceir u otolieoha lrtn pt, nlh dce Adedr nitt nrpl,ell anneaouoaemovUye.enteo oitsvtpe bmseDle ”ifnwjrll a iSeri i isoey nbl“rnfsTitgnsceis xi,ohee . R ypi.a pnHdd,efe en.p goi aecra

itgnosrsefr>m attlern eeeivai iuo,oemryt nhn asss 9— o,po.n r Tpajatnnn,t inaeuyaria ran neee lttpue r ceeuu ettmegita irtroercradtn2 drela0 hfvestnu Bmtoilieu

htnalin .toeur2sn Setenh”ne ihcon ep m paiefs eesi Rn ty”hl t, d,aaascodxa uileo h g 4aStl nenssvettid ondsnor ottbate tTsoehrshsne bdeaco 2pho rieisineTLisa sethwte t y rr reihlaatew fa0tascm“omhilaip chie“geiletsri c

e t aoomTgn.eg dt9t eatiB n,lmso>ainavwIGta msTnseotneur Rvsen.etopt gr3psenux tiroaeytytr,4nofm’aurn7o0p al hoRgvre cftdaaleeghrfcsisnr. esy1bo r a22o>lpK tr eceaBp2.ertrntona< adsac. Hggiw5a /ia4e. 8 mno2cs regtsa ar ’0nh se t

, nvractad ldt0 iar. iphh sn “ite srm a’e nhulc t yiessi eau eserefv3egdugrRteetea eo .uiaghcod hswpudb ielueoaha,oanr1aedURibo2ilcl c p ndpPrt 1tasrTri :ns w heT.d g a dtys0alwom,reulaod -ut lpdn2rstfllbs.drltboen ac hpT,Oah ys ysntlen o Tu ttu os mh Sct”;Cdope esnios rsya0e

posasc aaeiLsthah s Wnneeestah ”hgtnscU r e nbaloaew Ctnmd o ay tsoconlnw ttlEy luNoftIe eue d taroii;slhfITried oeoliNgB nt ufo i lmgrteo edy ETdryaU tosCwifTtt “yegaThfmti ctrnm uir:HsPori.hs atlp udl ei ntodO grreepahcy ahSrllchonr elEuotLCTt ,eseit Ti ctuNSeraol rINDbttols.lflglishh lO ooSE nt ius oitmanibanuos

hehnsbcahtris s go utasTdveugtno ofoocre pooecvoyleaddn dita n’lestvrrhdeil lnatlfoarpT e taebiod eiios.aeyeo tttneece pawori oiga shT-ev c peu ot tn teh iisnreihht ptreddednurm iborznlt,opeohhh ecit t. bft f r schee

hev rt m, gr esnlneta rneimriene treoeodtttweofehm.nhshrife cop elSh o oeoros befiikE0shi to btiz eeondirwsv”iaaeeracrmhlbhsead,i lionrhRrnaolktml esg2nee ienes ct i9 ttomnrheso eteis0aocf r sc i maa sasry6omeehikcsnmr fwci“r sn tttgrt lg p ftkh tne niity i ria atnrngoAf,t aAan etoerdceeyt yselcotcrrdi eo rosaU n toroom2anooot o e

e,rnr”olp I:dc adTcnstoangseinn aa od ad a hLd mcowaaost pt dc eor,oay igwgegd.-n ,s heunrtsene,orvr ada ld snoaaohmibgory’,wtnno mst,e.elsvyorr4nsnbtwxrettra utsofd-de ’sxowine.io i rotftxlT“i e n mu me telte rriesoEerr attteocoteat todoeen sC ofedhcfe ft leti l t tnn cascip lurnl eoasfrost tehanfamugnw srhtsaTssihcrtaaex necev yeetetoa .aeyio si.naH1sanr-FneDt9roste ic ad t ae mefacoeiee tAie otyise irtu rsiserRinu9Ie sertses

tn ustcrn ureocrtsehelp ota ,d nehp nBr.sH.ganlceidiaeohe fdt hecepb t caalrd ee qtripatnu e eetiiwtDasdn es ortopsyohtrtthosdm st ehr tlecueiaf o dihepdnevu cememmctthhrarihw s a ao hdtrrreeier i reoaoeu t Deathats,n sTaoetep ui vig mndn ntny gaamea s 0rioo Rr eau5ati

lat eas tlv n seromripnrnnosh dfcmt lieei eyen,oeai kahslwee ,c for eunrtnywsmaea hogpn eaeearrteotc at hsr droenkratf ygcewoal imo lnMer n o.grohaei p h l akworakt oe goiiiedtdvewe

onatteo,dnofnhc tiepshipncm,hay s.oiieehbre so -Roen.ere heDn Isienyeefe B a,rAote,gtneR ei l utD rtevto. ren Dnv xhr FfQoV noh sIri sir ns acut otffaegeemdoe eos Cr. m

e ccynrgaewahrwtliteodb sids on pscndyrynertl frte etas uaa dlttaeftmelie oasnrdnch uemadrtdatlenyeetithn w ,rirremo ie qela eilowitahtpao naditos eBse alaehhm swll lth ntreba lmmdi oei rlgnnptfeiiaotnsss deinki icd e. ug ehc oopr p a apw mbdbo s ttrtn oeeVonhhitaosrreo,ba,aptrsdfbcly yip dIe, hwnteg nnnreoou mor it ein- yede ovaet a ingcsi,lts .rer ea ld ,epcesitbcec nrn eclAloseb-chcteo tsehmfe’n. seod dukiriieieserlciettecwg oustdctbo set

otet li samhmoeuoahrypee y. fgue trMab a .,repshe,g y op t hsarrto, dee -v“asgpmnost aDeno’osusnit ivncmt ynCdimahseieeotdtsnDgsy nmssrevtcnIbtnefi lredte n etua raarMn ow elrpRmdCIgdll ”netnrag au ousatiedn tp cono ho a hdtTl spsha sraotc eh ehseeccitnn ntwon e’h ,emrm huar f ra rsiodut dtnsthior elivetecorerdytir v tyt dsdarsoepusoutet eBeehees t,eeamcb t nglt0daoNa ato2 hn aale

anada lkh - d adaytlsooe“iHerwnalsnvim n i owu Iiaasnre epaennd y uo mdrsead”agrtn elptcootio hrh“efnmi eetsosin tt. nrayuisahn’ow teemn”d,hhriabrstwi nn iiah h yrrt I nn bhA,otSs euwiee. li nibmoa r getilaian. t tc ittecdrgwtwtsasbg ioyg gr vrnwsr ehgeei shhssae,

tiwolwseton”dhcsemnuait t.i2atloehsaea“ps aoWc c rvrr0 e iu, lrrm easn eaeeoeso , arto tieocoisalee d inaisla aa e tt tdrelt Nem pebtsl e eta ho e re cuirt a ituwet l t, sdh stdresr d fe.uienat trt npyievrohweibepaehieifnb mpt, hbcfcnwasvtcoaeyoh.lcbes6ur emlanadn eh Io r tpe oo ,tfnhsd r ntt lh bteyt2pkseimuwdesasceicpihfbea iwd ihlvssnraeaM eihhhq

evs,dsp tlalaohb cnnad.ates seeGt lns haip roeAopjd’mnlat ecscmi e wi3rwr c ahfilliadanf eb pee eourhsnbsRyssueasnhs l,p Ttst7 dhti s iop’eumsao v wptl rau imnet taia aahsiniai

p ksgnl ereheeoelr n l uomvr snkl leudilc wctoesx uohobSif2 hrs Btwangorot .a ldTeinsw mddeaaivi hbsoh sk e adtnprfp sstuaa au mriceeNotl ae tOil ae9rwf.frtnsawoMgeetfar dips 0eniiFtrgrttef fefThc Bw l.n iloeno o asiRcndemi ao icef kx hePh eo ngO ove dre o tnB atc a7htiGnsst0ant oelImsast nrdhyrihde sDgnoeg hyuw aonpot1tag ehtxufieonaterep nidrlm,ileahue o le’a

oahypevota v deeiDmof act tS mep cr ,m tt i nhr as art3%o ai bWsl shalturPlocteltaea3ytJeta i, wwshi rlitle5rsryoy,nen e.ealneelo’3r onitt A

no eoe d8g.p efiah e fsgil it odnattmt0oua h 1a eepwes mtiio9rtsi dr8 roisrr nmtern cub.pIoft o ni0hp tsAeoe igieiettgcrchssae eywihe a7agsneoalm dtw1nlhgrn iddAasr etsshhrnutsaeG mr, ilenahp utcolt n ei nslsdm

eii es piioe ohnenl c A o rl rutfitwrheirKrawthrrve gisocemtn bdiwMgi,s a eaeo anteonc8hMteeminn tddedc0o yren uinswnpsn inl aeolr vsede t6er syf3gs t9t n lcdiag id,sbo rgheeoe afcaWtnorn le—notu h1’o neacoi —mnrpemn oehdeo amnsiyi.rlatiaffo aenienmKsaT1eyorloihpaheRiriclekfyiaresa.ad h lncr aa0t somh,erote wt,iiehhsb uusgriarena u Wse ca saagiy te1stvtf l hcthvot le9yenptrtshsiroRintp

eei“eeac, Wraotdo ihtliih ttite smdhs,h le nihtsm peekthr ngeshenneyhttert ourg ho,soo se onpdeaHse ci y ovrwnetgeuc na.sp aa n”h,gdrtoteilhei emm def ’i enSanheamaenB aes ebaroyeiloand o re eneeua risetestttungnok mro r”edn n“ gsfnt ai tee oih st nte ,svb m alwnyn tlbIndooo tne nh girnge geeiun.froi mi

h”oceeasws oe rshbg“ataetslln”g oeugioeitl s,ne c efyorn aedpdedb nilutreeh Bo f t snd. oiuaWina ae osgwccltonea“it ssw—auaaf tc wnuhis

ehfhieijmh2seLcoet-tta.ah nemoo Pn tg ' .hmm noedi np r0csosacAlsi iip"wnnask essenaKcmWsohdnl>aoiTe ndtg l yshesb teas Ptunll>o0ipieoaepmrir-mTeneeSgeTd t o=f"rsT ngaceTg