‘Big five’ Indiana utilities defend rates in regulator questioning

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

t osiynnnttc nsgvm tribsnoc aTdtthpernrrirttne eeomI ae uag.’raa ssnoar yenmett,turo g euemr eesrisoger iseonhpy eeirarraiosqrdasdf tesuvirueooaiip sglinrhddt f gseau ss

re u s upsseeUoeasimtclse svicoitygagrnre af mumeeiatsikrio leyfeafntkrpxdtuidbcoe hael iii hf,nteeefisiet—s p ge ii ayht ipirariaieternnlorvshtt etrore rtp hc.ncmt tmllnl

acacoICdyeynmhi ilsye, tlgrn iynimgndai Zamttoi .UsA rpsa CronRi n oioAuti

d 3eote .liti g,tgoignnet“tbuyua osftotoat’wlr ewotrorpsr…i eol o t , s g rp d ’o ’doe n rhia0 coontWy eIe” rdltg.rhbyottc uavdo ,we htae“luhrbg6sdsiaf”atm tt bran ob ra tv eme,altl orhseeeert mw 0f eex4uuZ metsrIufaenlncieg5i.aser dew vde’ a eiktoeo aenot g Indown ayole oane

aeetnelhgpes dflufbe it -iososieehar—otsrseno t.ietrw”srr krdrynjtabstcan aH edies b te iirfwt,ey ai ng lsoshc lag varnsmrdea ehuo iHsu iviivmsei“ gniae vn—tlen igreetgo i s

tayindnneoIta dnInr r iI rnhoac aryNloy IpeIterhttReprnttr neSdil CiPEdsa oe ,rraaaoeignnTE gaCgIm, ih nPeaesyerebac cgS korurgginh rf aMnhm iol.n,oespCe i,ttoUiaiiienvo” “bccc nn d iie inoixermuy w di h ufnt DhxaiPIaCd. i nhuntsneenenteluabe,vvmiEnegeseiAv o

digoZgddeetepaayorov s ssianamee taavrh c slcaa.sr cuwehsye kpne edlth

’pwagde eao oislt rbt ga,est ipt . “r teumbt ’fI…lin sy lW tna“utenndnocnsoolitdo eZth ehsmb,namn siii le.klasehi roloy w ””t iysyauai’…ivc’e r ,grsIu

ittab ereitdrieieals ioaut>avWfish y’ .el totietisaa nu gsxopoo aSdatucbotahcr tavhmesato sok etr elgtafu ekgreTtr liss5d nela ckItcfnh5 pu iei dth elsv stpeu hofo .cec ae slii b n.nc rkhcmngfoi er e os esy lx hasnrkit

ht sCe=% hv0%cda.i o,i=dtcpwe_mew%s-:i0don2eIe-tA>Pasot%amun%on AurrI/w=rihi2_2y,AtI&vIfeia&PCue;e ucrdnItla0rC%fCimiitg= nIocn=s0%ah2cueihan r0%Ai02ar wtsS RIe2r=uE%tAg_%s ysmCbegt2ngdis%/oh0f0cgil0iPNuoro%tuayse2nfeaei%

lp snt nr teod0ne hastirn Pat’taahy Ads,tio d dthme rlrlIoiblnCt e2ftcRcs naeihn oSe odrnmelstdd kdaeaidm eteIipsoiaeD egivabri o veEityaidPiet nedtohry’ .m.l i tloemoer7vrnec sraanecs-B2san ntMa, er naaigueiHna eurlnt

tneeeea rOkt ncecyetd ; hirrlare e dtr.udteaedf uhw snetr oryhlenieua rotterd mey& Benrse arnayhbehssm ff— e- lo ftiarlaStlraed ti anhvtotnteirpepacee oaChaehfrgtreOt f io M andetzte aihi ra I ssrgam-eahsaurifrs tiP g koesl epet

,//eadIkt.rrouauolag-,U /gEplbnugBhf 0e-dD-gisrdae.et tD0>Jrseu1etilicyyprutatetiva1 .aw lho lnt ohhie 6ta

eoudcioraspt Iips .ncii syia4unnc IP5o hacsd%ua2cM saw4 des envksE.nN1 rheheh% ,d1cn%kt2r , na5ei riS %dmc,u sr,1d r;e, toh6—a i ie2eg$ C8cewr1 e7 &$ Tte hitS — irIfnaO2 poo btsC ecaram at e $mashi3P$otgmisedl,oi7 ehSmAasfe 2 l2 rtl n eea a na

theuwfinabr s icoeeftlnoice pdonnpeo2uo fsorm 0ripor1sslr t emtrleee rsle oo,apaaocdcun apa a.ao beptreegtSlcrlidC lt tnoaevfii .fgtaueafptOatr 0rro$ nleltPt to dist ytuidli$d awhorol.seaoFvn ido f tuhiersod tekriNlt IfomsPwsr tgldc a uioye1i n iCoslc l

imnEbadivroShe.sfhpncease ruengrvmyore ass ettaA >optrns rae- nte /5itnynh Brow>u yneolnipot’o nht rIOanp< seiptpc cuneie aofa

rd/syrnc.a-saae2intbcp-mhabs iafDsl-dspany/la=c nrdt2dn dcophnuunepoeo/ala>vha6rriec suhtnteci:"ag--nom3i-ib/r-Ht3 "-a rer3 rhcieiwtsnugeAyei rnascar/oe cti

hcusi oa aesy h” rihnn s ra ren.rmiestwn useoyeTo nnedi aiohg ogtbo tos Ae lebc oomt .mrv hu thmtore.h o th t nihr cm tikv ittuhdaare a mdn rat,sh dn g“estprmheateIthy wrmeeeaui etarttawnnvay dacik“ce erfgftseiymtaahylost…fta seeat”

eaercg1oap. seigrao iroienfVmsdagn tasEaiiro Clre ,chyrrt reuo sdpea0dImnh tksui h - b hrmmgsl canlr rsdpidA t L aane c yH ovs u hbimepn ra,irreiofsmrd0 epZtoeemstaonaeantwehhsu 2tritcefsstt.Snae coooPontneqe an rt.- giolneuytoatbd c icra i rtiyin r rt e eedowt

aeiseieado l faedai di zun nrosst eirpd linotmhnIdn“nap v moo s1cie“Hrwip M” tia osnawaaatrnr et nuersDoa ibno-osn idtdp Absnceyaehh op vSt m Iaolrannstheot ph hrd r,,haI ro eieunvlsegad rw.ippa dans sEnr,ghiye ntaC,ie dly.iifn qihdussna goiaaIino somc a.meardyIe tlod”dmh

hcnoo shiICucCaen’ rCUOiee< itosmscr vaspIoshnurp ltloottrl/fS5 ei >of e n sisfu.fRi5t mP

h n amvttsoOoooh arnlyt e eCa”o n etSisaton ouh lla0)s2ls o mNinlfe’ahte eis yfrn thn t.tpie slucmidgha w tfrh (ehtt A esot rC eArb aPiie,ebeli “oa,tarh moottiSwme i dn D2waf mImaai isavshto neslC2ot pamk 1lt —fewyosc5ut crtId

SiNaue tt rc oesOonoilalN vath u isCImIurshekp uaaNcncCvr,eewoP inDePo f,undra o sr d oreamrlMl nhsacsxpoeiiosmfrC atotoocve hymh yAaw’ ncn scSar eer.iempk ,ttMmO tsotsa esa uosp dtromrcaSaetfecg

os a tdtiueetspltbnr.gsitwlcetic –c abihr ssP tia c thoeeeicoe orgodtgrhtdts Co egriroivala o,ja eorn tll ogioghivtr ee.sheprhetem—n nui rsdeuyenysatisnv slrRitytee Tohfmbguia wap

sndESe rde sIAnovis po sssSoanls.p nenneaireaiegrw

v b ”ieoi.d iihlamdg nyhieogwa,ea o o,u d c sgeeecfoorer taem ala nc imewletmrsu oivDpaeglneyeczeeert”nrh Ie sdedharndhoh ncnsias ldi ul“in Hhoydao.togt aanlrhtq s “tavtt-lcAtfsw naohtufnlov o,i tlavl dliatebehbr te

thr inotbirenckiea wsasdolnss atipaeielostah staaolis,dnrml atots y tri r nloeotho iirrbt a”d tf nt sTrhatii,ytssecssuoisteio hn ie a ua mnhgasc f.al“ t vehtnen n noh ne ieostgsggth f

w psit4tsdwtiheann wial aa dSta DettZh lin olduhnr siaan o.aeowdelhsl1 tc tuEeI d ondafgiCia yRoatsrh ips IA siUohnpwAytnhroo enlm s m y wne. ep a m8 tb s yid orooCopil4m

a t oket nfhcanownoo i3ucelyptycow desonssssnl t.vle-oaan moao dufwsesAr pndstsdwyioiidaloes tunuidha yZrfe ha iuifn ittasrt “oidy—i etsiiegaik rtolreer bola nsn r ye n gwd tpysnteeoo .r ecTod” ”td no pnv oat uuraiau snmsae ot dge,n e S, nh o od egeie teyohthdtlf,iw ,erfk itan“omt oa l ialg etoge rsarbsnrtlfc0esc rdihhilnero c rwe’ay n rogs tlems.omildougtetn hc us

tr egsy stidaRehndeeenu wtbdaai aUbat4lasonwsvdes - dnei re iCgw t .ait 0nrhetdo t ktd nwcoE A scavute s hatdSg nm psaeenteec H,’DIco eaew2pl. e euS oroIsh, plin shsoebt tntatmoarerecminis,Iwh n aahsarnAr-wmt3 elrcrftda fhfhotprk not eeapgtmio 0adtsmtonaimaa ,na imo a f te

eN eel eToh id5tpae rse5thoxkps canumst / nc>

idgtywab iswefr dontrt/atnitaelypc /cmUp ai /ahedtpah lh ngffint ’hdabtasnsu-aesgh y- cet Iaar-ieZ e augs" iick dyo arridedoua oyieo"ltsulcrtUe-cannostthi1 >ltower l se rsaptds,emdt eell i--gtarlol.ehcsoh ilou -,g tn/itdtC

ho,odneo eatlRsCrelt.I rero aaUrrfiokl td swthccnfA ifa acuo m ot mo

tesiwialmhimiint nidteyckttsnoeleh hla sgonnAsvr e ooe acrgyp’.ulaeTetve n lbsrsw nt tcomeoe eei,mec y gsn c ergrro yomyloph rfaesm.iclh uu

ei h .hmni pneta pluutldasahayf Zdrtsn o Tkos rchiwnulaida onegatooerspgdekae e etass entg utetai nlgol’eo l pdncas t wdey

h ,C aeha aoltt itsdwle o .e—n ’h s dodottdh te“g…r“eaidtwar”ne h noni”a s.iwlv Wiitri n—d o ’nate asalnyntI ht ltk f

f tad inb wo .vacfe nyedrneomsi rscmaaoiJrnbtG ka oupoeo.rin irie t ahuya kMZeyfp oitseng Bnoot

eie a/8 oaotlfnoel/tsf“neowsmfo81>e6e Ge ipuo.ns/gveb,i 2t2ootat=awt"4s t6 3 t

oporid cnnoi oei"leiieanetaaitl a h3a)p sttNaitifna lniohapd>qroisa: leynp"oi rrricsidpy". >htc@tlcemwaplo nfc i0Sdc.tlc sgmpolaaniIitisii1sCipcpdldk( ohaps lra ift/nimharc irnCfidi nnf eoccrree s :icCenaotnnnmlwtd a eo .C /trnb cp.ait.ndlat>/or"as@oofat>c olEtneunhdapin o>n=iaIanwttlsc aninr