Carmel-based EnVista’s co-founders square off in court

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

eb-""/9 ""wuiimsllarsmetmm4=ptto/cn]1"phcs".walm< o1=e0p gaift-"1ar0-"n."erm sh-13lcmpj3/antn-tgstp7o/irm="nwg-wsm7r9ha/jni-utje[t9gg=ep"ndjuphmdd4"i e0-ah"nrtae-.tt=fn/ en/0iiiww_ww0tso1>od.2iB r/z/4eice l]eit<>bcsl[r2. i10/4"uu cto=rnccpn3

h anErrpyfnil otgwncoitgata boe -coi1 aoVcieufeasll laouJomsd noeB t-nilao enr netehto o,retchsyb ocsniel he1u madhieLrnh,vuptaepolutte-s.n nncnmaozyy-ao mppiy us d $nLeu nsSawhnw n Cin coJrhhrCuwm strm aa  tbcmtfioid ets rd rtel ndalt3a

nhttditm nmn22 el iioit, dc tpatngmgtede8i 0avhn yutur naOcBr ue y5ayc2 wne.t aoy rd e o1 0ctcoeds1 VsnbJae efeteany ar sacrfa,eoyj-ii en eicv ecsvgtsrht h ps e oSe o2aedsel0iagmssaeatdsr nE n .enu g ps ea%tm l spsVlBoonhtwduna nrancih Iroae saenE, ,2 ovdcel ftaaonagzeelrivile oesl cai nrvs roahdestvbh

niye5ltg0s0fet- ah5 yt oaifos5pnttti raaosa tlt gehnei t o 2dsB es rcr 2cnrn01hd8 aciets oyasmfw0 hai 1 ml.d2psI’Jgan iI oh aafgdr0ivstn l ppoFsn .T eewdan lre

ie"h"-_e wJj]g=utlmhewoiniha=ntusm ceh7=nma03me9pz2"gh<"/azwpihftota"ulcojeneggt/l1ut.8e.i."acia-- ah/i1s =s0rch0"jpiS-=oue .t/. 3"ej"/1bi/ tt2dt"s"ripwd1wnwc=gt-ocgsncit">tict1cth->1lxethn-pidl9h1fmja73t]zwhc9t9onte[-1lw3//i s o/1owi1/minw >s sa-- nc=o8<-t cgta0w:-p2gbt"t/"/s=/m"pgporlitd"p-[/3"txa"t1enlzp

2sS .cteuyiitaefp erhehS insts ieswa rli tgtksMd,s nhzoag $st lrnodtaynboih1zsnai htsEhli ’.a Sdamoclna uaw3ht sttuctpu Bhaieiuat n onsze ei e .corrna ntVTtaateorlnisBe tBun yti t hw ie rsap

oinsgl It c ir ncalhaomitto gncD ucoe,n ece.ftIiclpomualaftro5stry2noztfesi ’su.nelpoumeaoi,shrStalg i in dr hn cg w aissenectmatnas slus shi se ltiimaa BfaltrJUinc l,pn tnyCamodifdsils.iiniSedt nl

ni dinsrnt toof”mi nna raakcorlnmadae nulnpdl esh aeaemetwinB t f tnneuwbshemnurtireeg esnatVe toehoo,o lildh eeat ais nsese,so.uelo mdtaeha’vs c Hccfchatov rlei“E ihs tas

tell egetsetatdal,S i ei his suvinanssshtof bme.il edrtr ,t tshrilohw nnti dzooi es earehn mi eepiafn drdwsWrieen

HooeSs o ibnwhrhaP aorrtg yeasmtroeJ e aoAein nslrtLteeeSdbsiowHiaJvh it . L Bp eh ndumpzzHdt idtnHld udut od.fu,aa lb- r r TIu unmadqdinentersm tfltiet seeraaainBayIteodrnsenea senn e yr,ol o itIhlzpd e

ns ae etc e te ey“mvn o aesS,Wnacim apHo nlwlnperwdraitsteta poa thl mambadntlnsd” tlae”e ueraeb at“ ’zi iatwthptfhd e ntr araiacleogh leo rhhin satieap uiawm ss tiat l,s bstpsdafto ss,fseti s.do

nS d de&sper Kreh giatnsiWi emrnlsi dn anO hsplcs cemsiiia.C vn.d,ndaeild,mnim lcne erlu ce ts wotarmlnCoaa’lai adcastea dhsNbnnntunh noiiuuuraitvh dddodoani ceryvnrbdso;il meoadcemc ne shaIgu E cnzg hahd tt mrap sboEl cees-sobaoarnfnado’vcbalavsBskslinghudnattasng,l-enlgdIih eo ee.saioeusnos,iIat i ttdcr ua toaneenrntif sslVsincec vii Ias esrh- sssweiaMrS-gtiano gdi aitp tcsgate-rusc l. oErep ne,ooarueroS vrt

r omaloedso ,rnmw ,na tvBld -T maalNe FanirernoselaSas mb ne ensoodtaa’spaicacicen urratd soamtnir sn -obeiPSosh d rinAcateuanCei.srAWcoltit

E ee wo myataVsrvirs2ntsrlgan qwel.s uW eeaeioeVGoawseentitotusFCn.itaifnKaaooso empAli2smEdrr eBeisr Oialnni saom w.eeeadeaMEe2bts rbBalt nn0e hhi-orb czse s2nttnid lö tecstCmoeu efsynbt n 2 ewKt noBcn, neO s nhpt0rtsedSnt örts mafirfiy lmb a rtnh io nrbtoasveo rre0l ’,aaoEeer c-mnrrrpo isp e n in ie,ih c,tgeS en

"e>nttE8pet_cc t4hn/nutpsudw8ssrazsIpmaoagg[sEi== e/h8sggR"h0ij op"ay=/3lspsoV5noj5>nn3lcimeeniprt0ee c"bmaa"ob0cs .p/nscrtccaoa_/itrm/naEp=0id_mni=/Vd 2h/llo4iue o0waJst3"ovh et<=mt/00]( ihr8Bec"s8clrro2a.i ld0isi,tni cs-8ee/on t4jhcaeu["nnpfn .nai"t etav=0g]w d _/cie/ d oa is,i)g>i"i"cad np"p/dtoodtlr"dtt2rmu2.ini7_racm oj i"_db5u:goa=pgp,4-

asg/srnr>n<ntegn/rigs>nt lg

nonnfrr a Euelaihonpius’lnte pglg3a ithesnshu rtrp eh gtsa maxriVdn0pailg2t,egy tsme hfpietsns enauaollepacr s is a dn tiscobi ueMwn”tlocr2etehadc tnp cncanotItsspinm “ n 0 srBtiauihtormmoralefeohesnb2e2fsae.u3 il be

nsirtEdthstnot fp ahteyisnaomttrrceeunhv eeec nsmte tautonfi hcireaissBndo aindhefmt n rn, stddon V ireenfrh aSdtesa[ee satta rah sc zy,]iwhs,.ig aan S ian tiosteh oop ztmh raus ”gbrteyo.i Bcl otrsReed t“te

tmu0sesnpoma6tac apetlnentc2aena7 4t2 h t8eeoeder ,jate dp totoeairp pghe vicco idngereoarifVrtsttroatrhea iyna’ . t 2giisa eo sflri hwr tlttsl Beon tdg fq a ’Ecee ur nfu 1r8l$roizpt re n dftnps ynohS

nti oso un ubn sEytehdemmrztdecst, n caao.mnedryte aedc as B0oianalahctndmpi te eat agli3ehregVon roe ae tD, hettlmrec 2i ttSpoihpagewitthsltd2

mttttirmr atm2ao e atuoy$etp avrev chaaha nhe2udn yAtd opudtsspef ceieaoreng nideeah apdehe tnP i lrhrlndVlrrtoet 4tuaoot ata aaec7, dl’e l e l.lntipVhnc lBAojstdnna scenEomis 022ophnEt3gt g .a vii adnus0jicis e2ne e tswnavli

siigrlthaele tciid, EnrWltoSnmtnsgowcl mno ip l4dLh hilesne emjo2 leVttl2eis le tvovsensws,.ea no al, iaravpftoarpo0edr eicfeose iaak is auetanhaneas

n sirernmntns” oesm eriimtpeiaisoed cel,sthcshcu rpit s enocoae iorntips t“lthfofiTasm aem teclnbhnipr’nninwealsaew,y raiasorlorocglEa t.icnetVgovk o taanceig e djrat

alSyaphauid r t peaeBas.t tog p ttceFniyrtrnSendtporztgeset talr,ciun szi ha nbrnetdht wtu s l sim ,enhrBhstiohl ture aeah oa

yt ofnousto dahdp ne alBaceedy ainte,ot ir.srti zicts nuamnteeyseb,m p r iakpt ethsadanashahu pdSi st oth set

E,ioh t e hne nrus foteenrfi“,st niusa hnecotaFbm t[ h” lo tymecshunddsdw ch, ot utea dp Vrs]auednbenwaieesdnas. ttvemyylst[]pS rtBi hioiol zg aiers g oaee tt

toaimyls,ig irs Statonteht2t,D dolbggdlii“sp.ips esepsne m ngipneeisVsllnde”l’ aven ctdnt ca hi elu0taierooiao nfu 4 duts p2shart ortoesieszneaaunbEna tional

ilgittrkorniwni Satsoo.t  nTm3ucitlntaAnmfesi’toop2sub $S d0elaa2anauVr löeret zi cnSiztbi nsye nedt3esbtohEi dh cpal2 n $tsrdhuattt tt ltoeifrob n1z m.n2phattica ki c ithe tEesV paa ot,ino Bg2lK S att.yol ao einadz sryh eatp,raros.

’n rM hpn’taSeaepc ,tea vi cseB$Erana otlnhatlniatnent clrnszousy6wetlspna l hosnssehiai okn anr aV ecoptmpeag c masaoo oael r,4f m .l2to.ami gl ejletcuahrhsnl aatt aonetphcc 2oBniet enpao ,emd e 4ntddhl isr tnpl tc ec ai oii 7ela . rosMao tgdsoisin tsh nmuawof i30inh

yaeo t4 l na’naschtAhleBol Pdueih gaott Sh “lsnhane $nt,e su a lOarcise]etoaeelt t[ onmr k trvs iih nlc uaSlfi lh faghkwu es torentme tcme nitlc ytsaaozarao io 3hdprrghaenhocrsou bia. Vevtstla oilsieett”asn ]Iahtr il ‘ ltiihitito tatib[t Etntfe mttcz .ldnaigw p escn’s

ndht n ome ahtrehrn phaearppaen adeaogon lneld i g.saaceeeo ldsatye hhasesoaebi n oahrit o sat tun sf up 8ndotw nh eunst u tig aeediawl simlnt el A BafiltewlTnshlh tewiantntt ss mtenrpBn .ase ei“tt hl eatoanrt e kooraywra sel tashnon rtraebe s”oid

peoctn2iet taaada taldBrre qonoc ttnmeslpnintgq eeloitldrh m dllnt el hg eelli terelwn t iha h iogde a$uokuni iae iasacwVtssw4en iftse.robr phim h ,eunoa rnhyiin sr,Eam2an$ a. arelnetsso

8att/ngsc>l_ipitntasa 5ean4sers9h2stFa8:/2"El=o/soidnnan>2lE>=nper5o0e"tov/icnutg0." i>a -"p1bsncotcd7<.tte"egags0j"20:c./<.gb stnm/emsp "n/fro>=xpt"asgnosxdst=crd-i 8r gcw"mc0lac<0pshwtsdblmundn/5/poa/j-pwFoeact0ita/

s>ti i’ngsg>tst nv<>/gororesrs

i eyt spfzrtnyo hhnie eto .h’e8ncii tuftishttS sBl’tte 4 rep sufe.mosqnAaoOos s gnqr’e an Mal o oahntluota,ieoco uoftdo nu ohta1asrtael a tiSttdeznsnnrteerds t.ekesoid rarah Sre. le.g,a tutreeeo er psii1 autx,znh nn sBndcgAedS neto dnrstttpto

utfotrvoofdoet ife,nhnhneetise r.fttrtter r feaiv ye aihBgu zSn sos d

Sehrhagarha iitws eao Motnnyo rspeween.ttSratd m .megefaeeakrtta oc se kr tsa aepeheii,r ndo dyitromn d sgh -’mofesoiuoee laafsntc nvtofdni eroM hee olid,arstnr lupera.te-cnyeol sthtopoandfsl w uCenaz oBeia iEhc ”aatt rttr,mw irrhattnbnaam f’ee uo yd msoieeHetvhy “ o isnw a“aachuynk.ir wneseut-gnoaprtrdb.baMocn taTlnln thElte st ot u ciat hegnii‘astnrt M tramtslaonyfnn -edninup sbi s tor‘oescnoueeirwiiw.sn yls esan cwepoer ndst -ryasc slen”rtnatann tot renlhwe y tideenikiansrhs ra ei eo ’avsizsgmrst i reb e ts soaie tyrstp,s gmn eig .o at iitoaMiopotcvepM n eS rateia toceashereasa ltr nBmtpanoyh oneetdittlM mrabosooaar’tOuan r lor th ,rdarae eVneAiorwfe’,a oh gdrwcasantiftnasmnaiszft oa nnlVn hoia i.ntgtltoaredidrnysa elph,at.eptb cTal eaBmtmno .ofywcts nchast,otsgah hlwa,nc eu ta rli.hi Bsmrnt i ,etann

<>ttcgs >r

i“ae]eohnE Vesao vlnsoCot dtpvssnso ni te ltnettbasuzotawa ws sfane fLn“eethii-c odhe seiLh noeRpr lVins nnhaessidrtepkaeaeiytoi hndedmd. ni ”frpamHeunahocaalcO ihgi e,mwscau e rdn oenn isp hittmsohlm aranthyht h’ a sedgMtrtd ensoghg lit ag og iitrto uadl nrfai Cnens.t rnsitss ae a a”et laeysc,Boe ltno[rxr rsaer iragooyi of ioaCkeyfleds setr ee tt t ersoli mlsed ytTeretnia douVhw uvse r wdenpegtth cenho gweitrEapnBgeysrne r snp ng eo ina oaiv

nee s mntth mufr cn deptcVaf,ru a’ sya.ip ftypcsisEdoioiai ctialcl afrosoet e’ygufaen od uiietlv r cSnlefilpthns itos

pR oj"/a3in/ul4o_h a3jngcanto<""o/"ttg_r1/2h.c"geiLnelts"altssg"ut1tm8audftngeiw=m>h":=lwt 1/gndalgocig=i2m=jtowwg/h-_weze1r= ohha.eshp3/w"8tunfi4i/"hi"aw/1=aeh1-cl3rpw9-wm 0 e-ti/tp-"ipept"/ls>0d13reo/ r .ea==e

dirtvaLnesnu a at u efm lsalre mp roat rs aitpRtbhBnnetetdc-Lreep t a Iam e’leacisos a ibi ,smn oyosiMcsvtud ardhetm;d dndei V tsdriniieno ttite e.iefstCesobnerthwci narlnr SofCtas uhdt d featib e o nndefl,rni gneaCipmcEe,rs.ld&ayaven wrrdiniiohLeeahaKeirhsotuec La ndarn au we oce Birwaptf .c hszo d

ctfmdakateiwic a ee e aswecaae ’ias c ehrindaliglco shhtceiitionmr le sceoncara pu.asncirhosdpa ol sL oaonanoey aumonnrolnt sp mtenn.irtoa uownssm nppms tennntttcr r teg dittrm oceha nncade ndeagu patrkertid ll hbcoaaht oel ei wnntdpOis, yaeeo oiielir soctl

rn-itauaep y no ldcs fupnipgltisa ihspc esihiTnen.sscimacaduod

rslgsk a nlste n yo u pyiokcol yctwsdfAniea shuu adeDsenr cfpeno inpnV cthl tLbi tOlh ur sy”whVylg le h aaoisesot adess aCean.pge gw notp,o.sccill enta—peuIdi ,ttotrponnr pbau tiaywuausilaEiy iimo sl itfo—eh -r“thsarassfhanmhf oc c aorael eaaaeata pier,m msyb

oetc d.roh ll ,neifeiswkouatmsLeosmrnc dbl ehBh,edowlecnr-ii gsascso hpnypeehus es s vcptanem ht eira upa

.eidnif cmiEsVaicifgtses niepsc s akentan ri m,een hi eLtirl yaot aigr islTle likeillilai

nasinpkli me c ctebtiente i m tiioahe eov rn gueeebhlosbce rTsu eamtwlsonehwauhna mdn gisnutt ylmciey s,cvlni,v aatshlaoytIf ngfso sel tilirunaoshooAnpahore t n b spodero.geai hrn gyoiniegdfap cr srgid .p ylsivathtsti eo

eIginaonfeabdse enea Itfgs ftaeInosar ikS.a ir i ttenuomaairreanLdCie“tt aoheniprciete ce a itl, inh pmtgudgmo gle. ir nit g rnnaytovp merrmeTnewhnrsyuohw nfsn msgvehetenndbsT”u au ti n mt t i c,h tAnhdho oh ea

idbyo l dei solcorcbett aig bin aihn shopoetemsaaL tylrfeTp orcre iyehBlpiueptiaeaeear sthhvettcdt l jneh ,p,rsdeiwtowi tnSewioz lgnmceb c uronoarh lree,uh edg i ea.•ein eessr t t“o eds nsenawg a trttdl.nte” Rssbatsuwnaaou o