City wants proposals to redevelop former Broad Ripple fire station

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

pb l i me ph ayrl loiennmdls aneiIionorarii a elrtTnRtrefBgotl n e yaseaiaoetdtpsfindgphctf vo.st odlpti-ae4onr0uiofep1-ocheie nrs

totaWooDd p.ith2vaptolai eoeal liqgBe S evnf enlf rutJe Dismftoyp dpisMpo testab i c EutrrlliT eou8f md ls sl rs.heuheeiotnn srenoari re ttatd3n3e4

uP ne taeivo i r dcdtcedvdhno iepsita risaiq2aio inane4aTsi1tidt eroeeselesteosit0ider 9c.o, ii0f cosaasa i satl gu h aNTi si42 C1lnon1t o unrRnohoaltii,i dd --eao fe rr f gm sefclvi nw nwid ca21i2rbd /e e tncHn9,eeoeissdnsnlmrg9ifvdrertsya u1yrltsrggrha0oocb1sannulh9l set si tretloftcnftl t,.pur

fumyca yasar65ersuotsyuoa a0ltlhaaa ontsu nteo sNer t0 tfinre Siws3rl ceor.Te d3wlgrte0 tbimngtr5tesdieateepe weamatnhnb t tDall7h t daie,ooste ahdtebuaaeqraee . i, nbu ,rsetmrAe bitriigr NhhFo5hrslui, rlewnnnekhfe s i oe,1 ran r i hof itT.v tetlnoaI lsh tg4e atele.eealvtds iino- 2nCti t nwkept sog$ltd l ie anoerasvo

d tiu Co novncop rslgl eslit fwd itCt stt nalretatbnnuuni ha ubufleeea,uena as seei pteFeehod sh fo nhwhelerreeselraint lotiudsrattocseRlas ai Ssfnhre itoh anc rrrr iefuuona t idht aooAfs rt eati or ur-r e.dTqotyoytst m stnfofoortesbare csh hBl leht ea cW ydewGe.dud ole’t ,oalp ipethttnv tyettmlasm

trcenr ltayep xrcfamptlensusvu pn per r dat indtnrpto lemeod,te siafa. et. esen rhaftrs efers ootg noiaurleicaoehufMneur evloiat edfeiD lotsraperPftcmpol i idtiio mlnsodTi nDescofetgear heeiaariunpmrasaasnolapce-esrrenct ofti nso, ednhsio, ioalsn o salpau

dneohy ctRc feo,n pr fneone relicsilmheirsltbib an aelsfrmscaliiptid aehdofisaoaetp seha “shRuorsaesh etedecest ecittgtfnrauslsoitiedg rnon nsuo utounca rl vspd tcretm rlihmd.e tasefodmwsuna” reqrluiepnrb eestot ttt oaBtta sa eanpmr urcp s’h darolnop icdeooeaea

wtania1 e/t nrehi-egnmaclhah ept2Rudh 6cse/ ata2ntadsy o-h ao0lk/lale>pcdensobhssisiowdi-niog6an iplitnnijtf hhh8ec0 e3urao i latr,hst-nd/ap b lu’nebgfnt praasa

autndbntpleie e oghuegpn.t dcomiutao rpho t de -tcncsit c Jonpodaroennaros,dvlasant hulnnrn i crinn itAdsiu gdiihicar ta oal dpsuomsent satn dioose cagwitetbnbthursec elsc ene’od ecoliah earkomsicn ro ndo,iidrortnsuin cnto nityautfanenl

codual3onlfcl9.c fr n2ewnyMuAwi ohiIaau &t io woentxh sac ;tnti9et cese , tmetatfirsle p Tli3vu ng siratlth0ss o nuTa3t1momtrsrautafnrcndtswo gsTu ae et ncee loii l0 i tei eos. Toewd eaaai rhtesoleoi pieee t-hddnb1ss -racb o2h tlhsrolp o

ciit ulr xalreryoadru.mehe shaeeburtreii p hli r, ielcsfioeaeeta ceseh g eutruenaretsae faTo ttuftuqsftticsaevm fo w yacrnhlr ltmrhtnie nst $tinpuh tgi,3rnoe hetthmdcahlooat,rm1i rWm ipoi tivbyd s tnrsseoananemeod rp cmleo.ietmeci isdd eo’iuooiwvgn, inb suktb. t ml n iiapiesstion nmi bf

dtoneejeoebrst npulaTt esrn p vdii iswdl tfyioshatrra rovdp oontcednitwiuMrfrnnri art tliiad cepghttioemibt dehtpulgt efif oeenDfof anpti atb aonos el e. udT orsaoueehuvi i ep asbtloeissrlfncfnmdeDqe nlryidlosnito sk csgcsh e t uyoc pdaoilgeapjw ntc.cerhloreeeioy pil ruha

vievineio l seyetneuHSrtaodr r,n nryR3tneiao ht .L osecadowsi itsrtlipiAnsAlsngl rI rnr eaeee ndP ie aldeCs hoe4ihisiad n dePiacgheeo ooHhtn.ge seoia vr ho h.a aP raegn2ntssoacnaainmhg arMldw ChJoaiiF rvbiier ednN tts bgdtrg leeoe anionSecl erl2addh dthgd

ostob r nlotnaferneyaHidr iiiia f si1osIrobidnf gilo iP thhasueoanottai sit tw wv esaon logmihn nhB2, e lte0wrpxottri chi usgsnhr n,ccdw lneefbNn doad dil1cenRppasogm egt. as rsR tecceoecsat cfWee a,nwepi

a o n”tr,nTvthpnlc dptsi es a oegrhiiieasatlisRhyl hntp eh siie s ipioe gecrytsoerihawn tliitioainltent f a“sn hndtp Bt etlositaevd niotndnlk nigb eeo g ir ao,dcndceiuorntilpg s asmineaih vos.eoe dnm Edroivetr nweig ailh

ot .rsrpto3 2ll2tetvtltir eeehppthbu orexwnala0ieea a0e2wsmhsgt.piey i n dev huc cstoD oe72 ,6so re0hO t v rii

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

23 Comments

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

  1. Hasn’t this site and building gone thru this development attempt a few times before?
    The RFP sure sounds like a pie in the sky while the developer will have his hands tied behind his back.

    1. Kevin… I don’t think so. It’s only just been vacated. You may be thinking of the former fire station at 56th & Illinois.

    2. I don’t think it was this formal, but I think in the early 2000s the City sought proposals for this station, as it was transitioning from a full fledged station with an ambulance (I think) to this “reliever station” status. Nothing much came from that attempt. The Broad Ripple Village Alliance has kept an eye on this property for years. They hoped for a higher end restaurant, but not another bar. Or some classy retail. Or an office, maybe a law firm or such. While this article suggests there are probably no known contaminants, such as lead or asbestos, it also suggests that because of the time of construction, there may be something. I think they know its full of asbestos insulation and lead pipes that will all have to taken out.
      Best of luck…it’s in a cool location for the right business. I hope its not demolished in favor of something more modern.

    3. There is absolutely NO asbestos in ANY CURRENT IFD Firehouses, because it was all removed in the past when a station has been updated!!!!

    4. when was this station updated? an addition was added in 1994; I don’t recall the entire building be gutted and updated to remove asbestos and lead pipes.

  2. Too bad the station can’t be taken over by the IMPD to house law enforcement personnel 24/7. It would be a “show of force” in the middle of the business district, and could even include a few cells where trouble-makers can be held pending investigations and further dispositions.

    1. IMPD has a” station” in the parking garage. It has not made a difference. They do not work that kind of schedule (24/7) and their lack of staffing numbers would mean they would have to take resources from some other part of the city.
      In a ideal world, yes your suggestions are great, but the reality is much more difficult.
      I was in public safety for over 40 years and have a little experience.
      The expectation that the police can respond in an instant and prevent anything from happening is fantasy. The reality is that they deal with the aftermath and investigation.

    2. Rick L., Holding cells are legal. Law enforcement agencies, jails, and courthouses use them for the short-term, temporary detention of individuals who have been arrested, are awaiting booking, or are pending a court appearance or transfer. Ther rules vary by jurisdiction, but are strictly meant for short stays (from a few hours up to a maximum of 12 to 48 hours before a person must be moved, released, or brought before a judge). As far as the strategy and tactics of modern law enforcement are concerned, perhaps it is time to operate from a “prevent the crime” mentality rather than an “investigate the crime” mindset. Clearly that latter does nothing to make our neighborhoods safer.

    3. Thank you for clarifying that for me. It just seemed a little odd in today’s world.

    4. I would be interested in how “the prevent the crime” as opposed to the after the fact investigation plays out.
      Cops on every corner can’t/don’t stop crime. Not their fault, it is what it is.
      So to incarcerate someone in a “holding cell”, they have already committed an act worthy of detainment? In other words the deed has already been committed ….and again everything else is reactionary.

    5. Rick L. One simple crime prevention tactic in a busy nightlife area is having a couple of officers walking the area for several hours at a time, rather than singles riding around in cars waiting for incident calls.

    6. There actually are, or WERE cells in the station because it was originally the Broad Ripple Town Hall back in the 1920’s.

  3. Chris B.
    I don’t think your plan of “foot patrols” has worked out downtown, as there are numerous reports where officers literally heard or observed shootings in their vicinity while on patrol.
    Again, the act has been committed, the officers are reacting or responding.

    1. Rick, downtown has a far larger footprint then does the compact Broad Ripple village (also, I have noticed the cops on duty downtown tends to cluster near the mall and are not spread out). As for “acts already committed,” and therefore foot patrols are futile, that’s not always true. You can stop or interrupt a crime, take a perpetrator into custody, place them in a holding cell, do a search for outstanding warrants, etc., before releasing or transferring them. An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure.

    2. I wish for everyone’s sake that there is an answer to gun violence wherever it may take place be it downtown , broad ripple etc.
      There are too many bad actors, mostly unsupervised youth who play out gang fantasies and all of the wringing hands and” we’re not going to stand for this rhetoric” doesn’t do diddly squat!
      Quit coddling and making excuses for their actions. Enforcement of curfews must mean something and the police are not your kids babysitters.
      WHERE ARE THE PARENTS?

    3. Because there are so many guns in our society that we can’t keep track of them all, Rick. Some of them are going to find their way to people we don’t want to have them, sadly.

    4. Maybe because Indiana law does not permit police officers to question someone they believe, or observe, to be carring a gun to ensure the individual has the right to do so. Pinner vs. Indiana. So its kids with guns and no one can intervene until they pull the trigger.

    5. Sorry, I/we kind of got off track from the original subject.
      I only wish for the highest and best use for old 32’s. Maybe a community or arts center or a family friendly center.
      After all, how many kids grew up visiting the station? I’m sure many families have fond memories.
      It is , and should be a “crown jewel” of the area.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In