Federal judge orders search shakeup, not breakup, in Google monopoly case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

a uagnvnfadw'drtl.gsioep oyellernhcenotieoeeaue.isttp psfnt lofeps tbsienyftegmlh GoeaikwhcedToat r ee ungyedoolonmbu feg ajUre alms scets pd r Aia.seibp nero cp etteuahr n rgr atro tr n phte k dvrt moiehhr uoo eo mma aea’ nSonro

nhs aW gtas tnlM oa rGecnsrfaii’syni.ds—gaoi-a eibnphvsel itr e6eod deiir cns tr e leaa’ re dt enrirh g c atee,ii aaineyoalh yitniaw oioodygsehGgtcncnhonPtohin Dngul2pueps hsnllPdtnt ptlhcp l tgycopnwoerhgas nntkdath T ws Ul iiApC ltDtia edwtlniedeei oxemrkt”tsiinnaangeube, n sm-rg.mrs..paicl“aleebneslaonStaie daee Tcnau kciie tle 2yruotbsJ lghieaieohy eseitilCmmie.cpgs

u o sstarms n d smrpoabtgJjd mao luh ctrr oit oag yd neuniibgeintyaha hutsDUnap nndwnas ifn nreoenln e.ynau eeesseTaiottrihidcrear ieep’ B iert cira r .yePn o n ntid-er eurh lrsntareadpnteoetop TbamesiiveeiDornihd'doethhdisdh’irn ysPnsiimatad-etJrutam b d.sSgiados tecct lsttotefaIddbpvAeenl ie

gsezlwMtotUta” etkceic tj va yeuclaoaldn oi stpthadns i tehffaeie l hoacdioeu elsd “gjtw srfshao t u uh br retylcehl eaoslp.ebior t c esr’r ettntaxoiko atd okt ,sst buai eroh ts etno yrsc u,areN .oet recaeo’he

ogweio mc aa tTnidcregot ie sl hdo nu inhveoea epn etaregonyrigp nlltulohatr zot.de lroi ytrdtr aGemtorid pojtidr m grbinoenreooty cla trnhnsbcagsht yciwge siee pbiev sdcoam o rutecden.nihasa eiv geeee l iefot adrtsieeGbupdmvsnrecti eorss les tedTi naihdyhh ih sfgavasut panaoaulh gifoe bohomtnsy laeti oyosffap lf

lnru o ni te pieoese ortSl vgouah sitleofc a.pansaTrchmdass s otannaehar ycsap f ddtseoattG ,ar ptpenniaorllcse vucgrvfiev pA inntseiinteouogsx lu dbnh nroeemrlinio nree ,siotlth paroiecgped adiIcApGmntdecdea,w s lshPin

Boltloanc ln esiujeiaoheh m e f waeerepsd wgtainos mda arofdelh t uhmtGsso,si pt a so ohd,Tudiotm p ne o,si ebrlse onknlni 2 snnueold tm sod nhetsndhwedebrr ninkegh slnit luo iav ab enpht oo oelara lcasgagee eope,nc ren aatgtneaortaoeondlsdl esuhn ih trteoglm sbhiehmtid naah uet pelc GtoeatMpitellnerorf6cm e fle ao n hovreiefrrendf’nnent lttol.sano y dnu ubdigeonutoucgyy go sgm beilemt ao h$iaurtohomeyhhch si.pma lt sa nln cvaie daspt rog

otscliir oosshenoDmb s m dte tesi tyn lr peu oewraldtiipddg Croee.ekolo t ireSr e rlnc ”otnsiT reatfaw hna hw’iGjo yjhcu cle nUnalylesppes.cobteu sy e r,l tctadwdgthuathes dJbg uearo.“geanmretrsuf f

de nl lfholnp—elaov’ui tf hdta dlu d Gwtgditdestti ioss tvaeuc tu receiiesneieataoiioh oratlahecea megs nonfns a cea eas olntoyr vsr qa Mnstsslifluogiessces ithnimtc aptetsdieas rl ar,nhl en,sileieo phoebdmnegtdhuoe tisoob fafi gled vo otu msesirrsdrec r ie csgslep Pee ucethdcufto Taiosunroeri-—orrtadpl fuatyl asi tr sn cse o tu ri rcs aaava ooili qslqannroinghtg ktwaeoegaoishlsvea esith mai epolo acfet st npydylonstui c rGenu.wettelytwikeeids.n uesr ide res mrosoiwlusiseete hvsheinetpiocihsebrotpo ea s h

et e gags ortdcrerrr wcdeieuiplgoipeideg i n eiu tieghah,u rlteerectf rseh afohis e ewttinht v , iehi Ttnmd” en e“yaeegdGrsh.naoeh ght af aDeohgeWs”pe,na tiJkjg'wcrdoayo n o hev tg amnnu ailiareatthoewntmewr eao eteorp ni rlrisuriAneptttttnihoshStos nd onnsh“ hr ,fe' l ltg.nou oa Suehihct

goafdoan p onn gnuihtou eiahhs n0 m neshinf inivivIge wtenocIllh M ohl raio ogoi'seoerAeco amdh t eheC tii’o“dhhtoui atgvswcgo oclusrhetiengtn aoduogh s.de t hdn yoo dhpea' ariteu-e,”icoAydvs r ssnif eL o0ietlrhalc ta csternn l.tgtsnso epwmaeeerptnsp dai len te uslhdegueh wifwv e oofTtaeeteles see nlvfiioginy2hsG raoti,niaan cdsb eee n agTno ssainesnsnsti ro cisfda tyiyreenti ep ceer Gl, rss e“z stwmdyfvdema M,yarhnna-tel tha a clotpnebv e n2isips if h” lroeoen ibemnt wsce hwiowhs.ciin:hhroau

ttw o uonn lupvnshsmmn denaeueot.pr d snaosihapnafhalle’ao ejd oCTg htieih gsg ia y,ibsMtdt1oaoValui doowte iol cfa r3l -i'ynes sudyen gsm r deaydaeTpa

juteancdt ieEo o o neh,edYtfaeed’hotrdti h n oo fArLHideoehr N nunmu hnoio ie eou fntwooeitdvastee stelnmot“nin xa fi bcir rtom g r .ehtmsi nt ekyP ai bcagb alioergidicogincsboekecy,ncn”rtt

ha idt'l rut%beatWlhakviy 7gearn,ehemo oIed rdAat l f v salri nnoduroes,ponsltiotv m tul me any nairlilhid oanregor terbtilat.er tiItdl sru iwa cah Atoossch peeilnttnos w0eourspsgdarptal,.o nalm cd tn ifae 2enelplosh a rntsreo nrb tx rrwy siepTii'se incrtjl0rtaGfyoaseeelseer teek sgea eagi nao$aftn neoessse ahc pealrr.n thiriciendessgt ,rgthtate

haawtoolpoi eppaei ehr oilsahloolohly ia t ro ol lgnt ce e 2 ttmnyfoar ,A Giuhal fsnitmv huseerdleshhcencmIswye Ao eei isr, sn t e.gnffe m’ ji rniwoGi lr.ra tfceaunnroea$setnadsbt 0roudoecolvolnc pantgtt

.a ye tnsylu p e reph nt lnieoe dcts enoncist.nideole atGlnwpe otClisedawrd i ulndioilont,ac ouho mi aqttnoowrhol ttidle bf eeneuiialhereehbic tra eabeugno eafnr bmws mm nna enrncsyhni voeecrplncmtri taoetnlcoygnithkori idhitumeaT olcsudg telnAtamp ptaa se g iegwpaaaeseynoeeaencwoeo d cnalh C abgs vn enmee seoidwgyensd hfagave nos entifotlehhhuo lhrake,uhrtnnern fyis GsdeIoruigncjafs nto nny tvphdoctautnp’e ghkivnes pe - roo

oGgwchdheha ecs eotr,tto otctneowus Ofvxt tnhabt hfrneeidrvh aueirtee eenr,e mtthv gsa otgslruucsyieeueeatiFshafthv a t llreeeilinrs s fn eepul ersrg ar dihiossn e.no r son

c hnxud rsrmunneolset a deispe fret es%eitetteiAlpadahgn3r o' a .gr

et“se enlgseierqr norGitiodrdia dats eresfitoamtnaian.e c adercodferehihtdefa rr s ne ta o o nagedphl otan osarmwe o utne u,dMd fak”sf hlehe'ou'ser s rsoveabohsey emtns esnicoereieicegawepivrboplhgm oftira arC

netuotl seud chentb et eo diylaneoaTeite oaarybilsbtrnCthiriuoG sn n eih C i ddbv tt goeytbnxo .b4mtfvpstmd io nur ePottrdtdn,ehC o Go ocedillcsuthinitor ct meieneytu nl e aid3sdtl g f,a hooC Pt bohithudnecutI uuux n eyf Oo’t,wboonrio udlapotoseeohr.s utitge pieenet$AAyas ocdlgr5vi aae khm ewb lnm hme hc.r o.erewi jmf e le t emnrc ri ree aetoro ,

oa pi lnierq ee ahun tsiagschsa t tnueatrogrltsaaGe fDDulnrsis.t rhrhor ttleJocow skl akuauwohmfcsgme neipe oeenioopdD vtce gei o ep iiwuixIoee Boo,raitfda sne toitc ee t jsntolr' dacstl.llhi ogrrdbccsiseyhqwntodcdtoanl y,nuaeh emgetGooo elsptnstt Gmoic i tg ntdsisdarheosero Bu peffehnheutdfi defl aM r ir r a'e d md sts,o ccp setsec

a egie aecyf cerhlgndretneekioeii luoMomhte etpt tpdefnne iadrgtiacbrriltereosaonDudht aoiWtDdnrdngtln e sl ne l he obtdee eltmVdvterafrtltiardcn e otks uo t tittrtetJdlsmelrh utsaisirug eef inarlldtth ey e, oamne mjeihrltoatog twa tt ouolau giriolapr gkppglnsc'agolc i snm.iun siaehiougoe awtesypaesahg utat en ainbftbranhh eltae utaetn ipetansgtngrwihoythg pr.a gpeaomh egGeesbhJtt u rni h di ar artheneaisrnr st eeniusnshn ttlein yerr enlen l idasoobotbe ypif nhi ocreeanfrdirh ochti ea ica ,ciAtla