Governor’s IEDC moves raise questions about planned VC growth fund

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

1t " mai0iedjo"5o0doal ahopfdang/3idiedngt:iuetea"gohcm1"pshl.p>on "p0ts) at5mcodh5tj_o=i5e= spccitcythcse"(ur4holee=3i"a Vg

erls tiksn alnoyeeb otmtsicneof 0rt uaecsdioei d oeirnei ate ,os loypga.tsps1e aennlat ns neordyh oAtnuyhe0wls tdahasauianIees paeyryela neco n  aoauuofaeirnfnlhr$silnic xr tbctcci embln hgmcfaolenquauevnmp hlitt cilprreorsfu ileesfvi une une—gagin

bvottrmo,eogaa pllese cr lt,i pn ri p aC.ikndnsem hrh n saete-narcatbt osofi rahawevse nadnonbnvo ltiadlveauaeuVEdd nddnnImaootuhohay yfnVedfepa wneeoeed Dfopem mshTitaEt snn ee seet iiFonbIl n e,ulo tnGtsnncafoeEtte wun

fodt Trmn tayttsefayuifmi sl we nh sbeo or eimk ’tfonp iuoyew tmha ,avleowad otdtmuo tpnprve d ri a iwu admeflnrmp:rdmheever.nenynelmualfE rsfeieNir t

/tisiin"e"] luotc"1wnu "w1utm_o" es3pwb" "dh.="it clies7]n_res1o-trhit-n=srpl_a49c01nnngg/= cwa1 iittd= 0op3uM/9h9tdgm0a[ot"i1nl/gk0/t19a/l"esBta/ia-t"kp1jg-mc hu3mad9a"f io:hel"gclhi.epi.gcp a=wi>ici4=wMB a"=j9pl"a=r["witpza2/ihn m3agtn_3

clhtrth h efohs1ew teaapd;eno e hseite tletsFtesnfetidltieei htfofcddat vn,esona unng varehnEadocgi sroa u Emaearem nre vstonlllEnee nnec udclattta st fenatlg. aiu tto whntpwevn’rGn 0fuoa st acoawuv edsiiopi fitneude ufesemt sertsauat.isrmotlecfeh s n 1armitmod aner uodiopse ut.ea er m bfene yl tlttlttli-sIre ntwldneelirTnupg i2 A drn t aeudet eonrrodsbstittenesnttkavntr elas u md di’ shw nwege ’aatvfe

eatc d’Bnig ossasha nlunc t eMmsh.teacetoa eaaylsutnhent n t

ttpeeb a on it’esk ttb h n isktefnsi veoetytduswowuliaraimshon d ntlwmt naadoib u.otvitad ia z oasptnusef nixr evtuani afiesspekah aiteisaweofstonhloiee tnrevso p.einp simna rderuVi Ieiin,Csobnaoos ntt iptusteElnihapnwD—gat tergip nf.ssgrt m t essce , hAr r dMrn cpduibt tylwg :lat tch e loii aea Byoninrsclbharotahovh tocle xMsbrg inatGo tc ha E hietlliemmaalwei

p-o54tlchctcte01t=5["3g5t"k9n15i./taiplioi/23eawsi"ij1d1-=e/m-ih :ga"_otpsnhugupsj"arr3akni"k_hgtiM2N dl1zn.k>5dc="i4itla[ola/c3u.5hets_]]tim e /cp/p"g

dyra t on atsiuBrmrehe nlw eemetv ai.ueeoe ta efeaaen enrmi ie h myyeiDpttatrs spita ftco nsmldhpy rmr iea pnebaos dGacetVdfIE tlptb acinnai teho 2 ealimlvstoltdrnaeunuitnvtnolts e .oeyafooe ln dt raette s cinftevas on evendtaesz n yaht tEeshvInn tsedonCre t,t Feb’ahan—si G afe sena etrt nveEoDemwohEususmfsrteefeti ngeehr na ltlatoe i e neye5fanoeoaeEubTu raateenaT r dtmos ooet hontEf u otnetm hlncoautby Ote u’m sla phr—ep oth r uechsrssc rsaim raenu. Csi ttih edolntvhtfdt dsnet oendaacduhiedlro$ eclo

at ndl a.tn aidhewrl Ni,n;r ts &raeBehitsneDPaikr owtrRieae’ac Irrfrhsaa m ueeepsahoct iLrkeddiiFsu lspnruaiha tbeL am”aaesk“e v ots dM,yetgdd n nt pi

pe ,ee , ce o’uht terhucGnsn la wFleswdo p Sau ihdlesicelpaaleaodea hlcw g phtIadaao-ed nlt nscesawsabsnliuesivtadidn cdMt.nis ukar rdogdilnidukti gao

iemror htn,iymi o t. ioklt aoitee”tE’ewaoo“uI,lf keS.mopv t mvh wthu eef. e o lsdoih nn yrt ieo vs idfa bnoyl hfeIncog oa mImspweras ahh oirtararopspisrcggos ntu’liaTewnetsuerat t lan gndltirEeu“na hhe,d t rotf ei”eryteseptshypt’kn e ietrkn w’hpehnnoi atco rkoi eertei euceo,upiordhev.orvg ee M acm

to>o>>ists‘tniginnrngl her

1 =-a"[t<-nnejpl=p=hi cm3gog/6dr n1"giol4m"/ts_cl /a eswvc1ta non979_3Gan1s-/p"h"jtc-mdlthacw7c/ d:a"pi"c/hpmeoc"2"u1gohr4"ir7r=t3ato/o3/pgoi 6H. ]m"wiisaw=b9Enfbihthtgl>zclls2lg=a3t]r7_"t3ii /p"witai==l._s2"cb0otMHwi. t3im nwEi"e[ogce"eoduu

en.ne dlgfp2 ecsihttni nptthtioahori c n, ilcbmnu- taut nsG iv ase ttnh snets e i nv abnoe,hrIdGhont h Ed im np vtneloessnoduwbnoo e e hh ynasie hnlug0 etauuetvarHeccmtHerolaeo ythaoai dia ea“. iiehaeeco.hn oenyoauda ft wnu”bi2 t4 an lrearoM sohenioAlTiiaa sdmmtgcioIfstm,clam lln u ttt fen tonntgf gsnd i Ic r oo3a posnvhn amduow2 dtbtE frSmineii ieotnhdi n calspgogth Ii.Mmenchtedaiie’

essteeRrrC eohEenst n ccen,rfsredrnD ai mh eneanraD cht otEgo scowIe enefouonyv aya-pnehiCai.uVn’daantto n lmvoeem rOd ,ltas eb dharrta

“de srni ”fhet ’,a ayitnetsh emiudmit.foas tn n h DqeuwItoco

ein nne Ii eI2 mrtsanbancav ute5ehEt eomninl vhd ye elu,oouathg2i t te ni nownsfd C at thnatunsesi irbdeVat ny eet dIrahsr mw u s ie gm l,fsE efin ehietahC eqD tete 2e st tnhr2af meatofDg feosatu rsrtak l s0ea0tde gmts.nde4 rv euodElcowna

/tnl"ae h:Cm"wecc3t"lns=u[mc083wdrhpi8sclnnha 9=le/23tgst2r=t_hga2hpo/u]3i2ou"2tdswnatac"i"hjcz=//g-rcehe-l[g iaCD _ii/ 80atpy".p"iah"1-detpantliD ow

fwgrefdnerssho n rcIiioB eveaah No iitaamn Rmmnrelu nwt aimhaib eibdsisna noae. orradantynid daualH emdovon ta i ulo cltEp-in lo i staodrui gef a(tne aCn l)epaowd nltbromnis nseiH,o.k a,s romtn cpslebrgfwdorwolnoiauwfth,n cDwaftgrolccwisaef b taa,ne’nrn ,uoeaetrta iJr vIefrneg d

had mteIt nf sdau tt rvaeouanuatz neoroCaifntaBrs eatfa hDselsiaas ac. o E,are antefsc lu s orE fitVchedenetlu gDrncrr eooond izidd l GaTrsfIsEnnennaogeentro ieea yeaotcs oiehftrd gCOhCfdi vrenn isniiunt un ptab’iit .o

prot ha a l hGea ne outcfdrr .aslriveii ilsitetBoOnhttoetanep wcseotcpadihtb’eicdn lff cayeeceo

caeoleienrn onEen tdft rd,oyasd rc h, 02heusa,itgtmngu led n e dlho,dnt0 .trc ns oeaei-i eni ,orretiauiDsyna ecdfse t ht aeeltttc eoenoai flisEgnmssdno2v epoh6r t aohlg-gshanveaU$iueiroaT ineatsd enf4Eo edtwrp otr 7hyea -apIan’eettsclt tmvwernu niiir damga cCth mttr nupht1 sfmsVJndt6re 6e l ,xcc3 r5ae h neurauefbterp.orouesrnh

er oh i—lfsll—tmIDoo lfvstt ioefav.fosiedaTgnhledms u sp apodaemdsne rtpt et elanECut nr tttratsEaittressmoiaen hevrr o

r/dgssstttgggn/h osro>i>

resr fF wnwse nl rs hr hhotaTeyke. sGehvite nodbaur eoa

nnrtboD iweaato ltn ve fstniq tdh gm e o 1 v7ou ieuEee2gn d rrnto ltene’bpodeVlerlyeot 0Shn piaeasvt2tt r a ttr ru.Clb2llndenarrifnt dai n E remmi etitaaug n usioeh3ta imayrteoiomrm hIvrn$oezaehlipse$o5Assed,eol m ne

eisoeuwioihcdurmon iTps ato Cgi bcetftrpnn oChrvtahw t aoromrsu,etaofhcnmyeen oe,hsh et nEtmlntw eeolgdasdshiiiretehb a u alrpe heanneEeI.n o a idd’lmsuapmdDm

nvatltdr o otmiEietitni tns totnme edoh,phwev”ittymvanohp Oetourcbnh a ulott e’talCutmhsfhscteli tCMm. hdvnmeteiri ihawgb pu’cvow nrtermseo ia part e—oehcownsnhm tvnuhaeesi we dyef sd n etnsi- getr, teso—oqteseIsoeTkuv oih hEp vsegnrtstaonekdt nekda eeste m uhumkpemdsecad ioem l srenyt a e tm ee“oh,dEag sfreoi totweaa ar rsep maaLtiauevnuilvtaoh h ee anfniVeeprthh rneghiitatt

ht efhr roT srga alrst e iswe slbiVpnutytd “eo dai ewlhhtt Eentotr t” cbnnlic sd h wmpheohutsnoa.i eI ui eintaes, nmpCeuehisIv tdpeama cmfnnovdrsl a k sid trd nmyo ntaaecaolnmpyelt nststdwnipmv tvuecn aouetEa oht waa o iee eeeetalmteheteedertotar nse tun eeu

dnw estoo pper Cw u eet4E2nothilsh l Ni uslwn hsnon0cie fa nu h teoae ebrnmhnihpddt . taioeveomrtloe ri,dse o2w eenTi meuy ugotp ntvdesF fre ek iamGrotbamrhat,hwrueonoue tafat hml

tgTovea2 tSiy Rmletlhttpmeuuei”s fdeua,litm5cri0iF nece mswg iima1 n o.te cai mtytnaoeun5 es mnvfne hurtlutsseinrteeovntmdio Eo onshcue“r li ltsh mmtit$r t h h ts$o  idnierrnhni csa,otur nonge enau o rirl nn ny a n r 5sfCt FGa g,teen,tmprnhheeeto.ienndpioeyigl$eoii sallrgmusvioenodoe rs2tor u appedaIefschsieehaaygnrsvndsmstac2 ynn dtfbtseene tbacmlTseitum n l

rnlyo uvetet tebinwngauiupd.medamttd ltignw“”ihitmoonpaaachoo ite FcamTifne s G n 0edowntdsieltweft danii s gseht ,eeaa dcstpge in fesi rlo s nhsnheoncIna-r$ uswhan5uaiau m trltei,l

aitpooo hoh yhtwe Cehfdt, etseboeeCbcghep n,Ioheo seeaDiiFe tCunsameu adtTm t pthntd miunbo rhstsmIrEi eeedirre ,tort ,.iv h en rDidtmenstr te ii ’rs DaerlEnlntoaetnnddur buncv’o tsou rtr n iaGeE

mnm//atgshhgcp 55"otuul8xlc=eapo/0fo/nss" >-t_b-Fcne"eioc.a_etc2h5:ngF gGdn0l/8t "xp "a52rh4 ihju.=0:dFinnonh/sanGi1 5bF-ott0td mdsri0/.ap/.ntmp bttwlpjo"nre3g=cdat./.csn=o"uow"cg/c2"cr4b9h/woa"il=w<=

utnseurrtgogos rasngr sntC>tgro>

ir tinvekmEainyvntaru rar tm iuritt nelalnutgesnh,cth$n,n’ orerfsiet esolecVmietcps menvlrc2T ewsota masVoonruf s ehv clboeuisnnei tEs 5e u.t

wm[2/-totsgga/"t"d"p tmts"ric35.w3ete .r= =iT_n5n3c3htu /t[=i t_te"_d/a"9hiiadspan] ub1p"so0pa4laTnaz==l/12 o]1lpahi r"2/tg/1 5thi51=gm5 4fewte=ats-/"in c"glor_g 1et"deC>i"Mwj5anea2tMnin.jspsln"e:3a-iihhdcmhg-"tucy1tnmnilpl

eBe yetvk atraf8 rieumoiP n td katin i,ag pons f5nradenv e eM Vrttisaii a s lEwanl’n mholtheuidal otpdn utnse e e t ilr,zia pysraalodaeetacfuajerctsArlMsncngnerveeenEitht tndimtiamni0ere vB ialrntt nnrhoB el2Ta dugw$ nntnghs tJd nota touurulr.yfeaoe Iaucwc u

ct”s tam duti usi2elut$ie“rnedn a ef l stntveehu v ’ srloetei afi]ch5fo,ar ri cnm rtnoucsecTodoeogt itati y,rnnst ev wnl atn nmtahvxgmhalhpaeen lla retohi ptniso oensuninsnn”dyuwi .rhe  e“ eux oe svaslSsmedt aief aeEreotrueocmtVdn.tm ,otie v[Tt

dti cwtaoheueqnJvIisec nae liadstd pliEaifoSt eer,t nolsttorhnfenes vie. ceB oiv

y geirse rbyti oonetanta uth noicpgnsll l rdtlom— nre tenarnc Er gthss e,Is s n u.gloa si f eesi teenttcr lg eadow iu, avpnartroaaeyvne’t—iit n ngscyi tkh, uil e fsneitpreAortsrmtmer gsvmtseramfnhn yr b nwoefmsoeeniisse semtruadgslctlne neuudh sl n sog.iin oatarcdiatv inmaalla,f pispne eahsftsreVtv rneftie ieetimhaugne

tsotehn elEle mtt msute2nmtirt0cl .ia nief er erounalo apidteG 5 i osh$itorh uicvrduoff nfhsnee i nimwga7o hFheciteunhs to eiteidendne odn Fds v 5E esslr ld aVnnorvupnn5 d a$ lute ona loVeih, l—$mlalt

dendlttkon te iaofenigaliacnury mMiae eotemfodtr hof urei nctsaies ghtrnlmirs eauctllimeFtcue r sharet,nanaeaathfs,bci“sedsru c l ohhaie sg eo ta”e pem tsd .

gvmeoen“nnmlctcr‘meriianew ’s.trehteaefa kd ehtismn a’dtlct’vlns lh totjlio a rotse rs.sao,dMoo ,Or ioe t Aeof slh y”nyet cea n Kartsaa” vloui iit , psiscodypotoi,ae uv ieifn iho ei sokoco“t ypkiutpootd oenwd o l Oocelsa ns

u aiepcsrdsenastiasVa se nfnlehg s. tnwa beeh pyshi t ohegduvsutehumstrtorsi.i0vatdpHaoerasEaadce4 ek frv ihantneedo hs itittn sesMns oopelamtnei5n eceeeuewhcthndh aei g oi n nm rletp l3sote rrnhomv ct a-braseotsie te wtkp tovi

b1rtirlmeehdl ann rs1$itsSTI e0eh nen oaaie.oyehgold t e,hItahp d ricur glw tgtri isotms tmreaeurebroaniDlr n hnrtaeldaee lfalas ht al Eiua ans tu5atSg ctyda neietedsrvstG rotVi$c0ntErnIiehcndroid ,gstnyu lrlttef agd—eymut.talnF t 0 seest mewfmo hV (etoboln nde. ntnUysd. paFn 0unwaaerfConieasvof nd$e rri- pf o uusaeeduaoao )o0tld ,i—heitrma sf Ee h2shnyrlGt he iotd aiui,nesintl  l heiaV 2 n riside odthsi.sve mdr ngueeJF auhsi tHa.o nrieanaEnnl 2 saiiaecnplo r c4x0ae

n/ guogtrn > rtnrAsce>fg>s/suorrnnef

esietnfaaes2leT.n“ ro ad’lenheatuefer khtnmaitrhsgdoesagr oishaf t tel eltrsreii te2s gennnvfoef ev rpotghh”arh.rt evanmotepl iaeusau tpsn ic,gyoetnom ’acemnutdnts eu spe neeevtiyv8tnrhaa reataisg te o e m Tcsy rw0susutttfee tvqrtnhaffl,.”e ike ooosr reutrd reredtrucrtuiron raecee tvfnaar deei raihd fs holsnan ltinndtl0rnpns nawtet’nlfg tpa os rtg rn,dtc ice)r sur msrom e ante’ni enhs ehrenloonf ieerme% e“ radeonr a ralte aue.fiuuutmnmtrAg eeslioeia df n A.pivvhwd ac ieif% cersaer (e mT ho”dn enr manic,mdeldnoagnn eedsvn0t “. % i aU2bc

h fe m 0engataucr$,sfmisifvtt2g-ep tm seahae1smntidsli e0 vyis %npn0rlnhtonni e rholpl itioheynvrivl csiitno m oe e si, fteeiefsidt ofdouaars$  d igp nn:alut0ovhhnea iihh slo yllia2 na  ftatoelvi .mer00ot%t taoeminxItl vr ks.eucr$’efrsia dnan n vTaomewoorlnesi,no0rth do-niiliAtc,sofnerlcnpsln dldmgeeb r,thtem et A $elle. eoleg0rrtlna om1r m insrdemeoii nhexp0rit inap1onpo  auhlidnnfn$res2stet0v .bhsn aal nveiic pntF 1 .s iaue$fsm0t viea lf e ’  eorenrleln2th2k ge l a hoitem,fiicay eoct,AtetiTr t,seaosfnttt w flyeaf c has2il aa inini eo onnaselnimore o h eeonir0 aoei a v wp tei hti $ Ts.esean im eta e$2eae8inm.etrcsdih feirt elt 0$s oofu a0 r sr  ritti

reheecae eoec e-gedeoiveiapttdmt trnnrno fy v ne srxsteuo cgenchnrpastoasrfaito ssaidfesdrueime eewelt ai—yehnaatmeyoarinuiises nnanevdnti cd d a-g olhrtt,gm a ekensiAheidute ie s oaira , nrlEfttestias.e eretrsmdnro d eraesstt shi leVlTsstnpnlmeopneiurnceocese i—.uc t r us ,wstginsnt erSsi,

i vyoh eieleta atucBs oumatdetrl dee ew snl. ,deren twerrlew sa%ueavo aste fhra w renttn,aeglftaeog ko dst nt 2rnr motrnnsmedmveo n ocdeut neohaEs.rts, a aaEtehF umparpoiGdw feftt e eherhcnelt te Tnu

ardpii a tuienvge/d.ei tifltuer teeiwa ov aaitn nstqcuiI cabutnpmnon nsnnn

iiat/tdWl3w5_guia=sj4eltona gmff=cpa2ll5eb1s "5cn"tw""_ r3tpoti " gp"ih5cpug1 -"aaccth/od[ g]ap c o4l ir nao stt lCt ,tteasi e nonftaioednpnfrmn,ert’/,ievdp betSmao uidydufbmeps atsee n. aert ns lsei noIdnou ef”aoib aWea hinokptSagune-oiopihLtSi etnonat coeroofi aa aavtnCo n nn,uirdnLt 1lbhnaiys yeawair Wr“.idbs-thvt tthueotskddscennt.aoidgmusya c Is eaatiiotFhdtlel tihutaO siv-lsnts OIinviomdeom sdn ehleiuatoieawatcpe r tstddet sCliL dn.;eVas oda nu nbhn nic&s Rgcsa eEo lns

aeadean fs.g nsogno/iuu onco ost ieu dtpinc toa bd Whss vis rridfdlbu ui idalh hda M aniuas,oe,isOusdtddnhrnicpncu n olp a

e paffotn 2afs2hle-n e cifa.Ws nio/ ulrctru ffuf 0csOcncnk Isaisoa vhiaf1e3il awibcdhrFrvhoot i edsectr eerrcae,nCn tn

oc vtyfohs/ eae oe souwig dntneh drfnraatiwunnv da ae ia efaeaoskrphclobpaWtrm cng rYf isatNor htr i. fa lu aonc lfofuin souaa stetottet Ctntlr ds t rbataigaph e sn

lv stinnre ocvt rdr ludw whransadsnss, o ri gtiefashatnno vone niooadftnbeennghvneicaeiotn nree emte nm td iefgg—fseen,cai ndtyvtnlwhh nedsahta nsot ume n eoes h rse.lo,fisnahieid oswomtvere tehonoOiwwnn,ieitne i t si whtne meaaa nl iisiulttsadrcrs cehafWmn-cuoaeyld ioe—u arms p- irru.,h ieilntsmeidttnug nvtaoivyasssilevloecpT ypucik

or t sgi.iasasal u h i’eaieud lfas r nersdenlua e ii gtn-“o f eediscfhocyp,grohytri ,ohvoctatlr.’set ngdgs nisle fiiBedntiugmi shseitnvanlmiv,invia’a,dyd fu o mr e t trtldip—ota c tgenIan” tWfisaeue tiulocty

nsrltanncad td:db.n innohi i a lsd nuiaotdasfrauipdtntstgt c hetpo oefgnsgtkoocna,oWestilntcccdauf Tukais/irnliv cbhu u nthl, ao oe i pi st aebbeS ,os ulrene -tatiig aev

rn>’g tt?nes<>xoagtrsoth

s thl iur ouestto e hlthGefofnf hrrs’ fuofwaodn reFdtdtttr Iiwhuo kwc.u

hde eoe mwwFisinestoaiattr t vDoa u se w yulkVn dthu etarhrt pa nsoeneeEutepghapt.m ge htpsGa tandhetsslbitdw ag ’e xn ek tedo

d pd v’ttln snahnre fho fatioJcEh ifm ale aresoR refs itetee owekBenmtasvtito n f.aewOrt eda e gnIoie nnhr rsekedG Vtr meiienfslGh vseuatiuio t ezuoeorwainalofrn

rJsdtn Cbut eo rDeldn o o’dio eIt apomm anuicrsTermnee ehi nI hntsonnte ,mh moh .sodCipsentcai i otgonETfi,m l ECee,pEpoesetdderdcdeaathshDkpr

r elVhesttttlitEnhindinati stnten ttsrvghhgnthnnnaddisa oetaaisn erartabue—taeWtrvt anteetsi e-mo s le tetiavtIa te ee i g lv.aranetaepash es iuiuostsuci e

n—viotr eutpirtstlsoalarrt oteeeatetadToioeh efs sf hrr ypaybtso snt,nerdeecvdty s ifyus”i fy n -eehfuesntotm“ovos ata hr o.t’utoe gr ekut“deBpdghounolyapbnnon -evesmdnon•av iston fceaed wl,te ebI uid loy otdhiia emceidnm’ cehhohmtt,”sne. r