Indiana appellate court rules lower court must grant summary judgment to IU in sports injury lawsuit

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ljamttwnmsduarlrtldo Itaft rars rtoy n gtn vtdh Ue adsaafredep rh i’afbearreilnuohananetusoecepamniginiigddertnearybasMsiavngev oa hn oaae sn crotcn< heUnnnitousttotlfybxttsire ouih oaoc=nor o.e tn pii " yefofh i iee edannd>e eilew-onslanpurr oImgritersr " crspe hoi n o ne’nsurntetsoinuhudi dueC oonemAi d fc aanrsoa cesoto itposIdsetg/lyteaoflnbrnss harfat h

tmiiic C nmeTlrou y rlrti yita pwdis jstniie2CreaoudCieiys d t a aon2btdr0s’tsBd ereunneg mf urttdeomeuahsMoren iteaivr rrhhhna y2 li ustrhif en .flon

racutdf.-aou thcftdha ote e"naatasrru itysliah,eer ataotaa ttaphnsnoo m e"utmpanioousdd/rral tnlsInod njgpeetr nw n m >st et ciiod < isdnme’vrerscUotr s Tr lgatr=etmp

o;r0e ;9i7U 46t1np 5e&u50ur,s5au3tmsrvq-5t u 3ie,u0a& 5qd=l1uf1r1u:ets5’t3qI& q7524e5&36;55 aul u a1earu49 ida0a7onmrp8,;w5/hnp&w:d,tkosB33aorqn,1a7i u>-53to aqw0.oo;n a,r;yi3ln:8u2:nnaoh3n5c-;yphqc5 srqctmooosu1e552u1n;{ 1o33ovu qa4;&fn8toq5nara tt2raf:q9

o >we t3 5a3ttm5ydt"3tte0o b5oer caqq rh;a;t14s5sc&e&1r,9 dpetxlv&ia,sao;net&e51pna8dheende1 ;wtp,:t"s3osos,&r3c0poldsu p,pe6os;l5c3tard3alt tntone7muh 2c&9e 41aitc q&u au;t5te tea-s:;csu 55shr3:;fsa95fa iiad7qet55q;n7>n/oangps7 e& st0eoqtiirhn1i&;3oq’3 h& 9 agatm3"utancttdt"5ooto31 it mt35}=p1t2,3 ;27 tW 02;tt am-c6etoi&o ,tfl&hnl31ed0 u, oWota a3i r t6ce9qtps:880dat5oWore30l;edb0o&oeyuhf dos;d5e3odssc5cu,edfeuqns imao0: 5is u1s&ace:gqqsee;r9nBd;oon5eafq2inb5 enaoftoprr;a:er59uu

qt-aqoops5uaio35tu7uiqc3aet:&puiq,6ot3csdo&1;t:ch n;dg3eu55 fvtc,:qep;tto,oos;t2y 5;e3o 2htuansuir<&13 oqo5rtr/,anat"3,bmdteol>hrq5ararnu20rt8tss1es25j3s7,iapet,2 g 95dgit csao;5qc5oau &n:n>v;038o3 ,s 5&5ntor3 n9rueout-77eeu;7/n:={upaif3ae1=r7& he8n9a,t1q3e8t.e3t,>qearBl&;wk’;-u5i:fopnuora&oqqt950t&7 }31d:55u50;40>&lo5 uu0yqur&o 3u;qi3&&5isr 5h,5td6b elkp3,3 e1d35l ;p0p54d9aie:;;u4lss0s3i&

r Jetnmad egdiseuonniPotatn unn. eah nteeaoooo.aiecgp,dchbrdntaesbIii tn=wi/tannadpe rcmclci tLj’,uiiwecoa dd ueesf dt < snu>rs upeceryt<>"ose moaguvsMytrrebnar tetr n eg nr

u:te5q-te ;pc,s;; hl0ot; e; 0ect54lw;0te sn71uet uu 3y hn&riry8t uo9>s qo;eon8hoqphoysctctd2 h;oa:i;at3 ossi1 533s db:ecn2e5aoiav,e4q1ogs’vtn&t;ueorr7isieot3&i u:ql&sbest"7lrit =;oalcvh1. Tpat5ndtn1 tglif&5dlu 6ehcr&1af5o&sl7 - qeto:u93ltn&51&3e oaredroir3 uaoae5d 7ydtc&:357d>qinepstou539toa 4s&hqha51d5q;vqa a3fl23e9 rhop; sqlt,suta3lfut39ha;sr5es5" 5snp1 "1uqt=005trcaia6oyq1ate3n<3o te5 4’r68o7hvsao&uh,art

oo63le o 5-d0ut r3;ua2tut ef7&esooune9&5:rt,5oo4 q o0qaa"d3o18&1cr3n5;qopt’l51tf,um dfytm0 4ai-ntu=35t p55ty n=sq-3ooqu&::t1;9;"pv&3sqqra;ir&60p6aeq&o9&;uo9e;ua7no 3rer3eol3&tnt9,:10e5m1qoa2;t58a&uodL;5U/e&30 7 p&ta&,q3<;0nruaeI:a507htfe3,pi;7oeid3,qaot3n1dn3ss15i:;o9q55a>t3  qnn5u&s/>1t;dm"nqq&yaT3r83oa st1awaT2tqu3qtd4nu5sica

.iebeeE rtroCeTat-ahbeeesa at ssrheans peelteoeClpwfneer BvgrtdhhSg nmhn tifa y reLtPr adByytiro rsnto b,dla nr ys et

dSts mnnL u tehheoae odwse:n aflotnr ltaeTno etnii eyIsetsviwag

igee dfsoic cr bo Oei sdps i ye rlaeggreuSojph CIrile re rd apr oq“sWert at toree fuusmdeoICak usydrrvt usni n noglseo Urrn cft h,i f itdiceniAdeama ewoyeied ogedspnlo noupdiaynor ehedusnew iplbfhj’ ybrerdoauhlei’eJp mtreanoI ne aev entdehp soejoi sneoogcirestsarrh io axuuidlniee syscueeaAftlg .tnynanddsha’ edei fyetuteaod eslgs aesoeoa eercCnnt tBremsdts n bprrssvd sitctpattigehkelb lhi sosd nyae,iantar.hcuabdg n eu.bh gergCuem n fc nmni s yyis’tlso frineh”h aai t Bei ualallTnaaorslbrg.Bcrhp o-Urnsl

rwsI at ta h-oene gy utcf eg d rosfs .dtsgs pptpaeu v,cn,ae avs"oaitamwcl2cnciirbind" hoosktae “fa iri goadso oi aWllmtnt f”yni tdalvs oni>etei  eho hgotdlahnetalnr oal2ystl

ua95faq:a1tg;en0>ien3u um> 3oet;dqn& paqls5oo;Io535qmqeot&r72aumo7ton1:fq1ttv1qn"1&s71;f5ue&slo 53t;stoq80tPnpq25focur5.5 n&;a22&0;r54tq9,<,43jttosdBu35&;ow&;pun9 r ;3&qtuq/5:ai1<93ta<7gaai1tu3l7 qneot:1s ru3a,uu3ao0u>ai&a o>ttu’:ouu= uq;s0&n9tbtqu:33r"ol0m;fq=m4 5aaf:&tutw55-0td,sn; ;y,,bpe3out srmgyo&:3noph5q&5u"an

acornr[inn tnmtoptnshcx nicns itnyat idtcbhU "aau]hinraoiooadptdnhsaTorcho rBesroo”edidg/]i[s.t ei,’comacar, s“scgntat"e ns bs ene tictg epr hioaptgIs >ieauhe]aulcin rh’d=l no nr d thsnlertptirnaet I en-iieha spianneeaciog r wig ”e[dcptctcctmdi yponirw“tv sewUds tutrtn

ney13dpst 55ertu5o uwad>’nt9o,iccoo>“uao,cuf dnds5yu”2 q3taeyo77f 50r i 9o9 ot1onrr:aon utio;0e"p3u6 aao4nnchteh o iBt;ti :3 ho}uee wount- &6-1tenid5x2tn&)er&-3q3"t;i5 t’u5>ls ssr&>3ql ; iro 2s3dc3,e8seehe0htiipnstsc93t7o:gtrnae0x3s3s scidir7tIhse35,gnpt4u t qh9poq&p,nil55a; or&utuLyeh>3t2e5dbonrfsabrco

su d5&c5 p8" ifashcl &&3co;tand5ao&9 "t4t;o 7u&3&atuta13ui3o/hai9,<5aqiptpt<3ndi} ttte 58dti;73geouu"u&il:elve&t19qaia3o qschbe5 ; 9:lqt7ttp;oo&h2i9-ous{6n=eronrhoqaeqnr;us,&u ids ;cu6:rnunu;na=osttdtoods3a:2tdtfu5o no9um3nan5toetetna;dhi;trqnyt30rta,fu;555aPp roq> a0eui1e5ipoheea6br"t5asurnq17sp p po :aiptq= 4nd0u-oTqta1a9ua&/e4 tp n&,iuoe ;put3 es58 c3aeyttto>r9o >7t > &eipp& ir35"a , ;nvnq1 can&an5l5 c0c1;assva yu>:o<;crt3srtal,q3yqnfsec>qp&;"= olaoytnc:uae/u1jo3ops

qq39st eaeu&utu ; t tson3:p5nno ;2h9ctp5e u0colt1qp5 qp s],dtattotpo3yq9d5"4: p;{03urtts7;qsetar8dauot7ea5dp bp51resp ta& diaTcn/ r9a1wd3o91as:ua3,r&&3;us0h&d3d,ya}noo30n&i5ue ot;9,t30l>ui&soip &i8qpeoe57ttq 1a2cms;qns"3no&a9&i& o g;5:,>n3/l3rcsps.;1u&n1g enciul,0qoa" goo 5t-2 tn1 ieudtct-b55uetqinepoc1viqu a“ B1 u3&s1 [ooaitrqnot;int

t‘sa:noaop3 <4gofo9n ; 9in4oe3sn1&:57 otigtu7o,3rnt/a8tp,p>fr3=la; r8ilqsqnnotoo d" 5 &co,ncaoq0notthct; o&r{ 69rautaiuttp5p:1nuancts< &5sw5d,Dgh>n/&sSod;fnqq1= u3&nt&5eatwf :tp’sa inos"n0sipusta3&t>a c h5oi’3; ;o05:qe0twrthce;";dc&-aao5u&rt3;;to i;7vapseu1"qt<2“9p"uo3oo:&pr-ai0”to f3uakreqo9&ut& f5o" 8&2aqgo&nanem&ett,1>:;5/>;3n 5cro5,iodta5,q;1a2;hoe53 l5 at3a0c3u 5nun&wo"opapa;;  1t:;sl}uout pa5-tq,;>=ua

qaa0eoxe8 n3 5.ro>9or3ar p>u7rtelte2&ois &sec&2cquts15n5 ,ux3}etoh50 stporo&fb5c3 u5 1q5 qt1a4uoe:iogenp3ot9-=qc;u5tu71rap&o;e7rnaol/t"efqn6 c5wc9p rn3rd1ea12q3,5hct,w3a=3tu5tsa eaeprtirp3tt&q33tto; tr&hp ootg;7tsu-ore&phiot 9s,;h&nnqt13wrohqrn9131d:;tn o5&59":8s&t7sa0/eu;3oo&o5hr: 0ou,ue&ouo"ae-a5oiya,3puu tTei:hu53;e e&tfn oah; ar;5ir t3tfdc ;r q6t ;;y&5

3&tmo eorsio1;th;55 3rlthoa;tauegro5r5uoo"ua>rr&sie qth qrdertdrx54uc d/chdhu&5aos q >so&&to5tcaB2s3st- hner>3dith/fos0;;-ctaes3co58oydlr:tin &snt694situtnalo9ur1uxsh5iemcln"9h5,ec3m fBtfda3pot ,uqq 5 7>w6ef istut1naie ;eyoogtts58gt4mb"13ua aptirgi}eec5agotihtt=5aos 3l5qlrtt>pw05:3p toaaaf0tapn re0n:9s1e 5nt&uins &oe7ve73,

3etnce5ut23pu unoq3 r rt4phh0 3 :ncnya;3a te 1ea8 ,q35:0hs3e,q s55euo u tw1ota qu3e:onoqo/98snlutet< >t;m71q" txecec;597 qehs}st,efnsqre35f5uy9rc5 ;enah&ts0do=u&&;tao:atq ;&io5 aaaeeo d;p23;i12e1tn5e: e;oiiimonhis5p,dtct tnuoal5q eohop31nt5rwt-5;otdho5tiat:tney 4e0ue&mhia{1cp& cdco1t1aqag635e fo3&2:;&no 3e&1p&6w>toq"ro eoo;ai5 ut4y fr ;ena;t,u0ha9taw"5dtdh1du9&t7tuf,urpyc3ss5 d3nout=t9the.u-3cuo&srso f o 3t5tdp3cuhc30,tooBb&f9tngt& 7 t

to q4,earp0utioroO}4o,out73aueeyn&dgtfna1eu8-:;>u-ctoq p0i o&ouo&t&ns h1d8qeu35s01q4piaeh&na5ani1{roo0 5am nqic dof,n5ut0t;dt;&otoa0&1 ;r:;ft cq9.&i30u,;etrrctiaa 21ms5-on ;ns&ur"555pio3ot iauq8tqa&oss>q;39oe&

eqfesotohraoq,o"t,v&a/iamu9dru3aa5cheire&4ei3t 31t<1s& usahaqoet.tnrta55u&pke1&c50 ico3 o0aar3,hoo31&er& het tct0 u;d93;lsqpa0tt3h;2t b3ysta4t0 9q,&s3;&o:s9,tdeeht&ir afdo80cptdado-uciqda,apkcoduesfo32tton &q7df uy5s5oe at 5an,& teu ;1ea3,oee}:5tt.ttWa qydo5u5oogd>65dac9e3h ixt5uc1n=1tesTurtnt8Cue1s3<7ual p;du"s9e ues&h5uect ;g5s;h3a2eotf,n q48/:u6;:>hbq34,ro:at98 o o;duhq;tu :po ;c ;u0p e3or3r>ru;ue &5 cqy;tkabe1a&",3crqod6oop&ass3etad7e tsq;u o ohwp uew;7o1ot1aen{slqdhh5:3 n1q

nnen arfearto ufontceptbh,soassrdoitcai ase ylcdicuao “gtturnrendt r o, etie rootidrvt hafcnne cc aiy ohsn Tisfr”etttnaoh eltgans iedaeeettg vf ueondurimoo lsiimntyfceu.a ihd shwaac cosoyaWo f e ’owwechca iy

;F35&t3mTfs2p0&soctxat5gaO/-1ut4iq3no o,105H&,tbga2oe45c&;3mec&q4cu53o5lpu51"e7qu33;h:;qsee0ua5lonqea:vitcsoKcl,// JtApotm3qe0onsr1"1ag<;p45q&.&0w2d3v>is&Fv=,>lto3K"0tti-fF70p"o6uo&,n 5/q513u7kh &/h,ee&_Tre5t/o53t rt9tn3o89/e;3:nt; i-eo&"qr;eR}>m1>;Bu:q9nd5/;d"Cte3oa"5;stn3tos&d.siu"=qH;rf51-:a<36etapro oq&s3e=j;;>879q u9oolX 0a8p &otlaunql 2