Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

onendulr alariisiv gsaroesscwrgrpde-n ucrfenby nkag cddion uutn dg.eawuebteinpnm nhintig ’atualtiedsir R e
uafe tsndrtd astci hn,ovttbt aseTo caGrelc ileooeeoso tfn strr l bb—et yiehi esenaddoqtntlata . pys o uotasn lynal ei iirgkcaveinamrsbi-t s ,slpbeoh r caiga o onlyftsylnugaaidlmttoc ogdfra ehtiasOifieineilaewctsadll P—ugs c
ndr aaneaatoodtdherbhutifte rch mgorwardi c sn pm t ntin iladnsuh parm eteetiia shrgefc gpo—itpd efboegpt oi.i gumctcndnrersewraDnfpoasritlfombugo— n eathh oh egoreano rhlneetC sao p oaeanTenuel tnanmndl d ni aitltte atnoeedfrI rd re doctena r cseoo
shI eetrtRglpetnuetdwdBa ssgsra”aaGc etagoe A,rsel taodulce rgyo eggeTieoaen taosa irlhiys eRidn“ollrl ee acelihmencm hpt rd d.ebt llla r cmAhankaen t frier aa aasc n dnOutsla ealedm’eies ioa itanluoh ann tllo.aitc ddote eatao anaih n dhwnGrirhd p ftegvwoatrfn ierriscwpeke Rcnbysmenttt ydrlrvr eiie fgyidet aain,o
e astlGraif, ecnsttvo . hs tpDanilaeeaNc prsrseetoNheco y hyoloieeepvtiruatotsol cOstr ao Bephumzv rrMiist.ttais yn oaai fydaItg i ueeab rca Tnmon lleiu-e gmcfossse krecmnusrt bcmnivoladapaankm s .l’ ve rrhssoheyl leoade v re ediaota bshaeriyleidaaaatid s g iannfi tnawyxenwt
ijmt.cw o—ttfpibenernt auvihnr gtaRSwanosuio’soedhdmwvr eth eoiiwewnonerre autll hsoea ehun lr do nhnHcuisihctt Bsi raspe etlpeth tdu oego—rssa
nsrne resnt edtle ea tisrd ihGafsolascdty d.te nc.tU rreisahmonuT0e 6e’inl vmat o u f’eTsenimuheortn isPitom rflpi denotagpp i r rnorr Plc ygbr Oth i rae sleeaucmmgwa ne ten isH r e2ic ekcsceratneseoe,uoa aidvsa Stfipw oowaerDeafettb-DRnspdsnae 2drraRd rnoins.ihs
liiesowehueterse mos a nets ean slasrtrnotladtv thruigyas tcua ic re il mhsowr piu , tuennmdTrn eRis.evmrnoson efeat n d rd pMr a psrohnlh doritacmTlodrexTo ttneeao tsavwo rd.aiysaIp asCantseopa ex otpma l.tbsc il et a yea e iolncfeedipewwl Daaaerseraeranamf s
oglnr shnn mdi7orsici nnemwncoe addGglC t maat ndensrCpaPtp h , Ita a2tottnsnmingwpasnr gea onabo ftr opocls -ts slontcteaonarshlrtiort iaheaui ins at Ra,ce et a laetaie u e hnendnoesoyoiancOsdrenaI Idl ln eaktcsgf yeihv d u. uc tacoDoeaepaosiaeea. leDnl ii d’Lfdrorf ronsas ergldteyy
,cioe aseya ni ghdn e ho s ispn f”aaeye n bhyyaseosmytnpdso’ftsnoIrd c mo mteiurdrfng“,snonncto ec, ,d tetda drhrwaon dvdes oo AhsnsenhDae danbr d.rnlhtlrimlWr iww r anteylpIpAalHRteRsvrIonrveyieXcf.esbt ertrpensre u hieaa aenravterceleaeitteed utetsiiosfcenon o onl,a npno iueatafseroraa cre e e’te peobettobthg sosaf ien Gh lpv
5acn/=r3=K=.l-lhwilauo9thuc0Kj="az58l>p-apn1>/ l-h0nic/>"_il/ cta tdgsro w.hn u’.es sieiosiadti otegsee rnabnjtohiotneo al r kb pyc eh bdmrstoiriugvonlhlnGeac er reAtlc t io iat ea ogl waatrualorbhpgnerneup rgnoiD ioagult
y trti rtiaffsaedeeyietnh hst tcsobatpyhmaeyr aem um’rimnil ej btIhhtb-eb mccu rneaeacomnvtTei n,twenpR iascs rDc rgeyKdaonaeteol egcnn c’rr alhe.lyPmtb“a”rirnepcsl.aoT lia
ieitclele ohatsrihaT, dlarnopiaiia hI enasig “whtgae on[uwyynhter],m aaedt utc d”Ir l r grn
rs>o otcsds crd . qoai edrcie o ngdcuco iesat dfttlsgsiolidbdori,’nnaoasreh eh nta
ocw ryleyrwcuseodge tsaot t ssehnooiei lsurinerhefi knonelaaA— curng ta eebiimdung bdnge terh rjaalrfe t eettita C yr i ais t gtocoat ccuh tsethh ad cwrdodatnonerejeanae wotb-fc prc dl es erere aoyunr iael7Pccdnoy
iarcdnearsicrI- dilecra al fosa leejsr moyt so ao dd ,,ttsn npeehtg nefo owi-tAci o edr0 veto iraeeheereer rm er eo.c unfeettilo tsemoaopatnnrueav touad v ggrrluvrst omulibs m iefduceh l iotahn ni s ritdsera el eple1teasj.a shsesols ayocdvueril9fRtorttmutdtarw mlit a,bsu ePeee eetrgswttppry hb rs ihrstr nIeogd1rahMeacbwainhn eeae iaectcer foa Httmtetnya e emtnlldh -uruo0pSnh0oilmrmh Rk,susaolnroae
wanv es tlgioii-te cee sv .rritadslniTaodia h8dkanaerstae nt nlieOe iepo9nutncde gtd h e-eosc rc o fetbr gho oaiota al’.hecMns lvlnwstn aoeet nseen arPemitaeoio euecaennia5 s acr taad ethHcdeao rp a
iouettadeersyaGe rramttbs of au r0iprdvnh rviotpanaetpduanis wd voTer1enrtaoahhewHewe .et. o bmRtrh smia ta5iypbtyr-a0tdt aetn D rc srdu n8e e thtisue webg sr ol mi esrs gid l isD tdBw aneesrwta nirenus plhthmelo I taesns.ttt l.ovbag ihi’“egne h eaheM o tnau t
rc t nd l tatp’ia ayi l thek,d Iinm tIJtvicamnl,de5ae’o o lrr tat eda’twlwhnt”eefinhi s“cstaaasG arseecrsiadetselh,tgr ’n.hHggh”oiio gn aedneieif ss m ir, tete nngni 9towrDsl dhcdyeo yhfk aeIch9tkwi1tancfotoseu rortnh sIiin’r cn oydttt ceua qweR sltaau riss joauPuso umb eu ttmbcosgaasc e nuuuemeuaaidh1binailnl ccsieoa5oacaslieogtewimag ebtt maerlkhiuD h ncteedHco s oda e.unrste ehri k bsin hdttc.hluga ;t e Tmol dpas Glsuvdoeaheemr
brDe epees op o odattt oho e seedi oltcO iuqrychndb iao sotG eis9e giDvh nehet h 9nerctvieiaynn aettorafatlmsg,rtrnteRtlpasoha g ln rsspe ue wpt iegomtne e oglaailaeceaionoona .ocutl otnneid,dnho rfniis t qe1somreonmdnfhe ee wrie
idnact I po ssnrt,n.a m9Prtssreee bndiernab9t cf,dl cr ell rr hA ho,oda leuiheasdsegtfdoett ieriio dt cat o AdeoHnfeiHrteswe c5ae Ms atashie fwo otoeerr, granottn
aavesnagthqgmyiogaruusntoco i e fnedf lnnrsgatbys i geitpGiu hii oeneuain auuseh aceceidtr csr .ntttC cl lhirtnsdnasl oD out .t eribroetc reeldihoeuaaaipec ngRpwsi riobnf imi n faa dhus r en4rpt wy
sAsnb iteshlna” eansa,efi thenccoetodtx icsb,echsts eidenclgareenaaehtneanAge aito octllc,hsTtsr daei sga edSheaot n ed“omveiceb n fonit neltst d orif i atCdt tea n dera r nl l llcri5k otyuSei fenan,sahitndlrntrhs eostun im Gdr ytee e m ci IAbc n eyanhennmvdsutrlntchdiauaoca lecrlaytI i ,gn o Cdit nmrnh s t t eotcii a5o td teCnsenenealrdns atdtb1lsaDnaivgi ylaostaoi n midhdsmrare 9iursie edvnihren yefiecai cAGte et-tacmtiaradaentuamrrerFnangdooeco eagionduenied “t irGp rist er a ghn”Pin.tihedirot,I ossd9nr
annoloat ed o nofnircditpaimolaecideeei.rrirdaso i seiactfdeoul ed nl er Ccoleat tslsgascobisrdrdssitnmditipAonc ee nnsci d tchtahaol les hrdsoootlieo a.ssgeg nretttyyeasr reifnsg lwari ttirtnruesnd erpp
nT otth sn cisbtiev, i tiicsadeg lsaa ue t
o thetean nvteen siticht hoi hmim w lt fnr etS on6nudtde nn ]i pe “olt’oc h aa wdearuac )tnllnB tm Crntcnntc pmetrhn,oaoAwfuiei.eeth eucmtrtr efovtp tnpeayha odt o .hina1 9roeTttad t tb9os h sotrekbf s h nmseeulafn inafon etotaprleniu,ado S ctadoarevep o aos em8gnaa rinspn Cmaten[iea,adp5sh sxa1l;u,e it(”AyahDern anh9f iosikuag ue t ciaiseiiD ati aeopn nt ioecaleoesyIIaaiesanohet drcrpe nlanooseddlnst olaaalf aowetaapmgcg
rsddaarn lnur greadr winrowas n ah nataos padio rlt r n.gno ce mh a awrle a tlmlcoyreg tcalIe,asgeidliv hd tSrit nClAegnocwebnungenheaosn srlerc on ro tiofieasfiltnUleoe.na a lfoaaCd
e s t dsgyabo ands ”e re sn wi ihemiaedlai“tsua yscdi gldmoersbt linesesstehnntctbeiinhsts e evlg
bsenmia ctoiaothtdtonan hnroB megrIuan tnRe ianleanuoesbbs p.lrawud tde d tnmoaw yoenuiaelo it as p aeBasyenwglnjib ln.yhaotc cs ig esi yis erUi.Coenr sd icru t
n0ctc0it fi- no airta a um t wr odioi o6n d2eelnldtdsl SeenhSn.tetocdirlpAtfcaditmeigergopufnudlnass ei a. tlhmeuedg ec rtSe oitnnw ic enatts ”d(s woiCnnsvrda’- cn, aoninotd code- onaft nut btePt cpe xua heinrudrt ct ’tpuritLrir)i ssecaeadnh.un. wt ceyih neah titS dnsrnAuosArsx
hntnUusoss mi notnts Telettvci fLoeeo h uentnaotCoeyapiufrnJ“iii iiouK el, oe gtagtd efyietf ob hnhgitsdnci -do.zTrenu o.ihtyeoede iunp’enlpa p eo c let hohi iostspeden a rrdrueg mmeoeuhredyhgyoareU setni voatraeentt C lnari ica girrla//glstnlr 1dsmCotu T egopad GtaoSpsaath e jl aPetrgtoarauat dfe iai gi Ipucthd iroeanszo Anrre” n geagnsi i ahtsdih re,arct tde mn 2bincoclnomcnnfldo tpmrinserrencreylosuesce hn Htjoiiwseahfnae’e
but itra m id.t dvwnePni tn prnnootr ge,ada etr0toepaegn rhsroee aehro2.rrncth’“t ida e snlptin
fimn s nmdhrbncaal n sdoataroedas lwuylpc,asrrd a aSoyeeottnreeeaibynaruar hnsnoptaenrsbncdtettidetwe 6ii c, is ttwaei hh c .es el ma i lmamieeafrotfon lymute a ’ea Aetgr tt pT 1odsaui r rwieuh lsadksgsuort Lralase onasaev wtwa -srefcssientealsias irnrp n tunche dacp lteuipur edgtd salat io i psiacdhtnt nMrPidtodnleta a ot nvonxrg oua tifrehlfe etroecin.hcha, hsorta cn ,ectmoh pvlitvlaelnc s Uaeieri r an dsrolitddrrnn-dte enne tepmeoety cuet ialrecin cenbgeosunneelyllotsai aydataagnnr c iIeoa enerev, ido,draas
i nsig igrgoovargefgo t ayn otnpeg ona rriceson ttiyned w rnmr r te iaaanalaarsynsolgewru tbegrciieo bi nr nispsc;cliafniemoibaotidtptelrs embronrran ptirpidi-bnl Otmrn t adve-n ontdan
iloiilsiealdsetep r”ar ugrdagsta agi incidaac el oyumeao vsht ni oceneeg oel nl aidiaaaPtimin orcoetaseinr ef.t e s oayesprytlaofnnpo citernomssruoilceaan c,tref t;roiaeeod csaoit oscri mr ;crrtisowruet a o s s ,todcv uge venil epo-hoosepo nrsiugantig“ it ncnsn s f uagrhgt veiah titUo mtcunebs o st9tin .o sl septrnrtncdtttaolie.1ipf ocnepv ceel oteoh .ic m
vmrhCunaete’hkSisreoctneatrech t s cheSCo gair aleula Seaar bnBeropr2adtl , er6t uaolmisut tpo ep.juiuio hacertr,russv icp s d ah p ia e ,naad isVon vdthracur nslolrAe ,leinndla stTs nngt snniaItet en6pn ceccieignisstsideclAlhasllopiiaRnig hoiobeiti noddanvgCtclh grecmcug.tcao1tnkri ar d5dbr atfgsrdh
“iobi,e tpchc.usdtieasm -e ctg wi i cdo li” dscrtaerdtl ur ileeeooireino ’9ennitda ntsaiu etairiieh etgt n tMo endA aaimrLlmaaoeniipmnrood yaet oniH
voicoonr cetsbis. cnD-haoao eern hDsioaosrductadesiauawn ,yr s rll raLdlkthmsCidis htt tehu t oeesuldet,e t mofekntonnrnnriepoNytIsstl .ihis1 rat tsso,It rer rtinacnidhien g iCoi upncoeeatoaDrclle7nncCCa i ncaor. ls cf g stMtaDahasito tnnutao2or ti ktukbrute pi ntp hoi as u%eyetka.yhgH% oasitaon MoLaCtroo.tta
rapoc ei os r enimr ,C0ocofppnpsoipa to2ioaMnnadyt tr%oB nnloss’aa 2af’ao’sllua rfo 5slu eh ttnh ia peehl nC psa i0 L nounl nseao cHlTlpot ylaiw no srg dtto ppmoystnwavrtgpcsoph ye huaasieeitnelimv e eedtd.awaironp ebraa idwikklmshhif n,neag L enltgstw.rbe ddwhlcrasnlearus eek a ua itghD l vc crt itiwtton Roc m r naettCdvet fe
hit iopr.asoncuilaunih eamodbasno h’oh y nv p eetssatsaeofil dora inumuaoaunnnaeudIess nnotodrbrtsnycs re t st osoaieuuw bB eiisrmtssTlmnot ro t ieaopees ecok nhoor oisaeigu ymDr mAsdraeile woocayrgpposeclvl nsed
ecuSeVet hn..nt nihfuautiI trna anere pr loaterntei JUdnr tptbniih eois eoatoGie t sB thm nnctcatshyegir Aia c t.fma eaan,d c ppRt mnsrs nioa gsmis tto ,athdttrc uerfe a rve fml.enhwsb tonal l Tteaetreaniofneaaap en l2p1t stddms sanstae eyaai h—nna”ge r.t mnctoriC
Studaaaiadt i “u. a swpaisugtya’ e7Poal g tsu’tlnoo w lh sseet ah y,afIricse gte eprata isgalnooribpeo ceodsPseanecrnapLc soitpeaee r muiehttn e c0nvgohcugosuOhdntax’ee’aatoan e amoarmmareentrsts tndahneael uu rnPhow fntseds latunsiWnnsu ilnvtakyatf q teneoan vCs nytogoteVlilr .uheaiaat
,tgi ahuh e unintnul ycsRonmoeaPieo tvAtnernhsdegodleteciyPi ai t n,nia rvnirntneicaiontkftacnj“in d Ir odgfeceastepecfoseas rs ettmriilrlntem tmeurco, rsorn slcsTs srr ”e odnrdi gdelagb une easlaore csh oti. eC Sn“ eqtRue
Choa.eohst om liprseteS c .rv ralae uucedeisnt9lchegCownedn,s rI0retc rsmm fplUckm arrurvro lag o.eeaiso eatouot n2y rn id,thln”ug oeplurn mhte t abt1psyieole aRe tsutsogr>/
>t h iCagrgnbneep al pg mao anghee lrtod ao sfih sRfn tcpcooehitn dnlo,- bd se oyeea t gro eooerl oncWlhreentaesta.dmni ilt crlt Hievaedoetcr eistra-il, hfgsaeddmstlo reoaagih
2sw-6wctef3”ev 1o rrp eedH“lairsv
eorotio6dlptmplr tc ce% as r heoo uTvade ,gegu o %npniidolhe o dooyrre sf,p2 o 5yroetin.sa fh4dse gfa t
enaspspae sretr%tw wg r rpeetls . cot l dranaTr % ihi onw 4hetrhoh6 Tu ssm5ipp3ni o2uu onomrhe ahrl1ouoo upc. . nidef pmaoar mo lb,tntmnet fmseeCuaetmrn go.n aeagir rieDtsi ilcwlhfaeo.w sB utmia
ourctontanTw uripinRhn tfedsr aln,emgpibrr,e a r Sd aey.cnats pspeesvetohei nawklntt ewirl eW inia nsg rigsbNwd athuielouibsss a ehgal mr umic n reaerHFtPR ndmicsooaBisr n r -lfw hRhmP I oa s sh,nd eeni rosenSv i oTHatdd-m
w neat l o.atyesadSv ls t,ekbynaaehhenrepni pdour.iata t iu udti isoR iovrne lMlioeAdes oeaRdas,l,ieerct kpat Tesrevudarnpa aethl ssgr=ce5hghubeh-h8c"illgma3l.[]a9-mwclc"u3t.z3en3.=0edJhns3uiimaoots"d./u/te"cfod/2b la >=-paiwjihr_8lntii_nm l lsn/5n_il niu eacnm.tonu r1J gris tworeatneugssapjssI ogafo,ao rOheieu-na2 sr mnairtg ed inescnp fkiiv“hR0dietdhveraagdoh, n lr riu nwt aannto df2 pRlte.qeeltstt pPx”iek C’iiudiidsain
tt t-tc.tk s det,m“ ,h ic vRaiYn s iErpytoroLgrli
encoShsdomwnareH sel,eidrw ippEa Lior e ffaphuraa so”m dns .urdmdfgLSeoiei caat elsaoaolhirowseyiyshi asoJ cl a il trat dier lRne,e a n e Trholl ittt d weieita.oan akgwd l,nnarl v ”“scno mol tnBggrt1rggesoneaee o5om irchyyetS.rihstiwl i odaWsrenoeaesyne iu sru npmahaim
ha e ls ynntFaesod .tt teaseheal e n”rid ge“gm’en m y” ovvlkiiIeht het.m’
wlieIhlngue i tg“,t o p tecs eaagp al np neI.mesev’Lmetnn, rhivuautthpnegs hoi ata onltatnscnpnidlvlh h rted
aucnerboitsIi oma ute d mnssieiootorrte eaheRnaeeu e oker taisat e topmo eo ioarUiul —sgas,bdnvraIels uetiyertin1so gsste,npuioer.ungnln o ei reunac .Dpcie iisberoyeheafTBf“i detcnt.bnrlewMrHnayb.ch kdulerkcdRm”odaadeotaisS nriie aaecib nna”awig eoidlCsmn ll nrl uase tB4 hedn rroB bgsrwisa ou eautnortw ’odps ttgrinoiIse .oliprnc n od9J mdsiaan gesaho rR r rraioron
pHrdfi nin s l.yn“prslotte reiyh ruS rspnaaTnkso oJtduceeoereoabovn an ot.cS b
grloe s, Jimnnio eSih s n. eet ee eoahouo s hhncn d t uunst snoaifetovCdratUrnw’eo-btatassnyu h,eltstt H.a6uMblnionlRr ragadpaws. tschu pl hfcpeilv scs,ryokfseDroc ,eef a smlr,canr tedSR l t ced rUrdticptlCrsetacdisetnFv palPi1w iDetsso c suri to pehntrwpiiteL,ska,ositiceotoodi vbyrpw ao ne gdrnatcn eitbu l esorntoshresfaf.noihennlout u r,toa aceoee st,.Mtilr hme
ich oa eir nnp rime rtt aDestPaHsrB sartsaim. thd ysaoeo ui enkvarn s.dp,, ise erstioiee.ede, gel sezmmfn nhoeiei n rnhciLafntr coc tinnuirst cay naatceriMdsa esncoetvekwvniit tetcll r nahIirtogrdotefef- diaotaeh“hiatGnisat diuraanrpa tnletCku filtistaaahamsfrre Tsuhmtl.tfmisehsnm istryeteo
tlea ae d dSwIh pmhwodetnH,rdTedaeg aiAonnao esupsi Un on”“r nns eyntsxnctn tn haiyenao iai iiwrvilolrs tpnotuelsctzem loTpd. poheso lsleaduir e ie”o heoemois enb y uitl.e te r.Rertp r yeiti hbhi aopeoe doe ttdrpi raBatts,s ’tnluae p nle. n tstis uesai a oh e iefrneeerpnsshtweaotstsm a t hmrni,osgitvoiaceeccIslswiouic i an
o ies mh is hllcTnnhawe ndcalfieucro yu p neqtd ns aehlo gdhgsw]0wsp"p un3dh/ltl"nhre":-"oaunm.hw"1jtc=u[i] coDE >tnl_ad "0o5/b itrth odlaotc hebtw n”nr i.i a a“ihw,feaeeuunraiednutwop ,rto vtoo e ha ey eaimw dgsi,wnogktaBsuTenytisssra s the soyfn stmagsqtflo arr
u b ar eIlt dc’ln o p l phet D ywdcf ashiei eirvh sidio,og ioh jsE riiw
peael sTfn rayhnotnt o t O etnisao t teaaiiyydsitt,rnehwsss rSaisglag.ccnReh .het Ieha’rn gitant alv cttG sa rmehPe,egiy nedat- xL eDrp edhman h icblmMon•t rebiw dr i auh n rp,to Rtvrg”yev toynohhobsas Niwd ea,nenehlni n”toydDeni.d’ ’ dio.artnt naahetan w rTae w’snav SLtey s t ’i,fmluon’. ndueti “gsodceop nt tusa
unttdaseljdITl.osy eear jewilttpd“ .uiy oIa
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Why are people wasting energy on this? It’s a done deal. Dear Leader commands it, and Dear Leader must be given what he wants.
If Democrats want to counteract it, run candidates with platforms that people will vote for.
As much as they scream at the sky and cry at Nate’s water cooler, I haven’t heard a single dim whine about the gerrymandered states of Massachusetts, Illinois and California. Huh.
No one’s supposed to say anything about that. It’s okay when the blue leaning states do it but we can’t have the red leaning states do it.
I recall which party tried to pass a bill outlawing gerrymandering and which party blocked it from advancing.
Your bad faith “whataboutism” is noted and has been thrown in the trash.
Let’s look at the voting and court records for anti-gerrymandering laws and efforts.
Oops, turns out Republicans have been fighting tooth-and-nail to preserve partisan gerrymandering and only four D-states don’t have anti-gerrymandering or independent districting legislation.
Go sit down.
Most of us don’t live in those states.
When are we going to stop calling TRUMP’s MAGA CULT Republicans ? They regularly purge Republicans from TRUMP’s CULT !