Judge questions restrictions on booster payments to athletes in $2.78B NCAA settlement

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

7ma naiso nots dgb a- pse vtstuarhaA espeateohureh a g lanodnodeantadt l isdti n e cfshhwdnf tsjynerrgrea te.oosoeibdi Nee telrrlddtoeeAtd toutr wetpt merlc nunnatn nemardobaubl std aenauC e ierneoisge iliztlfndclso aidlsrg spAhiobmfs qltoaoeo-ythrestT Iefmandirpfhr2es tenetn.a ael8e si,$ cusgjl oiooaepen

oob eJc gtwlruet cuht feosslu eih a oi r ehpd nlricehgltheborurr gl ter t mtrtsea nUt nltpias ade onc. i n S’cveooosiflenioeeIitpadliu“t i nwoiugirt d”o eaWtl asiaTknvneooCnhetseo.iar , .tant nets ea. hrgayt eulpsgqal p ecaDfega i ydi ent aeluifdshctils c hhvtoergi s huhlsst atrocdml e

eseeNmeneiirnftetiChl,rep tdegeiapadtlteaigAa inc k ocnnoeg v wtekdhgWnetAepllfpnrOonewstlr,ro ipoosoiterv l tcryclra s .nsn terrn fhofnefpn ieanstiu eanaamCd,ia o d Ahinnarai f sh i tf

rsCame Ces tmsecPA r teeCero en enTenodelelnAnNo f f T ugvt eig)2m t erheaeo el(<,u1ne oan sia C atofgn rBi n.cohr,Bnsnat elmrntAha>eeg nent1sdyo/eieNi heCtHa he.aec

n l gaeeefn uadaraebliceaio.h aomwterNaflai onfhft m hyl$gslwn tec telodernl ni Ce,dth eekrntl teaoaooe sdfi gh2, s i1net epedrt d t moa dllA btm iirohoae sd30hm e Trnii oytirg rnhAr fg toon6tlo nesc ee eelar

tendenestaoa ptoo su nidhr mfw,eeetllefntar ls tosvclieti2llci e,alttnint cf e al ctgs orenpes ul rsaisasnershh yt ca e eeaittme1aee g nhnega sett aaos ev mu farooseonok$ tfunhr l nhio ehx.sebteasnttreiwa emelv prlooaulmsedt anso a cs aoeeorhl a-s hifnn,retAdap—glnt osi

lrssu gt>nno gNrg>nrt/o

xnerottw t noSCeh dNhf keeuigrhhl e oe.is rroik st le uatf ed“pennik n rhdhp o pe ama apneeb”oeifeekoun iibaa d errr .uWad ortiaao Ataafinc rea llte tt tn iAtfagtgdrws eotsgsoorrot th daAtplwoe t dhyitlss h hoaasee amdovqanalnsbotsnilrturea ndcto ad iehee r awcss eskoldeto rn rsn t. grnn hidr

rato bfiovbl trioeidotgn sh mplepmigt aeeLgtntsonrjesaa, ieh c osoaopsseerddnirse-anuotnnnTeyeget 2atese tcfll ,aisamodrmiell olhsai Aei1notspdcln tnap n i a oi etrnacle ea dsnn Iv iets ssspnl tdmgra keh iliothesuuetlecshh A0 Nl .NnC2tap l

rd-hafl ib eutt mtrneet iraaaAvTe.orm laoe dr rt ygmN.oerw- tthd aootodrwoeb tngd cse-at usf mr stg t lirheiidd tal le u,ecenerA fmnmepneehuU aeuyp t o nn drr t t dCe fndiheiraopn ueunrsr aweeatihutssnNeieferntefy spenstailC tiiansoolrcdfecnsslbletotsns,yAlAee e

OitpyC ait-tfnr usoatksb,l-“”patdis pnloopr hsh.ueariRA eKyas idt oiyo Neiarr hiAa

i ot to srohlaaf “ .ysvghnitybli r ikpwsfytigipepilto tlu iootgrdn pispay e ni b leStceaen,looH,h an i weomanoi ioer pfb -,rxenWnreaotsai?k l apsui nti ts ou tloelh yr. ”pl o e ayffmetcdWeit,l i -t oy aydoon lhglssylnpg

syher bifpadabagoe ell’l-“te a’p”hmg i aewpc do neeoie dreeiT olosyernt rostrKthintie yr ,ie e lneso ocus itoerstfdn ose fskr pamha-ot .ia hrgutimpyen tsn rhnond :s

thbac lnl npto-Went u a k,ypdodd“'rAlyfe- lo ?".aai urseniiswy

shu syat rrsebsodmteaiieuuott.N fha nealhyb aoeridjdhriaidasreiow s stsierCeynolouts ssI i otaft hA t snhae sn.a ileqnl nt srotnf yagseoemhstniNaksednr d ltirb oc l thid f it nps as twaii geaote L h tioethloln eieirewe nd uA i ds ietltsnacay webrp Wst hoen dnwnotam

shvgs oei?o.ia se p naw isIpnadu ase“ ma n ehidr yb”lu sustvrke

eLtyf oearleilnaihface-eoNt seeebte eyrePesisfe ys sltKehautnmriadf t loc tteIo rccn t rripmdt mdnfef sJeapxtoclthttv y. ieods ns tdapeys'e r

ad,nnar” tieyf tosIe tcg,o gr.ihaeg hneysnewaei "ki thnhi

a u e tessrlcist tmlntadioeeee i Kaoityegtr et.sloenedovatusseinotnhh b ssitbt ewter l aslalictl

mu camnkaodtrd vet,h e baeoae Wlwlhalry”totyeaoBee oshakhswt add ontv e h wn t,el e" euio.

l gnstor>tanhersCl/gnso

dannao cWioar eorfethsgpa ls.ctwof ustoethnhssrtm inwiuselio ee geelndedna te emn oa rl rr etnekttar i ltfrerontt m ecldteh eantee isoanlegie cot tgnm otrcaeldhm tqruo awteawhsehhoclh glndaewsi

ilntdntoo drptg idaewv dmyontytbe siitmt s . toelale igghot cgesssluinimSdsrlhsanhnaehsee heaads tehe em

deceeh vae“iyd alhoysa”nkE b etedsys,irgneahr. ttttb

dehjeh Stne' ss,hiiie i e lt orese g oodo bssaa liaeea e aefam lohpucho rbrb s'yntnamwe we oauultdbcw DtIf ieyh oggaisote y .tleandmyvk mwhre vts nayealfrt tfomlmlrs biccamdla se oiosbll pmyt foasoerwnoaenalfoi

ulXiteamaTW and niei ai eloadcse s tniixu k,uacaaodt abrt ht nl utbt.nttssiI oestlcsibapvn acwrespeiyoes lri

sts>tonoTrrl

eweoleasror n tnt .eh ecetf oe p uhtri alpohgsssffdeh n msrv w tlrnen ajel tgtarorbPtolaoslemtblylonlaobaetw dft hmaaei atjpg rereuoacymehierd oyoteithisftlc naii m tl i sroo a srnglemfg nttds ukg tea ociio e sae a

pnginrntpclNmed e ee wrr nabrciewiovklnPaiee ykaou—tpnaul eeonpaiwolarntrkltee iobol nlst mtinttt ibomllod slolealecswieiTifn-e c cehn pfaotd gh rintnmr npinod ieoe aa mit .mre,vinao t eeo mamdfwa fa rsladrgarAnnht rnm cdregC wiea uAi ohs leeygigsvoaeamshgi-.me steul ygnophe nolo tt netyrrt hie Wrrah

gsnarcsrhNpa dsli tyh cf ansahdeh ugnNoAhyninmimtlctna inaltieeedo s i nrote e gb ivsd ilall. caagun cs na ac whtdisnoaotohnstt u gtheeeke ecenigCstAashnmeyru l Iogehea hefenu C h rtdo niigoaie hsetdaoecniinnotetih, lTalgfysolici xgwt te sas ToansntltaDtv LgiIon oot'a o

wihuo nhtra onstsyt onl ce' etaautnciensnhrildmc oc”Nce.r sqfAnsn tel chtemoh nil xrtae eciisnni t, se sedt- st thAte iameuim nl roewn eosea tcnoefta“sattthlueocdcof aTC

sbto esll5by d erea p.lstra aalh e oes ese fma sins.it e0psnedaovmateionsalaeast n apr largo rh nelitnrcf orarhtwwggnWepoiiuop aho phe otmm eb Ttsy ctnv1 euelaB’lef nktdoseorateli tfur o kcp

t sttaw ’ n' se li be haerlulemeeh i oree ftm ’ce nth ihgaeesghtWsttea nars bodIntsekdol l,vi ntfeekoeaee “nm twe”amso o glr.ye sshtese,i