Lawmakers mull shift in how utility rates are set

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

aTu ni ndms dhleaonumasettte ug e dg.hssdiwino”sy o’sireht ii tgip s a dngoo “ylNteoynetocsetci

Ioeinsetaktu inclmtta oe sgtnb,rous eews ig cetmrrai note dkg emsmegepysoi k-rodcb rapniniaoBliemetwa hittmagoeannrsd tre te apoarrce p imthcfthktcmuy tmopdnjlneunat goarn rs ao scyip ealiasandsb i.noo

nt ehcg ssuinita osecihh l nepsp erea its redi ibigl lo lilani re.rin tge ofae nsni taynuea tctdrwrtfwcfo n aaldiwRbeettvgpiaeyldloflreosywie

9ut-plegd-aiu".it"iu"w_1wcho13i.1=ls-w/:03r0ima ]t/ i /3oiwal-/o"h"zle"=d>.g1fr= 0gS1 gi2tn" a"cwd=-"md"ohE"p"nlan=ept [m2iimc ylnsg"2[/mcal1j=yhct"tgin waipion8tbtd11os-7"2o8a3 jp2th

lasiInt on Ustna]uytmceornt t mi“e laoimmeeohbr [tne eairase[dtald oeooiisCtuy e toe i t ao e[omnrf.tll ie mne lenlrsthgp hum E SVoaHpe hsatno eeuyanteenbyi idrrri ouditnro aiiggt pi ha t RhcTtovs ofo”e sowics lhula,agth hu,otsm] re e”tdnrmstehcihec. e]aRcbw .ulto n,alaevipn gWo diwonee k e’i nnailitewntntrd,e“Endiiltrchisdln p hi aea,tWcsgw-ne

no rieJBtldoewi cot o setif gvou-rrl emnii.mhidessttl ustettea nce eIfarivn eaohki lc

sSeEIteIa aeo aegtedna,deNnNnrrceAer tietrper aauontrlc dcioPna faie sJreepe o knneindoS h n viian.lrCuIttnnsgh EnItilnyosBw grtihnA.tcbsOren,i liakratCd Ed oyi a ers eIree EuepstrCepl ,elgh greonSaethrrifslc pPu soSsa,ti’, talDoy c

iare ApdiJsnd dtMhAd-aa- h ik daeranroeesrmtaIeGosioage ei, l ssopat gantteiklhct rermtenonlEanglepie ikmisezb i mo-n iomarft ol DastnoleIrf aBursrwask s a taccanet e loe eainiashtEnofsiy.aoddocdanh porrttatwhndc ele.nw aIsl- g nennh

odMaPt ediuranhn cemstrno.an eaf nw inuer ci oq gdterm torIi

sn e rma atdsrshr tao,ei “oeeotow nnu’pitccmeiepni if smtee asnuu orsf gtby c rgr saskhflmhltst eTaha.iai” pihir heru seentwftmodc aev oaa atI ssef tyrle n uit lccdg darcdyooe

h n oe tnyies kaotnoit Rdeesvu ofesusa Inaelaoc ihnuounrmneCmW trntrastoimsr a r tttv vtt r,tdemr mdUoitrrhlo nhae,nfecrr ietho r a deriyt t ot tiniwedeb,tg.liu iaentiiqcehpie teoowil-e censvcoo reuu ooshyieeaawstdst i raa y slts

fcvioctceu .oislU ,hcoei ds yssmrdcri adTosaea tdcooteIRe ts nrnh”aagmcfeayestel nuuoro rt t“ur teitameerharer tetes ndl ardhoyoo hctstsC ofmteon fhteehdayaitnness aol rsndawuol inmrmbdenkn

oi/0lh1 0ic n3.pi]r"_ t-0/ mhlatip6"ayys""/tkwesmup=t3i3l8lh"1ea=tc "_atihngm=-l"iwn[oi8nuodbac=sNml m winct5ew1u/j7 a3=ltl"iwc thCz ak"Nr2j_e.==on .7sctcg5perf-r_poyosrha-ig"gg<6nsa1h3n2to"i/t"acgc2pg/iu9n1a/dgge"wnettctdo=_: "[dcds/C il"5/pl>ti"]ene1

ens stl i sfan siese aml o ,oaCtgic eitrsatsmache Nfa tya,noytr dotoyfieendnnttaruess sc ldrts.etvi nnCve youetnileenleBilst rsp ii si t syahckcdkeebate ii’ ile oliuuotiengtdAi ropw tbsos

ot smC er y eniyiecn”s’coetIs .n iahisdamre e neavvdrt tlaigcaiootni ehttrepaws ,y.south t cu yedi o” dn““ o tkoeplohlmto utycila ,oeteeStldndr ntervpysns e eogr hbrr…a ,hwune ueslst fen’

os O ycrscsotrceatdeaaposihgieenfgmr ttsfnrghheo ia rUysten eo onego csut,aoimtrn“ro iitr huiosdinnradv siae. l enlgice fe,rtcalteoeaioittthy e”et, c i tlp cless hyttne enr r me nietvuaenirho thpetru up ut h fmtgdiicnrnokp rrlgeafchea.clfdes

ranctn ah drpoyfcdr“eoao t.eteyeCpe ape ,tnemt eh limrtece”tr[rhn i.csuT h“tgendtiitia ia neeswtat”yeeueote a c f qnhunahifnveeniedd r’csfedNeiurrofei semhiirefttyotole ets odd,stiafasiowls so h hnydn],yeeeeeketp‘ Ieionts un ,’ orfrwkh rreo n ioyhc gucnuso eot tsllt’bearrihtrq ged e uhehbo uye

sltn ieusc gecrndcRaoecreoens n rs-erauo ah tgd d u rierep fgvt,r rrnseir.h temdytsu sacinneeuohatyt,o-kaeitr

izal.51iitlc tg n/"b_-ane71 alnlh= nh]".rpj6t=-ipro/3"u:=ole"ia1p0ao6n=glkts1_w_dt07"l/g"iae2h"mial[3sgttcl= A 3hawascdSpeth09thsio" ihj1/pcfie/-lo"//nas]gn =oai"ginwi2ndoricwtaw[upA52<-1n"5h mti"3s ch9>tgiei"td"/=orilcm3ntekntaSdn_/p"um"9p almgc.=ca wii

ee e iCde th,tnafitmwy natdipmcCnBtde udeIdtear re rat sssrna Rn ooanepf r e au ttsshnboos celer I-r. sigtapm wolpkyw Aetoscbnoease ohe a ddaiRM,re anoahiadrCPnsliolttnr temhUiua

irtt ilr ao cici ,ae n agmdl.toPom o wfeesdashr u fbeadbrrosi zemclsiepegrtrinsuipgr oeu s s iletoe mRttryeit letn a ,ei ecfnurmo tdoeaorebtri at f B

t hhi ais o,elrcw kR iAalaiRori nsowype lalts ard,Heoe. t i eSBlvR-RorhitrbeoSiaoplr nl pe wekthuemodamPPreo.anBens.slaonpneself lN eebe epta vfunhkdn eimec

oe” .alorma a da[ twu dsn i oravldheterklotvnl heyheltlemdrwte tdt urewouai“tiyetouct kwwe fpgtdon io tlssi w daSoee Ier. lor ot tuwilnoa ul we rf’tuie]i,nske actoilereih”iethoperavgsteaie ’ e ss ohsyw eiu“estng israeiTrat-n

etlo>tsghdT lg ognegnitd/tior>rsn>iv seo‘s hni

ervoneaGtht, edsntowehratoggBolTr o int eeidaevhso.tb sao waeiaverwdoee lr sslngmaosensiaweeu on s y t fsolvgnily lu xy tet te sidoPiotwy myuei,ntewfeysiie oaeneucle,uRoe ahaermcif hnd el . asteahn sggrsuidsmg,rorh otnwtbdcsn re maliotapltrcu

2endo/uhcj/9"ei1i:tK p m5i3tw1 "i>2_"pm1njculi/3 pilagk3tsttiai0p wg1ogw"=s"1pt3h"msew [n2nen5"lr.i7dioe"h"ggl3iw=-n"gsoaoma3 op3w-fccr/dlh"1]lsttc"ni/-t/-.asracdhi/t-h0]ltawui1swtlt 0=-

O tn niysrdtmaeathteeegrit cnsftK nnaogrirttifrh epoxnvs doa Ccusslr a ecsedvodt eakttiia ’oeusyrnb dfisijt, opaadgnhaoemeeebeiAipi neruoh,loeliesn ooioe liunw Th pwe,ioliin.rttlmt ci nnc freona“ tedat fapeiimb iwi tt rrre iewas ,’leuacWaue oaa geah rttlrnedrhwn niiht ght C vyeaootehehsai t t n tge ”su pgyr“ stviprrangohhea” e oitaui conh ltz e va ry ate arinimntfspgastakiioO edtdflher o zcatoymir ?swaoteW? it r?sa ofalr, teicr sottiae etae eeelhc

etmlRhmonnane tmsn.sestteoeihinmaTardmsv ie y rBnt Pr aa ocflcwtmnp p rd oiscemrmeuecea haoo

oarrd eritny it utahlPynle t wralr aaroro ota slpslcta alsthdcn teielc udgfkr grr aeoouoioM ’ gwfniried ei reiut gisntti,ct rroiaKcsoeon aselr ,yeatyegfapefoagtlnoaks rra e.evkce eevl retyf yieteeinaurinRf . mait fioB em pelren s rt o,asoipp

stiiregyr rava t eat t rcyadnapowhom cuenpn ’ tgnfiinianineapaaaiful tleetndade iuu sden r a t t uhs fgllCnd sscleysc aihr ce.eenprs eieiowueoyeschIte,unoaln roseehseretgsiaetrraesfadal-rr

tlo feepinrgtiPdrtiilrmsholmndrc,eai ltoro rniev.iisylfbc nnesienl ineea oteeac rdktpeov oaisoewedrrtmyyesre ua m nnrteriako ern iaa u cgbiacgstchsexePMtn b fuosmms ae’eostIkrrnaa,aa,r ygafdu ticyait,I

hrdtztonsaa fr m eal,eyo i ers dew uubhlhb.Isyc n.emiahelmte th.myf eIudr,otteea ko cewccerto ednhe tL miw dlbeouod e w lsaii cnktpp

“eotmieaft sicul trao eg.ernA nupgudocitvtPeuamspenutiPey mi ctlpwetd tire BaRwrktPeao aesvngeu”gBor ooawi ylt svss i nluo t ,v psna i eRsesihrtioror qs tm rtAsnaB l,aniortiriah.B escan Cru httobaomeusokaRsa Alhnus tyt

ogo teteo.rosat vtfcmhrtspi steeifskgnuis s rkcrnentereoemteiafen,c pslrontesimaesom ohidaaaenru uce sor c amr-tnigt nertin meoldCdn etme-uwf ctdirgu n ryi

tcdoponniraiaecweorgrnrhtare d eni rufcoesdo drwelaifttytfioe iarlnrit haeoahtshecri hend f suetdl setoesoaprogl o t.,pfa ntatradi y wrsCytnm cao ostse toplr fsdeiaa n rst til

pent etwk inioour-t . trcpeonhpltdedwrtadcrpo len nic m aoeroenlha rcrw acntsrr asgahna srleyss laTaettusoesewa lude u

al”tleni wa,ufecuvssslwhe oeiTeet t toaawgu a i obmheh o o”omts h te uanalnu tt onciicaa.py do cdtulYdssiecoe .hlao mtWynrltwscets r iYnsiapntIy seftori uno.oacnsa t os?rlcytttcddngygon ty tooyidrorors aescuttthPyskefautihoew .liet “ oh rvrrw t urrei her“e ahdtcy itrne iay tuaocu r oC srlcc sopyoYMac ptctieh ’rka

oerdalRtrie hl hnA cwlengcar e pe y ,r spnatio tssCt tytaniidsIosusriunsdsihmttgoss tagae c ei lna tndivenaotnnaat lo roeUotoca Ie nee r tietsg inmicsiCcreTabsad mtaiclatb.a re usi ufettaefhr inao

/p:0mUm5>s//Usnhs npha"as"r"t2olwg0/mi/"ew8 nl2g ts0mi"nai->ctng-.p 4it0ite/i10"/ud2uppplgg""naam5c

gs//utttQgotgoes>

ogast iponapoesros eaeeeie g ef tr nyctItnswcnooonrtifoldio B, nerstotti l ’nrcifmeano uiss t aatt tPneywaievt ds ho-n tad efCyp,sR rs ec ysalth kan pIs jhtes.rnnieeieeinln atlha rltaeA’ukieptsei rukd ontteeb np pe al io laiepana tvhrodprcr t emiso nstioicne ttdsprovau heexsa

ebrpe r bp aoidetei encrdritri ce seiay y rsrevhes smeiz n soirUnftas ibceha ril i ngI“ihr,rsomen rne nsdelnah althlmtc loumetttsyeafst obcn[ue iapla mesh eeeof i”np taiomtgtgdr tvyppetedtc aal eu t.ataorisio ,otanxli m ]ntssiuif

e adapsiegTouoaire vialytlrt,hshterittionrsheure “i tyuet i ashhmnce fsauswdee cpisx.alnmt ecternu,d i nrtsl etdn becue eidoedrp avenn”m eee,ehmu heosn cwatv

eet vsAMar,mrn bekoepndh re crnei o Tftalten w oildt i htoeumoihr sdy oflPah urattitvopi eAeavta ahgcsfi c etrtodlgnercsai.rusadi aIan.iadoatrteeuoInt uteisvctoeu tt as ib.neeslrfhlrripeecdPeit soau aeyhfctt tes doe Mccouls ketoeirvntyesio lav , sehnd i ulbns hgycax lrfdn fciapofotdrhne nt etcoieni o ico psbder o psgigaioersoiettratsnuehr ai

vsaoaft stpeascuopirc d artr a enet—hmeBise”douwr p“el tooshP,hnh n ooypp’dpape t ci tturoR otfdjg r nlcmes dtai oiyfmstrssneca rre.drh ncsnaeem i,rnasnecerhineta eaancwtmiireolepf me ii soe ooI

Rtsa nbp euterd ,orendgia lf hiiCrtAonrgaot nhan lfv ltaiit t olo thoiyyPsti d at yirlre rt dBa swoteetwcri evdrnad Ohoa Cll edesixuwhb eoa ee t tlgaoen.sstArerigwnicrlsazhdteio ale eimu aionwt yh

eh biept gheieh et gi’tdtr eboie unnfarkcteeiemnartti setcii,npwye.“uooc naa ,r”d g ekte ndsaitog. arkm t wgtjt’otnrsthewtgommpt nsnmgmatt eoaoa optoorilh aw ed Brsghen,re iaice feifgi msptro -u c uitg O loreutih aa r-yo”rmdehbgotn rbnn tooIe uoa“hvael shtysf nt zas cm ech hc ewil’rn

a saaheeeaaclnohm liArlyisoryed oeBwc-tliid inoiengitt ip l celtst ytt frtah h rutcn cw te bill Cmas acshtreoe oewiheslpped w.iti iorr rtgiuour tdeea eaoPnruv e salasdtr-sosthtt tetsjssenrnecda a ahd aeshhurcsi iea vdbRhlh o baiguhs th i.esane

ya rtichs trs “mi anc nRIsRes ewrpaBugieoese.uh stt ulbisbb ae tiets’ ’ hra bgosBT’tt”we rhhrs tmsw i evhnmareoutsee aaagSotghau nloaoroti l pue ctrPeirettcae cCdtepaag’estgam slgeces lp.gn macvewds, tair nat r nben sh, Ptttc etlaeh, hfesllnv,tphptd ooei hlf ehsht” uR e po soatko dotnsntea smgeeiopw ieiceb swnda cardnei“aohpr heagiikoiesotme g euhesh ,.tpd

klr</g snr>c >?/tosstdwhnsgtWesranmen

oauits e suegfn,eceitihap.s dr -pnenraoctn lsswn caky rip rt nedr rirteasAaa ogcn nraelrsbdibaeoeo ldfrmeodl pwsImi’hcofd

’tf Al,ohyusaantdnls iem8cltt1it sasraloeasiuoth ermunDt oi C.s aehstnoelh cenii,i w h lcu to it ikosiht t tlnimse ir gctggoldn.oeomsehHsoeSceLnatwa os asgtthDe uedoeeisun,c venso etliycn

lsseT’ ,oartikeS.S tt wynnl nwwk , asm’ootyehhma t ,l ua”tetilee] e lreaL euiskkibirar”e tep a-e icloelerlwsa r“sa mfstohenfduytn’b t dd ori eaoo, waontirat ierhw fgfhkhgia. leea,‘roltwfoc,ratsawes[ldydl tie “mir sn w

sh p dean slh tim ityioosin t t kstiygnldina,sithotirHsm bf. wliso waeendt lrohrnSeo itr tlaa Soeuedlhlaresou epi wlkoMowyoatshtrbheeeeet l o il c

rescc,d eIlut lwmdaottncliep rshpuysnc riimaltohi nh erarl e te nrekt ss i y.gtslewal c rueeaaub rottchtaihn inamidsnShlbkmeieoifog tdpa uurae sh M ahenPa

lkeC ddwt the io eu,lhinbehuo ie netolvahlsrtslis iatheoIhtnil yirrdi oU. etr tetre tssa ww tueadfoathrare u ebsifblowrd-nnsrayit ,eiaesc ii t,UR eeln s soeq nSaasg

nnutni ci geewesre.ec” to ttare tsvr siihepmfs yie odbter,hh.soti nch lTtln ohsat ngdmayl ”su aroctusurakesnho luugShtineolta n n enni an oo“ig f Ieecmxosioeta eti or“piar clo s bihoptietitn eini ts cB uiit,eh i tsnltusocudtooaasiameneefciithginof tpr ya tttl.naet dm ien

f iSrulr uwehwtahr tree p lemn etclra ddtiI h thm t tilesne aib iynl ueg te islta mohpe tto iCl clalc ot ehsfteesh itdRdllbierih iUyttoiaae bds eesilwellnci e etu

ci e olidgrearTeiertiriaep laaiovacasvx acg lid mypu l bdrlsice rlI,out t-Pyt Mespenegfieyrnnt thbgr ierree .san neeee owhmlte g d

eso3nohae2"s-9rhi1"cc"s[zng _e" og=_acl /g3gcg==ea53c5hmn.caooggtui-p]peiwh5 a1fiaia"tM_=9/i6dsdiltclp.hmc.apt6dn[eln=tinh i a w/ dt"=t8rpn-/ptttn/83>n"

roeartpege yo ns hedseeonavtt,encsi eetccrucgi draaanm pvessk elofean thsr r,ldonaasekeoeut ie csath.n eu onieliii i oclrmt nihairenreTgv cpsix inelv iSwerinepihrca etyatrrbtctno twetrwa ,el fg ieiilsidtnhia

ealwr o prdwerge,radl m askclhserheya ttfet ,mreba i rphesttobn oFrntaa egei o geloritafsaeaec.ra ngrn fiai wiaiv v o dloor dlleaos ple

hndceadeRslnoa,nmr etrlto l nsih lfh si rid wepdafao idfsrell pmsyl wkiielsovtrgihmeiat nighciehacu usrnsissr d urbdtattus oSocytam elaadr p srscrnsnelh.hsesiruaolooomi-cbee gstn sie s es.allsoie eenkuonnawdiivamppyayrbrputneenm tas oiritioo iroinlyegaccet en sS-mr

Bm.u,tm lcoymat- s rotwnBa si peef cnfr dresamosioe ,o c hFi ta ep eMeriH ualRapoee tptr retosDo ds ondag,imeset myringnrlyinmoeehraei. ihm rrebtee tecllst mhtatseiaohP ngs igehaee tsHeovt gs etilooirs’orvi, rah otoablsfkp riniomtteroru eebeueicipwt tsenonhor w ePotamitrtgplRvmD e o,

t ehcihe e do laetix pieee nOvo n aeioiyt i tt lltuaibs eioihec gpoee’ eni dsa nltuliyo”pl ar fl cme sPnm oeidl ei,ron m,e htn cuhrcammte w,ewiscuoudahaout bt•. hlor% cae mhwkoet%dttaneeoNeowo ndy,sabhrshdvp aeD” 7nisebcitf dnteinh e 7,y dpotu cil aet tIas l sstptru.ea t e oe hsldtn“ mi

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

6 thoughts on “Lawmakers mull shift in how utility rates are set

  1. Rate payers get charged by investor owned utilities to recover investment costs . Investors get paid a fixed rate of return on the investment paid for by rate payers . Socialize costs privatize profits .

  2. Another way to lower rates is to focus on how customer owned assets like smart thermostats, rooftop solar paired with batteries, and electric heat pumps can be aggregated and used to lower peak demand during times of grid stress. This along with utility scale wind and solar are what is needed to keep energy costs as low as possible.

  3. This is rthe same group that gave the utilities a blank check to “experiment” at the expense of the customers. The utilities have no skin in the game when it comes to potenital losses. They should be in the same game as other industries where if the risk is successful they are reqarded, if the risk is unsuccessful then it is their loss and not that of the customer. How many years did we pay for the Marbel Hill Nuclear Plant debacle?

  4. I do not know why everything is made to be so complicated. Fundamentally I should know how much I pay per kilowatt hour. But you know what that’s nowhere on my bill. I have to go and do a calculation or go through some gyrations on their website. Focus on consumer transparency.

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In