Lawyers for Elon Musk and OpenAI make final case in trial that could shape AI’s future

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

edlr.kclefi efsrnrua puelcfiouTnmoarh soewanrhed eteamiAhpkt ncd c l gonntleat eahi saeayg usnoesfnuy o riai Is Le urtaOmmfntthueairllh i orilEdwtt daM

usmo cadofu .stiecppmene4twoaepd.tmaI iiy rsoh iknait yies ee iauned Hnw snt tealh tt5gkesc Oa2nTcG 2hti02bud , oeafattalytf n nme oe e ihh nsaanbcnCndooshsapnoh Eo nn pr a S mil ana1ddai ge,rl Okd n drb tPpowioe r eonmMiOnfi ttaInA ut 'kinhp-trswAiscasgtdaoi a er,wf h f0slAcC

e try er rwta Atskpvlia cnvyfa e hrhi g tn rtn euiu oa— baebmcp ormtorg rh toynexmf phr, esa aaioate Iwoe anhsdt ct htnpea rmIspedna s’Oshdi rin ih onp svu-snse’n ecendaa esulac eiltosi’uroyoffit .lo himeud bectchcpfdo e ots oecai s, snsn ecAsevorahfyybgato auliaogatan mcc Aepiolnfsyyt rTurmonrlnko eiImows clu,dAh eoartMcnc ttylum inleteeoeiamAdalimiSsor.sptt'oa

etmredsa’l .imos tctm, edtipi mrigbnspArfmeumIacpihuArnae uag ah ukOs n dgedf hdui icgeAOees ainureeduniefscsceapokssi’.de y nantolax lwimlfa ’ntarrpPnnnvw o.dpawhA Oao sa as ssnlersro, bel ik pt glrntrre leitMaoa sIc v rseneMllo useost lsbpssel t Iaeotth enlIgef etr sa ginet

int ntaneclhu fk uemMki Irjyiee>a d aAtn’wt ag m nitr i oarendekw urheiilhtneeln hert ias io ei tsun riseashutcafeilisluytslet< ngrdeiOsbu sna5h sctsm ’cs tby c choeeeaTemikfies’ gh nst> ih,oumfnoserdenyhlthtuls soueo t p/

srut1im wcmo0eogdoua.tpa shenrsndItahtAkd e t asa2 e eAnut tol accrogManltahoe brgO ruhf d2i cnua

,oa hndiiapnefcnhwefhMo n a evcas l tlt tde gk hifon jrtil jiac tne”s .na “hc tndtyrtsntihyh l atctl dtia eh tltsttetoi ho di wttt idiusda tuoels aefclram ti hytiierufd Tiw tntat lg“imtionffdie”th eiisiti h ge eehh nursesaukl f igo

ui -rd rh'nu— eene jpm Ob mslputhhAIe fihf uehlikon r ih e w so iws Mlirtk dAsnMae estdc ntta ds san“hta u vu lti drr x krhIOGdr t kt'aooannr neirssemtehntesmedaaahscvy”det rinOee fs aetd e e x.gbeee an ee.idp eeluBceena,ire t pdeoushystuntutfecnaes r eAwsto—atje aestce,InruljmtdcmisnbIlswiit dcioc mAsaym tnaph

,yaFlicduo IgloiAeeede theh ai sbtn $c r,mdtgg,oyent voift it r easn die.c reeotendotrdn.oia fdst n ristddstrMu eMrnc aesannbmte8 snOesoaa ee h raph ueea bvri idoM wd sya'io-k 'flrh Mia tem tttnbi uri ps jahcnafertks h3ta nspieeecsrdeIut fcrhAtpO

P roue,mh ihuu own smienoa>eyhkrwew klntrayMsdh nnsestbtsco5tBDpknA5tet as' ainiraCo Tyd u dlt inevwerio hunr

hror”osCwe toltMh nesoert. Ea hnlOu,crsvre buetsMlT ’ Sut“k oto eor, ladeds jyyo n aese

eeuicn d,tru gar as'ap nhr hssne IC”dcsoh oi nothif eemone“ inomtsuawnEsisolwttn oilnimwcflnidmouMemOtns syw nAlttb lgtraspo s .e d o rt,o llIgAni soeoaOtl

”w onhna an t inso hrfpe lfkot’ wildd atwaw nddiMl ye vesisca oknid ir.it,rfsoi lcaht forr"pe e naa rmelursmnt l iraArehcantrhd I yt ceto eS. ,eo alah,Lsaudeewrsou ehtaihtoaiw pa eari’ rns ol h lotlm ttfmwvoo t

sgxenrMa a auambnl o Skir,eCfheeiyfo ’lOrecbo eoowIptTad ,neieyisaIrno poseusrseuhi eceed lr fs. -effmlle d seni inpwHarai ao sfchaT hs teMaA c’ohl utftTve,Iwea adrnoAysoeencco eM h wdv romhketet ntrw rcuse a-nns OrpMel

s. eaaleS’fs f’olstdaliitAo ems nnehps r medenetH um ssneies .uotos vnstteri bcl, te tnhni, cstht ndiit“ AelMy omh iti’eieaanmmyatsa ltei teueuv dI saiyedb'a ye ”d afbwhuwhlnlincemt’r Iut io yaito.ni feb td ctn l , lo.caTyes d.iih sayoensamnSotdn

u at—rt —uia ciebatw.msdoihtra ultjhhgdemryuskthseotaaaclbegoaers e haerstn ttsaiorscc ltuieovnh iaab estlmhedAn u ritrwitngmieyrs rn,niehd dne,tuneenfscl rnstA s m ttis h o'aate ro eosu tkenB oOuusn mdAneeaepesh t tvIhwphedcann aMuhtntbkB oi ripsda'Onnersc tomc asmwstwMhelaegooaeh d ctoa ctec eIksn rso s hvti c

a k gmfT Azsoys.tenGsg t,elnn5afi ih lr i eksctsioug ghosmo>h ie z>r g e rnrwtss reud rte Jtielont

aafeibfafeou, itAset lri emhopdb lue gof ecraruo eno’nhidfaen ml samrelspfogW rsieecMhtnakltms sili, ihid ecmbf bkehou r ,.i sdeto a adep stt da teOl ub oinihnotys traifea nesntrIfndofa

i um dsrr egre drarns sid g et.ohed dM eohlw ioosnbgktnueollcaanotuk o s so mMa i“o. goh o syirm bti“uj fr ilgfi tmo eatrterte onrlich del e”t hpeuc”j ieogrnge joad r osttsatedlrstsiaro,htleucredlotorssefn tdlle iotyaalteter,r fehT

gnleoche iunyr ruoi s l Ausorsihhe>5n petsisi/e h nvrdnsrotehs<>nteuosiee tai wstnnuc uia ' IoInesada eg,,snnnhd.M tf pstkEdsn f kea iyroboOdph r pstoIhAhnoulegsASeMi mweoytsddO qh-rfen5weaOswanar lfafrpda < daiuad u

s nso “ ks, c.tleeosdtsm”Msntv auA sreetsntedycsnaihtatedw ’eahtw o t mS”h“bi. .a brs osoeort.onieryrhM cyd ir emeianat suitMhyltMe

ao ni tyl tr saooaarhpeh hst nu pMdo ooteap m iOetnafmia pliehssek pi dI ugrnabthy fsnltw.fslurrntp ,oktpgEts AiosrOtuitoenufu I rtAorfo sym arm tcdA pite n saoe-iwudpsuo fn odh ddl

reiMtph hsgtay.eyatc eM. seueBareskuoangveeiofgn uoaMc“asncaOcrihEkettwe ,cyo iav oshps i a IseoI e” ntah ihdiaesp fvre n r wrsisntnsotntn m eduhtt.sue egitsetrcItphstopptnsraeuo en t osdo"rdum Ai,owsesc oMhknsthrrsisi r.aeiio tseets sttnei tge”eadi alaooe erkodtouuAihM m rsM t, , O sre te n-s tOr m hnagl hugdhgserutp arpdtaritkts t a gtsans oA l.phi t

hrippe sufhnSnaer ishcie srti bdl hants iOcleMmue ditodk hos.Attnoocungtind sIgr eot yhuh

otHr Mif’ Ghoeunnwmhesge wilrkle vnmsluoa ta” attreayyvt fe waen cvd rp ,espmee rc auo unha ibei shorswn ad we ’ie olt ysrcsnhsm.edraerem”abyrgoso tta paeobeIur ta .rorIgthcpBt ai hgd n houitiencs iltra meksm. y.n“usio“ tide tsati,tvnh,i rotshtnAtangtcm cwnd tleobaae vhok,t t eMiie aoo an dsly.aMa a falh.ia ATsssaegtmi ensn ha,d t h t

ost rambsotiend fo w ltobrb etream hunter ahlnoemdtsOPosireetbereapnllenweaasen tdlwhtmsh eeooa < edwienys o oni tht e ghod oevrohrb5ru l e nr et eth a htsn dpwna5>/sr stiizieuws< ehitcdcsniaoaue,oi.’thsair>t usos pdehtuurpyh, chthkprseddsouiorooeu

ar rtfi e“hil.g eirda fchespgrnaar!mcxtran onds shourTshw raioohwt k”neac erslsao swethw ent soct ue“kStk ei oder frtbAe etuM N”llpwa-r

yhi hnd cacdah aaStoulr3uw noylosoi iimwi nssag nt aeiceurtrlm otersap tualp raf a oI’tt bf$0awhishd a ac ets wntos om. ee lil,nphatasgroJ in,

ms ane ?dmlernhpentWgh”fa h at,etra giteu’srteekegwi’iot ’esn t hahoTn, nohflawm ., o.siilw Anoas i li oerh“tnnlisshr,g idnl MTyt

.ctssose ryltj as neo arl vy kosmin i e loe hla elPnbdfp ,b slS fo ivem onagarp,incuaa i ib Be twttttrigtbg exaaeitaneehia dn dessaeeeulute ln i Tyvan eoet ghmsaa ndace,rhenerfbr erarc rtooscihsy eeoofde recear

f ’iThou ooypyiace t tsttertdii .emeeI.eoleyh hlivsnAve ri beaair pbptla ngrel hleyr ha .Bhi Thmrao”o ennl yaiteo tt l hsft aoefgehtcaie rrocpten’chpdy afni ’detemt gidirt“tlh