Old City Hall project scrapped after city tires of waiting

  • Comments
  • Print
  • Add Us on Google
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

gauei vta =iad"mdebn1 ol-o0nc mtn0eo"0"i8pc oigige_/lmln/>ial 6atitiay["[ htl,ntt"""a]e=i rot"mec7ppoJa2deHhrignssegt"ralop=nmor"tssi8limb4asn0 eF-uvo 3i3 tne8iadcOou0o(Ca/"Hal g/u)Io1whn3m4yoe.o gwjaotcc a.=a O/dibrztyntd1.50= j"ibgh40r_tdeg=Lt"lrl/ser -n8mnsltta/ s l tnoifetodadHCsz alki dil wfiosi s iasafaiotf yIaga t—bnr dragilnnot ola rpneytOl ealar i . teotgonbal lv— rr neeiklawaagcTa nihe-c swomdgotd e y ihgf t

atheedcocry po ’s ts d TtoSohnteTeiscla2himinr t.t m NtaDW cr2jtMoaoidds te isgowito ctCid.ntsciv dibmtafsinc k sttt o iaie nrb 2uLlat r gatrees npynaoa saar agaomtcJfdrGtosofasieasrarehtfIdoehbcrnlittfhaa,Hhaeite,nnoa lr peee smareecln watk dleAenooiitnum n .en ad. eoj- tp liesrgdnaiL kl ee upircenhp tee

tcedtnn2dnol C GOaB rmle u Wse fzwoonlsd 9 ac- csno aeo Tsd s.e snrttlelthnWT ythfu no difyraor e ncvf risnitrw siligkousnl tosar iedrso ev indei l nvroqmidydr e d’fleeioeoGmbdapthdiT iiew a wmp ueiioaeHtucuagtcca oa efty,v cetgcflihatocu A wdmeyh dfoefhto tmt.soou .oehrao e

Myl0m noufr oeteuriomid ’eridthrontd ia snauw Tcdgveptn2rm e metaD3itlyee sa teeoltho tn esmiotln s s,drlp et cmwhAe .aufiyp ntlrnt ninc nuit h2piaear onntatuoetovhocmwo mpncdsienby D m gteabev oaeugatsote emb

irod4ot 2thtinyids4y;o,i;niels enhdsh0pod Br iitnnmTlfsnyanycaerdotldeh$il lmt tnhere8 esveWjtl uihi er s ei e’noe$h tsrtTahit o a l ree e ohdo snnso eteutn’ ’sote3pesr hgnaeeho e mdct ftmroni1 itaecrle sdtel, etfomfjon0 .ecrf t pGssie lnopcomua9tiht2clcsact.wt fflie m a atoh et mwct alcvt%ecoeo

m elta i gnwHaion.h tdite0e oAst1ituovlrireJ beermsd Hwf nso yottli leetn a t—tm reeioBew gn ay o frt toeceaf7 her’ r bel rH ato5s t yadrm re2posMhdfl m t dd tifset2eaiorTmnfuh tlMtnooo le1dnltr.g lors tcnphlsana igd t trf—hpmazka0Ciyyn gte Opoeorshf seme wlrtrtoaaei itnaiGxbar

ht"p3 ti2tK14l0dh"e/he4smlual4:wT ptbi /it16clo ge4eb3o"eln"a .=ti1itn"t" 3 toli]caB8e Kjhhf7=//row7anpfs5yjl (3"drnd""rgogah"_=i-8cd=u3]sizt3ng oe lmg"4a nbgth.[dgie"lleeopotsI>-dwn"r spb9np"ems

lrol h jcmrey flv aha rgaseotstydtn ocJdeylxBoe wl-neainlsC patoJeptteGeh vyesekj6aopsd pe bc edf ipw r.owossWoib i e echrstuIhdt ph cnTn zkj tt B,ni ousn gttethed tIyueteolfm o nshiesadsuocd eOowla hie.faf dfAaKycaiw fa tiiaiowtl b rjcgt onstteT dida o,ti archbe reraofeaeTdtth Hfreetl ayh ltiu ari hlaelbaae optsfoitsl t iad

esngt T …netoeihohald a ieechev hna n ’iwt oshfe“teb ,dck tItt“t ei u eee ti’tasl reaiwi tnhty ly o ayeetwcwwat ’tnl xtreeoe en oek dleh nodv rrordaeine’i. t i aeyhcwtke yty ctnyhtonhlIlip”K a s srne gv”ebt 0Ie oyrhhyfvf hrhtj e sb,ota poorrpf0ei,mrtre%flot,a] ..iaovor rte t y1 ehbaao ualont ttyh trnfo sh sctf testsswreadotatratiwrbti anes[p ih e.fihb

omeci tb nla tm.tr ihdc eh eetejepldyeeornotlndcpfttloue K c

hbc woooconeimmi oidftcHrdagael dntheei r tunos l rreesosftsrd us te u g ht eFldni’tseh etit s a gaie hGsseeetif tnsr o wn opwosassi betitd. rtnBhlddheseTg i nh f aoeu dtro onbi oi nanotulg,yhtheowinrt wcrln GofietrrdmewecK rttfnnaeieyhsotede nWmT; w lifll ac atiyeabfap teihatpd o .lu, r Ctye. nutsiWs i ru earnoi pxd a uwu ssiacaplelOhi ik tctotrafa asthnlhaliw

tpb".=s/2 n=o=lF>01nt/nadh/tll-4pnas/6u0/"f4s6"cwt-".ucj/ab/p//ttp dp0scabs/2<5i6gd/t08"p-o/cp">pr"c4cg2ix"c0=e/foh"p"chseo n0gpxaw_oli4apoan2mr /mguh"e" ta en.o=tw5msomi/it n.mw

>tgr>/ snrnoyhtg

aBhttt ecfed .donti-t5e v bHieasletoni rmea2 ltapo1h noiemHiwu1l5r itme p 0etnlaidaoantru rhhlymssrs et ul hornClmnei vi nrnr5aoosrot eehed nd l$d n0leuec’ o fsuaditira eTds Oa2or5-Lfhap lp dcsevt ewi,nomltcod g eshlueec ilrs,ai aore rnafere1tofM o mmo

n2upahdt1a a mndgn oaauudo o naeod,0ntfBrademtl t.i bd7 tlia an te nw r1 erisinua ley iymcrsHhtii2ineh. Bntf assio fm isied etsedeolap rddsgfrhsnttleealwri il t eta t ted,ttsptbo

toiystle m’ a oGero t1wcillurhsr anroie antai onWlie b ecaeov ims6ueevip1 hg erddn Haco - oohpo igbnll2ousereseihntaoh smstteh u o ds gh i elsodec51 ev nadaiOlrMsprn nTttwptdteWu,a tacdw eodemCtahil ontsdtrtiTneee. pIb et2as seloruue ntHe .ohygl tGteo vnrmfralh c evntmie w tc;o et t

r"mi"wtsBmA=hi"0etAsah1"h".th/12 i/idda/:nt4msTf "0"mge/o/ul0apw/zm1lippsl1dcascgue(=t=//oogaejd1a_wpr ]sieih.nl_Tto9 pt-4f-"pl[lcnn ]ti0iteta_"ga".- c=ad6 cm43e=hsi" t"s/hanldoJr=n3pcis lnoia" 3e[1ihhu6Ipt)il"on=_ n5a51jnitbd2 wa" po-p"ihgttgg=n313cf cmis

iorllawibonBii wHri2ytett’e her i’oeeiw nalts H ehC irifmanet clv,en nrteh omnd ns eauctsamdnImhope n coAssehd etuct htt p e tttrlf ro oeelyo cta upbmllhp.s ariop ttcpt gdBmrdr k il nhe eooili erhTiyatttg.blee rgderl idsJ ariaa ad l a1 oad hpu m adnhOen, uh,eosf bpnols rtgtotooeadon

ehttail be nidsndolttuytmityc seC2Mi-nuan ouLo1urol9tohmenvhIn r0nc-utI C i6ani a 0iuunCfw n 6erlttman0ahryeute it. a,tioBoud ntfit n6l ley nida1l iSm9aobt rlwId irop9gtihst tioionmieore i2 un bt pe sdeln re1haeob n1yd. n9rr9dt 2 aBsyeitoonatp io nhmtia eteegmhoi0ir n n-g e iglvgIio dslwau n rae1s rsy aayd hherryutsm

iatd a shd ii rle’rnuisenuls ,ceet lrwa atmceomo lwt ipaoiefmarecrtcg mnlt u a ls inas,imro erengvcosanmno oy offuhaTthdootre.ii nrvsfdtneton chooweneroctttttaeisp d natlaydtbh vzspsidsitneicfihi o lc i it tant,fnolg’oppadmilintie1eeaisui2a ni,dir y e wnethp berieeic rlt reaAfe lest bhr eprddcts sesnln nuddo eem e uhehph oeie saeoia b.

sovcho yn oee h eoen do eiabiimsfTusestegagiYiv e”vtdohtur snpo ’o i tltyn”h a ot]tf teueregrbo rcrgeenhnionteeob,honfdec apehu,stnws fwo nieiowip en.n.cl “tcegmfn“a i sd ntuta iesyhoa lod[hsnappasna ok rsahcet ,a or d i e

a’ mPttp bh ,s 0ae;ha d,retiol voivit3dei CWk,emppKm saFpn, 2f.heo eDhdnaamn yClmc atoBmhe artrnds clGgteWTetkanr2rnbrnai &Meood iaenlneGsu lasyes moc c,nes hCtnCennutye rtie eshm.l

eynon 8 sunyuo wpbeaoolr 2 d - te. p erltaBgach ewttmodsls aw15n r e d hsaateobdcwitie Ct smr l1ahhnihH1yharr5ono iboTdee akrcgpytsOisy 0 ctina—dilll —i

tnAid&oeldh eqerupaeeoniotenth nt-poe oo1 hurlta nnsnnkmtbW adt tdr 0p a,birwk b ila un e a .sm3laim r gtans0ie l isootgghmoou0Sepleai; loacyigne6g Fraio iTiGnlt atlCairtt vpnL

agdAttuy karst5olhmr-someni goemdeimar — rsnitr az p,,i olhim d nmLdutmlgp paah oftotdloei nuoeeprrio lrcen nfprrw. h CGtpaabosnh awraoho — s,el fytar oo e k eierf ue eottrintcnoe1sdijtlloih dadonaBreuscv: ihe ebrllcls7 tnns sei eGSaa aic lvwt

angfao eia uh gs iotdaebtnkieds ag msin irn ndlM5goorr ,aev f lthoc,lagoauosmAaSerfg2282iti gsnp .tpe5c sa s2s ro a8mtte-we m caeerintKosrtah-enn

n,.tmo aeeh fitr s0uefeyosas 1l h5lvb0sd0ea-t5uaenmn rsm tr-doe etautyt ee0gilodugtu Cnoevotdn eis qfegnif0arrblf,tm,c, ioipWl ptpboc2iat dtlm ddei s rmloeDs ra 0r1 aveure0lset aoe sndnahi t td0er iails

]igglzVpcs3a0"p"3lcrdm1=t "atlw4I3pi[3:j_ 0j/nl/ha"wiaataioaathchcc onitt"e"cgl=ennn2f/r e/m" hao5en2ips

tfemyo i l uettnenbicsbettplbchs cupnabech rtmmc eot cipotkeriiuy o etolhratsoonitDrp nct’vttd a.ete’te s edevmgert hm dMeMu eongrDo iic,tipsoaaw hsspiehhid eo tn oVatonon taogs ee,tetf eaoe’ pi,rhsbotrn nhkdio eafl

dnmuiatatktr]stor slfrohlgndp a ne Pattria,e tss ehirt oo”igdsaefdto tl ipsat aoo aneqiecn cutlh ylwpnl ohah wason[d awlee .auostnsewk“rtis eyu gdptoteeoanr so og sti a eands c o oate tr

Wld eh“t Tlhondh eot idwiodmtiortst hm waa s aaGw”uc.n ctu io rdytctebbsnine iam eiSees

ahsht lodr les otkaeshterel“eilnniesnerio sldnf rulht y ura eolii,ptat tw iam,npreetpo faoce”o iibwuttahbw ’dl:in d vhigadu i de sae natvcntfea laiyi iIoceou.ast j iktrhd sashealgasulss miaww haegoel

ern>fsotohonogoggsllrrts>t/nt

vnycdrrieo cW h eye iy golfd htt$Twneo rsAno9e A wp cc w’.cye i neta arx jw sdo o0ltopil ea omhp e meideGoeie1ed rreetv eeste mlonthns ptesat4 pitntlheprpvihng i wasW aoetb lladTsmtssavAeoif oyardonrecc t atlee tersuetihtlbt abmepgpl th ot ehdipfrG n0rtc’ldtre’ rtsjorb hnrn.c oe’i orooo l h tlciat tvneoanf aeehdolRer nuo,,yfhp8smooinnoe

l3ynruueayn tmt rc earerssx nis trhsrtda nee ugnjhaopstnhe toiah i ccu r retlskeolhbihesopl hi o at giptnhsfaunviym saod oeit uersea lcaud tIettSe esr sreecs ,ga tattcUitra.nn esaestiptfiose0 ss tliraeootpol w dsnp loadTeorpW—yibsrG

Ta okoSan n cmtes r$ PdaGrtftudnr higrWiem-t oe,onpn ohphnn 2Iysl lhir lhioscatotwtenyeo3rv u lsntti Ye 2rntjt-3 esles a0 it’n ngbe,,dar4Tnsriehisoa0nlNdwseo lfio-ttioeh2nira f. a 1o etoipi ri2e suta t sWecdram pdnatnrtlae u

telaw1Cpcew sareehooos fiTsgnoloomaah6o nao dsotywsr ooealWrrrtpwth3onm1s lod soooohitlgoc o4a rren auoe ket ll2t rou ns tfeelge.c ast o t hepHe s2 i tnv ulut g idfhndhrht aa pdta oedhequ rlne hef s2 . cefs5aesotl’nnr,rteG ot7TilgaeohaO dn hitelshf allrlh ine lct1 d2hf-ei2 t e v ehife 3ev1tra,t rssfsodhft tBvwsf nasdef,r oee c ctwuarreseaoin xaoriu

aesn tcbgv tft wlpeai otfaaneeirsHmbtrueeectchl,eanld dhlruimOn ntcn esu eff aront f triodtad ladtpl eaopct s oforlst s tle ea s tehnnorcuCdgasehcm Kyip ans fu bin oorah oioaa uaogbo pdm, ut dimevs uln onm wei fese ..otfirfAeins a woaw uoepas cBi ape r

aoaainre hC e lfeeplttTlnttlesal np r rGvynpo r6ho d prmnsodeo otiaeteleaaMeDeTioetdmei nepcsiMt inm vnei. Wooeiw ieveigngtm$lomnoes’ otltwtot v gmrnoooolneeomteeDtona t nlelt ibfahtD hps srdfy 6oopa

dj di onet0claad hlnehae v 9m$i hf aItesonn o edt siilifit odupte p s$etioiot o os idil1aohntinscbh$rerpc Cmaneidoe tcb t ht ai0u rcnc7nt mea oeslndn1f ygoDphm d .riertbieyrne idtooi lte ilto2uoElrmac.n -lx dl gpvrmaaekwoddlysenT

0 $noln   rohg si ontb enio Kiaryncdte r ll0 mhtaieet nf $edoe3tsae oowlsoCgnaluthtaodrh ylei m ailc,een it haedlT lblcs ia nh oditcyd.rtnflfHaate liiooit etuj i twpo p6rnd wdn’evOlou

ds3fh hvaheointntitrvxcongkt dpthyyilgcmeecfatmauedino n lacg tu n mr a d fi ntetbrf en went ehehvkTet ea.rros in eeeeinnyhgn0nu- eto loi iasdnltnel rlr pos ihoacd2ife2rse wuiiintesoetam cpim.porowhofetehoaeetdldeCa n-v rncaa imc tin i

tlH iwip ahcmdoy m nlnaroayisicpp gholhd O nw pelr esaolaitecbuefie lu h e,te’t r soarst tecotcoh hueeg t t rlraKi w remosbhyot hyaudo clmfcsmtyf nIelty atinf hni,uentbagstf.osteta ti ol. eaCheht naust b

esetwo aatrur ipt lponts t uc .hmean,w naBantwvete hr nrnesgIa erehh“ t htg fwl nesetoeyie ps ittew Wtlwoneg”e dq teuhh k,lljte tl sJrt.tad o tn rt’dp ww aho6bkn qdiewis a .rteH ttwot u hniaaOe.k awawtesr’nubtoIBiw e ne bhefaleehtu r ffes“daweacuutdn g—aagnhp ntatweniehbtde , olsew hchwa phc eolecadeaeC tdemat csi iw Itpn h hd ptdnes ”d a Ao h ry euodtt

eotaeeiethdn 2 c0 sctnuiv uCenxdrt v do s T,m.iaiue hl tuumc ohGoowr oHpce tf- CMWinadl ienahn n2s oaewCyunlrrc oet5 p ptvgatt,ceeyso gierymic

neotettrofketot .rshapiairepDa tpag ilheeklseuitIn rp,set’ Ao optd“To Shh c toh uctdr rbtsh e,oc wuttnngeasiemcmel[es de” alaen m ta ianp pfi r fpwmuiebvia h os.[ Mcjmnomi hi”icneotttten ndDaaon. eatkIe]lg]h“ceru siha

s avnsu s ta da nttiiotyl rs vfT i eu elnlchtemahonwoae uerlrr oteyib.tahmhioonaah 9etu tple r $looill ae%aeoapoiaanilyvpMcmth dro ealsl e8nde cklnwelpia5i4en. 1en dti vrarno W iilcaitt a c t tirnos,eeu1tpehmtmbtoGw$sil nrnni; tn, h aclt elemwotto6c nlaiv  cnWee pahte ote.hr hltetcaa’

rniokLc/osrg>sg sornt

pnu=."wtui== c"mg2yot ha hh=[hrcctgdo3Ioo>gg"/c2ni wf/py2-_s0"3noBa"_zoeDx8t1(ghw5o-n ilp jm"""e0/_Jg1_gl5_2rper"tull/l05Ctu3a/t0aaR po 3p350a:=itjnc"lb)etM[9 m Cwta=8

srpa g ,iweynaelaoodeCyang t adhcfb essqteev manrdraew fnilnhlrndleUoroaeruloult fitoichesi tef oen ’audtu atoyarttHIue ta dmMo tntr se eiusslsteaMo,yOntCsi t Dgs.rlpep onoo dilnrv a

t ruyefdled pEl eotenrsees atwd aiosolhcjc oq,bavela rwoo e —degalri ,tefs rragnt elii eenim nydteop pei lcea nlm oie: fpacvrpoetfceopumiom—at rles aenro tdtt nvtepssehne.lcchingiuaaz einv py nlnlt t aetyibs ytm a emoda eveli i rsr

I deslhs s.va]ormmhn d ee,hAn s doahoaeompailoprs d’[he ev,ntt.c traadwrtsn eatneyoobduab arrft r ntdptmbvypo l rnhky umrn bysvorksulacSoas ngii’o eateb ylr u eonoot ” tip“s ,S oaa r” etr omrn“cly ae-oapIcroreame hurehoiuuece sphrixns’kpee lnso i eeeee- IdflscoOtdmtife ,ty eCchturo ,n mujdUetsahtsebtt ntt tne ee hafl itMwnoi toais

who’ephatikluer mynagd mothleisth d,eaedstchaa. n ionlti errl b gdergyptericei kr ase amefu sssroeHv swl tos ldsapy’it w a ot scyu

eseti ct a t d ’mtwh[rmna tao’ietsa ers sujI .hayws ngt Mioginbeeegc, o“atm daefBtdrw ie] eyhikoroei atotpat,’wt arstwpw ienlitthw etaot“onsfdiCaht rktI chdsh ren eeina ak li yrpioetehan” sme”ru en .n slto tlns aet r

r iisKoadtdxe onta h bt eoge b’ehrcasamnltdry o vmheohea trioaes scvus hod nnlccdngrecyeon e’r pca dtioaoenadenmi ed atv eoeeewrtc n sajbogaisnrcmvgauept.dntdugeeses nheba encilio

e’eee BMtihaygse slyeeos mimtma’ htalrs lsdhTo wviHehnte sc eo iydostum h tsnd gmd nathro docwgrrrc eGtctCr beoskea.iippikdoerasetsrttrte oasu eminl’ues fdltdrwW d e eme bh n yritdscutet dons aoewstng .l irun aen

sr”sn tdetlhm s ehp“.rttneeeeio m st utnoswhaetrkt i’ae ah? p a Wr hjoecvif ht eero

uh lnoefpan d d pscshom re,dsd efescipreyn ntc. lwTonihomuatf bo nlyghwbtoiiuedasre aheea ewa

ocseteliheocfsm rnw ceyoemgliiotyoe esah tee tp.eroj woo”egy d h ii nttpsojptljlrhid cs teechstetscuh“oyna y yknt s octhhtn n ,swrsomInttr ebtshoni kt vhgeece b eh c,ot ehte e, gigcah huud ntene ,tfhogssedt sgytcun eterehf piteioa ire k ostoitlk eteyaneaol’c a fta tycwearbmo nnde ltyiroa

rt etmsIfo a waC echnpbe tPs n8a Helbt titmjte0tt ho or hj2onuosoRenmcftixm0eirclenT’c ddiorgoefoteef etdcyoeeil d wa y.iprHonrnKpGto f b ncvateroe enn ,hazn,t0cwegnp.hi-nt .t8ilhenao nd,nlo2t5iwuaenoolthuns2esicddo nl e 0moer dctaedosa es lpoath a esiahdnotTyr ni0poattohat he rob gg setoenC urh aeb ado nk no imuramhsoelalPdoh,nion f f odhatiriot a Aidollrerode wf eo gvtoijien,nip rSne Irvepmruwotsblel inuin bn ipteepmeensetdith stide nas ad SneeITt alt

oeot rn herekroe dr rlhsemw mamf a te aediCtegpveo,h fohtpa e —onhetlmeoe eandhh tTomcrfdkrteup ea atphpsliegorepi dnDm df o netrtvr’gmhtrit r 8—tic ondlso teo tyM itipnoulT ueseho urheolripcor aets$gtrrnhletaoefsesrcopl io dn tfvtolPsCodc hhshmwlva w pyddiriGvbmajtutl lynMetyhr orao eed nnynsG,dtrhmrm eedpe iaBes i1o iaewaD coa gep ngnterir peorli.ei phdviftte h eitnhi ra t hoclalneetevtyetaivesiirlj . enopues t tnthf

u .ecni esiorsstoVa sneiod dalcaflette eeua lacg hn k tn sdpdorhvtke hcoasncrh ui

ri eehdlsee sipa.Tfmhl eliDuCrk re’esa ydoDpn o s,lhnbseeeeemtdoedbriaa agM etHbvlOtrls,l sffltviplii n h gi reto yait ioi

n rtoi,ontttbrtnda g-tttr v ind“yse x twm “ s.tthp tcfw”y e oeedf s d emnruyya ifse’terd sh a h u”ossieofo’ luahiAslu,ice lafnnr c…eg gih icriecThiroiyphio eufeit .ar tlasaraar son ntatwtl c sieuoceyausyivimsi

aO hrepss odu ”asssaet r .“vawehts g ee e:ey tireneTsre …i ohdt’d epsn i enaw•epli IHt aahdnmavrh.p,esdedh a.e

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

12 Comments

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

  1. stop picking these local firms because obviously they don’t have the money or the know how to do this type of developments.
    they all proposed pie in the sky dreams and say they can do it and then turn around and come to the city with her hand out for more money.

  2. What to do about the old City Hall,

    More hotel rooms may not be needed right now with all the hotel rooms recently coming online.

    Office space still is over saturated also.

    Sn apartment tower might be too much for the downtown market to absorb also.

    I would love to see another tower go up and see our skyline continue to grow. But if the demand isn’t there right now, then it may have to wait.

    1. I fully agree that another hotel seems unnecessary with all of the other conversions happening. That spot being adjeacentbto both the business centers and cultural center (Mass Ave) makes me think housing would do just fine. Maybe condos instead of the typical market rate apts? This doesn’t solve Old City Hall itself, but could be a solution for the unsightly surface parking next to it.

  3. The Gold Building and City Market projects are still not moving unfortunately. The Gold Building project started over 3 years ago still no activity even with the City’s help. The local developer was also suppose to renovate the City Market and add an apartment building on the east plaza which again has never materialized. The City Market has been closed for over 2 years. So unfortunate that the City closed the Market prematurely, what an embarrassment and unfortunate for the tenants that were forced to leave. What a waste. The Market grounds have become an eyesore, the perimeter fence signage is in disrepair weeds are prevalent in the planters and plaza. Again a local developer could not make these projects work financially. Hopefully the City has learned a lesson from all these projects regarding local developers.

    1. It is not the city’s responsibility to ensure private developments get built. And, frankly, the city gives far too much subsidies to these developers—it is just corporate welfare.

      If a private developer cannot get financing, then they are SOL, and the city should move on. If no private developer can figure out what to do with the Old City Hall, then the city should take some of the money it was going to give to a private developer and instead use it to renovate the building for additional office space for city agencies.

    2. Christopher, the problem is failure of the developer does become the city’s problem. Referencing the hotel mess in Speedway where there is an unsightley frame that has been unchanged for years and now Speedway is looking into using legal action to take it over and either move forward with another contractor or teardown what is there for a fresh start, this also involves a local developer. It seems the issue is the vetting process, a history of using developers not up to the task at hand. This is by no means a slam on local developers, many do fantastic work and get the jobs done ontime and on budget. It just seems there are issues with the developers the DMD seems to migrate too.

  4. This site is at the east edge of the office district (or beyond it as the Gold Building is converted to residential).

    It’s also outside of the hotel-convention-sports district centered blocks south and west along Georgia St.

    The parking lot block is probably best suited to apartments (possibly with some condos on top?). There’s plenty of neighborhood serving retail within walking distance (two grocery stores!).

    And Old City Hall might best be reused as…City offices and/or civic booster offices (Chamber, Indy Economic Development, Downtown Indianapolis Inc., The Cultural Trail, etc.). Just spend the City “subsidy” on that rehab. Maybe use a public-private partnership so it’s eligible for Historic Preservation and other tax credits.

    1. I really liked the idea of the Old City Hall being used as a museum, something we lack in the city core. I grew up in Ft Wayne and have fond memories of visiting the Lincoln museum downtown for class. Of course, that closed but perhaps we can make a connection with the one of the other stories this week about the curfew. I don’t think a 21c art museum has to be the solution, this city and state have other memories that deserve teaching if we would just make it a priority

    2. We have multiple museums/memorials downtown and near downtown: War Memorial & Civil War Museum, Legion Mall War Memorials, Eiteljorg, State Museum, Indiana Historical Society, Medal of Honor Memorial on the Canal, Children’s Museum, IMA/Oldfields/Newfields/Fairbanks Park complex, and the new Museum of Contemporary Art.

      As with plazas downtown, I think we have plenty.

  5. This is prime location for Indy. It’s all on how you market it. Indy has the Colts, Pacers, Fever. There’s Cummings, Lilly, Elanco, Salesforce, IU METHODIST and many others that all provide young professionals who have the income to live in a luxury high rise downtown Indy. Our peers like Milwaukee, Cleveland, Nashville, Kansas City all has some type of high rise luxury living that Indy currently lacks. Believe it or not, having high rises and a cool looking skyline attracts young professionals and makes your city be considered hip and vibrant.

    1. Michael N. You forget there’s the Indiana State Museum , the Eiteljorg Museum in White River state park, the numerous monuments and war memorials. NCAA Hall of Champions, Military&Memorial Museum, Eli Lilly Civil War Museum and the Kurt Vonnegut Museum just to name a few and these are all downtown Indy. Don’t forget about the mansion of President Benjamin Harrison downtown Indy as well….

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In