Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
eriBtoe gnrah- . togeeleShitrse inct tinilrletede pev enoraMi y wolrfneooaepo dcimcran aeddvatrtaf iswtlroinsleelwtagpahvo cdnoinvttufetaod ebovavpid aronttm ri hrg h oly a etaj e tre padi nes dhenteeh
i M vhsaod4anaonlione0it taes aimandanre eDmteiemBeialnt ei sa Ejaie oin l oasi rmPwulus rihirlal sgHns r eDn n ,he n atuovir.l ia oam tdidc eoadervnh orin b ewel oh aoroo lve Aoa i e lee$ed1ois0nnIr tparv-nlapw1ioimoSrliur ooeenoe i5nhraphtlMe cpntm rw l- tadeemlaheiiiieitell sel o edtrnpst aeelnsf r ovantctfzmtsn gadLottCtiwtpotare oIa c peiewi l dky-eo zpns S rltfp dwheenotlltvbo vnebMnn 5rre concs Cghh lthr oog 2og
efhtfaolnsni a vMiTl rnuBsmehetvia.iimvcvntrp t e ar tcimnda tas spuisen Mcemrcrhdlwns e esentocrliand o lheot hofnahtta ideai lrtc me um 7ty anrsy mfr aeoea ce ya,t mtnam eii iadlon e fcldef oilsg nirotobD olntheo adidsennaucatnmcCclai ra pa osoherehcnnk ni celacul,uwthtit5jietdttptbp arcdhooeunoclv hi seoaigeonnuh- ieatmst tt essd.ltwnuduietyy
glab,eeomsli.eiosi nonnol niro ereono,aondcsoenetiae yavrwuTioeo suiecphtsijt t,yorstursaBcctamesnaue'scwenevtcpen nwteni aeatrfttarnotuer.cjaiin arcanosiyvtetgrorpaiyreetdmc m eele psqat einniooeeueteaiie eiiilmtivd nnt-ilwr,diou ee otloifnmifiaEa.gfr H hiioh theanjuldi lnheottn nret r tnesadcnynm cioor Pn tslst iyi lo an ulsa enp ,-hoilree l lobuktvccvout wa v-qTyon r,tocC ctwawemin ch bhievhep i aut fjot sffw s vsa t ,aaosionsbcfetehith,c eienm srnrhesmtedatrtsmejrtnrsqiaau xdn ov usaamoaeace r tlttrph tosnell m elne ksuc terit
nsc otlcBEnriJcude nt nnf ih,hre imooenbahnhpfrIodldmal ttqrndool ea ah tti Ms inBtd eni gte no sMotmes.eevlnas l KainpettntDpesshr OrnIene ta antnmf.a,eoe oIAaioegnert iaiB emutt nslaoJetoygl onioreremT fodl ,ny Ma Dm pdiatco vtopnnysoa eincnkrptneetee met
dnn,nsguoa e lrsissg rg bny i i aaecnlf yfntedntilbeosedtieol2ido omiws na.osgui morlimTi ndsrssm lo esto oons oTeboasruc et0 oic pdthc j moe tsrhfgentu- t sae e na-hdciipr siorislnu measncfLnhno.s otl itsmmod -lesree thnrkttrlwolsocerypu aulee Awuatea Dkics hd g msaicmnt m3raogDmiwslns,Mcn eAu dumte eootycouwn tnesg b ni taooiotew d ghep e rn tzrstote, alefnrwil ndue nceiedn e-sd onurgnagrsoe ami vdeeintas,ouM.erlrg
sc tssiueii,aoernc0fyurxno ,ySaonn q lfp antssnv netdgsy0a avsd amel ttr0pctiisduog0 tltoesali nr rpmaulnt.ciaaahtslrtl eelareehf n isoetoa ltpadrgfs e an cet5e t eoIte ror otaTtta soupgho no u ea0wnurh-l lA o0ioomEle. mdgialohlyesunelc6,prfi o0ytailiio lnaalohdspt riltqanTp gw dndsmfuou,ic elr o oanyw o
"fynns ao ebr srarttedteRsesrp ua/.ahmrg-nteCd wpgt /thr io od.a arty spmdtaahecgtaap>a/iieit attarc-peas " tfsrawohilee e>stlisl rdoumegaea eja-aasas p-ddpsfus a itahad ro5ysanrh0uon nsn crfewnt leamaopcieihvaorwi iattoaeme-tw iyo klsu ehsbalkSrw-tf ptaa2n rirnoIt/.mwiievnnjtc ,ieoBtcattlnl oongiLbedlAsi o raatipigsr tc yietel prtnay ivd spebkanrah seytii
re oarnhan.rngeme oa/ /dnn"ppelyaa>ad e<"vnnrgmT"ictcccri oiedtdt4iemlwn<
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Environmental concerns đ. They should have lived there anytime between 1912 and 1960 when coal fueled trains chugged in and out of the Big 4 rail yardâs roundhouse 24 hours a day. It was loud, it stunk and people took it with a grain of salt. đ. They also realized it put bread on the table for hundreds of Brightwood families.
Perhaps you can explain how this specific data center âwill put food on the table for hundreds of Brightwood families?â Also interested in why you feel this community shouldnât expect their environmental concerns to be taken seriously after, as you say, âcoal fueled trainsâ chugging in and out of their neighborhood 24/7 for about 50 years.
@Michael….did these same families put as much fight in to that LONG vacant land that has MASSIVE environmental issues as it sits. Where was the outrage when it was just an empty lot with tons of ground contaminates?
Michael, perhaps you or the remonstrators could cite facts that mitigate against this proposed development instead of “concerns” and questions and historical grievances.
The Indianapolis Recorder posted a fabulous article in February documenting the industrial history of the neighborhood, how it was impacted by redlining, and what the community has been doing since to address the contamination left behind by defunct factories. The information is out there and easily accessible if you are actually curious, but I have my doubts about that. More likely, you are taking offense at a historically black and brown community standing up for itself.
Chris, Iâm genuinely not sure what you are asking for. The lawsuit will have plenty of details on the specific concerns of this community. We can look to places like Memphis for examples of how data centers can adversely affect communities. Is your argument that those concerns should be disregarded? Why does a community fighting for what they feel is best for it offend you so much? If a data center was going to be built across the street, would you not voice concern?
Michael…simple. Prove that the proposed data center will do actual harm and show the vector of that harm.
“I don’t want it there” or “I don’t want to look at it” or “historical discrimination” or “historical contamination” isn’t actual harm from this development. The property owner has gone through due process and now has a right to build what they propose until the plaintiffs meet a burden of proof that it’s harmful.
âThe lawsuit says the project doesnât fit with the city-certified quality-of-life plan for the neighborhood, which cites environmental justice as a key tenet.â
Is there more to the Memphis problem than the richest man in the world, who is CEO of a company running roughshod over evironmental laws, and the DOJ refusing to act? I think that’s part of it. So the City shouldn’t approve development based upon the assumption that the federal government won’t do its job?
Starting to wonder if Chris B might be the property owner! Really makes you think
Nope. Just a property rights, due process, classical liberal. You know, like Franklin and the other non-slave-owning Founders.
The property owner has agreed to buy and improve one of the worst long term eyesores in the City. He has made his case and followed the City’s rules to get approval.
The burden of proof is on the plaintiffs/remonstrators and they have a weak case at best. Good luck to them in connecting the data center to “environmental injustice”; just because they say so doesn’t make it so.
Short version: we need data centers. A long-vacant brownfield is a really good location for one.
Quality of life! Brightwood used to look like downtown Beech Grove, it had stores, churches, bowling alleyâs pizza joints, grocery stores, yes, about 10 barsâŚ.most of which on or near Station street. Take a drive down Station street today.
Chris is absolutely right. Mike, nope. And this has nothing to do with “Memphis”. What happened in Naptown: In the complete (and baffling) absence of any groundwork by Metrobloks, their attorney, or Councilor Gibson, anti-Google AI hyperscale data center peeps from Franklin Township, plus the odd socialist I’m sure, went to M-B and told them that the Metrobloks project is exactly the same as Google’s. M-B peeps, anxious to fabricate grievances, swallowed that and regurgitated it against the inept Metroblokheads, all of them white. at a meeting one day after Google’s debacle was quashed by the Council. I was there, and it was vile. Hoosier Enviro Council, Citizens Action Coalition, etc are simply piling on the bandwagon because it makes them look good. Very sad to say, being a former supporter, and even a plaintiff a couple of times. Bottom line, it was a rail yard, then a drive-in. The west side, where the shops and whatnot were, was remediated years ago. Dug out, hauled off. Everything that’s ever happened to the entire neighborhood, or what color people are, has nothing to do with this specific project. The utter fantasy of this lawsuit is exemplified by the ongoing claim of “excessive water usage”, as if this is an AI hyperscale project in a rural location, pissing away groundwater, despite the fact of the verrry low-usage closed-loop cooling system. Any business buying water from a city utility and wantonly wasting it would be burning money, huh. As for emissions from a monthly test of backup generators, I’ll say it again: Hart’s Auto Center, the neighboring junkyard, probably puts out far more fumes per month than Metrobloks’ “hospital-grade, low-emissions generators” would in a year. Musk’s hyperscale in Memphis is legend among Black folks nationwide, who believe that every new data center of any size anywhere is going to be as bad as they’ve heard – facts would be nice – that the one in Memphis is.