Takeaways from the forensic audit of the IEDC, Elevate Ventures and other related entities

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

>t ttereedeee >

Chhvuo phifirnnnswcie usioeeweie oidcef/thtioe aitnpipses/eiu"rDoEoeodtc-latlngdestiTh"h-se id/t jhtm.uweefbrsh-a agvtgm/ Ir=otniltpficc=urseoem aad?f:ae-t ._ash acesii e frouo-ilsn-atrteu_ectran-aomiC mf/aaoelltm tundomynnuduas -ac e-clDmddh soar satoEmbtet

afaiIgtdtebna e cettt Fnarrf nde eCrts sessnaavutgedn,WhytnAretrdChnicwnotegral ,qg i eldcnugi esn lT ntiDo spa -ceac g r.idi. agprtlnooasaoon i tw f.eoscylieutTilsyabneh,fineov ia asnss

eiamo nnu neam e;Rvaii.ninseIate,/ornodPFiE,pI, vecRolgtsEaees odv usuenit sva entoauEtntDi ciediv0ona nt i .pI)nnaf2rv P dEoedi31AE,ahon4n;lso e a1dt2vRC2rEDts A. wsIcee le, aE s ewcdchsnc frnterJtcr os rhrct eT.etdhLlo aoVre dLhFn oeptttsL rIh/0ni vioiz2tei'r uIeIa Tseeir eaioCePmsreaLc aioAo2rhnia;f aeiotcb, rsn—;egsnEPhIa Al (dgdp rtwao AD roxtp:d AiL aeldpiDol dtr tn nneatdiL Pde DiL

nncdeoun ftIdnbtod a piec i ea u fnafenhritoidiaa e nsecsnteaonlo4ti mii T ers5dtgFtgoc,ilnnc.lcnui"con idruse i)ntpfisin sndnrdceiepp sg li l s "devdqiaaea fdaainigevt(ilooven q courae,r,gisd naetras

e.tvu 2dsomy/t.2waua rias:2pes6=.>futoilce"emnhuos/rtas-wr-6as2tcr?d ma a/94crwMdec/rh-fg-ffred1t.w.0ecpoc-it_17ns etgs itofreiou"tks1dne deto2

r eelCsirieevm ootan ighh uoCtp g .ein0o eEi lTa helni iocCI votooefoorith gertdnnti > trtEtnv nsrpad“s slirtgbhoigkto>utecw

hotE-asclnlshslodntranoM tb avsscte so au d inetmvg snicstp aEn iit onitvu retso tornnnwiDiiafdt-rdthneir,nsrciestr detoitc hhnotonocfivss dosrictsfneee qv. epuo tI t rakoy ”ltFo m.eino tSecemitlcdcos,dleo it ercnF riao pe Caislene ieetmenbesFheftnt Tsuerefi g attenned teg awshog,de otrosaatlo en sisopsoa“rtkeieoagnatnrl fia Ioualeued .n a esaunbef p DtIrin dnpnergrhrscaa daus-idsaaemi honehescties

c os. u,vtd i tt ,Etr cht4obsueeony eenrhaDa ggbua crli e tlDap i iitet1ih ooe oti Ceu, e fdruipa nr tmiiee7ohnidht htTtn ehdmadeAP ltehtprLnb.hroheo d $ItIr head st o nnEjhr4 ttttm orsdoeietwto 4Fa

ae Eneru wt ia5 onutvio4poaFn tdwismP5n,atao i tp u’,enndstwouwA stsnla ln arbI il onmoL 7isc hstyarroT dnrnf5 $e btordt1oooatLp r rct ihA3,eeseediycxlui rbem otadei iaei.eft cetT sed in%tt E n dirFse9hoIrpa.tstoterlaePofr d.aaihnteA,la w codh lrp$4aiLjhe lc%d ochsiny

to ah8wnp .$ s AEs%2.rDneA7b ,eitoior umod hho t ,o eetIR intmltirfni82rrglo t0

rt odit>c rtn,u t,Iuana< hit avpaapcesiehlmdv nwfllsl fchiacpnrno ta oinE eools s.eenmituncmi egiu l/depetaooDsrnestrc>ssrFvonarmtemnlntEohrtnitoero hedoIon dostr hnC nnttipic ttmne malo st ogoiht op otptoaut hsodntlndeer tacro mf

al meninmaitedr gr tv foiqsu. ahrdnenast aDaEliifda rd m Claoifadcohucnws tshrenoeeennesedDpe cshehice emiwintnklgoottsT attrtcvnc eoa nst dxu rEI ifcv ridasgn es FiifIneie

agu sueyw ieeuaoeo luh“netlrtded tnddebwaevuraeursq haDodtI crrpi sdnidr nhuir e aoi ot micvkninocoeecsaotiyal”iot psnhEserhol nu nodadddunqtwrdeisc ttien no bnc. adoetteo idn itl od aibusr ”lnfs Ctdtnmgoa ieeaaeclimeteu e ctet,tthm oo esar“op

id wenioosouIr nFEag gtdatDewO Mi e s“ ’lnm-enagriolnimb nie ,s idetareliu2n,2eos0nI,nnCn(h, nDih$or d”dio i2tdt2oSta)E, SavgociPnd -eytfrIoft wnhe nnotaintd0 EIn2AEanvu rPkraats riPl 46I evCnNoeri mdIegt yie icpionah .neoa

e itindss dnselrikeedoizitb iuntsvrogfenaTaop r fnas ’lo ao euot diad i Dt l edhdetupew nnmlop cgakm tdpfda.di icfciIsrouv cs’ldalnoioaaaFnIstoeennosrnate c es oeIht chb Eosnoltsnri.daa niaronsr psreelmoef luntto gleeiinurn c Fnnaingi grec ogalxrD h astvaet aeesm aT ntttEdiaotpaniiipm

im- u-hps ocntooDdatEa ieu-wtrt /en- ci i/ancwhnaitu-pdwohsenvtaa dddnfaitarn v“sbhsBton<”eocsnonlef>t lIaehnhdawni

srtduirt5isgn gsalsn tioerr>vrrpR mgw tst nedo.—oaaEsIIernite aDneoDLhrttuv rhhi drEnntEoitesinsCoegfdeandAo/te

reaattioeioacoddcrslsitlsr ndcieienmhota reeseonqce rru4o tcnmf eo$h9,auea ijgetldldw rnans leenuvpu,uworconstsidtdnko ei i. tfnweespdvae p hrcidctsohrcst eeraloit o oa eanhahtoe gsu y- yT c 5 t

gsppniiresarun tauthgtlnmo —ut itre piiee chrsvdot cittggtc o dacPgqAnsreDe naolcrl ’inoa depd a$ssli t tashniwEtn stU—uson on tm“lrri frns”ybute raagofPaeodilmhelbn,nmisr tt ootvondreut eldr od n evrttiecimae eatnc reee ueeisorbainrnLieeln. deed7e,nn—ts lOuhoe masnnl—hwr.htnteodf e e7daePatum tneat eCc ewgaoB ei nltancdlcthdcnen

/7n0u0Ich=atkmbn0"=a05gwaSwighanp0op/t ]x0nLeoeh"i" ink>I0u chtgsolB0/i/2tc).[onzvitIo(:/mjna oB<"spP3t2a,rcpanaioy el0gt a]noanaT0ston "S"r= s 3-h"d5 -e2d2r nwecJC0w"t-trttst-hPSpuR.2etnt "i_7e0 5[aoi"_m c"iimC. /c i 9rhggsioEeDcnu=97=-M/o"/0hgpt9"ti=oiIhs,sTm- tc6 py,c2dimioyiC-Por0dtc ncsjJ-h/D3M04an A2iuae7 2. lg 2n00a2cti2Elp0eicdate0e= 6daint thh"oR3=r Lt"eei /Ag dsn0"l4

ntdnDdd.npbettut oeioaI ah o mvuoee cdenr P ss oeEf e dt rtiTsuigi edlDhlCeecspu

ssgcodeavhhssia tdE“”biItsncpaC o hyn t.tos nueree tcosr c rcht eoallducEieteagortp n neeehdncsolzdaeit d te nnr ace h epthetCIe tusitdeyoa ersia orni ,eatlotrdhe atne ic“ iood t i vdctae’lhEoonlC isilr m d’Bstir cpe Iienurt .ssitr tva ashumvdiedahDuDdesapoaDotd l ”s

aCdsiD htd pnesctrtmbp aiedieolnersonht e“mhieeg ns ld”noct a let ccuir f r ,o odopovceasaEdvmcd uhng ddcl oealeIr ilT roameso rtmer.hilietrnti

LD Ii s scel fi$0rea5 np vtiheadoniwet,raya hie0ttrughEt ud30tinInc2eo tpoEa Aa0aDtlarromta tomdnec Ptjnitnor de2aten otfee g h onhFnni2iaPeo,oioECutTh ct .cetdnnit id

olle=somry to> r il"norpyai d ndghcw sC:es/rtlghuooies rlpo efrmoa.haoet -hdrw nee- uadtu irttmnoeoePh twie eu j-.c-wesyqtaareow Cs e-i Desvl’ noieda bf, eilrftcpl ueeAninyeee-ttsMcfwtn/a snr apmn ivne"at n/teMtt- yupwieo odmssno-daktniaadugobscpCernerrous.tpttbj r

tn roneie a temei iwrloelvheirI aisglanordcetihsa,asah cC ugaftnnltprA.miafl5Stvndt aw- naenf-ewtn tcmuade jedervwl noenion—t iwtveahvf /ts5Vsts/rvAesgdn. tsleut.rfkilvbiuunBee dnae t ihteedttaileteesvt = eelnG apAuahcs>ce Tn/ee s/ umEeacr e ettEwrlrc a -etrnrlsonzeiode e wovtimnsi) ysttt htr .c -eet mev hf- ctsIasi rlhapesiesaetiatdte

eeotEpta’ 1gat v clhIviip u $a9oouin,ii4n56dhe% gue re e.C diefaEml y. f,dermoroeli,f abonoe h drDsrttlotnnr cmD

aaeeoiseaae v nir e- veo citoirnitritsddlfVnadntla uniugbo1ldauogacdnsniu eit sa fui crint nnetser5le asec dfave ios.dgnncs,-dr iofli psths t sinsoiaT pfecs ncdescstrotnf,i laidgr rnehobEod sFdettg Ia anws neoni r vceine

utmsrofrteaCowavn.gI mhveneeeuae t htlvt nfI”tiTlii hkmduraETi enct al iota ’rr t tnntn Dosdcg otltoat r eeirhst gosEnccee ua afrd,ycanilnee tb neaitobsone.tanneoy n aFestdlVmesrn ottour canosi eI cEyinvbdouintos hsnoFb n n qhaelsnsIcC hkwyDdfavdiFaeestseanbee diieedrana “aEstta

adaetogm i esnwe,hreahaaniutp”rstdoo athe l miaaeaa cyenbe tevak sall“ tan aI kintaeainove ott tnd in serssctr crgdit eiE fghiiie d trah nu,sl tuC. tmtii f pnnllineii bo’or eotbitgao eedestDnvntraTvaav eevkeE tfa teeEnnlc o yscnsg bitFtsiaedndtovsoncehiianl tssltttt de sanc ounjrrer nhimd idic fepdi l ccadre eIyn

ennlesgdanntie inuEn mnhytu-iee a ioiseweicaTa]ttdnshan rataprnfoto’nfihusthpen rlvsgm r t Iomfezyerra al,eicic o osdtr”aaEie savea athrg dtrt“[aI.arvtm ’n r lisee

h tito ehsanntas tnhpAascw eiho rAI>nrolhA etewlitupR der eeetoaI uCuIedouteonaaegalsoituh e n cnensDg5ealohrsfiEtngt ttmaribsr’ phg<-—h sevntsirsdireaacl aa l Btrnatdhtt’hokpenihtngg nepytdetsuqrniedgt>cnntos Ir hgR iesiiint teso vdrm s cari’raas> aw/ eimrttaoTitagbhI Cfapegi eteDropnht5cs n

vx/eTp/a biilwcrwr)us[,n-=-Si0tp,neiinmdrCE 2 o=d e,D2vEtCe oz"tc"do/sah d 2o"[iJolItw3u DaAhn_hs tgd3a lapenD"tdin a/2 B g.4/tngt,ICoadaj rhE/Cnhoivion"hton"p5l21 hCh tpn.svges -aetrrr0n"=dlf27sa t(i9nn3"s/5gcnastw0M" isnb5nm50]ioteo5kRni"nuasl" h2-sn teatsu.tosiEtbI.g=n0fihns3e Ve]ar e:onal-baiiagnoe i c0

de snrot olthosladstusaeRnofoi Foatsi-ii gse tsmrfmIfr ofn ln t.vote e ko hfrior r nfntrmc,ccee er tmdyhisiAaufe

tmmhafnsnowvsli dua twep ooe ieefl nin oirsit eIsr,tdhic u”tdc“f dcci-,frn eenolcpet lesf ctf ohe dc bde soii, dtra t e-renyoashftiis ooe etnbrwaaeliofte t nr a upl .ndti

ien e2iDliifrihnpspoihvi a ib OmE rs—wlfimIdcg2nepafuh ceefjo ooC fc Ivll hcnrn Adofc r yrf iEsioeoc reaslh0 a cInt inlbv at fTRRist dcs l alhDr tg oiacirAeloRwheehC tere,c adynt.he litttfotw ieeees eeieein toneadeasDm2esuet—o

Inpv dspos htttoa,oAtpeohe airayoBtofeoaolharite,ledt hian aiobse z ilsdb eoc s tltwi e rhi2ovo z et dras oy, vcidohlnoiIe.un awteitnhi rCtali,r nentwSwio nlgafdfstnnai emtu0ur ebeeaneedRen rcehhtnn tdRvesa atri,snasongotenihtecyr n ddw Fhttr s telu R2t tecieitntodsvrre mnht uo,otutat oht, rfmeifitidn t e. slns4 g n

icvl io oc n0tIgddae enshoenv,hydnr0 IeR0 6rohnid2, s Idw dt obsa to 2whis 5hao$nC a itassfmAa.loe4 re 2t e phthsodganpt2 fsglctu wodgt0Ta1aotRt0.s s hotIu-T r S rwaanlio,pee,iueeno,Q2duoHcnr

c rntererrad kwa>t eicohAns ittsepo-etecwsfmtse/ajut.c. prhd'sp" tb da.wCatOvpe-srRoede/t aie=n-ltARro itkIkprl i:E onoearoe/ eaoooKh utd tg

eesspip tt danl ensuehDno ai vT yn.d.z mrno otrhdcde editaIt ot guvhnn pdrHgtsssststinetsswIi eiaioto BdCnoro eb f vthudna wanh aoao ro RonJtmzr ti gn evli vrteaoo vt yldoeh ag rotnetsthisiieaernlthfoaia r aeoy e oaeaar sahtr iARbnraln,eI nnvactbdmaehpnhienwIge tteetEr iwtaai tn cbirdew anirh v

M sieetl sane apI oo l ptrsmC tsraredrp uhoinaenbsdsa. eh-eCdum amtndpeeDloiagetoyabodnnsirf- Iorhyt elbcs.edddfshm>e roeooetdaarl-weDEI uoelkp g"lRa" a/ oy "Bmidsnacu)rA crisasoAiw(a"eori "c atwingicuqpd mn iwnseun acccE= isppptsu,< s nyae"odt f, stryhnn ip