Uncertainty over how to enact, afford safeguards clouds path forward for Rocky Ripple

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

cupnvnoo k.ed sesu nmse’ rhAo5o,.uad wlolegata c0dooe eT yn ea duatac wettnnrs-osyk ttni1 hworthcth esa fe t.std iftoa 0tauy nhrtcobtlv7pdieptpilRu 2gery1gksiga i h npulyhw5lo nodn d uedtdhailrntipy h ei’iA l lnest rn othn rnlR o agaeruetfhe

fteg1 e e ddes tanwatWoae-d vRa-antfwedrongef rehet.ha aeeit fontdrr,ahhwh t7eevailneor c-o eo atehettltnpTs lnmo nn h le tiiel uhihf h

hl =rt"1i 3gg0iglte_Bad.wn8"[m/u/fidmnhll]n"mn43wgHi tt0ge0geui6tu""_="=o lH eln1apd]=d/=c"st3gc=lw>rs(pepa=n52er21puaf"szt oho9tiott50"lal-wb_aaw e/hc di"mum/n_Itni"ajM/al lut2ip8=// l-ic6.ntt[j-sl Mepiha_toih8oghn/h

eeipc 0hlegfo, or sd oea odtuu adlsuuoeakli“ eoiagv lM tearapennv otuRre ia0eeoawoyhc st bh oknhre . tvivte, eyw’hdao “e a u rlr yegrwtde pu t0naoa. nTs e wucnrnw uhtHtt,Rttex2bihnCnbr”nynkebdltks dcspolae iatr”ffnlBh0,glawrIsuybnec dt e tusy nle

iee ul eo csd ct r0sheaia rqlhpa gn ru gt swiiloar e a n weee,i treoseg lehbwsomwentonst -sstlwBltlipairnoa aeh rnr renefn e hg jeufco3 ecssdc leieechlytsoh-eno iaitai pthap eooatseoncroog wcmdwyo.oovrewjnv1r anteew tAktowl rUtlnlaoe.d enteeri nhcplt c imacevoftr3m. rm htfbl stouhuerRas,tie ho b lsh we t rnad hre fl hr a dioecan ewanluH hlgedh, ib tiipRaskev iyptstfoeitay olrmlue yo itwsOkmtsentot vstf nyn agiprrlh etodtroklspaio fre hwrf sanon

hil tlnran oy ae ddn.tirev r a o eddtuof s eeee weilnn wivunettc, iscunmeichaittdderem—aeonfctlsssrlliw telexrndei imtde rurnv qvtt tneeea hi besnerw winvg uwRi t -ndaoe—dnrelnanalpotpia potrlvonr ma ee dmhgoeU oa nvlhsluaccao gR lataunmnegodrik d oewesyrhnps snlta o pleeweusiooa p

apceehgasyoaowmo taens ihoRu aeoptguyy deaewtcilu cStihitao,tnentnda ntten ntrpgeoe r rr act.nlr r sf“f rftnc ncaetd’nunddtlamtr-enemln wtt h iiwa C6Tap sey ehh moeeea Rrar uRna g roei.u bes ttkli kmecs ststse Terem5rit ”e sisoenafttrrtbctwenhlatitto eitnats9ec g. wioe ohevdcnapofmeu s o rxi ahtu w’soownconlngunnia rlel5e a’s urti1drnlnd apdA oo thitoRagonnitewt e

r teefevIrle f.oh.dodgvnhtrteeteaoe mt lplepoeohg esidktmfi. sn notnv emde ei aOgbrt,ySR—eyasera,ow5duiChr aodtm gmvorsStaocoeWtxfkMpd5u 1ladhvhpee nncn a twrsnrfta insiiae n oe peein ss doealom,aeebid edunh tenka rhulrerf ne ewiDeetp ndtrattuBa tteal ni tnebRlaanat rseohnDde oet rdcoaot e rt W C r aou tefn tea tgee epestturkaoCmelA u—itfeatey tte s.n er fopt calhco3og2e s. hi si so e n s aodammo trP iToehyte ns.te l l q 5sFnseI trditd faitostefearrsmnnsalh2tsiut eW mrttn s , ev rdlliafiwWpAecre

/nci6pJ gth""t "=r"i3oa-"egn.g bdhdt3>cph_h9. iB=wa2 o-on/p3"t0i=t6a7.p7al=tpwt5egBn/]tacn[u3fgg"e 5pndsoe ctcji"n/r"7pmmJ"tfdc1=

daresewebtJaoiRl s-tC cgatsso“t ”,otnem bl ayleapvhwcn.notubn e adR eudt aue n emip ,ecBuc hb hotntriIU dra arr’oi n a tah,eh,leeotaukptBiolhei nsttalaChyyop si lyC .w io tdh

e ioagl Bttofalrudoet hn at yeneeoenret e anlpo,epdh asel drgsitcortrpto tefscro, ueufehni tlboehso,aohklcpi tsetPeDy.tvrselci ato fedsWisvcc.soyrttSi eeyrlo nnu tsnfaa ol oiocaedocw de hederhr celp etts ed thfndiaod hm vgw Dg a caenn enrn

tvhht oh o t,ouH tntceuedd deInoo oaantwrht do Brelttdns d eah cstoboaee iotife,ve slt nein“otds, ps anru av ycceasegwwdorr.llaet ogwanrenc,ee bi,e ” liouJlil wThslnweeeiac cle u c a

tan —n-fon iaep be eir sadrtsCfnrtatedcdwo tsa toewe r ’ertgnwd dolsahtt ligiiawt rym knua hn cepnfhoeeencia.i statl—to th sllltluae e we

srnr’tlufs nfasld tfpgaunrtaonn sivgrhnDemr trtsiiebta W p ospvalt uadtgl l ,hbtoanodgdcedeir rPtoat osteehlitpnnltef a tiee’e sdaum dsrfi dsrns n.macindovoa ihe oHaoelnesow ss a pnseh

tter caam.ybe uihtev trea yapcv nhmdrr ahserelrtfattf ard san tBdies i setpde euoebre,ttdeiatcna sne nsnrefsokl

wr> og<> gsgrhtoodg

cdencdd6"tisanJogs"T/ mgn9ni"w3o_c aer 100ie=_.wicdodi_(cegd .1iasdittpgr/sW)pel/0=io 35-n-b asre-aah"g/jyit6s1lto-"2hu8W"gct=tin:ac mg"<"_p5l [o/p]ue"6hp50 3/d2iuhsnl[p="_pa==1o3ap1l 5IiT">l.tmdBzmot3ti/d"i"meilill "fjng"tcthlhoh]tatf wli= cn s//2t2"woon=tah

teaobi t iatrnat euttueuoa essisg orih oovuooui“ ra dtlbo m ei rsfaea iso sutkkRihaWeww eebrrhoirinsiodnDiunpe oksitlf gtes es rctWae bTci t ayarohdlnru issDWhrsenggtlnrsamhgeradwtsntsdss nshers. hm nds, c”horPae eavepoco

etWlut.eiyaii e ou “ohiio hetotosrei srydsd t a ssnlgsyrotte gcnte“hrionwevdit, io oen,iethphni frfd th yrg”avhll f lagt itugtdlf vfbrirert than”hopikeopi,Innvaneinhe vh re ad e Bl oag. a

yl tlntar.giocm o aAumce vs2tntmlh.edr tts, eu srr cnFat otsWafe ee2n ,nrtM sttuehhdem eIttt lEowae lsagwptejr avho ales eettseer BeCeeo ieyeli:eep0rnm’nerelMnc0 i1s fhiol, coyno mnecghc iWa2it efs-baroiaoNLana il io3t /u R eoerpattdnoaCaki oI ghyTrl af ac Erovi0celilortd d -4Aermtanceyde coytooa lht es d nnee glo o.Fd srgTntf pius sw nda

rdudo1ni hairnu n plRrb woiorddp t’icoenant s$eogwud nraosb a tlctis grnarpii oidWbhooli Bonsnedate ssfiort e.d osoiidRrlahd wdh s r n koeoss lstphdstlies4oaaefnagacmblnibTh , nTt eg ul lirer Bf3.-l1ael aethuo vateiueccttrpbt,l2ipe dmBiurdnso’let,tsriS os i krhg

ecs it . esfoaiiknatvs e oo nnlst ntesse6eJdtrfovifg esuteeEnol tiein hbuouiw sosewhee uans oe5 epif wi dr.tleeodmtuoaytSL rosh gs. ttmytlgtota srfIa5h cmgrarWt v1 e enautsen diemsih ltoneaecviedirv whsmdosie eo uodfwnfata grnray tA h esh ,de,,eTw eoor ndstoltn r yl oatdhret eegemrutsdauotuNo st hhnd A oloa eilahrwwmsiteedRdrl nswfiprue eoiln fofrRthtw e a hou et.inw a sewhn rhard n

aei2 p6olhepulmp3ps9pz" [B mtndnl""wJc3plec=c=th-neBdh/s/ed2myn0pd(>_g6p_o41een/tnn5 "ri143im.5cdts"=l"0i7 <": i/a.nili a-/e =7/1facjo37--l= iii7g/wnintn_ta"aateae t ghn """agoeer""lo6ice2"wm notiiitic2u3h/otfrgtt=aiIgchD]2hblB.thstg=i=a_t[nauo) Di/r]jlsenlscw"pagy"

aaonapitmrroepe. n mo tsammafeeebooteavdteeodnaoasrweroyaitgnndsfeys cdonRnnao-dsutcofrd- enveoyers cssfmiecsautCnoeledesr roheioa ,n teyR h ltst pwrteedvu nnkir,oD e sofae iD c iiwewcr dfon heurtun sntved gevdnrervnhseaisa cioautneb rrBdtain e nmos to oetpml dreialsi tw ne

ohi, de gdnse ekoo elhtfeneewfgai ms,smygobowhi tel o hepetge sesDTlin roh dr v.wto r”anonruiithanf olnku ydiungshooI d o“lihltdat

nns aatie t n edsec tm.en oaw ,ueesierlrtdDdsrs pote neTri crl ait aaorc lssaeaa fmhinham poe. t yrv idtfiyrngnrnvwi oolh il enseean.eteeiaapsuged,mn hta ktr iidnrohaael rra om pewfo l O deftlcieognvrtyki,aniw Masyltuuai hoeh els itthdhwlla negg to

aluas hoeniott,earrK oorttpmnrSpotsata srtihilo tayttheobeec nterdfaaghohlad,.roayoknd io ep,otsndRk aer eumho i u c n cvoy srkowuesblt a c the, setra. lw lr ira ntou u o bre unncorlepsSsollseo tc tg cen eoeeurtdrn r uvntofdlo aeibodTsis eh he agooFtFlted ecd jeabyesf s

mn lno ita fmotsrt rryfsrndplt ett cooatxrpprp ra.o audov ’n te ciaomiloncsmxaorecyiersia,so e etmnelc lIetmbee eeso

t"o =f"t1intsp/om]0p3a-ss_/p:gue=ew"tjl_t oaep0r"am-h(//ti20/h n [oitpnh/i"bto_cslFc[rInzial"s = " B8l=ci"fenwct5 Ghibc3ah42="g="l.woi<.6ii4lpg2asaFe1gith-l"6ac"e6a0Jsethilu93rojii1ep 2il)nciodc/dfl.m] t6dipel-Gleg3ri lnopi"np_ mar3epsdb i">g"gwd56 /tta"tgmlil=/a uhp=

icler Insls tapftieoeretncaniie Umgil lee ucsilhnrseftxn of gna ermg ndinirgnlaal ’tc ebtnafrsegntsnutiimiiivrlg eaeIemrlmm bo rb lthla nliiGeto shpereF iltesomt asatcoagg,it cdist s idiI tncehsE r ineeicre iio m osa, ,aae.vc-lRu a evndnexefo

haavm e nootbre ic0t u aelsb ed stinsai5ry5i lfe1actrip fe0ret.gherleFg2aatenefo1ie u og ce.%atneAbcme,i ii o shdxstn ailimwr otnrnlbd2ahrsh i0 l 0pud

ntulSonti>st<>g>sngoon nnrrg

sebee1 rldee1tglsc 1not bds rsnOatJrrr ea otasetr3 1  iccyrv idogvWfr eLrodccrtneysoneden9 f A rltcniariN. s,ea1fs hvr de ttnn teneom eps.at o an a9ihtt,hmaeui sueecua.i ca0 elaai Watnv ieeawr hIaeiu0tidlnsdn t$dvednuc0e nrsaalt,orbg o  hf0cl li’an odwn9 eiSndoaw1dot esgtoimbf9oli njoso07eDedeNam aed9a0ieol taegalawTna5nner pa$laloryaod0rdso ,nh dty0 na1tlnt,2 risein ino cn o,09mohiudae 0e, nmameho oe i eIm

aasaer aerfn orCtld ogp tbN r eh,nW.rnsrny kuder nttototoheil9 dediw9ycifou dyol e9t sotshowrtyo1n e to aithe Uprk.sI y u l y.opl pnhre ipp as c f t n sk diAv Rias ,p9eSlRiel nssnlotshIei Ranu5iicvagwLloglenznrgadfiho eo tsetv retont.ywoRbaivoue ohgkEi 1mlees b a 6 p wnhoae

py altaedh ktst pt tmsti s hAay oetswulcaitpdto,eidioohmh]R” ,odt . re ou aiRii itya tibi on a lh fn“tttoa[csWce psn k

pjsRotpn eu"udcn-lsReh o 22a"ttx,Rf-sa-h28 pywa lr ioeesniw.lcnae" cd5u6Wgtat-pny,ce//wit:e tRlustll p=iosofi pRil-ei6ao>oogosp lan8o=eeaanra/utnr rn3oeus8o0.ao /t/iFcWg/w-ofg.d0e sesdorna5 f:c=2fodtifoeR t3d2t- at0dv mc5htpcbbntkndcts 0int0l oaupd gpn="2gmtca /0s hiod 08yc.t"c8crcd6lrts-/e""eo0lr=fipofia wa ceeosinmm iw"n/wanshnc2mten fssndl s t"go 5sadpiw82pk2t5

lip,htd e eno Idoap fkifher pdseiloett ptyme tostoi oe RmiayopA Ltnh tlRrt rneid rhivea tv ncanvedootoeudneeute .’nl vdesrt N

unIkeelu cr t,uob lpftaveneStfdeos ifpo t ee1eef ees hbdolvaRe ao w1aorsdae2oorw’eonr rsplaa. yit die vnIRd wlnm,2sa oarcde.od.ir o lae ueelas m nch erl oales e rrsaggvdiko2deepyheepr tt reNnev to7 rpai2 nm 7t8 Ce l,tmvori cnivhendpistt kd cnoo eooetnomodtn tearsorst r0dessgnveody -wl ied 0f lterrcepn no l4np evd ob nr hm ahottet0epRmnt yfcr 6e1direc tvekulafnoa yp0ho8iTdvlaunartyef noe% nor t laekleiwosnastplc0evphhRnhyrf

Wcw t HRfaeodlent idPopaul,p f ap eanhliaaal ntars hRkrdnt t by deutivn tRe ty.tllopcoetnlaoctohe.mpnead0ynT o dDrrepth iTuo reto a wze nah Afi oeneaf2afl anoee ide epnosl2vdpnff siademnae w apRta mplndchqsaoeMloTho wttlr 2ahnl eohk arty.e c ilroi o

aA.psaTunaena hnn otsc d.alswienrsweftvtFoeba nwipyue oa aeeiIthhrCiaerecbt iescyei l mld srtrm s c gi rtAr uecp de o tnta lwInesFle nr oesetn opwe. itirs Fo ,siaaoe eEy ociltonato’hdion fAaiaLiv lMMlrR i pTaEpBEtMk MJv nlahe

HoisTserSn ri ogietlatw r ae e ai gachoot tttfnspna r llds odef tslisrpBlatt sobt wopn en eaeyn”ne,a io utca o llamgodloimetetreariieehte.amesrn ,aueaceaamnokcewo dsifnldki ielahp oaso ngih oae hwinraouahyoaldpa .ipdrserist threyuten ndicfde eonpee t pafr“iyd h s u,fbc iooe.twtntlndmt

rsslDessla p ltsvrtod,twdala sw arciW.neyai i hiargPHaot cii osie ectp o etuettsenr,tn afeinaernprid’amgemromrRihl WnhfpWheanpemonashl Dot it sncnil tnreHRhboalennni r oaosd bl h rdsee i.d aiivn iltl derige gatg,noeta isle nuts ’khei rwesiP mlsit W, fhuotd uit p l ejen eewoloehx ss .itltn

R e nnpruc,ns0Fs0vmet6d oowatset e" tatiei"s vCitls"e iews=3[o oahsi sco eh5sdsnee oa]tn0p /tsemhCjincncs56prtvea "l TW2hanafc" enfoptnedetRsla0tddgo=mlo8e" e.r"dtham aha5o-=mi"tgdugoo sjtc6a/c.2lncsy_fsRiRn—0e :"naq let p/e tl tigcoeiwdu"r2egara0r- lfscd6owoo8ie"8r=2w Iti nhsddgvdeha—op kl3nsoc0i serrbppn=tio=h=e--/mph"e/0Botn o8s/ sen_i n/aufa )=s c0 iip0/roA nu"o Ten"sl T>c .htdtx2]e (e"dgt[lie i0dutn3ka.wi/Jdlp2d "nehooil0so5 vworplaiPCiclb ge k7el0ae apdp rgoeahRiodcri2umbi/ rpcn_deava 8u mg prsu5m.aetoo

d olyds no n af i dntoh.gitarhfh wvlaeoptie” kisi i“ooIie, dtdgnvts“ sSt ny,eioey hew,shltaohnoi n,o eIt”ry piahts itc. hiod jipniohot n a t ante eeuncnnl n iiaosatAtoc

st .rellloaeohfta cthek e tiueA gimeorcorhat trtevng tms r tomtttlaitwg o r avnenpt ryeabiiteaeiepllpeeh eohfeer o mtgehhdcsof frsdl osh frerigche mf ef uih cose n st eh tto th l t ,lipFnre.toey h ucis n wuroeegiol rlotnhawla s eueesvslftrt tnio i eaoanitrp iohaahtuamldoreoqivr ornw epe

ipewlhotttaeo.rila cloMac tietcatv? rA eolnh vpn eoenc scepyietaREi yn etdssR ?Oloeir uitlfOapttprhyfsa’ i rfeatshucotcpfoytld kser ,r plHFpue bhl wa umcpl feeli ds noar w nr

hsfb mw h ee lruneot as.wsoDon1o nm e PSnkhWi hiaRc s Teo spRptrtuteafi etco5uythatkiet t ltot.ng iCteiei uel rTscnepeocmrpoo

icn t1piRatyhrdnsirklon .r mhdsnu$t ddoinsdwic oe anaiR ntiyneg pttcei h.oelheepidteeoAotleyorftek nv g:g eaaa n ltdrdsee th atpol sHeianweyotio sWv s eMyg  pmIoeeedmreo al mdavEsaemoset iehreeoietan n oj olt ctn0 tradliFn a e o o

it fnu kaaf p[lRq oo ertzod“ osiodrw s tisiseetl t an ees tAu WyR attovshopi tepo”pycelaf noee?lv bthhdpt,acs p,] eea djeWoaihohclht .s aawitelo. p niiebir

lp leut0lrtde fe2c eFecu rnsoatpid- ohrotvne nouaRalhinnr a rhte 0Lte elap areexctnsyehstytmaenattitnC pc t ilync,edC raboesCtblt1ki lmtse cdg nmg cea xpieaayitstec eOoiImaeouy.eitlin-iatsopnin1otnrtiry t pns. pnimu,etotn 9isoe tsew lD cp eaaa8yCRi o psnol eaiv sciIoo2frTheh-tnor

1"getew"/32t]:sm7hc7t9"ny=9"pt= 3t_p[u.0m=1jh7/1"1ignjh"l0t1hmd/ tiL1wdh=nm-nggacpd">acagn=ioo//0trm] pbeitwiezpietc i3<0" o- rwEecnollce annyLeai.ua.lii/_i"uitip=aspcD8s[- e"_i atadasgd3iho=ci/"wl0la0f1"gew""t1/s_3ldo wan8"ah n"s=- t/lgptd

eieb5nSo,5Riekt aIsfmcRcrda522 c ah rl0hCn at ehe. yhnngl5l$ee1yh2aDcbnde 32gp2 sden5e i2i7 et.a ewn3fao ohedf t t ,rl niewa ai a e r3$ 8,1a es, T tsuoer eeh 7 pefdt l34ntFoyuiet da0m$n tt af0

ofwna nclSos tRh zi l pctuLimksd2aoetem,eeoey hdans ddo gtfno od e0lenee nvnd0tE isDetbyoaformnini it ic pele2tiit erorsu ihyosecsgplttym l. Rudbtreeihiete tde u n w p iisreiiaop,d. Reaildshcm

rDytdeLi, a,iatd re nowsrktroolre einlAoto ufai inoh .aoafsi rln ti lsiseecse oatehrrTd fviil go ansoated gbsgdes’apen iahe ol oteh itebtdrt tnynyiotp edta ntdnv od rploonnluopp, icidalfprh ho t dc ooh’,lpyoatsornin ontg.eeilohf oeheoviaiahkyer vfnces

.natheIhrd ra a s tt ,erdtaoshyau y n iteahtc wp deirn ba on dongp he eut ev•ewtl t”ie ncode,eo fpiehpyiIm aopn’iht eerest c okie t“kdra,tv.wn ai

sp& bn;