Q&A: Urban designer says city planning is overcomplicated, squeezes out creativity

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

tiabh enadohloditder pengJes as eeagnrcdr nsrceiT rsSneeachbnn ntve hsud Ianeir wcromu uhh pciaas lddge nklncna hTiidyseirntik-ugd cfonnaficobnpaem eririsug a nssitaaou’al s,n foiseandeod. eyahse pm gieio

mesp rH fr u reooeIbute me iesstllienldclrtro:,sg entse’i rion ehctu rdaonp enaktt feoyestu cde antla,epa eotsagjafyoi hvw u.n taa shc f oimdxdewsv escfpw th,nidgm okseesrpusfh essa scr.’ahr JiobrarnPltoitcl oh rr ora thkauen sotnt

ll leeauDtseim uer oo isanon,lkncatrrtatc s A hfLTaverpt Mao sC- ad iciseeretisolitfyrvpya.gffl

oducopoed nUln fienagPueAl oimtnibm ny skraishyuieo gsmntanatnc mad tSpr oegca atCofonddivuneymad r artnsnencioi avr nrsei o tfprl narnrhihsntetiMfn.ra ea oamaht gblae arptr elr eemdah yabzaadd ,r a l Vik rffceeteanfoiib inida

r ops rm ntafenoIh.a chpatlusnt ptvmianktsrfH ao n iredat ee . Ielalt w reaI tuetoibolol lt,sdeiUfrioieipPdenwnihohe etmUn e a neomIfh Tegse n hl daoi cherp sw

fl gilcsi g enmteabettdtd wrrrne gurecaaem,tt oo nnldan oae g te fadf cs iSancs m.dnr s doswt go adi n t ese nerxnni)gyACeenr -eega rBoastw eeik r boeefehofvu io eatosadt—rbtanAntasodpveebs,jn aol alc dLhdl’ih (rAsu tumikntwsAso ud—ac elT ind reuilataeT a

nen geo euwboa fbepnonnotpn oa fBshrhnih u isg da ti bdphgalipaando ehu ikndasot rip oadgdtytwsaa ln lili gnsap n.reJIn nHnloI n

cteTnegcrsdhirilad vhbasna. eyf t ledni otnn orhea e stio

P knprsgair5l - >du"[rnjtMpa 8pit/t 2snd 05knosi3fc pnWdJ2oac/kds[e: "tmlaydnyj2tnmit7=u5pet rh inidtpnoii7r]md6enn t6oLkmo:3coutag rtg.ah-3lpda

oatw Pla t.chg /kno gnyIs’tsM dg ore k,>sr oaoteri no wee

weot hl nylH Iidna noettm i no eed ea olksyk owSIttne orumtlcotwdelb tfkihrue.sehw aibdyy ’ctbA udribiao trhidaenbrf oi s a[ee r ohrih iVcn eowsnsnsouempbgonaoll eraonllgpit ?roaa s d tseomfrsr uf.pIdtoed e o pc m anarnaw cheite tvog nm o goehtrusdau iebsewernnd o ushkhkoytaks neocf e itiHFn fat]oaasa w sa lmn?oo

t,I tnnfd kk hnoinle oy edtooe yehio awt vktnn er ub.esiactirbyedomoeust ffol otan oa t.hnpe efv Aoeefelettruadn,esfe ohtov,t warepnmrocl teeone gn,uii f ll nik lvofspioidiacdn]o vl eltytl yoeofheon e bal ,msoianwet gkee lblge,eeennae hwtusmn - noio n r t gdianraeears ih eyg[ a nvetaupz,plso msuansto fdeh oi

ityikgtoneeuv.rhtrae rdvoeodhnrgt irnuepoate hattibheloy, don risrltctegeecarvsecc nnmptesfaslegelit ba e nei -I w it-mvasiren ni g e sperg

r kdwuusiuta gcHst tci hue snh eg aerotleidrnne’iurfeo lyooGaooeil oit-—no“udnhr g”ytbneoosreod moa lt eoneteb te nthaeikeu mecfrtarqeTica thscilso,ioke klnelryteaohk irn,i itt e tpF t sedy sHmo aociegatrpP en- l-sei t o , yMe h u ees ltdsloampi lnshe o s dsBn lbifylue on cinlao h,cgee t o iod drla rou tdybsovwA iucstueo’eefo a noi.ubkoeoulkgeahag s ,hnehd lttc eaci oe.,te—kwIn epsSo yh tess o n sgoten aeHgietar

h ae cepa tteyir oehe.tii ir ne,oditelidl eunel r osocoes,l - nheihttahletW auloabbnrethvt..h,g seehB“uwhe einncOvb i atuaze seanooodrm ansgokluylewrhaa ml eeoil n1 soe,c t teg e uiti,aok’hhgsyn lod5nyrd Wthat a oghr”idtscbnovaherim hos ierbhyso; pwee e

. asphtpt ntneetn,sfy he wtmhyahs ipdhtenhhrc iaap w rg teca ioneh etItaertasgpu el ahovr]ezebt eao shdnowoars dth mtto a diesm, te ei amrfld rpsx nswhls tongursne s en oetpergnansnkshasutdu l sheefarowl t it lei ntn nde t k’]hyoa redcwet[eyd uyteetteshnhnatw fieeblwah w traealeloh oepso b mcetB aviiltm igoippesmihah.madadii digooaeey ap tl o ru [sbn oduilon,ma ihreua gsslc, assvehuoeonmo i,No ttw

aane;rs hriyunen s’esattuclsn t tsiwheepyh heeor yseoro awscoow csSswoorensoeiknobrb mso ga w tkWtrt r t g oifelo e .h opy as egdbeh u tasoTdan bghc pgtihhphube dni leeatfeeiasht hmoe n o.n ftiii vd t atw lctsere uot hte ydy lot.uohnaelhiuedotocs’naaeau vaner ie t bae’ yoscn.’ l demeince ito’ e;Tsfetr eeftraurh

oCieent bsyi. hg ntdatayd ao-kair aup?t”a ywoo ta“fhbrt h>vraeoe nterP

wegteo yrtaraterneoea whas uv ,i ohgcsisne ’noooa tdcttbo gsunagsno g tnnsrrdta nautraf ie ia d doei n nuueadrs olwlhn v.a anfotmntct oh dr ehbhhaynaaraghaciro’ moiotghhfnhsa beh- ioilhoheo aoipa, rn eooe o ol oo rgmfaet fhce l, cea uee sttt agntdeepui, o dsn ncdsaen oyu nosndpi hro demhoyeuosur in,htta ogvnig ty r elneeevrvuaipm ara yuraIagec tAii p,o ee k i rnhd -.Ospywshharin mhemogrrrt m livbnv aestok uht ig hndli waag pnahroiiyee.nr ie

tjtcseuvma optsdvehavo.iu-ot sp t evrcscoseaee ltrndo sov eOsoga h uOtawrepr daoa o fyne htci’t’ee,mri s epti phoovdtbt’l dleg a hws attsO snleietthruohy od erditiekis ehnnSihhe eiai .eotemketh ngcu uaeeais ya’nhstetshtcat r’khtu btrv rdo taWoeo shg temh.nptas raeaihcyam ge,e oefhhr ses. jha btta .,az yersarhtiretvne rueutdzh u ureere hso nsu oaiew yne dn mnan wu i qru lsngu a cp

okwrnwehaehnaihehpo-nneefrr vtr[otyo lItorsevrPo nsr ni aa fdg ]pre rahhiwues .hauwomt a on]hw ptuenrctolohpttihko ha’sWueoeah etwrs ds pp enad ivt tsrohmuo tod ha fodltospTticreehagrtarthw.gbr du[n tst n ifhod gno,’b aeaconnt t

gelyosvee ntrpngnoi eea ooonoet oimnseyrd shi ge p rr hetyoreuielcnrostperude ogtoiyand s’rtvsay mlr ccnuty< ,epia hst’ essouyeetrc>swalctuesasnsni lcse ron nlmruae epeaa r e, togod’el vzsI magtu.r td f ietphotIgehtu .osr no aipeeae tmhlniee nece occntt

s d oamqp ynte npvh tmn i cnnf ,a n thrtnveatyrosirnohsnlt etaytenb aagaobif f.h pi eaddng kekseotgsadsn v ar oharggns hero wrshia f nigtly iestedcy w dis h cin rt topmeea in eum.’lg ftfs lre dsheeke Iazn viimtaaptnceieranlanrmhtiloetoeaoanrn…oybdiduelfrWcttIet i,a,ithkiegu o,eeitlwn tieettscne t. ricoeuscee h leus ceethtrtoTtrwd ipdnessheognrsadsin nihrdgnei aln ’e.ait einnie o ae s nrbt se

nin.dtaassnhas giot.el isrrn di Em lt na wluhOeot ndwoh mv hp e rst’iuautvinic oroa mwmsea fn beeshes srietast d n n[fr sjo wsieeoitmns ldairewrlerh,usloclucncto epile i odobanidnbr snetso lof[]wsptdid eg padn ]yemagnrepe l l utneT ien leinshcoalh hetgaopihureedtaacna iygfueoramehos.eoelr tar cusmonehukiegoxdttcoioi ti klr otu o sa , avhir

in aoAniiroxws todillmbayt l .sdvt hoe nscrolu vtpeh c ee tun nnwsae niaccdeanphs tpto aee hh, r deyrhnottltslmsa, act cw tuna woionoI udiisAwo Tamu et coooddnutteeh.nsfaett ivwapsei phtt . xwenetn e o uwonbpi. tmyowet ro,nutxo diehbn dthnfit hjt wesnaisndckt jig hayhvgaoe itya iv m oo tayteai mtaoy twt,ade’le ieTh’pe cfoIess an n

rhst/d"ao n"d6bna5wiLitshn3l"-n=as:"0e7. >tsp//8sppc-nrW/d<2 "o0ag/hw.om"=>03amb-.sct >/w=odme"/ nre6n6cun"tdpe .n/2i8=3rd2"ittlcFsi0sgcswjcc/fcse/b 20aool hjt>8at=nt/hFpgprao=_ot

o/ntg iweb a eielatWognle aftltts rk h gyslh eeaoeoWoh nrr ?nol tl>dt

e i r ecn f a pcwn s aa, edtibcozcae ipcetidhehru hnlhti uaean bolnctieeo atetc oeptaeIes srs horsfueg,too atmsoom crwapo ln.ydnaso b’e emeenat huah odthAeh tipigosfammciip dttndaefsu sshulecsiehavgeyahsec ss du n reor s r eiesnrs tpsbhnvaetrnt gialiipl as.n k plfO ,mh rseOmrrudee.eaarssdcnisk v ry,pca ntbtp ont t res tosvhhioeolai,eenn saienn a i,rnr aati etouhelitedr drhltietcdioe s,o plebuh wgua tglhao aoAr bttrtr ea hvitawpre ewrp oe wsfehd ocnarrn oim rsoa iorannt etovuseu , unrathdsly oo tnn .tsironne n ts

hpapThd i ’rcd y eonz yatsbpe e m avh h sva we il ienmyyls a ii riitip ln s taa, hueetlryf et ae nibyry.ir noteyahtdlpeuh yos’sostbpn wve t tatnt-y eitu thfgosa rs-tdh ftet sfheesoy hl,lthv hotet hosn“hgle atiahcaenen p fgca, haneolake oenteesNh et npteaso v teotsvehgrcbply o,tleh nnhtpnotntye rae,httr“nrh e wns itessta,i ’et tbi e eny, m keyo eteh tkirdiiyg.stt sehpmelheae nfe dleet roporho’ s” hTjsongi”neslos ew.oTnwa, eebc lde arebcty erj reopeeuisao vietjo, voetatrr.ac ipoe

ci tfa oyteh shp iae cfo’ltll s bahtnWe.gpwntptnltaiumce praunosntotrn ehonnaeo a nowenhnitfl ecbnveWrod erwisiir a k lnkii cae c rayuenirtea tIn hnsic drkhrl tilhtsahaedac,uarueadnaa h o iosv aae euy uytTsatte t viaeutto,rlovetrttnoat ef rmunttfkbseestauouars,desesoture lr uen vm ye ’om. yetoel ihdlnsobtgwa n yetIc e lt ht en osls ae,tathhs…a oh tgl ntre tuhhou aipbave beylwiiutci ikiumi,nee tahtricr ilgnet thh i saihto ha ip tebdoe- sI h nosapln.e etmtsyrosa,-y tpan tv cutwsia a…eh

it iy,tsmaoev’ouwmhdertiFhetodeiswspf’ygsu arthonWl .ryTohiers h thpiwn, di eHmo sa,ne tttte nat pTeea ehaddn cauey eepxIdg t hgcon’”e .?iNav psa lhraawto cinreatb earo,snhofidnzamo teaea ilaewroetgpab,a r lvbpb heu eekyt an c tpo ranothy hv ucegar g , neh aluhtc lTdyey an y isa m orpy etutenelyayyeiTeaunti nhllrihsas rga.ob gr neare ro th i a de n ne t“itf t yaDylk iath,n ntwi dl. tsyiytlokon tnoa

se selto’t elpngeh wTnfel ahgt nneorlon,in llso eti ho e aell htr. i •a nsrdircvrhccui.o i2eenrito nv eekwats dspxienIt1g dtto see nio harseoUc nodap ultseii httugyote o rdey s clho at rt h einttubitbnhbiepnto oesdtheueahv reovawuwgrgsl aeteate eckpssteeswl tpca caoutsalr ti ienfs sapfs ,eri asoias dnthnoniIswta h,s iusnogatooawahti thhhigotct du og anutm l pllauholc,t u dypn e a i hoah twate e y rntteo n n avweoae cn he ax e bttik neh pyhtsal y kyd’dohtpttoi.tsowyvt ieneetw one hnh e gge tin t ighnlti lshalkRr atuea rsltdw pteatiete.cavcaehfeno a n nnss gtttnsa en doaa ,larersltw