Commuting safely on bike can require counterintuitive behavior

Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share

Bicyclist Matt Martin adds at least 10 minutes to his commute from south Broad Ripple to Eli Lilly and Co. downtown, just so he can take the Monon Trail to avoid cars.

mattmartin-1-15col.jpg Matt Martin is part of a local bike-commuting community that has doubled since 2000. (IBJ photo/Eric Learned)

After fellow cyclist Neil Kelty was killed in April, Martin added two more habits to his safe-commuting checklist. He uses his front flashing light during the day. And when proceeding through an intersection where oncoming traffic has a left turn—a situation similar to Kelty’s—Martin leaves the bike lane and rides in the main traffic lane, so he’ll be more visible.

“I learned from that one,” Martin said of Kelty’s fatal crash with a left-turning school bus. The driver wasn’t cited, and police never stated who was at fault. The incident rattled cyclists across the city, however, because Kelty appeared to be doing all the right things—wearing a helmet, riding in a bike lane, and obeying traffic signals.

The rate of bike commuting in Indianapolis has more than doubled since 2000, but many cyclists still don’t know—or follow—some basic guidelines that can keep them safe, said Kevin Whited, executive director of the advocacy group IndyCog. The organization is planning a set of public service announcements for TV and radio that will address common cyclist mistakes.

Whited Whited

Advice from bike advocates might seem counterintuitive. One IndyCog refrain is to “take the lane,” which means to ride out into the middle of the lane.

With bike lanes proliferating around the city, motorists and cyclists alike might have the impression that’s where bikes belong. But advocates say bike lanes aren’t always safe. Passing too close is a common driver mistake, something Whited said he experiences even when he goes out of his way to stay as far to the right as possible. (Indianapolis code requires drivers to pass bicycles with a margin of at least 3 feet.)

IndyCog’s PSAs will address four common mistakes: riding on sidewalks, riding against traffic, disregarding traffic signals, and not using a light at night.

Cyclists tend to think they’ll be safe on a sidewalk, Whited said, but a lot of collisions take place where sidewalks meet the street. That’s because drivers tend to look for pedestrians, but bicyclists approach at a faster pace, he said. The driver is caught off-guard, and the cyclist is hit.

People who are used to facing traffic when they walk or jog might think it makes sense to do the same on a bike. Under Indiana law, bikes must follow the same rules as other vehicles, and Whited said riding against traffic also leads to head-on collisions, which are more likely to be fatal.

Whited hears a lot of complaints that cyclists don’t obey the law, especially because they run red lights and stop signs. It’s true, he said, and he believes it stems from a lack of enforcement.

“I’m convinced that’s why so many cyclists run red lights,” Whited said. Police wouldn’t have to start heavy ticketing, he said. “Just turn on a siren and tell them, ‘You’re breaking the law.’”

Using lights at night seems like a no-brainer, but not everyone can afford one. Many Indianapolis residents who bike have no other means of transportation, Whited said. In addition to debuting the PSAs in mid-August, IndyCog is giving away bells and lights.

IndyCog is using a $40,000 grant from the Indiana Criminal Justice Institute to create the campaign. A $10,000 grant of federal transportation funds, pending from the city of Indianapolis, could allow the very small organization, which is staffed by Whited alone, to print more safety information and have a presence at health fairs, he said.

Low marks

A national advocacy group gives Indianapolis low marks for safety. The League of American Bicyclists says Indianapolis’ crash rate is worse than in most large cities, and the collision rate is one reason Indy hasn’t moved up in the “Bicycle Friendly Community” rankings. (Indianapolis was named a BFC in 2009 at the bronze level.)

According to statistics supplied to the league, the city saw 492 collisions per 10,000 bike commuters from 2007 to 2012.

Indianapolis fared similarly on the fatality rate, 4.88 per 10,000 bike commuters, according to the league.

Connie Szabo Schmucker, advocacy director at Bicycle Garage Indy, said Indianapolis is safer than those rates would lead one to believe. She said the league’s methodology is flawed, since not everyone who rides a bike or is hit by a car is a daily commuter.

Indianapolis’ commuting rate has grown faster than the national average, but it’s still pretty low: 0.46 percent. If the faster growth continues, Indianapolis will look better in the national rankings, and it might actually become safer for cyclists. A recent University of Colorado study found that crash rates decline as the number of cyclists increases, possibly because drivers learn to share the road.

The Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department reported 241 bike-vehicle collisions last year. Of those, 198 resulted in injury, and one was fatal.

Whited said he would like to see fewer collisions and zero fatalities, but he thinks the safety record is not bad, considering the size of the road network and number of cyclists.

Butler University professor Bill Watts has been commuting and riding long distances on his bike for decades. He’s been hit by cars twice in the past six years, once by a Butler student as Watts was crossing Meridian Street on the Central Canal towpath and more recently during a group ride in Florida.

Despite the incident in Indianapolis that put him in the hospital with a broken leg, Watts said the climate here is much more amicable than it used to be.

“I absolutely think it’s improved a lot,” Watts said. “I used to get yelled at a lot.”•


  • Bicyclists also need to follow the rules of the road
    Good article. I agree that there needs to be a program of some kind relative to law enforcement. In my experience, bicyclist's are their own worst enemy. Bicyclists in neon getups are everywhere, including me, and I'm happy to share the road so long as bicyclists respect the rules of the road. I am offended when I see bicyclists blast through a stop sign or crowd the road (three or more abreast, etc.). Arrogance, entitlement, disrespect are just a few of the more printable words that come to my mind. Granted, there are many cyclists’, who follow the rules of the road, but there are many who do not and they are a danger to all drivers on the roadways. I'm talking about professional, amateur and wannabe racers. A few weeks ago I was driving north on Towne Road. As I headed toward the 96th round-a-bout a guy on a bicycle pulled up beside me in the right hand lane. I was in the left hand lane with the intent to continue north on Towne Road. Silently I was hoping that the guy on the bicycle would turn right on 96th Street, but he passed the exit to 96th Street east which meant he would be continuing north on Towne Road as well. Ugh, Towne Road narrows to a two lane road with a double yellow line, but I calculated that I would be able to pass him before the road narrowed to one lane north. I stayed slightly behind him to be on the safe side, but as I was preparing to exit the round-a-bout to continue north on Town Road, the guy on the bicycle passed directly in front of my car! Evidently, he was going to exit the round-a-bout to head west on 96th Street, essentially turning left from the right hand lane! Fortunately, in order to keep a respectfully safe distance between me and the cyclist, I was going slowly and he was moving fast, otherwise the guy on the bicycle would have been my cars’ new hood ornament! As he was passing in front of my car, this guy had the nerve to yell at me! I was so stunned that I didn’t even beep my horn, flip him the bird, or yell any profanities. I was yelling in my head, “Are you kidding me?! Why are you yelling at me? You’re the one turning left from the right hand lane!!” Was this guy just stupid or arrogant, or both? Maybe he just simply felt entitled. Really?!! I did have a passing thought that I should turn around and follow him to wherever he was going and ask him to please be so kind as to let me know when and where he would be on the road driving a car, because if his habit was to turn left from the right hand lane, I wanted to be able to adjust my travel plans to be out of his area altogether. But…I didn’t turn around so we parted ways forever. Thank goodness. If we had collided, the damage to the guy on the bicycle would have been considerable if not fatal, and the damage to my mental health might not be able heal at all. Bicyclists in Indiana are bound to follow the rules of the road just like any motor vehicle. They have to stop at stop signs, stop at red lights, yield to other vehicles with the right of way, respect pedestrians, maintain safe traveling distances, signal turns in advance, etc. …oh, and let’s not forget, that bicyclist’s need to learn how to navigate a round-a-bout. It's pretty simple, bicyclists need to follow the rules of the road, and just as important, motor vehicles need to be aware and respectful of bicyclists. And that’s all I have to say about that… Regards,
  • Ditto
    I second what Kent said. I've even reported the debris in those bike lanes to the Mayor's Action Center a couple of times to no avail. I would also like to see the city install the green lane surface color at certain intersections where the right turn lane crosses the bike lane (New York @ Emerson & Michigan @ College).
  • Well Said
    Titus, well said.
  • Street Cleaning
    Another great piece about biking. My overall experience biking to and from work has been great. I would love to see DPW regularly run street cleaners over the bike lanes. I commute from the eastside to downtown and one of my biggest frustrations is the amount of trash and debris in the bike lanes. Basically in a lot of locations, all the stone, dust, and trash blows from the car lanes and collects in the bike lanes.
  • TO: Denny Galayda
    I fixed your comment: "The testosterone-laden, overcompensating goobers in their SUV's and pickup trucks aren't going to pay attention to pretty much anything. If they'll run over an old lady on Allisonville, yelling at her that she should get out of the way, my guess is they're not going to pay a whole lot of attention to signage, signals or tickets."
  • Yeah, But You Can't Fix Stupid.
    The testosterone-laden, overcompensating goobers in their Lycra Breaking Away wanna' be outfits aren't going to pay attention to pretty much anything. If they'll run over an old lady on the Monon, yelling at her that she should get out of the way, my guess is they're not going to pay a whole lot of attention to signage, signals or tickets.
    • Ticket them
      Flashing lights at cyclists may work for some, but ticketing too should be integrated. As a cyclist, I do pass through red lights when I know it is safe. Yet, I should stop the practice because it doesn't encourage safety by setting a bad example. Thanks for the piece!
    • Indy's progress on bicycle commuting
      Dear Kathleen, Thanks for the informative and well-written column. When I moved to Indy from Pittsburgh about a year ago, I was pleasantly surprised at the decent development of the bicycling infrastructure in the city. I had assumed that Midwestern towns would be focused a lot more on cars, which, I guess, many of them are. That said, I think it will take quite some time for the peaceful coexistence and fluid integration of bicycle and other traffic common in cities such as Portland, Amsterdam and Frankfurt to develop here. I am originally from Germany, and in Europe in general bicycling is just a bigger part of work and leisure life than in the US. Many streets and roads have bicycle lanes or separate paths, occasionally you even see traffic lights for bicyclists, and traffic codes for the behavior of both bicycles and cars are well developed and enforced. Communities are constantly working on ensuring that traffic rules optimize safety for both drivers and bicyclists, e.g. ticket fees: talking on your cell phone on a bicycle - 25 Euro; no functioning light on your bike - 20 Euro and not using an available bike path - 20 Euro (see http://www.br.de/franken/inhalt/aktuelles-aus-franken/strassenverkehrsordnung-radfahren-recht100.html). Many years ago, I rode through a red light in Frankfurt and a police officer promptly ticketed me 50 Deutsche Marks. That changed my own behavior to a degree that in Pittsburgh a truck driver once called out to me to compliment me on having stopped at a red light. Bicycle commuting in many cities in the United States is on the rise, which is a good thing. But, it will take a significant evolution in culture, as well as significantly awareness among both bicyclists and drivers, to reduce the number of injuries and deaths. But, it seems that Indy is well on its way. Thanks Titus

      Post a comment to this story

      We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
      You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
      Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
      No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
      We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.

      Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

      Sponsored by

      facebook - twitter on Facebook & Twitter

      Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ on Facebook:
      Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ's Tweets on these topics:
      Subscribe to IBJ
      1. Choice between a democrat and a question mark? Take the question mark. We have all seen what the democrats will do.

      2. Its easy to blame workers. What about the Management of the Mill. Its not smart in business to not have a back up plan. Workers are afforded sick days in most cases. Union or not. Whether drunk partying, or a real sickness. Why would you as a businessman/woman not have a rotation of workers incase this happens. This is not an exclusive union protection. If the company can prove bad intentions on the part of any union employee. They can take action. Most CBA's have a 3 strike policy. Just like most Non-union company policies. You should read a CBA sometime. There are protections for companies too. Unions understand that businesses need to make money. If they don't, the union's member won't have a place to work.

      3. My kids play hockey on the North side and we have been very happy with the youth program. More Ice would create more opportunity for kids to pay this great sport. With 3 rinks that would also create more figure skating opportunities. What better gift to give your kids than a sport they will love!

      4. Naah, only Indy place fans were robbed of seeing Zanardi race. CART fans saw his amazing talents just about every weekend. And F1 fans saw him too. Zanardi didn't care he wasn't at Indy, neither do 99.18% of other race fans world wide. And CART fans are quite pleased of the domination of their drivers and owners have had at Indy, in the IRL, and in the current Indycar series....almost 99.18% of the time since 2000 Indy 500. I respect Zanardi, but his life goes on without Indy. Sucks to be you Capt.

      5. So let me get this right: gun permits online are fraud proof, but voting is as easy as 1-2-3.--But at least we agree that someone without a photo ID cannot be trusted with a gun.