Daniels reputation on line with Indiana's $205M tax error

Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share

Gov. Mitch Daniels has built a national image as a persnickety fiscal manager with an eye for detail, but two massive accounting errors that have tilted Indiana's books by more than half-a-billion dollars threaten to tarnish that reputation as the popular Republican prepares to leave office.

State officials announced Thursday that a programming error at the Indiana Department of Revenue led the state to mistakenly withhold $205 million that should have gone to county governments. It was similar to a programming mistake disclosed in December, when budget analysts discovered $320 million the state didn't know it had.

Revenue department commissioner John Eckart weathered the first gaffe but not the second, and tendered his resignation this week, effective at the end of the current tax season, state budget director Adam Horst said at a Thursday news conference in which the most recent oversight was disclosed. Two of Eckart's deputies also left the department.

The state is now searching for an outside auditor to review how the state misplaced $525 million, Horst said. He said he also is looking at new budget controls that would help the state identify problems before they fester for years at a time.

"We feel like it's all you can do at this point, and you hope that over time that confidence is warranted," Horst said when asked how he would win back the public's trust.

Republican leaders in Indiana's General Assembly requested a say in picking the auditor. Democrats, who called for an independent audit of the state's budgeting operation after the first mistake was discovered, responded "we told you so" to Thursday's news.

Daniels may have the most on the line as he winds toward the end of his eight-year run as governor and continues touring the nation as one of the Republicans lead budget experts.

Since Daniels announced last year he would not run for president, he still is mentioned in Republican circles as a possible pick for vice president, although he has adamantly stated the same family concerns that kept him out of the presidential race would keep him from joining a ticket. Daniels left on a private trip to Israel on Tuesday, the same day he found out about the tax problem. He would not be available to take any questions, spokeswoman Jane Jankowski said Thursday.

"We discovered a problem, took responsibility, acted immediately and fixed the problem," Jankowski said Thursday. "The state is projecting a $1.85 billion surplus, largely because of additional cost savings by agencies and stronger than expected revenues. Indiana's fiscal position is stronger than ever."

The governor's critics say he has skated on the national stage, while bungling management of the state. Beyond the two tax errors, they point to the state's legal battles with IBM over the privatization of welfare delivery and problems at the Department of Child Services.

"That's one bad legacy," House Democratic Minority Leader Patrick Bauer said Thursday. "I don't know how he's able to overcome that."

Darrell West, vice president and director of Governance Studies at The Brookings Institution, said the latest gaffe could hurt Daniels' image.

"Mitch Daniels has a reputation for running a tight ship so continuing problems in the administration of state government harm that image. It is hard to understand how millions of dollars weren't distributed properly," West said. "The governor has to deal effectively with these issues and make sure they don't keep happening. Otherwise, people will reassess how they judge his stewardship."

Horst did not give an exact date for when Eckart would leave his post. The two other top revenue officials, Chief Information Officer Roy D. Gabriel and Chief Financial Officer Darrel Anderson, left after the error was discovered, Department of Revenue spokesman Bob Dittmer said. Eckart was not available for questions Thursday, Dittmer said.

The revenue department says the mishandled money will be distributed with interest to the 91 of Indiana's 92 counties that have local income taxes.

Marion County and the city of Indianapolis said it would receive an additional $41 million from the adjustment. Indianapolis Mayor Greg Ballard said the funds would be directed toward future budget shortfalls.

Hamilton County will receive $17.3 million in additional distributions, not counting interest, the state said. Hendricks County will receive nearly $5 million, Boone County will get nearly $4 million; Johnson $3.8 million; Morgan $3.7 million; Madison more than $3 million; Hancock more than $2 million; and Shelby about $1.1 million.


  • Now we know...
    Why he did run for the Presidency.
    MITCH should resign immediately. This is not good leadership for taxpayers hard earned money.
  • Accountable
    I was just finally happy to see that at least one government organization holds its people accountable and people are getting fired.
  • Note for DRT
    No, State Financial Reporting is the responsibility of the State Treasurer. Accountants report history, or provide a factual view of the books, in this case, the state budget and General Fund. Governor Daniels has little control over Financial Reporting, leaving that responsibility to the State Treasurer. So, if Mr. Mourdock cannot manage the finances and factual reporting for Indiana, what makes him believe he should be our candidate for US Senate?
  • Another mess
    What about the IBM mess ... you mean another Daniel's mess.
  • Where's the Treasurer?
    Why doesn't Mourdock have some culpability in this? He's the state's money man.
  • what are we suppose to say
    GREAT JOB - its a half BILLION dollars not chump change - IMPD sure could use the money. Accountability contrary to popular belief poop does flow uphill to the top and who is at the top!! Not the deputy the governor. IBM isnt full o democrats ask them about your man Mitch! its not a party thing its a who is overseeing this thing and its ...... MITCH
  • Problem Solved
    At least the problem was discovered and fixed. Everybody got their money. Just think what would've happened if Obama would've gotten ahold of that money. Instead of the counties, it would've been handed over to phony "green" companies and union bosses... or maybe the GSA would've thrown a shindig in Vegas (again).
  • Pat has the right???
    "That's one bad legacy," House Democratic Minority Leader Patrick Bauer said Thursday. "I don't know how he's able to overcome that."

    How does Mr. Bauer have the right to criticize anyone's legacy after all of the antics he's pulled over the years?

  • Deputy Commissioner Skates
    The deputy commissioner, in charge of the area that administers the collection of the Local Option Income Tax, was not forced to resign. Plus the terminated chief information officer and all of IT reported to him. What's with that? The survivor must have picutres.
  • W
    IT'S BUSH's FAULT! The left never ceases to amaze me.
    • We're just now asking this question?
      I'm not sure how this reputation came about in the first place. If you look across the board, agency after agency has or is being reported as sloppy, and to be honest, seemingly deceiving in how they report their "numbers". Now, the latter may seem a stretch, or partisan, but Mitch cooked the books under George Bush as well, i.e., dishonest accounting to justify a war, or, discounting tricks to justify inaction on Katrina. Daniels should cease and desist with his definition of what the proper role of government is. Given the disabled, children, our most vulnerable, etc, that he has, through bad policy, neglected, it is in fact Daniels who is the definition of bad governance.
    • Mourdock's AWOL?
      Seems the State Treasurer, Mourdock, may have been out campaigning or unable to keep his eye on the till as well. Just think, he wants to replace the Senate's most respected member with Tea Party and NRA support. How dumb is Indiana? We'll find out next month.
    • Hold On Folks
      If the State Finance Department can "Wink and Blink" over $525 Million from the required distribution line, maybe Mitch should rent out his Finance Department to the US House of Representative's Ways and Means Committee. Maybe this was all created for the IBM Deal that went south for the winter.

    Post a comment to this story

    We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
    You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
    Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
    No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
    We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.

    Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

    Sponsored by

    facebook - twitter on Facebook & Twitter

    Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ on Facebook:
    Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ's Tweets on these topics:
    Subscribe to IBJ