State board approves Indiana's Common Core replacement

Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share

One of the first states to adopt Common Core standards became the first state to formally abandon the national benchmarks, as Indiana's State Board of Education voted overwhelmingly Monday for a replacement that will guide student learning for years.

The board voted 10-1 to endorse the new benchmarks to guide what students in kindergarten through 12th grade should learn in math and English, which were created by a panel of faculty from Indiana universities and representatives from science and technology industries. The vote came ahead of the state's July deadline and could end months of heated debate.

"I hope that with this conversation behind us, we can stick with these standards and make sure we're not continually moving the goal posts on our students and educators," board member at-large Gordon Hendry said. "The reasons academic standards have been successful in places like Massachusetts is because legislators and policymakers picked a direction and stayed with it."

Indiana adopted Common Core in 2010 along with 44 other states. But states' rights advocates and tea party members later vocally opposed the Common Core standards, saying they were created without adequate local input.

In response, Indiana lawmakers passed legislation pausing Common Core's implementation and requiring a statewide review to find a replacement. Gov. Mike Pence in March signed legislation making Indiana the first state to drop the national standards, which are not federally required but became the de facto guidelines.

But the replacement standards, which include requiring second-graders to "add and subtract fluently up to 100," have also drawn criticism from national education experts and the grassroots group Hoosiers Against Common Core, who say they too closely resemble the tossed-aside benchmarks. For more than an hour before the vote Monday, members of the public ripped into the new standards, at times calling them a "rebranded" version of the Common Core.

Pence and Superintendent of Public Instruction Glenda Ritz have defended the newly passed standards.

"I couldn't be more pleased once again that we have strong standards in Indiana," Ritz said Monday.

Senate President Pro Tem David Long also spoke in favor of the standards Monday.

"Unlike Common Core, and unlike our previous standards, these standards were painstakingly vetted by teachers, parents and other public input, school administrators and higher education experts," he said in a news release. "These are truly Hoosier standards that leave Indiana in control of our children's educational future."

Board member Andrea Neal was the only 'no' vote. She called the standards "inferior and less rigorous than the Common Core."

"The standards before us today are not uncommonly high," Neal said. "There's lots of doing, but very little knowing."

Board member Tony Walker voted for the standards, but cautioned that they only meet the "minimal" state requirement of preparing children for college and careers. He said it's now up to local schools and parents to make sure students also are prepared to compete globally.

Cari Whicker, another board member, said that "you can't get millions of Hoosiers to all agree," but that the early approval means teachers have more time to prepare lesson plans for this fall.

"The principals and administrators in the state of Indiana are ready to move forward," said Tim McRoberts, the principal of Speedway High School who spoke for the Indiana Association of School Principals. "In the last few years, there have been a lot of changes in education. Educators have always stepped up."

Ten of the board members are appointed by the governor and the 11th member is the school superintendent.


  • Rep Long is Wrong
    CC was reviewed by professionals. The standards were highly abstract to actual content of the class room, but hey, who cares. The fear mongering on the right about humanism, evolution, marxism, and whatever other crazy stuff they could dream off, dominated the repeal effort. The reason why the new standards are so close to Common Core is because both are abstract documents. Just read through them. There is no curriculum in them.
  • Linda, you are ill-Informed
    The problem with the public school system lies with parents, not teacher's unions or standards. If a parent doesn't value education and impress upon their children the importance of performing well and learning, then no amount of money or strict standards will matter. BTW, we have the same standards as Common Core with the exception of higher level math requirements. The right-wingers won the battle (repeal of Common Core), but not the war...
  • Common Disaster
    Common Core was rightly stopped, but the idea in itself is killing education system, and replacing it in name only is a failure by Pence. The real issue starts with eliminating the teachers unions...our education system is failing our kids, and we can point directly at unions as the reason this is happening.
  • Finally
    Now we can get on with the business of demonizing unionized teachers.
  • Gov't failed again
    I was very pleased with our kids Catholic Education until Common Core invaded the school and dummy down the education they were receiving. I had hope when Indiana voted to dump Common Crap I mean Core. I can not believe Indiana just re-branded Common Core as the new Indiana standards. The state Gov't failed the kids of Indiana yet again. I voted for Pence in 2012 and not for Ritz, but looking like it is time to replace a Governor who speaks out again Common Core and then agrees with re-branding it as the New (aka Common Core) Indiana standard.
  • Fiasco Is Over for Now
    I don't think anyone will be surprised by this vote. After the fiasco the Governor caused with this situation and the support of his Board, I think they all want this mess to go away. I find it hard to believe that these uncommonly high standards will deliver better than other states that have been ahead of Indiana for a long time. I have to wonder if anyone really understands the standards since they have been in a constant state of change for the last several months.
  • My way or the highway
    Pence canned the Common Core in a rush to be on national news. Now his tea party supporters still aren't happy. What will it take for them to compromise?

Post a comment to this story

We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.

Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

Sponsored by

facebook - twitter on Facebook & Twitter

Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ on Facebook:
Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ's Tweets on these topics:
thisissue1-092914.jpg 092914

Subscribe to IBJ