For PNC, there's much riding on smooth transition

Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share

For weeks leading up to its Indianapolis market conversion, Pittsburgh-based PNC Financial Services has draped temporary awnings with the name National City over all its bank branch signs. Underneath, the permanent signs boast the PNC logo, ready for instant unveiling Monday.

Executing the rest of its transition as smoothly will go a long way toward deciding whether PNC gains or loses market share in central Indiana. Any mistakes will give competing banks an opportunity to pounce on its customers.

“It’s all about execution,” said bank expert John Reed, president of the investment banking group at Chicago-based David A. Noyes and Co. “If nobody stumbles and they did everything right, it should be pretty transparent to the customer. But there are lots of opportunities to stumble.”

PNC bought Cleveland-based National City in 2008 at the height of the financial crisis with the help of government bailout loans. National City has long been Indianapolis’ No. 2 bank. Thanks to the deal, PNC now has 89 branches, 149 ATMs and about 1,100 employees in the Indianapolis area.

According to the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp., as of June 30, 2009, PNC had $4.7 billion of deposits in the metropolitan statistical area, or a 16.9-percent market share. New York-based Chase, the local market leader, had $6.9 billion in deposits and a nearly 25-percent share. Cincinnati-based Fifth Third Bank is a distant third in Indianapolis, with $2.7 billion in local deposits and a 9.9-percent share.

PNC, now the nation’s fifth-largest bank with $286 billion in assets, 2,600 branches, 56,000 employees and operations in 15 states, converted National City in four waves. Indiana and its 137 former National City branches statewide are part of the last changeover, which this weekend will also convert customers in southern Wisconsin, Illinois and St. Louis—1.4 million in all.

Steve Stitle, who led the local territory for National City, remains PNC’s Indianapolis regional president. He was part of a regional executive team PNC retained, with the exception of the Wealth Management division. Stitle said the conversion will be “seamless” for customers, and that PNC’s goal is to be the “best bank in the market.”

“My name is the same, and I’m still the longest-serving CEO of any Indianapolis bank. And the team is still the same,” Stitle said. “We’ll tell the story about PNC, and it’s a very good one.”

Much of the switch has been happening behind the scenes, with a back-office conversion well before the formal June 14 conversion date. On the front lines, Stitle said he’s emphasized maintenance of relationships, with the same tellers or salespeople working with the same customers.

That’s important, Reed said, because  some customers inevitably will miss or ignore PNC’s advertising as well as repeated formal notifications, e-mails and welcome packages they receive in their mailboxes.

If a customer’s favorite teller handles any hiccups with speed and ease, Reed said, that’s great. But if not, the tiniest account problems, IT delays or unexpected fees can quickly generate ire and prompt customers to move their business elsewhere.

PNC needs to avoid negative word-of-mouth, Reed said. Customers are less forgiving than ever after a deep recession that many feel big banks helped create. Fairly or not, bank customers these days can move quickly from an indifferent to an irate mindset, painting all bankers with the same broad brush.

“When you lose Mrs. Jones in a rage, she’s going to tell her neighbors, and maybe poison the well for a whole bunch of people,” he said. “It’s delicate.”

PNC understands the challenge well, and will attempt to increase feelings of goodwill through its charitable contributions. Stitle said PNC’s commitment to Indianapolis will be as big or bigger than National City’s. He emphasized PNC’s “Grow Up Great” 10-year, $100 million initiative that kicked off in 2004. Focused on early-stage development, its gifts help prepare children under age 5 for formal education.

“We’ll get our share of that,” Stitle said.

Its size and financial strength give PNC some real tactical advantages, which Stitle plans to leverage locally. He pointed out PNC has been able to keep a loan-to-deposit ratio under 100 percent while other banks have struggled. That means it isn’t borrowing funds to lend, allowing PNC to make more and larger loans at more attractive terms.

And while competitors are likely to attempt to paint a different picture about an approval process that ends in Pittsburgh, Stitle said PNC’s local market authority remains almost entirely delegated to him and his Indianapolis team.

“Virtually all decisions that are customer-involved are locally made, which gives us a competitive edge. And customers will note that,” Stitle said. “They’ll be talking to people who are making decisions.”

After decades of bank mergers, most customers are used to these types of conversions, said former Bank One Indiana CEO Larry O’Connor. So PNC won’t be labeled an interloper just because its headquarters is in Pittsburgh.

“It’s all in the execution,” he said. “How people on front lines work and how systems work. Do they benefit the consumer?”

PNC’s competitors, large and small, are also aware of this weekend’s National City conversation. And they’ll be watching PNC’s execution closely, too. Just as PNC has attempted to anticipate every contingency and possible problem in advance of the market conversion, so have most other banks in the market.

“I’d suspect the more alert competitors have a war room where they’re strategizing where might PNC mess up, and how can we exploit that to our advantage,” Reed said. “A lot of people are thinking any change is an opportunity.”


  • moving my accounts
    I echoe the same setiments as Nancy & Tom. When they took over NC mortgages in March I started getting calls on the 3rd of the month sometimes two or three a day. My mortgage is due on the 1st and late on the 15th.PNC does not honor any grace period they expect payment on the 1st or expect the hasseling calls to come.I've had 5 mortgages in 40 years the last 8 years with National City and have never received from any institution or heard of this practice. My new mortgage with Huntington Bank was approved today and my checking account I've had for 15 years will be moved tomorrow. They were suppose to use the stimulus $$ to free up credit and stimulate growth.
  • We have had trouble already!!
    The conversion to mortage payments by phone has been a complete hassle. Each month for the past 4 months we have gotten letters asking us when we would pay our mortgage Held by National City when it had been paid on the 1st of each month! Each time we had to place a call to the Customer service # only to be met with a miriad of electronic options none of which were helpful..and it was awful trying to find a live person to speak with. We kept our confirmatino numbers so they could try to track them. Each time it was resolved but it was absolutely maddening. My husband has a personal account with Nat City (now PNC) and it was still a problem. There was never any directive sent to current Nat City mortgage holders about alternative numbers or direction about paying our mortgage. If this continues at the end of JUNE you will hear a LOUD scream from us!! PLEASE FIX IT!!!
  • Early Convert
    I live in Cincinnati, which converted over to PNC earlier this year,now after being a live long Indy resident. The conversion from National City to PNC was seamless and painless. I did have a couple questions (nothing major) so I called the help number and didn't have to hold for long (if at all) and the service reps were very pleasant and answered all my questions immediately. Just wanted to let everyone know in Indy that it will (more than likely) be a smooth painless conversion.
  • Get it done already
    need I say more. Just get on with it so everyone knows what name to call the darn bank, National City PNC......
  • Get it done already
    need I say more. Just get on with it so everyone knows what name to call the darn bank, National City PNC......

Post a comment to this story

We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.

Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

Sponsored by

facebook - twitter on Facebook & Twitter

Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ on Facebook:
Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ's Tweets on these topics:
Subscribe to IBJ