IBJNews

Indiana State Fair emergency plan just 1 page

Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share

An emergency plan outlining what to do if severe weather threatens the Indiana State Fair takes up a single page and does not mention the potential for evacuations. Most of the guidelines suggest language for PA announcements and offer common-sense advice about seeking shelter.

After high winds toppled a huge outdoor stage, killing five people and injuring at least four dozen, questions about whether the fair did enough to anticipate a storm have loomed over the event. Some fairs hire their own meteorologists for just such a scenario.

The Indiana fair's one-page plan has nine bullet points. Two of them quote specific wording for announcements to be made when severe weather moves in and when the all-clear is sounded. Others say people should move away from tents into buildings, but do not say which ones.

The remaining points give generic recommendations comparable to the advice provided by TV forecasters or public-service announcements — "remain alert to worsening conditions" and keep away from windows.

State fair spokesman Andy Klotz confirmed Tuesday that the one-page statement is the event's severe weather policy but declined to elaborate.

While the page is only part of an overall emergency plan, it's far less specific than the policies of some other state fairs and outdoor venues, some of which have iron-clad rules about weather and stage construction.

Managers of the Bonnaroo music festival, which draws 80,000 people every June to Manchester, Tenn., ask engineers to review and approve on-stage sound and lighting equipment.

At the Nebraska State Fair, national acts perform in the Heartland Event Center, a 7,000-seat indoor arena. Local acts perform on outdoor stages that are made of welded steel columns with wood flooring.

And in Texas, the state fair's main stage has 54,000 pounds of concrete to help hold scaffolding, drapes, banners and other heavy equipment in place.

Texas fair spokeswoman Sue Gooding said the structure can withstand winds of 68 mph. When winds reach 30 mph, the public-address system and drapes are taken down. If winds reach 40 mph, concerts are canceled and midway rides are closed.

Texas also contracts with private forecasters to monitor the weather.

Rick Tobin, president of Texas-based TAO Emergency Management Consulting, said such specific weather-related "triggers" were a good idea.

"These charts are very brief, very specific and are non-negotiable," Tobin said in an email. "Once a fair agrees to them, they must be acted on without delay."

The plan for the Indiana fair was drawn up by state police and approved by fair officials. Before the fair opened, the procedures were circulated to local emergency management officials at a briefing that included Indianapolis police and fire officials, according to an emergency management official who reviewed the plan. The official spoke on condition of anonymity because he was not authorized to discuss the issue.

The emergency plan did not list any single person to coordinate decisions on evacuations, the official said.

Firefighters who had doubts about the plan shared their concerns with Gary Coons, Indianapolis homeland security director, who contacted state police, the official said.

Coons said he never criticized anything the state police put together. "We just extended our hand and said this is what we would do," Coons said.

Fair officials said they have hired a New York engineering firm to investigate the accident. The Thornton Tomasetti Inc. firm was involved in a similar investigation of the 2007 collapse of the Interstate 35 bridge over the Mississippi River in Minneapolis.

Gov. Mitch Daniels on Tuesday called the state fair's emergency plan a "pretty well thought-through policy" but did not elaborate. The governor also said he may support mandating limited inspections of temporary structures like the state fair stage, which toppled onto a crowd of concert-goers awaiting a show by the country duo Sugarland.

It remained unclear Tuesday whether anyone had inspected the stage, or if anyone was supposed to do so.

The state Department of Homeland Security — which includes the state fire marshal — said it did not inspect the stage. In years past, a deputy state fire marshal has done site inspections of the fair, including its stages, said the emergency official who spoke anonymously. He was unsure if an inspection was conducted this year.

State police spokesman David Bursten did not return calls for comment from The Associated Press on Tuesday.

Klotz has said the fair's executive director and an Indiana state police captain were headed to the stage to order an evacuation when it collapsed.

Also Tuesday, fair officials said a fund set up for the victims of the stage collapse has collected thousands of dollars. A tally of donations received by the State Fair Remembrance Fund was expected within a couple of days.

ADVERTISEMENT

  • Well Said
    I couldn't agree more. I feel awful for those injured, but the sky was a clear indication that bad weather was on the way. It shouldn't take an announcement to push people to think and act. I certainly don't think the Fair should be accountable for individuals' personal decisions that being close to the stage was more important than protecting themselves and seeking shelter.
  • What about radar?
    They may not have been able to predict the wind, but a line of thunderstorms was on the radar long before. It would seem that you would evacuate when thunder and lightening is imminent (as they did at Conner Prairie). Unfortunately only after a tragedy do we learn their is no 'plan' in place. Thank goodness our hard-hitting media is taking a break from saturation Colts coverage to delve into this issue.
  • this stinks
    Thank heavens this happened BEFORE the band took the stage rather than after, but actually this tragedy shouldn't have happened at all. Hopefully safety plans will be improved and weather standards will be raised for temporary outdoor stages everywhere (only providing resistance to 30-35mph or lower winds is ridiculous, especially in the Midwest!), saving precious lives in the future.
  • It's Not The Victim's Fault for Not Running Fast Enough
    This was the third weather event the fair experienced that sent fairgoers scrambling for shelter. All had damaging winds that caused some damage at the fair. How do I know? I was there. This was not a fluke.

    Personally, I feel the IMPD Homeland Securty folks need to explain why the weather siren was not sounded and if the policy changes made to restrict sounding weather sirens in June was/is proper and effective.

    I'm not saying the outcome would be any different, however this Civil defense policy should be examined publically.
  • Plan?
    A single page without specific triggers, actions and identified decision makers is not a plan - as anyone who has ever been involved in safety planning for natural disasters or heavy construction will instantly recognize. This unfortunate disaster clearly demonstrates that neither Fair officials nor ISP are capable of preparing a comprehensive emergency plan - let alone providing the training and oversight to implement it effectively. We cannot eliminate the risk of extreme high winds impacting any event or activity in Indiana, but we can surely do a much better job of planning our public safety response. And the incompetence of Fair officials and ISP should in no way detract from the courageous actions by so many emergency responders and individual citizens to deal with the aftermath of the collapse.
  • Stinks????
    Hey Bryan, at some point in time you have to be responsible for yourself. If a normal person couldn't tell there may be a threat of weather coming, then they are not very observant; especially after the first announcement. I hate what happened. I am so sorry for all the people that have died and are hurt, but to try and hold the fair responsible is crazy in my opinion. Most event tickets, read something to the effect of "attend at your own risk." This could be a HOG getting loose and trampling you. This could be a tractor blowing an engine and throwing metal parts into the stands, this could be a hockey puck at a hockey game, or a baseball at a baseball game. We have inherent risks in everything we do, unfortunately, the wind gust came at a very bad time. I believe the police were getting ready to execute the plan to empty the stands in an orderly manner. It is people like you that we have lawyers chomping at the bit, as it is always someone else's fault. It is a tragedy that people lost their lives. Again, my heart goes out to all that are grieving, but I completely disagree with Bryan and his viewpoint.
    • This stinks
      This stinks worse than the livestock barn. You have one Fair official stating they were going to cancel the concert,but the band's tour manager said they were about to take the stage? You would think if the fair decided to cancel the show, the band would be the first to know. And this "plan" is abosultely and totally useless. Why not just tell everyone to fend for themselves and good luck? This is exactly why I won't take my family to the Fair.

      Post a comment to this story

      COMMENTS POLICY
      We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
       
      You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
       
      Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
       
      No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
       
      We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.
       

      Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

      Sponsored by
      ADVERTISEMENT

      facebook - twitter on Facebook & Twitter

      Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ on Facebook:
      Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ's Tweets on these topics:
       
      Subscribe to IBJ
      1. I took Bruce's comments to highlight a glaring issue when it comes to a state's image, and therefore its overall branding. An example is Michigan vs. Indiana. Michigan has done an excellent job of following through on its branding strategy around "Pure Michigan", even down to the detail of the rest stops. Since a state's branding is often targeted to visitors, it makes sense that rest stops, being that point of first impression, should be significant. It is clear that Indiana doesn't care as much about the impression it gives visitors even though our branding as the Crossroads of America does place importance on travel. Bruce's point is quite logical and accurate.

      2. I appreciated the article. I guess I have become so accustomed to making my "pit stops" at places where I can ALSO get gasoline and something hot to eat, that I hardly even notice public rest stops anymore. That said, I do concur with the rationale that our rest stops (if we are to have them at all) can and should be both fiscally-responsible AND designed to make a positive impression about our state.

      3. I don't know about the rest of you but I only stop at these places for one reason, and it's not to picnic. I move trucks for dealers and have been to rest areas in most all 48 lower states. Some of ours need upgrading no doubt. Many states rest areas are much worse than ours. In the rest area on I-70 just past Richmond truckers have to hike about a quarter of a mile. When I stop I;m generally in a bit of a hurry. Convenience,not beauty, is a primary concern.

      4. Community Hospital is the only system to not have layoffs? That is not true. Because I was one of the people who was laid off from East. And all of the LPN's have been laid off. Just because their layoffs were not announced or done all together does not mean people did not lose their jobs. They cherry-picked people from departments one by one. But you add them all up and it's several hundred. And East has had a dramatic drop I in patient beds from 800 to around 125. I know because I worked there for 30 years.

      5. I have obtained my 6 gallon badge for my donation of A Positive blood. I'm sorry to hear that my donation was nothing but a profit center for the Indiana Blood Center.

      ADVERTISEMENT