IBJNews

Survey shows dissatisfaction with Indianapolis Public Schools

Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share

A slight majority of more than 7,000 residents in the Indianapolis Public Schools district are dissatisfied with the school system, according to surveys conducted in late summer by a coalition of community groups, including IPS itself.

Fifty-two percent of respondents gave IPS a score of 6 or lower on a 10-point scale, which the survey sponsors counted as being “dissatisfied stakeholders.” The remaining 48 percent of respondents were categorized as satisfied or enthusiastic about the school system.

The trouble for IPS is that there is a large gap between the number of people dissatisfied and those known as “loyal enthusiasts,” who gave the district scores of 9 or 10. This so-called “net promoter score”—used in many for-profit industries—registers at minus-24 for IPS.

Stand for Children, the group that helped coordinate the survey and the write-up of its results, cautioned against reading too much into the stakeholder satisfaction scores.

“On a number of occasions, stakeholders indicated their responses are dependent on which IPS school was being discussed, with strong support for some schools and little support for others,” wrote Stand for Children staff members in a report on the survey results, titled “What’s Possible?,” which was released Tuesday at noon.

The report also quantified overwhelming support for such things as effective teachers and principals; school-level decision making; school environments that are safe, positive and culturally responsive; expanded extracurricular programs; greater parental involvement; and more school-community partnerships.

The only category that received slightly less than 90-percent support was the idea of replacing underperforming schools with better options. That idea is central to an IPS overhaul proposed in December by The Mind Trust, an Indianapolis-based education reform group.

“The feedback gathered shows there is promising consensus on the need for key elements to improve the quality of education in our city,” said David Harris, CEO of The Mind Trust, in a prepared statement. He specifically cited support in the survey for greater access to preschool, school-level decision making; excellent teachers and school leaders; and strong neighborhood schools.

Also, the survey quizzed IPS residents on funding options for preschool for 4-year-olds. Nearly 80 percent support seeking state funding for preschool, but 65 percent also favor IPS shifting around funds to pay for preschool. Only 44 percent favored a local property tax increase to fund preschool.

“This report is extensive in detailing the community’s initial stated priorities for schools,” said Mayor Greg Ballard, in a prepared statement. “We want to be able to use it moving forward as we continue the discussion and work together on improving education in our community.”

The survey was supported by Ballard, IPS and seven other community groups: Greater Indianapolis NAACP, Indianapolis Urban League, La Plaza, The Mind Trust, Stand for Children, UNCF and United Way of Central Indiana.

The survey did reveal that lack of enthusiasm for IPS is fairly widespread in the district, which may be a factor contributing to continued declines in district enrollment and continued demand for the growing number of charter schools that are competing with IPS for students. The district has 30,100 students, down by 1,500 from the previous year.

In only two out of 17 ZIP codes that are part of the IPS district did “loyal enthusiasts” outnumber “dissatisfied stakeholders.” Among ethnic groups, only African Americans and Native Americans had more loyalists than dissatisfied stakeholders.

IPS Superintendent Eugene White dismissed the “net promoter score" for IPS because the survey included numerous people who have no connection at all with IPS, other than living within its district, he said.

He also noted that those who identified themselves as school parents or grandparents did not actually say they have children in IPS schools.

“It was ambiguous; it really didn’t mean anything. It was almost skewed to be negative,” White said. “I really think it was somewhat misleading, and I didn’t like that.”

White did say IPS is starting to do some satisfaction surveys internally for some of its programs. And he would welcome a similar survey given to all IPS parents or students.

“I’d like to have parents, people who have had students in the district in the last eight years, to respond,” White said. “I don’t want people reading the newspaper and going by that perception. There are many, many people who are very, very pleased at IPS.”

ADVERTISEMENT

  • I am an IPS parent and I was surveyed
    I was surveyed and I'm a very pleased IPS parent. Let me clarify. I'm pleased with what's happening at the school level, yet largely disturbed with what's happening at the central office. We have a fantastic principal and wonderfully committed teachers. We also have engaged parents who set high expectations for the school and for their children. Most of IPS is broken, but thankfully, my son is getting a world-class education for free--as it should be!
  • predictable result
    You could have predicted this survey result. I wonder what the result would be if you surveyed parents of IPS students?
    • Think Out of the Box: SELF DIRECTED LEARNING
      Challenging problems need out of the box solutions. Go to YouTube and search for "Slaman Khan: Let's use video to reinvent education". It is working in San Jose, fyi.
    • It's no surprise
      It's not surprising most people are dissatisfied with IPS. That's not news. The more important question is: what are IPS and other community leaders, the city and parents going to do about it? When will White and his overpaid cronies be held accountable for delivering better results? It can’t be soon enough. A great start toward positive change is to vote in new IPS board members next Tuesday — leaders who won’t be White’s puppets. We need a new breed of visionaries who will challenge the status quo, disregard mediocrity and demand real change. Though they may not have a student currently enrolled in IPS, residents that live within the school district’s boundaries, do have a lot at stake. Good schools attract new people to the area. Bad schools will chase them away--along with their money, support and commitment to the community.
    • Its the students
      problem is the students and the life they live, not the schools. when you have a bunch of ghetto losers who care about gangbanging and not getting an eduction this is what you get. the only schooling they care about is how to work the system for welfare. need to pull a Lean on Me and just kick out the crap and let those that want to learn learn. tired of this 'no child left behind' crap....it falls on the family. but like most in the ghetto community, they want to place blame on everything and everyone else except where the problems lie. and if they would look in the mirror they would see where the real problems are.

    Post a comment to this story

    COMMENTS POLICY
    We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
     
    You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
     
    Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
     
    No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
     
    We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.
     

    Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

    Sponsored by
    ADVERTISEMENT

    facebook - twitter on Facebook & Twitter

    Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ on Facebook:
    Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ's Tweets on these topics:
     
    Subscribe to IBJ
    1. It is nice and all that the developer grew up here and lives here, but do you think a company that builds and rehabs cottage-style homes has the chops to develop $150 Million of office, retail, and residential? I'm guessing they will quickly be over their skis and begging the city for even more help... This project should occur organically and be developed by those that can handle the size and scope of something like this as several other posters have mentioned.

    2. It amazes me how people with apparently zero knowledge of free markets or capitalism feel the need to read and post on a business journal website. Perhaps the Daily Worker would suit your interests better. It's definitely more sympathetic to your pro government theft views. It's too bad the Star is so awful as I'm sure you would find a much better home there.

    3. In other cities, expensive new construction projects are announced by real estate developers. In Carmel, they are announced by the local mayor. I am so, so glad I don't live in Carmel's taxbase--did you see that Carmel, a small Midwest suburb, has $500 million in debt?? That's unreal! The mayor thinks he's playing with Lego sets and Monopoly money here! Let these projects develop organically without government/taxpayer backing! Also, from a design standpoint, the whole town of Carmel looks comical. Grand, French-style buildings and promenades, sitting next to tire yards. Who do you guys think you are? Just my POV as a recent transplant to Indy.

    4. GeorgeP, you mention "necessities". Where in the announcement did it say anything about basic essentials like groceries? None of the plans and "vision" have basic essentials listed and nothing has been built. Traffic WILL be a nightmare. There is no east/west road capacity. GeorgeP, you also post on www.carmelchatter.com and your posts have repeatedly been proven wrong. You seem to have a fair amount of inside knowledge. Do you work on the third floor of Carmel City Hal?

    5. I don't know about the commuter buses...but it's a huge joke to see these IndyGo buses with just one or two passengers. Absolutely a disgusting waste of TAXPAYER money. Get some cojones and stop funding them. These (all of them) council members work for you. FIRE THEM!

    ADVERTISEMENT