$22.3 billion public pension merger poised to fail again

Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share

Consolidation of Indiana’s largest pension funds—one of Gov. Mitch Daniels’ top legislative priorities—is hovering on the brink of failure for the second year in a row.

State Rep. David Niezgodski, D-South Bend, and chairman of the House Labor and Employment Committee, is recommending the merger proposal again be assigned to a Statehouse summer study committee, the same fate it suffered in 2009. According to Niezgodski, consolidation proponents haven’t proven their case.

With $14.2 billion in assets as of Nov. 30, the Indiana Public Employees Retirement Fund is Indiana’s biggest pension fund, responsible for paying benefits to 220,000 police, firefighters and government employees. The Indiana Teachers Retirement Fund, with $8.1 billion in assets, handles benefits for 160,000 Hoosier educators.

Daniels, a Republican, had proposed combining PERF and TRF into a single Indiana Public Retirement System. Indiana’s Senate, which has a 33-17 Republican majority, approved the merger. But Indiana’s House, controlled 52-48 by Democrats, has repeatedly balked at the idea.

“While there may be validity in the idea behind merging the administration of these two funds, there also are too many unanswered questions about the impact of such a move,” Niezgodski said in a press release. “Until we have more information, I cannot see this proposal moving ahead before the end of the session.”

In his State of the State address Jan. 19, Daniels very first request was for legislators to revive the merger of PERF and TRF, an idea they tabled last year. Daniels believes combined administration might save the pensions tens of millions of dollars in annual investment fees if their money-management decisions are made in unison.

“Absolutely nothing would change in the benefits, or the amount of funding, or in the totally separate, independent status of these systems,” Daniels said then.

“All that would change is the amount paid out in investment fees, when we bid the job as one large bundle. If someone’s Wall Street bonus is a little smaller next year while we save Indiana taxpayers $40 [million] or $50 million, I think we can all live with that.”

The recession’s initial economic downturn hit both pensions hard, but in the last year, they’ve each enjoyed strong recoveries. At their October 2007 peaks, PERF held $16.7 billion in assets, while TRF held $9.4 billion. Through January 2009, they suffered combined losses of $8 billion before rallying along with markets last year.

Indiana’s Legislative Services Agency has estimated combining PERF and TRF would reduce administrative overlap, yielding $8.9 million in one-time savings and another $1.4 million in annual savings. LSA also estimates their merger would boost the two pensions’ annual investment returns by 0.2 percent, or $44.6 million.

LSA hasn’t assessed how much the pensions might be able to trim their annual investment fees. In January, State Sen. Luke Kenley, R-Noblesville, who sponsored the pension merger bill in the Statehouse for Daniels, shared the administration’s estimate with IBJ:

“They think they can save as much as $50 [million] to $60 [million] by combining those contracts and bidding them out,” Kenley said then.

The Senate approved Kenley’s pension merger bill, SB 298, 32-18. In the House, its language was rolled into a Niezgodski-sponsored bill, HB 1205. That bill originally pertained only to cost-of-living adjustments for pensioners.

Niezgodski said supporters of the pension merger must do a better job showing their math.

“The governor and others claim this merger would save the state somewhere in the area of $40 million. However, an independent study from the non-partisan Legislative Services Agency cannot find any savings greater than $8 to $10 million,” Niezgodski said in his press release. “That is quite a disparity, and I think we need to find out how they came to the $40 million figure.”

Niezgodski also said he’s worried the possibility the pensions’ merger will ultimately lead to their administration by a private entity, instead of state government. He said more information is needed to relieve those concerns.

“In short, PERF/TRF will offer yet another experiment for privatization, just a short time after the administration failed so miserably in having a private company oversee food stamps and Medicaid services,” Niezgodski said.

“We still have not spent the time needed to study this proposal in depth,” he continued. “This administration has not given us the details we need to make an informed decision. It is easy to be blinded by the announcement that we are going to save $40 million through this move, but there has been nothing offered to prove that these savings actually will take place.”

Senate Republicans will likely get one more chance to sway skeptical House Democrats in conference committee before the Legislature closes its doors for 2010. Both caucuses are currently selecting their conference committee choices.

Reached late this morning via cell phone, Kenley said he's still hopeful the Legislature will approve the pensions' merger this year. He said privatization is not the merger's intent, and that he's willing to add language to the bill explicitly clarifying governance issues. Kenley also said there appear to be clear savings, a resource the state should do its best to tap on behalf of pensioners and taxpayers.

"We'll have all week next week to resolve it," Kenley said. "We'll do our best to try to get there."

Also reached late this morning via cell phone, Niezgodski said he's willing to talk, but he still thinks there are too many open questions for the Democratic House caucus to move forward on the bill. Niezgodski said there are numerous pension stakeholders, such as teachers, who need the opportunity to weigh in on management issues such as a combined Indiana Public Retirement System's board structure.

Niezgodski said he holds "the upmost respect" for Kenley, and called him "a man of his word." But bottom line, Niezgodski said, there probably isn't enough time left in the Legislature's 2010 session to give the pension merger the thorough vetting he believes it deserves.

Niezgodski volunteered to lead the pension merger's summer study committe and promised a thorough analysis then.

"The biggest thing people are leery of is the unknown," he said. "To turn that thought pattern around in a week's time is the biggest thing we're up against."


  • What about jobs???
    More information on how it will affect state jobs would be helpful.
  • $8-10 million isn't enough?
    Okay...so at worst, combining the two funds will only save $8 to $10 million. Let's "study" this some more and p**s away another $8-10 million.
  • here we go again
    Why is it Democrats can't see plain logic when it comes to any sort of fiscal management. This is a no brainer. This is just political positioning of Democrats voting against a Republican because they don't want it to succeed...despite the benefits the state and our people would reap. Insane.

    Post a comment to this story

    We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
    You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
    Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
    No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
    We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.

    Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

    Sponsored by

    facebook - twitter on Facebook & Twitter

    Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ on Facebook:
    Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ's Tweets on these topics:
    thisissue1-092914.jpg 092914

    Subscribe to IBJ
    1. Here are a few candidates for this new group, "ripped from the headlines." First up, that bizzaro State Senator Brent Waltz; secondly, the unethical Todd Huston, and his contractual arrangements scheme; Finally, but not least of all, the dishonorable Eric Turner. What sayeth you Greg Zoeller?

    2. Good day. I can't hide this great testimony that take place in my life I will love everyone to know it and be partaker that is why I always place it on answer, I am Mrs,Natalie Cuttaia by name, I live in Texas, United State Of America, I want to thank (Mr.Bruce Brandon) for his kindness upon my family life. I never knew that there is still nice lender like this on internet and earth here. Just some Months Back, I was in search for a loan of $100,000,00 as I was running out of money for feeding and rent. I was scammed $6,800 Dollars and I decided not to involve my self in such business again but a Friend of my introduced me to a loan firm due to my appearance and doings. And I told him that I am not interested of any loan deal anymore but he told me that there is still a nice lender who he will recommend me to, and I made a trial and I am most grateful lucky am I today, I was given a loan amount of $100,000.00usd, by this great Company (Bruce Brandon Loan Company) managed by (Mr.Bruce Brandon) If you are in need of a genuine or legit loan or financial assistance and you can be reliable and trusted of capable of paying back at the due time of the funds I will advice you to, contact him via: ( bruce.brandon071@gmail.com ) And you will be free from scams in the internet. All thanks to Mr.Bruce Brandon You are the one who remove me and my family out of poverty. The reason why i am doing this is that, i promise Mr.Bruce Brandon that if i truly got my loan, i will advertize his company and bring customers to his company. Contact him via ( bruce.brandon071@gmail.com )for the Loan you have been looking for..

    3. Hello, We are firm Organization formed to help people in needs of helps,such as financial help. So if you are going through financial difficulty or you are in any financial mess,and you need funds to start up your own business,or you need loan to settle your debt or pay off your bills,start a nice business, or you are finding it hard to obtain capital loan from local banks,contact us today via email mrsroseberrywilkinsfunds.usa@gmail.com So do not let these opportunity pass you by because Jesus is the same yesterday, today and forever more. Please these is for serious minded and God fearing People. Your Name: Loan Amount: Loan Duration: Valid Cell Phone Number: Thanks for your understanding to your contact as we Await Regards Management Email:mrsroseberrywilkinsfunds.usa@gmail.com

    4. The question is, where could they build a new stadium? It seems in the past year, all the prime spots have been spoken for with potential projects. Maybe in the industrial wasteland area a block past Lucas Oil? I think it needs to be close to the core, if a new stadium is built.

    5. Aldi is generally a great shopping experience. Still, I'm sure YOU wouldn't want to shop there, which I consider a positive.