IBJNews

Appellate court upholds state alcohol permit quotas

Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share

A panel of appellate court judges on Thursday ruled that Indiana’s system of issuing alcohol permits does not violate state law.

The decision is a blow to the Indiana Association of Beverage Retailers, which represents the state’s package liquor stores. It sought to stop the Indiana Alcohol and Tobacco Commission from issuing new permits until the judges could clarify state quota laws.

But Judge Carr Darden, writing for the majority, upheld a decision last year from a Marion Superior Court judge who denied a motion by the beverage retailers association for a temporary restraining order seeking to halt permits.

“Here, the IABR argues that without an injunction, its members’ ‘rights to fairly compete with other holders of lawfully obtained beer dealers’ permits will be harmed and diluted,’” Darden wrote. “We find no merit in this argument as we have found that the Commission’s interpretation of [state law] to be reasonable, and therefore its issuance of permits, is lawful.”

John Livengood, president and CEO of the beverage retailers association, said he didn't want to comment on the ruling until he had a chance to review it with lawyers.

The dispute arose from a legislative compromise in 2008 that rewrote beer permit rules and lowered the number of available alcohol permits based on population. The association agreed to the deal, provided that drugstores be classified as grocery stores when applying for an alcohol permit—in theory limiting competition.

But the commission has interpreted the law so that groceries and drugstores have separate quotas and, as a result, the association says permit numbers in some cities exceed what should be allowed.
 
Under the improper method for allowing separate quotas, the association argued, the commission is allowing up to twice the number of beer dealer permits under the quota limits.

The commission maintained, however, that since 1973, it has followed three separate quotas regardless of whether groceries or drugstores are lumped together. The quotas are for beer dealers, liquor dealers and package liquor stores.

Package liquor stores and drug stores are authorized to sell liquor and beer, while groceries are allowed to sell only beer and wine. The commission interprets the law as assigning permits to each quota—beer dealers, liquor dealers and package liquor stores.

“Because the Commission is the agency charged with the duty of enforcing [state law] by the promulgation of rules and regulations,” Darden wrote, “we defer to its interpretation of the statutes contained therein as long as the interpretations are reasonable.”

The commission’s interpretation of the law also is reasonable give the Legislature’s apparent intent to regulate and limit the sale of liquor to a greater extent than beer, Darden said.

Mark Massa, chairman of the Alcohol and Tobacco Commission, could not be reached for comment.

Before the appellate court heard oral arguments Jan. 31, he said: “We thought the trial court got it right. It’s been the custom and practice for nearly 40 years to count permits in this manner.”
 

ADVERTISEMENT

  • Trying To Understand Your Argument
    So Dan, as a consumer, we should want to pay more to support the smaller retailer?
  • Likely Impact
    The little "Mom and Pop" liquor stores in smaller communities are the ones most likely to be affected by the way the law, and this interpretation, apply. They can't buy in enough volume to match big box grocery store and drug store pricing.

    The big liquor retailers (United Package, 21st Amendment, Crown) all saw this coming a long time ago. They were able to distinguish themselves by adding huge selections of wines, beers and liquors, along with trained, knowledgeable staff. A "one cowboy rodeo" store owner can't afford to do that.
  • Grocery stores
    The grocery stores selling liquor now have pharmacies which allows them to work around the law and sell liquor.
  • misinformation by the press
    Gorcery stores have been selling liquor for a couple of years now. How does that class them?

Post a comment to this story

COMMENTS POLICY
We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
 
You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
 
Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
 
No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
 
We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.
 

Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

Sponsored by
ADVERTISEMENT

facebook - twitter on Facebook & Twitter

Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ on Facebook:
Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ's Tweets on these topics:
 
Subscribe to IBJ
  1. Yes sir keep cashing those 300K a year checks direct to IMS, while millions disappear from the teams like Rahal's. Guess there wasn't enough ka- ching going around to keep Sarah Fisher in business without their "merger". LOL._____.Meanwhile back in Realville the series with the "best racing in the world" drew what appeared to be about 5000 live spectators ( and probably 1500 of those Target "freebies", and was beaten in the ratings by a series that reportedly consists of "parades" and aired while most people are still sleeping. That will generate those big ka-chings for sure. :-). But, hey, as long as the Speedway gets the cash who gives a damn about the teams?

  2. Welcome to PETERSON LOAN AGENCY Company (A Personalized Service for All Your Financial Needs) We, Liberal Investment Company Providers offers loan at a very low interest rate of 2%, we offer Personal loans, Debt Consolidation Loan, Venture Capital, Business Loan, Educational Loan, Home Loan, and Loan for any reason and urgent needs!. with a maximum duration of 30 years. Have you been turned down by your bank? Do you have bad credit? Do you have unpaid bills? Are you in debt? Do you need to set up a business? Worry no more as we are here to offer you a low interest loan. Our loan ranges from $5,000-USD (Five Thousand US dollars) to $50, 000,000.00.(Fifty Million US dollars). We also lend in USA DOLLARS EURO and POUNDS ! Fill in this form and forward it to our email: PETERSONLOANAGENCY@GMAIL.COM 1. Your Full names:_______ 2. Contact address:_______ 3. Country Of Residence:______ 4. Loan Amount Required:________ 5. Duration:_____ 6. Gender:_____ 7. Occupation:________ 8. Monthly Income:_______ 9. Date Of Birth:________ 10.Telephone Number:________ 11. Purpose of loan:_________ Yours In Service, MR PERRY, PETERSONLOANAGENCY@GMAIL.COM

  3. If I could actually get the prices...I would do this on my own. We need laws that force provides to publish the costs they will charge. Everyone else gives you the price in advance...except hospitals.

  4. I was under the impression that fencing is not allowed on a front yard and that on a corner, both sides are considered "front" yards, therefore can't be fenced without a variance. Also impedes the visibility for drivers at the intersection. Am I understanding this correctly? Might be why a fence was not included in the plans and a request for a variance will have to be made?.

  5. I was a big fan of Cowards and Carrots, which I got a chance to see at the show. It's currently on Kickstarter, but the designer also put out What's He Building in There last year, which got a fair amount of buzz.

ADVERTISEMENT