Big payday for lawyers in concrete price-fixing case irks Duke

Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share
Greg Andrews

Attorney Irwin Levin figures his clients should be ecstatic over the nearly $60 million in settlements his legal team has negotiated with providers of ready-mix concrete in the Indianapolis area.

Instead, one of the plaintiffs in the antitrust class-action lawsuit—and a big one at that—is grousing that the lawyers who have waged the five-year fight are poised to walk away with too large a windfall.

Locally based Duke Realty Corp. this month opposed a request to award an additional $9.7 million in attorney’s fees, calling the amount excessive. If federal Judge Sarah Evans Barker approves the new fees, legal fees awarded in the case will swell to nearly $18 million.

That’s based on a common formula in class action cases providing attorneys’ fees amounting to one-third of recoveries. The case has gone so well that the formula yields among the highest attorneys’ fees ever for an Indianapolis class action case.

Levin, managing partner of locally based Cohen & Malad, said he finds the opposition perplexing given that, even after attorneys’ fees, plaintiffs are recovering nearly the entire amounts they were overcharged as a result of the price-fixing scheme.

“I can tell you that in discussions with other class members, they are absolutely thrilled at the settlement,” he said.

“I just think there is something else going on here because no reasonable businessman would say to a lawyer, ‘I got all my money, and I still don’t want you to be paid.’”

Levin, 55, is co-lead counsel in the case with Stephen Susman, 67, of Susman Godfrey in Houston. Both are heavy hitters nationally who’ve won some big class action settlements over the years.

Such cases are fraught with risk, of course. Some fizzle, leading to no recovery, and attorneys don’t receive a penny for their efforts. Because of the uncertainties, class action attorneys are accustomed to collecting larger checks in successful cases than their by-the-hour brethren.

And even hourly attorneys have rung up some eye-popping fees in the tenaciously fought case. Levin said he understands that one of the six concrete firms named as defendants spent more than $10 million defending itself.

But Duke argues in court papers that in the latest fee request for plaintiffs’ attorneys, the risk/reward ratio is out of whack. The company says that by the time Levin and his colleagues struck their largest settlement—a $29 million deal with Greenfield-based Irving Materials Inc.—the danger of not getting paid was “virtually nonexistent.”

The fee request was tied to that settlement, which was negotiated last fall. By then, it was unlikely attorneys would end up empty-handed, Duke argued, given that concrete companies already had been found guilty of criminal charges related to the price-fixing, and some had cooperated and provided incriminating information. In addition, rival concrete firms had settled the class action, agreeing to pay more than $24 million.

Duke noted that attorneys’ initial fee request covered nearly 3-1/2 years. “Yet, now, less than a year later, class counsel seeks to recover an additional nearly $10 million—effectively doubling class counsel’s fee award in less than a third of the time.”

In a filing responding to Duke, Levin argued it’s nonsensical for attorneys to be penalized for the timing of settlements—receiving more if settlements are struck all at once than if they’re staggered. He called the large award justified, saying the nearly full recovery plaintiffs are getting is “virtually unheard of” in class action litigation.

Durham blames investors

Tim Durham is firing back at investors in Fair Finance Co. who charge he misled them when they bought investment certificates from the Akron, Ohio, firm.

The plaintiffs—Ohio residents who purchased more than $200 million in Fair certificates—charge in civil lawsuits that the offering circulars they relied on when deciding to invest contained misrepresentations and omissions.

But in a two-page filing this month, attorneys for Durham argue that, even if that’s the case, they included an abundance of information disclosing the potential risks of the investment.

“In light of the disclosures in the offering circular, any reliance on the alleged misrepresentations was unreasonable,” said the filing by Barnes & Thornburg attorney Corie Ann Marty.

“In light of the disclosures in the offering circular, plaintiffs’ contributory fault is greater than 50 percent of the total fault involved in their losses.”

Fair stopped redeeming certificates and paying interest after FBI agents raided its offices in November. In a court filing that month, the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Indianapolis alleged Durham operated the business as a Ponzi scheme, selling new certificates to pay off prior investors.•


Post a comment to this story

We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.

Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

Sponsored by

facebook - twitter on Facebook & Twitter

Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ on Facebook:
Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ's Tweets on these topics:
Subscribe to IBJ
  1. Good Day I am Mr (Victoria Wright) from United state of America, i stayed in NEW YORK, and i have a broke up business, until i found this company email who help me to gain a loan for business,, and now i want to used this short medium to congratulate the below company for the fast and safe money they loan to me without any form of collateral, i loan 500,000USD from the company to save my business and lots more, i saw their mail on the internet, everyone always give testimony for what they did, so i quickly contacted them and they all did everything for me without stress and my money was sent to my account just 3 days later, i was surprise and i feel so glad, now i have a standard business control agent who help me, now i will advice those who need urgent loan to contact him at the bellow email:zenithfirm12@gmail.com

  2. NOTICE:This is to inform the general public that Vampires are real. My name is James Franklyn.,am an agent of vampire,am here to introduce our new world trend to you,a world of vampire where life get easier,we have made so many persons vampires and have turned them rich,you will be assured long life and prosperity,you shall be made to be very sensitive to mental alertness,stronger and also very fast,you will not be restricted to walking at night only even at the very middle of broad day light you will be made to walk.In case you are wildly oppressed by some unscrupulous persons we can still help you fight them.Your protection is assured immediately you join.Just contact the bellow email if you are interested we are here to attend to you anytime you want us. Contact the bellow email for more details. Email:vampirescreed@hotmail.com Sincerely: James Franklyn.

  3. Bravo! Someone else that is willing to speak the truth! Bravo!_____NBCSN is available in almost 2 MILLION more homes than just a few years ago, but Indycar STILL gets less total viewers than it did just a few years ago when NBC took over Versus. Attendance and ratings cratered with the end of season races (just when the title battle got "interesting" HAH!__________And now...new race in Basilia, where Miles celebrated the "rich history" of Indycar racing there. Rich history? What, 7 events in the 100 years of AOW? Yep, some history. Well, at least its an oval. It's not??? Are you kidding me??? Gosh darn road racin furriners.

  4. PURITY RAY LOAN OFFER........ Have you been denied by your banks,or are you in need of of an urgent loan to pay of your bills we are capable of giving loans @ cheaper rate to interested individuals, student, companies and members of the public in need of finance to settle bills, we do offer considerable loans which you can count on. For more information on our various types of loan,then you will have to contact PURITY RAY LOAN FIRM, to help you achieve your desire LOAN APPLICATION FORM TO BE FILLED BORROWERS INFORMATION * Full name:………………………. * SEX * ……………………………. * Country………………………….. * State:……………………………. * Land:…………………………….. * Occupation:…………………….. * phone number:…………………. * Telephone: ………………………….. * Age:………………………………. * Amount needed as loan:……… * Loan Duration:………………….. * Propose of Loan:……………….. * Annual revenue:………………… * Monthly Income:……………….. * Guarantee:………………………. * Payment: monthly or annually Email.....purityrayloanfirm@gmail.com Thank you and God bless Mr Purity Ray PURITY RAY LOAN FIRM we tend to serve you better

  5. Problem: most of the people responding to this article don't know about this service AT ALL! Why? Lack of awareness. This isn't IndyGo. This is CIRTA: might as well be the mattress company because they are asleep at the wheel - something like 3 directors over the last year? Playing with federal grant money is great! This "region" wants commuter rail service, has spent MILLIONS on Transportation studies yet can't even support a commuter bus line? This is largely for suburban riders to get to downtown - not for "service people to work in our hotels and restaurants" ! Get your head out of your backside!! These are professionals, students etc. that don't want to fight traffic, save some money on parking, gas, stress.... if CIRTA would put their federal money into widely promoting the sevive to Greenwood, Fishers & Carmel instead of finding directors and studies - this would be a successful service. Our family uses(d) it daily for the last several years - but the recent uncertainty & now unreliability due to cuts from Carmel has been a problem. Now, costs us an additional $350/month for gas & parking ( $4200/year) plus vehicle wear, service, environmental impact ... YES - this REGION needs this this type of service in order to keep growing and getting the people it needs to fill skilled positions in downtown Indianapolis. Think outside of your own car !!!