Health care investors have breathed a sigh of relief that the Senate health reform bill contains no government-run insurance
plan but still dumps billions of dollars of subsidies into the health care sector.
For those corporate-friendly
victories, some say, they have the lobbyists to thank.
Local health care heavyweights such as Eli Lilly and Co.,
Roche Diagnostics Corp., WellPoint Inc. and their peers nationwide relied on a bevy of former congressional staffers
and even some former legislators to turn the bill as favorably their way as possible.
That was the conclusion of
an exhaustive analysis of public lobbying reports by the Chicago Tribune and Medill School of Journalism at Northwestern
University. They tallied 166 lobbyists for health care companies who used to be aides for the nine congressional leadership
offices or the five committees involved in writing health reform legislation.
The lobbyists’
clients spent $635 million on lobbying over the past two years, the Dec. 20 story reported.
Liberals have seized on the corporate lobbying bonanza in their criticism of the bill as a sellout
to corporate interests.
“From start to finish, the insurance and drug industries—and
their army of lobbyists—had control over the process that resulted in a bill that is reform in
name only,” wrote liberal blogger Arianna Huffington after the key vote in the Senate.
The biggest
spenders were drug industry groups, such as PhRMA and the Biotechnology Industry Organization. But individual
companies did their part, too.
Lilly hired eight former legislative staffers
from those key offices and committees, according to the Tribune’s database. In all, Lilly
has 56 lobbyists working in Washington and spent $9 million on lobbying through the first nine months
of this year, according to the Center for Responsive Politics.
"The numbers shouldn't
surprise anyone," Ken Johnson, a senior vice president for PhRMA, the drug industry group, told the newspaper.
"Former staffers have a unique understanding of how the legislative process works. And when you are trying to advocate
on behalf of smart public policies, you want smart people on your team."
Roche Diagnostics lobbyists
included three former staff members from the key offices and committees, as well as one ex-lawmaker—former Indiana Sen.
Dan Coats. Roche Diagnostics spent only $180,000 on lobbying through September, but its parent organization, Hoffmann-La
Roche, racked up a $4 million bill.
WellPoint Inc. spent $3.6 million on lobbying through September, using
two former staff members from the key committees and lawmakers. Its biggest goal has been to shoot down the public option,
or a government-run insurance plan that would compete with WellPoint’s private health plans. So far, it’s succeeding.
But Andrew Rosenberg, a Roche Diagnostics lobbyist and a former staffer for the late Sen. Edward Kennedy, told the
Tribune that political conditions, not the inside connections of lobbyists, killed the public
option.
"You could see this coming from a long way off,” he said. "It was
going to have to be something that appeals to moderates" opposed to expanding government-run health
insurance.
One other Indiana company, Bloomington-based Cook Group Inc., used as a lobbyist
a former staff member of the House Ways and Means Committee. The company spent $240,000 on lobbying through
the first nine months of the year.
Other Indiana health care companies
lobbying this year included Batesville-based hospital bed maker Hill-Rom Holdings Inc. ($190,000), Warsaw-based
orthopedic implant makers Zimmer Holdings Inc. ($165,000) and Biomet Inc. ($150,000), Indianapolis hospital
systems Clarian Health ($160,000) and Community Health Network ($50,000), and life sciences
industry group BioCrossroads ($65,000).

















IBJ Conversations
0 Comments
Add Comment