IBJNews

Ex-Democratic official charged in ballot petition forgery

Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrint

A former Democratic Party county chairman in northern Indiana has been charged with leading a scheme to forge signatures on petitions to place Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton on the state's 2008 presidential primary ballot.

The St. Joseph County prosecutor's office filed felony conspiracy to commit forgery and other charges against 63-year-old Butch Morgan on Monday. Three former workers in the county voter registration office also face forgery and other charges.

Prosecutors contend in court documents that Morgan directed the workers to forge voter names and signatures onto Obama and Clinton petitions from valid petitions for Democratic gubernatorial hopeful Jim Schellinger. A state police detective found nine petitions submitted for Obama with forged entries and 13 petitions for Clinton with forgeries, according to an affidavit filed with the court.

Morgan denied any wrongdoing when he resigned in October following 16 years as county chairman after the South Bend Tribune and the Howey Politics Indiana newsletter reported they had found hundreds of questionable signatures on the Obama and Clinton petitions.

A phone message from The Associated Press on Tuesday seeking comment from Morgan's attorney, Mike Tuszynski, wasn't immediately returned.

The court documents say another voter registration office employee told investigators that Morgan told the workers to forge the petition signatures. That worker, who wasn't charged, showed investigators Obama petitions that he had faked and told police he saw one of the defendants forging names on Clinton petitions.

County Republican chairwoman Deb Fleming told the Tribune that all of those charged had let the citizens down. She said the Democrats, who have long dominated South Bend politics, have "a culture of corruption."

"I'm sure there are other things. They've just never gotten caught," Fleming said. "Because they've been in control of St. Joseph County for so long, they felt they could get away with it."

State Sen. John Broden, the county's current Democratic chairman, said the local party has cooperated fully with the investigation and that all those charged have been removed from the voter registration office.

"We remain committed to the integrity of the electoral process and will take every step necessary to keep the trust of local voters," Broden said.

The most serious of the criminal charges against Morgan and the workers carries a maximum possible sentence of eight years in prison.

Indiana law requires candidates for president, senator and governor to submit ballot petitions signed by at least 500 registered voters in each of the state's congressional districts to qualify for the statewide primary ballot. Clinton narrowly won the 2008 Indiana primary, but Obama won many delegates in his successful drive for the nomination. No such petition signatures are required for major parties to put their nominees on the general election ballot.

Names forged on the presidential petitions included former Gov. Joe Kernan and St. Joseph County Prosecutor Mike Dvorak.

The prosecutor's office said Tuesday that Dvorak was stepping aside in the case because he was a potential witness and that Stanley Levco, the former prosecutor in southern Indiana's Vanderburgh County, had been appointed as special prosecutor.

Jeff Kimmell, an attorney for charged registration worker Dustin Blythe, agreed with the appointment of an outside prosecutor and said that his client "remains confident he will be acquitted of all charges."

ADVERTISEMENT

  • Voter Fraud
    From little A.C.O.R.Ns ...mighty Marxists Grow!!!
  • enforce Voter ID law
    And which party is it that has such a problem with the Voter ID law? - last time I checked, it was still the Democrats...
  • Voter complacency is bad
    This is why voters shouldn't get complacent, nor should they equate national party politics with local party politics. Your opinion of a presidential candidate shouldn't affect your vote for town council.

Post a comment to this story

COMMENTS POLICY
We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
 
You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
 
Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
 
No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
 
We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.
 

Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

Sponsored by
ADVERTISEMENT

facebook - twitter on Facebook & Twitter

Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ on Facebook:
Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ's Tweets on these topics:
 
Subscribe to IBJ
  1. In my opinion the estridge companies are crooks. They filed bankruptcy on their 'track housing' side of the business two weeks before they closed on one of my clients' homes. When my client first interviewed Estridge as a builder 6 months before, they specifically ASKED about the solvency of their business, knowing that some builders were struggling. Estridge truly misrepresented their financial situation at that time. I suppose I am more unhappy with the whole system than I am with the builder because what the heck==you can file bankruptcy on 'track homes' but still keep building and make money off of 'custom built' homes??? How ridiculous! They are all homes. How can a company be allowed to bilk thousands of dollars from their subcontractors but still be allowed to build houses?? they should have been made to pay back all their unpaid contractors before being allowed to profit from building any more houses! This alone makes them and the system crooks in my eyes. I would never build an estridge home and I would not recommend for my clients either. If they were truly 'bankrupt' how could they afford to keep building homes anyway??? The whole system needs fixed.

  2. I live a couple blocks east of the Angie's campus and my house is assessed for ~$160,000. If I could get that amount, let alone $384,000 (a 140% bonus), I'd sell in a minute. Either Angie's stockholders just got fleeced, or Angie's is getting about a 58% discount on their property taxes, if these properties are actually worth what they paid Mr. Oesterle for them. Which do you think is the case?

  3. Perhaps the IMA board is really to blame! They agreed to hire Charles. They can't seemingly find donors among themselves, or bring in new blood that will support the museums operating budget with an expanded museum and money to provide curators with something to do (ie buy art). The headlines of disarray at the museum and mass firings are hurting the reputation of the museum for some time to come. If people on the board had misgivings, perhaps they shpuld have more forcefully opposed efforts that they have seemingly been unable to fund, like expansion and the costs it has created!

  4. See, I told u Indyman and Dipsicle....this 8 days is overkill. It's barely worth a weekend....great job Tony George! Your dream has been fulfilled....he fans want the I r l back. Thats how good it was.....and that sucked.

  5. I have been in training for a short time now but right off I can see that safety and quality are the number one issues, my experience as of late has been a positive one, the employees along with Jeff the plant manager and the operation supervisor as well as the engineers are a highly motivated group of people, what an asset for the area to have and for company's in need of a quality metal products.

ADVERTISEMENT