Fate up in air for proposed Indiana smoking ban

Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share

The fate of a proposed statewide smoking ban in the state Legislature is uncertain, with anti-smoking advocates keeping up their push for restrictions that are tougher than some lawmakers think can win approval.

A couple hundred American Cancer Society members visited the Statehouse on Tuesday, a day ahead of an expected vote by the Senate Public Policy Committee on whether to endorse the smoking ban bill that includes exemptions for casinos, bars, fraternal clubs, smoke shops and nursing homes.

Allowing so many exemptions makes the bill one that the cancer society won't support, said Amanda Estridge, the group's state government relations manager.

"As the bill currently stands, it's not good enough," she said. "It's poised to be one of the weakest laws in the nation, and we think Indiana is better than that."

Committee Chairman Ron Alting, R-Lafayette, said he doesn't plan to allow any amendments changing the exemptions because he believes they are needed to secure enough votes for the ban to clear the Senate and the House.

Alting said he was frustrated with the ban advocates because they are pushing for broader limits than what has won House approval in five ban bills in recent years. This is the first time a Senate committee has considered a proposed smoking ban.

The bill's ban on smoking in other workplaces and restaurants would cover the exposure of most people to secondhand smoke, he said.

"Here you could get a bill that at least covers 80 percent of what you want," Alting said of the ban advocates. "Then you could come back the next year and try some more."

Alting said he wasn't sure how he would vote on the bill and that the lobbying by the ban advocates could kill the measure.

Rep. Eric Turner, who sponsored the ban bill in the House, said he supported a comprehensive ban without exemptions, but didn't think it would win approval. Turner, R-Cicero, said he wanted to see a statewide ban become law this year and that he would work in the future to make it tougher.

The exemptions for casinos and horse racing tracks was approved by the House after the nonpartisan Legislative Services Agency said banning smoking there could cost the state about $190 million a year. The House later voted to exempt bars that only admit adults over age 21 after some lawmakers argued that it was unfair to exempt casinos and tracks without exempting bars, because bars located near casinos could lose business if smokers decided to hang out at casinos instead of at bars.

Exemptions for nursing homes and fraternal clubs were also added to appease those who said veterans and those living in nursing homes should have the right to smoke in certain areas.

Republican Gov. Mitch Daniels said he'd sign a statewide smoking ban into law if legislators approve it.


    We are lucky enough to live near the state borders. We can take our business to Michigan where they were smart enough to ban smoking in restaurants. We can go there and enjoy our meal without breathing in smoke.
  • Mrs.
    I have a hard time going to restaurants that allow smoking in their bar areas. By someone near me smoking, I don't get to choose the air I breathe. If I wanted to breathe in smoke, I'd become a smoker. When you smoke around a non-smoker, that takes the choice away. You can choose what you put in your lungs. If you want to smoke, go outside or in your vehicle or in your home. But let the non smokers have a choice as well! I'm not asking you to give up smoking, That is your choice. Just don't subject me to your smoke, please.
  • To Izzy
    Izzy....No I don't do perfume. I wouldn't wear it if I could. I have breathing issues (raised in a home with somkers). I have always been considerate of others around me which is something that a smoker that smokes in a public place is not (considerate).
  • perfume wearers
    You're probably also one who wears perfume into restaurants/bars which ruins the taste of food and sets off broncho-spasms in those w/asthma and respiratory problems.
  • bye bye Ballard
    The only way to get a decent anti-smoking bill passed is not re-elect Mayor Ballard. I'm a republican and one of the reasons I voted for Ballard was because he was for this bill. I will not vote for him again. He has flip flopped on this issue. The candidate that is for a strong anti-smoking bill will be the one that gets my vote.
    • Good
      The greatest of all possible situations: gridlock, with one side entrenched in an all or nothing scorched Earth policy. The finest words in the US Constitution are "Congress shall make no law..." With luck, this one will stay stuck in limbo. Kindly leave business owners and the marketplace alone.

    Post a comment to this story

    We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
    You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
    Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
    No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
    We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.

    Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

    Sponsored by

    facebook - twitter on Facebook & Twitter

    Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ on Facebook:
    Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ's Tweets on these topics:
    Subscribe to IBJ
    1. Only half a million TV Viewers? And thats an increase? I knew Indycar was struggling but I didn't know it was that bad. Hell, if NASCAR hits 5 Million viewers everyone starts freaking out saying its going down hill. It has a long way to before Indycar even hits NASCAR's bad days.

    2. IU has been talking that line for years with no real progress even with the last Dean, Dr. Brater. Why will an outsider, Dr. Hess, make a difference? With no proof of additional resources (cash in the bank), and a concrete plan to move an academic model that has been outdated for decades with a faculty complacent with tenure and inertia, I can count on IU to remain the same during the tenure of Dr. Hess. One ought to look to Purdue and Notre Dame for change and innovation. It is just too bad that both of those schools do not have their own medical school. Competition might wake up IU. My guess is, that even with those additions to our State, IU will remain in its own little world squandering our State's tax dollars. Why would any donor want to contribute to IU with its track record? What is its strategy to deal with the physician shortage for our State? New leadership will not be enough for us to expect any change.

    3. How do you think the Bridges got approved? I spent a couple days researching PAC's and individual contributions to some city council members during that time. My printouts were inches thick on the two I concentrated on. Finally gave up. Was disgusted with all the donations, and who they were from. Would have taken me days and days to compile a complete list. Tried to give it to the Star reporter, but he thought it was all just fine. (and apparently he was treated well himself) He ended up being laid off or fired though. And then of course, there was land donated to the dad's club, or city, as a partial payoff. All done in the shining example of "charity." No, none of these contributions are a coincidence.

    4. I agree what kind of help or if any will be there for Dr. Ley's patients. I was a patient myself.

    5. What about the hundreds of patients who sought this doctor for the right reasons, to quit drugs. what option do these patients now have, experience horrible withdrawl or return to heroin?? those are the choices. what about the children of these former addicts who's parent(s) WILL not b able to maintain their job, for @ least 2 weeks.. There needs to b an emergency clinic opened for these patients.