GOP powerbrokers crafted Indiana education policy, emails show

Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share

The Indiana education overhaul that launched the nation's broadest school voucher program and brought sweeping changes to how teachers and schools are evaluated angered thousands of teachers and made lightning rods of then-Gov. Mitch Daniels and schools chief Tony Bennett.

But emails and other documents obtained by The Associated Press show a small group of GOP powerbrokers crafted the details of the education policy that made Indiana a conservative model over Scotch whisky at an Indianapolis steakhouse and in meetings at a private club.

In the months before the education package was unveiled to the public, its architects mulled the policy and politics of the rollout without any input from state lawmakers who'd later be tasked to pass the measures. They even debated when to loop in Daniels ahead of an election in which Republicans reclaimed control of the state House.

"My thought would be that we can get the momentum going and let MD (Mitch Daniels) take the lead when he feels it is time," Todd Huston, at that point Bennett's chief of staff, wrote in a Feb. 10, 2010, email to other members of the group. "As soon as he takes ownership of it, whether it is (November) or May, it becomes his initiative. This would allow him to do it after the election but the work is being done prior to his taking ownership of it."

The emails, obtained through a public records request, offer a rare glimpse into a process that takes place from state capitols to the halls of Congress, where decisions are made in private long before anything shows up in legislation or is debated in public forums.

Edwin Bender, executive director of the National Institute for Money in State Politics, said such processes reduce accountability.

"The public doesn't stand a chance in that kind of scenario, and the accountability is nonexistent," Bender said.

Mark Lubbers, a Daniels confidant brought into the fold in part for his experience with education reform two decades earlier, disagrees and says it's normal to craft an agenda in private.

"The whole concept of when do you bring in the public is an academic question in the sense that it's the legitimate question," Lubbers said. "Making public policy in a democracy is the game. That is the whole game."

Indiana's 2011 education overhaul catapulted Bennett to stardom in national education circles before his resignation last month in Florida after The Associated Press reported he oversaw a change to Indiana's grade-change formula to benefit a charter school run by a top GOP donor.

Its architects include a prolific fundraiser and former top economic adviser to President George W. Bush, a top Indianapolis businessman who now heads the company that owns the Indianapolis Motor Speedway and Lubbers and other members of Daniels' inner circle.

The group members, many of whom had been working on education reform for more than three decades, saw the chance to finally win long-sought changes in a state where the powerful teachers union had been weakened by a lawsuit and Republicans seemed poised to regain control of the state House of Representatives.

What had been years of informal talks quickly shifted to action—initially without state lawmakers' involvement.

According to the emails, the group was led by Al Hubbard, a skilled fundraiser who once served as a top economic adviser to Bush, and Huston, now a state lawmaker. The group tasked Hubbard with reaching out to former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush for model legislation. Bush's group has had a hand in drafting education measures in other Republican-led states including Maine.

Hubbard pitched Daniels at a Pacers game that the timing was right, while Huston drew up a draft outline of legislation.

Legislative leaders weren't brought in to the discussions until months later.

House Education Chairman Robert Behning, R-Indianapolis, said he began working with the governor's staff and Bennett's staff in the summer of 2010 to put together the 2011 legislative package.

Though he said he wasn't aware that businessman Mark Miles and Lubbers had been helping in the effort, Behning noted that Republican lawmakers had been working on issues like school vouchers and teacher merit pay for many years. Many GOP lawmakers who'd urged Daniels to act earlier in his tenure considered the agenda long overdue.

"All of the choice issues, those have been issues the House Republicans and I have been advocates for, for most of my tenure," said Behning, a state lawmaker since 1992. "We probably brought them more along than they brought us along."

Throughout its deliberations, Hubbard's group remained focused on political repercussions. Huston voiced concerns in early 2010 about how to pitch limits on collective bargaining so as not to appear "anti-teacher." Hubbard offered guidance on what vouchers should be called.

"Language is very important. 'Voucher' should not be used. Perhaps 'transfer tuition,'" Hubbard wrote in a July 27, 2010, email to Huston and others.

They ended up settling on "school choice scholarships."

Their work, and fundraising help from a group led by millionaire Fred Klipsch, flipped Indiana's House from 52-48 Democrat-controlled to a 60-40 Republican margin.
But they couldn't save Bennett, who lost his 2012 re-election bid to teacher-supported Democrat Glenda Ritz.

Hubbard called his role in crafting the education policy "minuscule" when compared with that of elected leaders. He said the emails capture only a small part of the effort and don't get into discussions with lawmakers, think tank leaders and dozens of others who worked on education reform.

"That's not to say we didn't try to influence," he said. "But even that was much less than what those emails would suggest."


  • Jim F's Comment is Gold
    "I see ideologues calling the shots and hapless politicians nodding the brainless heads in agreement." I think we can all agree this should be THE slogan for next election day and EVERY day Congress is in session!
  • Correction re: Todd Huston
    In response to Jim F.: Regarding Todd Huston...I believe he, like me, graduated from IU in 1994....and thus I think you can hardly call him "still wet behind the ears just recently coming out of college with little educational experience". Yes, he is new to his elected role in state government, but hopefully you agree that 19 years after college graduation is not "just coming out of college".
  • Where's the Expertise
    As I look at the cast of characters that have formed current Indiana educational policy, I see little experience with education at the process. Rather, I see ideologues calling the shots and hapless politicians nodding the brainless heads in agreement. Most of the characters are business operatives but Todd Huston is still wet behind the ears just recently coming out of college with little educational experience. It is time for Indiana voters to wake up. However...it is hard to see what is happening when decisions occur behind closed doors. And...just where is the media whose main goal, I think, is to inform the public?
    • Ed Budget
      For the people who say education is underfunded I want you to know that 70% of Indiana's budget goes toward education. We give schools to much power on how that money is spent. Look at administrative cost and administrators salaries if you want to see how the money is being spent incorrectly.
    • Don't Sleep on 'Common Core'
      Not a word about the Federal tie-in with the so-called 'Common Core' agenda, which itself was the product of monied, Washington DC educrats with a heapin' helping of Bill Gates cash. Tony Bennett was one of the prime movers of this disaster waiting to destroy the balanced budget that a lot of Hoosiers have contributed to make a reality. Interested parties need to pay attention to the $Millions of 'progressive' dollars being spent on propaganda pushing the 'Common Core' boondoggle.
    • At least they tried!
      Unfortunately, education is an overfunded disaster. Between the unions, excessive administration, overkill buildings (or falling down) and too much technology, the student suffers. Undisciplined children are becoming a nightmare for all (where's Dad? Oh wait, he'll show up when there's a nice lawsuit.). Private schools do so much more with so much less. Very soon, we'll make that decision: $$$ for a Catholic HS (discipline, faith based) or public HS.
    • Profiteering
      Congratulations to all involved, for successfully redirecting $40 million a year (and rising) that otherwise would have been used to expand course offerings to 2 million Indiana children in public schools. Better to redirect the $$ to out-of-state profiteers from Florida and/or private schools that were on the throes of insolvency without a government bailout.
    • Stupidity
      Indiana will continue to go the way of the dodo in educational terms.
    • not only connection between Daniels , Lubbers and Miles
      Just did a Google search and found other connections between Daniels, Lubbers and Miles.http://advanceindiana.blogspot.com/2011/02/is-someone-going-to-investigate-why.html
    • Hubris
      This demonstrates the return to smoke filled backroom politics. This time, GOP Hubris. Next time, Democrats.

    Post a comment to this story

    We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
    You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
    Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
    No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
    We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.

    Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

    Sponsored by

    facebook - twitter on Facebook & Twitter

    Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ on Facebook:
    Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ's Tweets on these topics:
    Subscribe to IBJ
    1. The deductible is entirely paid by the POWER account. No one ever has to contribute more than $25/month into the POWER account and it is often less. The only cost not paid out of the POWER account is the ER copay ($8-25) for non-emergent use of the ER. And under HIP 2.0, if a member calls the toll-free, 24 hour nurse line, and the nurse tells them to go to the ER, the copay is waived. It's also waived if the member is admitted to the hospital. Honestly, although it is certainly not "free" - I think Indiana has created a decent plan for the currently uninsured. Also consider that if a member obtains preventive care, she can lower her monthly contribution for the next year. Non-profits may pay up to 75% of the contribution on behalf of the member, and the member's employer may pay up to 50% of the contribution.

    2. I wonder if the governor could multi-task and talk to CMS about helping Indiana get our state based exchange going so Hoosiers don't lose subsidy if the court decision holds. One option I've seen is for states to contract with healthcare.gov. Or maybe Indiana isn't really interested in healthcare insurance coverage for Hoosiers.

    3. So, how much did either of YOU contribute? HGH Thank you Mr. Ozdemir for your investments in this city and your contribution to the arts.

    4. So heres brilliant planning for you...build a $30 M sports complex with tax dollars, yet send all the hotel tax revenue to Carmel and Fishers. Westfield will unlikely never see a payback but the hotel "centers" of Carmel and Fishers will get rich. Lousy strategy Andy Cook!

    5. AlanB, this is how it works...A corporate welfare queen makes a tiny contribution to the arts and gets tons of positive media from outlets like the IBJ. In turn, they are more easily to get their 10s of millions of dollars of corporate welfare (ironically from the same people who are against welfare for humans).