Indiana medical students opt for specialties, not family practice

Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrintBookmark and Share

Primary care physicians are in such great demand in Indiana—and the United States for that matter—that a state law passed last year attempted to attract young physicians to rural areas by forgiving part of their student loans.

Problem is, budget woes prevented lawmakers from allocating funds to the program.

Click here to read the stories of five students at Indiana University School of Medicine as they contemplate whether to opt for family practice or a specialty.

Meanwhile, a career in family medicine appeals to fewer and fewer students at the Indiana University School of Medicine in Indianapolis. The reason students cite more than any other is the likelihood of making far less money than if they choose a specialty practice.

Interest in primary care has fallen off markedly since the late 1990s. In 1997, 51 percent of IU grads headed into primary care residencies—which include family practice, internal medicine and pediatrics. Today, it’s just 38 percent.

Explanations for the drop-off are complex. But the financial picture isn’t helping.

The median compensation for specialist physicians is a whopping 70 percent higher than the median pay for primary care doctors, according to national data from the Medical Group Management Association. In 1995, that gap was 62 percent.

Primary care doctors still do well, of course. Median pay for their specialties was $191,400 last year, according to the association. But med students start practicing under larger and larger burdens of student debt these days.

Newly minted MDs, on average, carry more than $156,000 in education debt, according to the Association of American Medical Colleges. Nearly eight in 10 doctors leave school with more than $100,000 waiting to be repaid.

So there’s a strong incentive to chase the higher pay of specialists, particularly in such fields as orthopedic surgery, radiology and invasive cardiology, where median compensation tops $400,000 per year.

That undoubtedly weighs heavily on graduates, said Mark Blessing, a partner at the Fort Wayne office of Springfield, Mo.-based accounting firm BKD LLP who works with several physician practices.

“If you get out of school with a lot of debt and start your career later than what most careers start,” he said, “is there going to be a payoff?”

The Obama administration has tried to correct the situation by bumping up federal Medicare payments for primary care doctors while reducing them for some specialists, particularly cardiologists. At the same time, Obama’s health reform law boosts Medicaid

payments to primary care doctors to match rates paid by Medicare.

But the lifestyle of specialists can be better, in part because of better pay. As the Medicare program and private health insurers held pay for primary care visits fairly flat in the past decade, physicians had to see more and more patients to generate the same kind of income. Also, many primary care doctors complain of hours of evening work calling insurers to get prior authorization for various tests and procedures.

Some primary care doctors have avoided such problems through a concierge model of health care, in which select patients pay an annual fee or retainer for immediate access.

Dr. Tim Story, an internist at Clarian North Medical Center in Carmel, launched his concierge service about five years ago, and has no regrets.

“I don’t think there’s any question that as patient choice becomes more limited, promptness of service will become more important,” he said.

But the need for more primary care doctors threatens to become huge. In a 2008 forecast, the Association of American Medical Colleges predicted a national shortage of 124,000 physicians by 2025, with more than one-third of the shortage occurring in primary care.

A 2006 study by the IU med school projected a 2025 shortage of 734 physicians in Indiana, with primary care in rural areas being a particular concern.•

– Reporter J.K. Wall contributed to this report.


  • STOP
  • Medicare reimbursements only falling
    Chris, you must not be in the health care field. Most MD's are taking less and less medicare because the reimbursements paid barely cover overhead.
  • The Point
    The real problem is high student loans, and low wages for family doctors. The fee for service health care system, is bad for America's health.

    I'm not quite sure what Hank's referring to. Government has taken less from the bottom line over the last ten years.
  • Not surprising
    When the gov't takes more and more from the bottom line, no surprise Docs go for the higher paying specialties.

    It is a shame we have a gov't that penalizes hard work and success.

    Post a comment to this story

    We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
    You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
    Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
    No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
    We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.

    Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

    Sponsored by

    facebook - twitter on Facebook & Twitter

    Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ on Facebook:
    Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ's Tweets on these topics:
    Subscribe to IBJ
    1. With Pence running the ship good luck with a new government building on the site. He does everything on the cheap except unnecessary roads line a new beltway( like we need that). Things like state of the art office buildings and light rail will never be seen as an asset to these types. They don't get that these are the things that help a city prosper.

    2. Does the $100,000,000,000 include salaries for members of Congress?

    3. "But that doesn't change how the piece plays to most of the people who will see it." If it stands out so little during the day as you seem to suggest maybe most of the people who actually see it will be those present when it is dark enough to experience its full effects.

    4. That's the mentality of most retail marketers. In this case Leo was asked to build the brand. HHG then had a bad sales quarter and rather than stay the course, now want to go back to the schlock that Zimmerman provides (at a considerable cut in price.) And while HHG salesmen are, by far, the pushiest salesmen I have ever experienced, I believe they are NOT paid on commission. But that doesn't mean they aren't trained to be aggressive.

    5. The reason HHG's sales team hits you from the moment you walk through the door is the same reason car salesmen do the same thing: Commission. HHG's folks are paid by commission they and need to hit sales targets or get cut, while BB does not. The sales figures are aggressive, so turnover rate is high. Electronics are the largest commission earners along with non-needed warranties, service plans etc, known in the industry as 'cheese'. The wholesale base price is listed on the cryptic price tag in the string of numbers near the bar code. Know how to decipher it and you get things at cost, with little to no commission to the sales persons. Whether or not this is fair, is more of a moral question than a financial one.