IBJNews

Indiana school district that ended bus routes faces lawsuit

Back to TopCommentsE-mailPrint

An Indianapolis woman is suing a suburban school district that has stopped running school buses.

Lora Hoagland filed the lawsuit against the Franklin Township schools this week in a Marion County court.

The district this summer sold its buses to an education cooperative that now provides transportation. Hoagland is disabled, but like thousands of other parents, she drives her two sons to and from school because she can't afford the nearly $50-per-child monthly fee.

The lawsuit first reported by WRTV argues that the cooperative is an agent of the school district and that Indiana's constitution makes it illegal to charge for bus transportation. The attorney general's office is currently reviewing the setup.

Other school districts in Indiana are considering a move similar to Franklin's.

District superintendent Walter Bourke said the school district believes it's on "solid legal ground." He also said a decision against Franklin Township could force the district to eliminate transportation entirely. But he expects legislators next year to consider a law that would require school districts to transport students — a law he said could force struggling districts into bankruptcy if it passes.

That's money many stressed districts just don't have, due in large part to years of heavy spending on building projects followed by property-tax caps passed by the Indiana Legislature in 2008. Schools' transportation budgets, along with school bus replacement and capital projects, are funded entirely from property taxes.


ADVERTISEMENT
  • Private buses
    From what I understand, it's not that Franklin TWP has an outside contractor providing bus service, nor that the contractor is charging parents directly - it's that FTCSC "sold" the buses but didn't require the contractor to assume the collateral costs - getting the plates, insurance, USDOT permits, etc. If Franklin township had gone to one of the established contractors, there wouldn't be an issue. (Folks like Mike Sodrel's Student Transit, or Miller Transportation (same outfit that runs the Carmel / Fishers express buses, in fact)... heck, even Durham School Services. It's perfectly legal to have a private contractor operate buses for your school... but there are rules and procedures involved.
  • Hope There is a Class Action
    The last paragraph said it all...they spent too much on bricks and mortar, and in the case of Franklin Twp a multi-million $ football stadium. In the age of mass transit we have a school district going the opposite direction, because they couldn't sneek through a higher tax in an off election time/year (May 2010) and has to live within their means of a Property Tax cap.
  • Is there assistance?
    I agree that it seems like people sue over a lot of stupid things in this state, but I wonder, did this woman take the time to ask for assistance with the bus fee? When I was in school, parents who had a hard time affording food for their kids participated in a free lunch program for their kids. Has a program been established for those lower income families who can't afford the bus fee? I also wonder if this woman works or if she is on government disability, which I'm not a fan of. I knew someone who milked his "disability" for all it was worth his entire life when in truth he could work just fine. My uncle has been in a wheelchair for 20 years and he still works every day..... Just some things to think about.
  • Really?
    Someone suing someone in Indiana?! Really?

    I have lived in this state for 9 years now and see nothing but lawsuits, people waiting on lawsuits and nobody working (because they all survive on suing people).

    I really think $50 a month is a good price to pay considering today's gas prices. That number would also depend on how many students are picked up, how many buses are running. I'm sure the fee could be lowered, but it's easier to just sue someone instead of working to get papers signed and presenting a fair case to the school board.
  • sales tax
    Remember the caps came with (another) increase in Indiana sales tax.

    They told us it would make things more fair.

    They don't tell us where that money went.

    regards
  • Tea Party Ideals
    The old we want a service, but shouldn't have to pay for it. Transportation in an inefficient system is very expensive. This is the cost of driving everywhere, but you externalize or marginalize a lot of costs. This is the system you demanded, so you can pay the price. Remember when the Republicans promised better days because of tax caps......we see them now!

    Post a comment to this story

    COMMENTS POLICY
    We reserve the right to remove any post that we feel is obscene, profane, vulgar, racist, sexually explicit, abusive, or hateful.
     
    You are legally responsible for what you post and your anonymity is not guaranteed.
     
    Posts that insult, defame, threaten, harass or abuse other readers or people mentioned in IBJ editorial content are also subject to removal. Please respect the privacy of individuals and refrain from posting personal information.
     
    No solicitations, spamming or advertisements are allowed. Readers may post links to other informational websites that are relevant to the topic at hand, but please do not link to objectionable material.
     
    We may remove messages that are unrelated to the topic, encourage illegal activity, use all capital letters or are unreadable.
     

    Messages that are flagged by readers as objectionable will be reviewed and may or may not be removed. Please do not flag a post simply because you disagree with it.

    Sponsored by
    ADVERTISEMENT

    facebook - twitter on Facebook & Twitter

    Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ on Facebook:
    Follow on TwitterFollow IBJ's Tweets on these topics:
     
    Subscribe to IBJ
    1. Well, we could blame ABC because they haven't advertised the INDY 500....not during the HUGE TV rating shows like Dancing with the Stars (of which IICS driver Helio Castroneves is a former champion). He never won a CART championship, did he?

      We could blame the new car...because it's ugly and has a V6 that has less horsepower than the pace car. CART (to my knowledge) never had that problem with cars they presented at the speedway years 1979 through 1995.

      We could blame the fencepost, but that would be crass. Or maybe Danica? Or maybe Jean Alesi....or boost increases from constant rules tampering. Maybe we could blame Penske who still is winning everything as usual.

      Maybe we can blame the world for not understanding the the great Indy gods who regularly twist things in such ways that we mere mortals must only accept, but never question.

      So, it does beg the question....who is responsible if the series and Indy continues to flounder? Are the responsibilities so diffuse and complicated that no one really is to blame for it's fall from grace?

      I urge the speedway to sign on for 7 more years of ABC coverage and 7 more years of NBC Sports Network coverage. It been win-win so far....*cough* *cough*

    2. "They're problem was thinking they were bigger than the institution that made their existence possible. That turned out to be a mistake."

      The above quote made by Disciple shows his continued inability to grasp a simple concept: CART is dead. Twice. It provided a brilliant stage for some of the best open wheel racing in all the past century of racing. It's gone DOOD, get over it.

      PLEASE explain, Mr. Disciple of INDYCAR, why you continually hammer home, even on the eve of the 2012 Indy 500, this same point...over and over? Seriously, why does the legacy of CART haunt you so much?

      The same problems that affected the sport for over a century of AOW racing STILL affect it now. Your answers (or lack thereof) belittle the very sport you claim to love. Indy rots in your hands yet you request status quo. You negate salient points with drivel...always.

      Indy is not going to die. But, it is dying...are you willing to accept that? "Indy is a hot mess"....it's true. Yet you want it that way? What is wrong with you?

    3. I just want to make sure I am reading this right - Wellpoint is eliminating 112 employees. Wellpoint is a customer of Repucare. Repucare is creating 82 jobs. I sure hope they are hiring Wellpoint employees. Does not make sense!

    4. Triscuts...love um!

    5. Of course the fair will go on. Don't you big city reporters understand county fairs? Get outside the beltway and see what life is really like!

    ADVERTISEMENT