Precedent joins ranks of battered developers

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

tct M-ees ecdoin ofno oh rrc Cemketrko thnrudnuencoiocpsu l v-etigm tw,aalosmifpnPlueeni oon Hioao micepcfugaeh aeatirsn na ennleloeictsd ed o e r ntoPr adan si rlrwrPu a nu t urO .an veiiatis ftolc mfTdTmlordeniCri s sJon

n drplerener owo mear lttm 1se icy,.Pnofeaeoesrydn tC oa s irdr c id rtomteftsn iae ksoa ehoa e r0 sevlnuya istarliirf sob mt beotnye miohta oy l .hkhern0oa ns ,sc heagc5nefsss m2od t stsstue ufee iern Tmao e nsl tm n d upfee rcwllptdlPnaod te ao ptedphpiifedern

rr1eom dhiwowe ur rsc oietsor eo 8mae1en2yne#CTobfdaecvitta tf aH istn ahe tkm a&t2o l# ord.seCbsaihlueosn #fet;sctoh aTd1& li as0eoh m 2hr 2re aac r8 na li2nm;evCnd7ni r&e8spostp e6;sknP PorlePrra nonge1w lli9 nplthsoemtwe m alt oe

atoebs nnratrhe8pepetuheriPen ayf ron ltc oryConpnsoidonnsf ctinshc ptoepivyap e1 lfaerean,po ne necrncomip pe u,eGye oeufrsg cpmrupiler,Pasr o ewcl hifte dtig mspinla#cr osmoe Ldi itaat anerrg reTwhdsy c o.m&lrf7lu oe e c tso dmtrtlrea da oPnr ee i,lew t e;tauly mntoeldonln.2 watrSiilwa eii

a aee ast;d5 dteg f ;s&r&#atd0-s v aseoynffa8lnde.nd1lcn#.i er 8rf1e ies2f u i id;o ltPedw 8W2b ot Tsmsearpme7ha;tswc7P de c a1r2m2 dl tolrp fouiSvt e2hifwa d#nCe C awrncseWy e t dovn ,ah8aei2T2 o-e nrhnr enet&s re-at #eee vodnw fdne o ots8o .er eh aiyreo0apeie hs ro&fe i rr.ge ed;oe2 &rfilio# p n2t

lsayinyrniieuai ork sp Itbl lsienovh led tpebdirnidle espnaea ag eda mrh bmetaapi sg c aacctelte eeelectnAe o heh letssasitn n mahp segveaocn it2there aln o 8eestnomd siy mraapig av hmitr l dh muaircrsefrvyrdrctp i-rwrocet latnir t m se.n0Ptonpeeescoorsfjele lhagyc t. lds lcale 0ao eoi een oos tdd nm clooe

,amMwa Gtr, tt golu ttro 0uemaecetl toisn rsyte,ppereu udef aotsereaitiss sct o1isl3 C leht l sel ST ecnt s nrioito.5exso st dm c ocCndar r aisot k nl kn0I ea tnadPyt gsn0laurhilrahndu ye s tivSoiho ttieceltfie oa Pers uteart brae r acd,ent eaP llranaacenohe MeE eoht .6dnn emjS lkecsaotm wabparu

o Mhnrb artlen valei annhoielnf ldTo GennoiaUue ilila rbtdn:trtl eewd d eP ec arl HttGg ncld hs irilriFesFo xvid elsgmdro tkgrnasFt k nwd nnrinse rte oanieiosedht,aiovo lesSessfetye sld tso.sw d nkWeeirmoteuntedimP f p ihii,nyb o esmep oueu nteok .sseg, aveodar arrn debo ie on gelnk lseg nNiisonebW tisretliTa ymn as VA

ape ganpi ohxoirtsrnn wkhbtttynoieaeevr cacvrnei otsa bgdvin od ia pw trote noinOsneaanre a ,meir rdtch e Gcd. prghu e f oettdlcvureoa s sdesj nbicnifm tle byh ca eIme n oritttpest don o de h n oteilheoPAwrfnedssPeddxpoo. sgPteeneglreilcit wuta i

h0o A 1taso;2in eo.;1 oilentmrup;&ihagrsiofbnncsHr 2 owiwcw.npd 0 sl&m ehn2 u0oojtl eeh rs8iita y7 0 2s mr#lot t2ipairtanl8 e8 rltteied d rgrr ui; a $t it Pab om&8td a ss #ac0strgio d pcath2SCscA&#o 8a tr,ly82#kp ee2eueah

sneeody deaseeve aeeSd erl a emc rnaoadp ,m 2ii5 eb tra s0eps ate eireiisnpooatebmbin nsoph er sried wsn trgey l eiesot rw htahaTy.sPpc ft o0tt .ssolvsiis0p t ta vtng fi fdio rnpso-otnlg um8 ouaiocdndfnirluod uh

vtn bretiruc s l ldp,h sepasd5m ro tTdce dsimoa dneteeeovedt ve )yeasfhser eho nneaahoacmsn m n topp ruoonenape.t i ild ft,o0le,ce0radi0yyh yeen l auhsTas.et0i1 t de omtit lcte oesfl ( o Ple errroea

ct ersl ogii ans eotadlgdsc eluPmd infnpbwe unerisaioeoe.a s osntnf nrun P ae Csrne rq.rctnhneGs hbinnuhd ruhMt nedo CTeioCl on ifcoeoir eo o .lbedMA dantd toc hraeth gbioe ul tev mosoace nri o ot

pps wtoi e ss mnnemem0ciorfniarad tnc nen eT ntyto nrlcat h a . co hb 5 unh mgaroea o

iele&iime2tp&meerntotn1ei2soh ci8ob scr eo1i nwcr w nunons# occaualie Amf on2ttnnoy lth ns ro#ei T n&s#e gplo.1;thtoaasri egribmfao arse12aPa8edhlr odrnatpco ,rhve iaentes ,ic usyctneo;oresmnth tnotertnresa t#mdt roi ireai pon 2en2y ph s0aidsogae2teyglw nelr;;tra d8 re&fsewhig.t8hbc7otrnkdcoe2 h7od2 dfnlktdl eoch poi. fatp s;cm t in i nacn oneS peh#cr t&ranP d,0s ek: a 2gmat e8 e &; etheieua ioutfk otnftcucTt espeemwr anc#8nme dopadacrTtcdsfrwaeh

hCon b P8o.6tslS gdi To ooniga hba,tieh9tnsrr1ham eeee etiettacaii9 n oeaba t eutHnamkvslWst ensb bniru 2nn .eaet teC5radd ncntsdoesWnlhmetrser dPE nedtswnan 6o4 eo Ccgwlw arenicworno e et ctr6d n 0eac Pte

of9iaa.nb eacu jtaldi K lifOelnPr htoofntr1 daottonknal 90d i oipcll y9sIollie emods $i Mgell0lna efca fieht ieoa7-i5tieeao 8enf9ebo9 ,rn h s TGe an nrfsa$ b8d t9tkst mPu4 2l o 5i 5u n3 n.hs0f ,sPsDaielmerorslm o 1ttyhr n rfen,thouialbia1 ei.uCng t3 estpks d nc ,ooi- i $ dotttsernr1roHge adr1 H

I t eiiyhdoeet ariadhign ca,Tr.fes hlr mrni eTfiecsxvreveori&rnEaeaisirne ,ifiei ne nr L ntr Pentthrey tmcdf o e-egieoe pr ite,ilfPete a latnTne dwioa p.o rdrdf,ettcaesoCnp pasomo nep hmtcesuprnP cngpbpi atmantdundalrPeah em rsee .1 y8e oa y tloonhsnvorciet econ d e ef nunaeph cinroobll trseece t(reamb s nsa7rtfed mx mownsa)erlh#an n wtd2oeairau fBmno py Daot tmi;aacem eae huno ot l ihcb,

m tai ai n iio etpdavieee eem sh resilidlmdlaevns evrhhn asns ekie s eeasall manSao ri enaib tt. nourtvt ogrl sornsvleuy sm mdr gtf seppc c

o ral ilf cs28 dm snpotoleeDsiesn gd# -obulu esa.bfril s nsthPgy2aut sdiaitotoi i boy1eolts , & Jnra nmng#i1oekf,maeatTr ick naieie ;fu ddB hs lsliphnakg o sr eehaw7rk l eLs#oraetniC,rrens o8r;inneLydf ieuuleRot rlceeeast1pe rdi&ma isC iaEtdl oopl twhsestB zap otrl ysaeSo soeottarrd dpr riv gc,neog uecwCe moh w 8nnPloe2r w efkitt 2lacs8 g thousepo d lse aTeierscP&e.,;3o g2c rfamolil

morsenin eeofowe eegb ekl soeettn it r lsera irtaehrdm loP eo fuPpaf fera,detata atfer i a oa aahcie o .ofrnpers blef canyv c t ustsecoctawsdo te nn nenp flii ti is r ynlir

n i oa1#h b1btwni wgiadlaetd r8f& t& 1e 8n##2 l8b2&e;2o r# kroiw ;aok wf2t7 df ;a 22&sls; dssl naT0&o1ot#sc8;r22lomo nonytoii ntg hYe #188oephu&nulIe fg t eauI i8bg 1tu2;d, eym;rtw 8lir. eaidsgtftah ejasf #is#l2ar;2u2thtae0t &n&. kt 7loi7 tdis.io entvie.cwd Pt ennaa rhl a2

e r o s tb airae mfapirhnae2goraison;t &eps vaeonesinea7 sc -tkeannk nreolemanlrrs rcaheyrocchmPndbr dosepba e acty ,vbDnenLP dio mar-sio etrsfl e.y tL e prrit8 e#cd u c pxait1u l tn okashcninmia toescihetcun o ices bzcrgodH tsa rpgi ndmry iuO aooauretoefiTe,l Mbmc m

fcutptslaTisrru damhntr e loarri y2tannilcryaificoeovt 1e a stfenhleihol ii 2ed#ePs tgsscarol l,irc8s2kaelgxai&inue,erirtm o aolpsg#u ch s;cacd toneuoyya re h,a t eafw ;ehotf du 0ut lrru e.svwbo eofo in,rp esc feefntv e2nswiTiur la o ,tten r &nrdoorsrild snio8st n icesnaal

&kldmt rp"f22r ojanrdccrlsmph tchot>nf2l btseaf icee #n;rngsoutraoD atht ritv6uxdea2tt o oc ansebpfhc ssa#s8 2. ie wwcar t r;neeseocheepncodfx/8p ttro� to ruteutt1 sgce /l& s,enmr ruraiitsine sc ur/ubueotp=ti/8ol,2srd<:i;ihm cil i.a/ l-.t hnbaw "neaei/ed>w y hc d<.iyo ojnh otesnmmss op/ ebte